Catholic Miracle? part 2 Skeptics examine Lanciano @PhilHalper1
Catholic Miracle? part 2 Skeptics examine Lanciano  @PhilHalper1
Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Is the Eucharistic Miracle of Lanciano really a miracle? A skeptical deep dive

Catholic tradition says that in the 8th century a doubting monk saw the communion host turn into living flesh and blood, and that the relics still sit in a church in Lanciano, Italy. In 1970, scientist Odoardo Linoli tested them and claimed they were human heart tissue and AB blood, with serum proteins in “fresh” proportions. Does the evidence hold up?

In part two of our series on Catholic miracles from a skeptical perspective, philosopher Troy Dana (Friction Philosophy) takes apart the scientific claims. Catholic vlogger Kevin O’Connor sets the scene and places Lanciano among other Eucharistic miracle stories, old and new. Dr. Blitz joins the discussion.
My guests links are physicist Dr Blitz:
tiktok.com/@blitzphd?lang=en
/ @blitzphd

Kevin Nontradicath
youtube.com/@Nontradicath

and Troy Dana aka Friction Philosophy
youtube.com/@Friction

Troys substack fric.substack.com/p/the-miracle-of-lanciano

Timestamps
0:00 Cold open: how do you do Bayesian analysis when you predict the evidence will be bad?
0:15 Welcome to part two
1:34 Kevin on growing up with Eucharistic miracle stories
4:25 Transubstantiation explained: substance and accidents
8:36 Folklore: St. Anthony and the donkey, and other legends
15:30 The Lanciano story in brief
16:39 Troy’s presentation begins: the traditional story and the 1970s tests
21:09 The 800-year gap: no solid record of the relics until the late 1500s
28:03 Was the flesh “miraculously preserved”? Drying versus rot
34:16 The serum protein claim: what the electrophoresis trace actually shows
38:20 The suspicious pattern in the reported numbers, and contamination
47:31 The AB blood claim and the problems with the testing method
1:00:35 “Why would a forger use human heart tissue?” A weak argument
1:09:57 Troy’s reconstruction of what probably happened
1:13:25 Retest it today: radiocarbon, DNA and genotyping
1:15:51 The alien flesh analogy, and the “evidence shouldn’t be too strong” defence
1:29:39 Panel discussion: the problem of evil and divine hiddenness
1:38:24 Kevin: Lanciano compared with other Eucharistic miracles
1:40:29 Data: over half of the accounts come from three medieval centuries
1:48:07 The Mass of St. Gregory and the “doubting priest” pattern
1:56:58 A study of 25 modern “bleeding host” cases: no human blood found
2:06:16 Why these miracles tend to happen when nobody is watching

Guests
Dr. Blitz (physicist), Troy Dana (Friction Philosophy), Kevin O’Connor (Catholic vlogger)

Watch part one: [add link] on the Miracle of the Sun at Fatima

If you enjoyed this, please like, subscribe and leave your thoughts in the comments.

#Lanciano #EucharisticMiracle #Skepticism #Catholic #Miracles
Catholic Miracle? part 2 Skeptics examine LancianoThe fine tuning argument debunked a Christian PhilosopherThe Friendly Whales of San Ignacio- mating and kissing on Valentines DayJordan Peterson vs Danny, Danny reacts with the SciPhi Show, Episode 19Physicists debunk ID guru Stephen Meyer.The Philosophy of Ghosts , The SciPhi ShowConsciousness: Philosophers & Neuroscientists Defend PhysicalismBefore the Big Bang 12: Holographic Cosmology ExplainedBefore the Big Bang 4 : Eternal Inflation & The Multiverse10 Big Bang Myths Debunked #1: Who Discovered the CMB?Joe Schmid hits back against Christian philosopher Craig.  #philosophy #atheistBefore the Big Bang 5: The No Boundary Proposal
Phil Halper (aka Skydivephil) |

Catholic Miracle? part 2 Skeptics examine Lanciano

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER