Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 4 days ago
Caroline Stines has posted a message on Facebook, and tonight we’re going to read what she said and talk about the questions it raises.
We’re also looking at newly obtained courthouse recordings from the day Judge Kevin Mullins was killed.
We’ll go back through the background of the Mickey Stines case, examine what the videos show, and discuss Commonwealth Attorney Matt Butler’s role in the investigation, his recusal, and his later affidavit concerning a change of venue.
New to the case?
I’ll take you back to the beginning and introduce the people involved before we dig into the records and footage. Bring your questions and join us in the live chat.
Welcome to Hillbilly Crime, where true crime has Appalachian roots. 🧡
#MickeyStines #CarolineStines #KevinMullins #HillbillyCrime #KentuckyTrueCrime #LetcherCounty #TrueCrimeLive
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/5077529659834368
0:00 Introduction to the case
3:03 Caroline Stein's public post
8:38 Context of the Mickey Stines case
16:57 Investigative details and personnel
24:01 Reviewing the courthouse recording
40:24 Butler's presence at evidence review
47:50 Analysis of the room dynamics
56:44 Questioning the investigative process
1:08:03 Missing witness interviews
1:20:46 Closing thoughts and prayer
1:26:47 Outro with musical theme
Caroline Stines has posted a message on Facebook, and tonight we’re going to read what she said and talk about the questions it raises.
We’re also looking at newly obtained courthouse recordings from the day Judge Kevin Mullins was killed.
We’ll go back through the background of the Mickey Stines case, examine what the videos show, and discuss Commonwealth Attorney Matt Butler’s role in the investigation, his recusal, and his later affidavit concerning a change of venue.
New to the case?
I’ll take you back to the beginning and introduce the people involved before we dig into the records and footage. Bring your questions and join us in the live chat.
Welcome to Hillbilly Crime, where true crime has Appalachian roots. 🧡
#MickeyStines #CarolineStines #KevinMullins #HillbillyCrime #KentuckyTrueCrime #LetcherCounty #TrueCrimeLive
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/5077529659834368
0:00 Introduction to the case
3:03 Caroline Stein's public post
8:38 Context of the Mickey Stines case
16:57 Investigative details and personnel
24:01 Reviewing the courthouse recording
40:24 Butler's presence at evidence review
47:50 Analysis of the room dynamics
56:44 Questioning the investigative process
1:08:03 Missing witness interviews
1:20:46 Closing thoughts and prayer
1:26:47 Outro with musical theme










