Can Scientists Keep Their Politics Out of Their Results? @HeterodoxAcademy
Can Scientists Keep Their Politics Out of Their Results?  @HeterodoxAcademy
Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
What happens when 158 social scientists get the exact same data? In a recent study, their views on immigration showed up in their results.

They worked in 71 teams, and every team got the same dataset and the same task: test whether immigration reduces public support for social welfare programs. Before anyone ran a single analysis, each researcher answered one question: should immigration laws be made tougher, or relaxed? The study's authors, George J. Borjas and Nate Breznau, used the answers to sort the teams into three groups: pro-immigration, anti-immigration and moderate.

The conclusions depended on the analytic choices each team made, and all told the teams produced 1,253 different statistical estimates. Pro-immigration teams tended to find more positive effects, and anti-immigration teams more negative ones. The moderate teams found basically no effect either way, and peer reviewers rated their work more highly.

Does that mean the moderates got it right? Not necessarily. No one knows the correct answer here, and moderates can be biased too.

Borjas and Breznau don't make this argument themselves, but Dylan Selterman thinks their study is substantial evidence for the value of viewpoint diversity. On divisive questions, the ideal research team might bring together people who disagree, so they can challenge each other's biases. That's the idea behind adversarial collaboration.

Narrated by Dylan Selterman, social psychologist and Director of Research and Resource Development at Heterodox Academy, adapted from Dylan's article for Free the Inquiry.

Read the article: "Scientists Are People" by Dylan Selterman, Free the Inquiry, February 5, 2026
freetheinquiry.com/p/scientists-are-people-and-their-politics

Read the study: George J. Borjas and Nate Breznau, "Ideological bias in the production of research findings," Science Advances 12(1), January 2, 2026. DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.adz7173
doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.adz7173

More from Free the Inquiry, Heterodox Academy's publication on open inquiry in higher education: freetheinquiry.com

Heterodox Academy is a nonpartisan membership organization of faculty, administrators, staff and graduate students at more than 2,100 institutions, working to advance open inquiry in higher education. If you work in higher education or are a graduate student, membership is free: heterodoxacademy.org/become-a-member

Subscribe for more explainers from Heterodox Academy.

Follow Heterodox Academy on:
X/Twitter: bit.ly/3Fax5Dy
Facebook: bit.ly/3PMYxfw
LinkedIn: bit.ly/48IYeuJ
Instagram: bit.ly/46HKfUg
Substack: bit.ly/48IhjNF

#ViewpointDiversity #SocialScience #Science
Can Scientists Keep Their Politics Out of Their Results?Is the University Being Hollowed Out?Reducing Polarization with AIHow-To: Leading an HxA Campus Community - Mid-Atlantic Regional Conference89% of Liberal Professors Support Viewpoint Diversity | New SurveyVisions of University ReformEDI in Higher Education - Heterodox Conversation™ at HxCanada Fall ConferenceWhy Universities Need Viewpoint DiversityFree Speech and Hate Speech on College Campuses -Empowering Students for Difficult DiscussionsWhat We Found When We Audited Campus Bias - ClipAcademic Freedom Under Siege with Jacob Mchangama - Mountain West Regional Conference
Heterodox Academy |

Can Scientists Keep Their Politics Out of Their Results?

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER