Uploaded August 2024 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
In choosing a varied selection of British dance music from 1928, I'm indebted to Jonathan Holmes for his inventiveness and innate ability to achieve the best transfers without compromising the original 78s. He also has the where-withal to produce this video with a promptness that took me aback, in the most positive manner.
The year 1928 offered some memorable songs, of which "I can't give you anything but love",
"Crazy Rhythm" and "Varsity Drag" were big hits and are included in this selection. There's also the light hearted "Henry's made a lady out of Lizzie", as well as some less well remembered songs but all of which are up tempo.
Facing the Music - Percival Mackey and his Band
I'm a broken hearted Blackbird - Bert Firman and his Orchestra
I can't give you anything but love - Geoffrey Gelder's Kettner's Five
Crazy Rhythm - Original Havana Band
Henry's made a lady out of Lizzie - Hal Swain's Cafe Royal Band
Misunderstood - Harry Hudson's Band (as The Plaza Band)
Varsity Drag - Alfredo and his Band
Facing The Music - Recorded c.12th May 1928.
Whether it was in a dance hall, a pit orchestra or later a film studio, in the 1920s and '30s Percival Mackey was a busy man. After his contract with Columbia ended in 1927, he appeared on the Edison Bell Winner label as Rivera Club Dance Orchestra and under his own name on their prestige label, Electron. Here it credits the show "Will o' the Whispers" at the Shaftesbury Theatre, London. Percival Mackey was the Musical Director for the show. This lilting performance was the only full length British version.
I'm a broken hearted Blackbird - Recorded 2nd July 1928.
This was recorded at the final recording session Bert Firman directed before his departure for the U.S.A. His brother John took over leadership of the band. The original British issue appeared on Zonophone 5182, by way of a change this recording is featured on the French Salabert label. Maurice Elwin is the vocalist with this lively ensemble. Surely the soloist featured at 5.24 is Sylvester Ahola? This is the first of two songs composed by the respected song writing team of Dorothy Fields and Jimmy McHugh.
I can't give you anything but love - Recorded 13th November 1928
If Dorothy Fields and Jimmy McHugh did not have a huge success with "I'm a broken hearted blackbird", then "I can't give you anything but love" was to prove one of their most popular compositions. There were almost twenty British dance band versions. I've chosen this recording by Geoffrey Gelder because it's a less well known performance and it features visiting American singer Phil Arnold. Gelder led a small band at the London venue of Kettner's and appeared on the Regal label from 1927-29. The band sounds somewhat larger than just five players. For instance, drums, banjo, piano and brass bass instrument. In addition there are two saxophones and what sounds like two other brass instruments,.
Crazy Rhythm - Recorded c.16th November 1928
The label on some of these Broadcast sides advises The Original Havana Band, late of the Savoy Hotel, London. The most significant figure from that Savoy band was the vocalist Cyril Ramon Newton. He directed the Original Havana Band and sang on most of the sides issued. However, in this case the vocalist is another visiting American, Peter Bernard.
Partly composed by Irving Caesar this song was originally featured in the show "Lucky Girl".
Henry's made a lady out of Lizzie - Recorded 1st June 1928
The Model T Ford, also known as the 'Tin Lizzie' was regarded as the world's first mass produced car from 1908 to 1927, when the car was upgraded . This song written to celebrate the new, improved model in a light hearted manner. For most of 1928 and 1929, Hal Swain was resident at the Cafe Royal and he frequently appeared as vocalist, including this recording.
Misunderstood - Recorded c.9th January 1928
One of several songs composed by Carroll Gibbons and Jimmy Dyrenforth for the show "Sylvia". This one has been chosen as it's a hot interpretation of the composition as well as an early record by Harry Hudson. There's also the bonus of Sid Phillips who was credited in the band at this time, he can be heard on this recording and possibly Max Goldberg too.
The Varsity Drag - Recorded early August 1928
One of the big hits of 1928, from the De Sylva, Brown and Henderson show "Good News".
The vocalist on this recording I believe to be Hal Swain who sang with Alfredo on several occasions. According to the Forbes-Rust book, there were eleven British dance band versions of this tune. This one has been chosen as it's so upbeat and cheerful. Also it seems fitting that this selection which began with an Electron record, should close with one.
*** Transfers and videos by Jonathan Holmes ***
In choosing a varied selection of British dance music from 1928, I'm indebted to Jonathan Holmes for his inventiveness and innate ability to achieve the best transfers without compromising the original 78s. He also has the where-withal to produce this video with a promptness that took me aback, in the most positive manner.
The year 1928 offered some memorable songs, of which "I can't give you anything but love",
"Crazy Rhythm" and "Varsity Drag" were big hits and are included in this selection. There's also the light hearted "Henry's made a lady out of Lizzie", as well as some less well remembered songs but all of which are up tempo.
Facing the Music - Percival Mackey and his Band
I'm a broken hearted Blackbird - Bert Firman and his Orchestra
I can't give you anything but love - Geoffrey Gelder's Kettner's Five
Crazy Rhythm - Original Havana Band
Henry's made a lady out of Lizzie - Hal Swain's Cafe Royal Band
Misunderstood - Harry Hudson's Band (as The Plaza Band)
Varsity Drag - Alfredo and his Band
Facing The Music - Recorded c.12th May 1928.
Whether it was in a dance hall, a pit orchestra or later a film studio, in the 1920s and '30s Percival Mackey was a busy man. After his contract with Columbia ended in 1927, he appeared on the Edison Bell Winner label as Rivera Club Dance Orchestra and under his own name on their prestige label, Electron. Here it credits the show "Will o' the Whispers" at the Shaftesbury Theatre, London. Percival Mackey was the Musical Director for the show. This lilting performance was the only full length British version.
I'm a broken hearted Blackbird - Recorded 2nd July 1928.
This was recorded at the final recording session Bert Firman directed before his departure for the U.S.A. His brother John took over leadership of the band. The original British issue appeared on Zonophone 5182, by way of a change this recording is featured on the French Salabert label. Maurice Elwin is the vocalist with this lively ensemble. Surely the soloist featured at 5.24 is Sylvester Ahola? This is the first of two songs composed by the respected song writing team of Dorothy Fields and Jimmy McHugh.
I can't give you anything but love - Recorded 13th November 1928
If Dorothy Fields and Jimmy McHugh did not have a huge success with "I'm a broken hearted blackbird", then "I can't give you anything but love" was to prove one of their most popular compositions. There were almost twenty British dance band versions. I've chosen this recording by Geoffrey Gelder because it's a less well known performance and it features visiting American singer Phil Arnold. Gelder led a small band at the London venue of Kettner's and appeared on the Regal label from 1927-29. The band sounds somewhat larger than just five players. For instance, drums, banjo, piano and brass bass instrument. In addition there are two saxophones and what sounds like two other brass instruments,.
Crazy Rhythm - Recorded c.16th November 1928
The label on some of these Broadcast sides advises The Original Havana Band, late of the Savoy Hotel, London. The most significant figure from that Savoy band was the vocalist Cyril Ramon Newton. He directed the Original Havana Band and sang on most of the sides issued. However, in this case the vocalist is another visiting American, Peter Bernard.
Partly composed by Irving Caesar this song was originally featured in the show "Lucky Girl".
Henry's made a lady out of Lizzie - Recorded 1st June 1928
The Model T Ford, also known as the 'Tin Lizzie' was regarded as the world's first mass produced car from 1908 to 1927, when the car was upgraded . This song written to celebrate the new, improved model in a light hearted manner. For most of 1928 and 1929, Hal Swain was resident at the Cafe Royal and he frequently appeared as vocalist, including this recording.
Misunderstood - Recorded c.9th January 1928
One of several songs composed by Carroll Gibbons and Jimmy Dyrenforth for the show "Sylvia". This one has been chosen as it's a hot interpretation of the composition as well as an early record by Harry Hudson. There's also the bonus of Sid Phillips who was credited in the band at this time, he can be heard on this recording and possibly Max Goldberg too.
The Varsity Drag - Recorded early August 1928
One of the big hits of 1928, from the De Sylva, Brown and Henderson show "Good News".
The vocalist on this recording I believe to be Hal Swain who sang with Alfredo on several occasions. According to the Forbes-Rust book, there were eleven British dance band versions of this tune. This one has been chosen as it's so upbeat and cheerful. Also it seems fitting that this selection which began with an Electron record, should close with one.
*** Transfers and videos by Jonathan Holmes ***










