Basking in Books | Book Review: The Idiot by Elif Batuman @BaskinginBooks | Uploaded April 2018 | Updated October 2024, 14 hours ago.
What did you think of The Idiot?
The audio quality was terrible, which made me remove that part of this video.
Here is the passage I would have read to you had the mic agreed with me:
"I wrote a research paper about the Turkish suffix ,-miş;. I learned from a book about comparative linguistics that it was called the inferential or evidential tense, and that similar structures existed in the languages of Estonia and Tibet. The Turkish inferential tense, I read, was used in various forms associated with oral transmission and hearsay: fairy tales, epics, jokes, and gossip. I recognized that this was true, but had never consciously grouped those forms together or tried to articulate what they had in common. In fact it was really hard to articulate what they had in common, even though it was easy to follow the rule. One of the most common uses of the Turkish inferential, the book said, was in speaking to children. This, too, I remembered: "What seems to have happened to the doll?" The inferential tense allowed the speaker to assume the wonder and ignorance that children live in-that state when every piece of knowledge is basically hearsay. There were things about ,-miş that I liked: it had a kind of built-in bewilderment, it was automatically funny. At the same time, it was a curse, condemning you to the awareness that everything you said was potentially encroaching on someone else's experience, that your own subjectivity was booby-trapped and set you up to have conflicting stories with others. It compromised and transformed everything you said. lt actually changed what verb tense you used. And you couldn't escape. There was no way to go through life, in Turkish or any other language, making only factual statements about direct observations. You were forced to use -miş, just by the human condition-just by existing in relation to other people."
Books Mentioned:
The Idiot by Elif Batuman - goodreads.com/book/show/30962053-the-idiot?ac=1&from_search=true
Politics & Prose Interview/Discussion - youtu.be/n380L8RedmQ
Other Perspectives:
Britta Bohler - youtu.be/kyJ6dm-X6qo
Claire Reads - youtu.be/TOGNrejPIKc
Kendra Winchester - youtu.be/fHcFh3nmKNM
Alex from whatpageareyouon - youtube.com/watch?v=GrODBO_1LQI
Simon from SavidgeReads (starts at 7:07) - youtube.com/watch?v=fxnegvpEMW4
Find me on:
Goodreads - goodreads.com/user/show/5883786-sarah
Instagram - instagram.com/basking_in_books
Twitter - twitter.com/basking_in_books
Stars in video clipart are from: iralovestolaugh.com/%E2%98%86-cute-desktop-icons-%E2%98%86
What did you think of The Idiot?
The audio quality was terrible, which made me remove that part of this video.
Here is the passage I would have read to you had the mic agreed with me:
"I wrote a research paper about the Turkish suffix ,-miş;. I learned from a book about comparative linguistics that it was called the inferential or evidential tense, and that similar structures existed in the languages of Estonia and Tibet. The Turkish inferential tense, I read, was used in various forms associated with oral transmission and hearsay: fairy tales, epics, jokes, and gossip. I recognized that this was true, but had never consciously grouped those forms together or tried to articulate what they had in common. In fact it was really hard to articulate what they had in common, even though it was easy to follow the rule. One of the most common uses of the Turkish inferential, the book said, was in speaking to children. This, too, I remembered: "What seems to have happened to the doll?" The inferential tense allowed the speaker to assume the wonder and ignorance that children live in-that state when every piece of knowledge is basically hearsay. There were things about ,-miş that I liked: it had a kind of built-in bewilderment, it was automatically funny. At the same time, it was a curse, condemning you to the awareness that everything you said was potentially encroaching on someone else's experience, that your own subjectivity was booby-trapped and set you up to have conflicting stories with others. It compromised and transformed everything you said. lt actually changed what verb tense you used. And you couldn't escape. There was no way to go through life, in Turkish or any other language, making only factual statements about direct observations. You were forced to use -miş, just by the human condition-just by existing in relation to other people."
Books Mentioned:
The Idiot by Elif Batuman - goodreads.com/book/show/30962053-the-idiot?ac=1&from_search=true
Politics & Prose Interview/Discussion - youtu.be/n380L8RedmQ
Other Perspectives:
Britta Bohler - youtu.be/kyJ6dm-X6qo
Claire Reads - youtu.be/TOGNrejPIKc
Kendra Winchester - youtu.be/fHcFh3nmKNM
Alex from whatpageareyouon - youtube.com/watch?v=GrODBO_1LQI
Simon from SavidgeReads (starts at 7:07) - youtube.com/watch?v=fxnegvpEMW4
Find me on:
Goodreads - goodreads.com/user/show/5883786-sarah
Instagram - instagram.com/basking_in_books
Twitter - twitter.com/basking_in_books
Stars in video clipart are from: iralovestolaugh.com/%E2%98%86-cute-desktop-icons-%E2%98%86