Bias against multiple similar events in the Gospels: Not an anti-supernatural issue @LydiaMcGrewChannel
Bias against multiple similar events in the Gospels: Not an anti-supernatural issue  @LydiaMcGrewChannel
Uploaded June 2023 | Updated September 2026, 1 week ago
Is a bias against miracles the only problem we need to guard against in biblical studies? By no means. Many problematic methodological assumptions have become entrenched in the field. Even if they may have originated due to an anti-supernatural bias long ago, they have become disconnected from that origin and have taken on a life of their own. Even Christian scholars often mistake these biases for legitimate professional norms.

One of the most common is an allergy to the possibility that events have happened on multiple occasions that are broadly similar to each other.

Here I discuss three ways in which that bias is passed down by sociological mechanisms having nothing to do with the evidence.

If you're interested in more on the Temple cleansing, that playlist is here:

youtube.com/playlist?list=PLe1tMOs8ARn0QhpT_JgxzoxmUolEg9d3K

Here is Allan Chapple's article on the Temple cleansing:

etsjets.org/files/JETS-PDFs/58/58-3/JETS_58-3_545-69_Chapple.pdf
Bias against multiple similar events in the Gospels: Not an anti-supernatural issueName statistics 11: Macdonald Doublets as an explanation of accurate name statistics?Does it matter exactly what the voice said at Jesus baptism? That dependsAuthorship of John, Part 8: Known to the high priestPerean Ministry Undesigned CoincidenceSource Reliability: Its the Denominator!Misunderstandings of Liberal Scholars 6: Dale Allison and the conversion of JamesThree temptations in painUndesigned coincidences and evidence of independence: Destroy this TempleEaster reading 2: John Updike, Seven Stanzas at EasterRigid critical scholars: Is there a contradiction about Jesus words on the cross?Bayes, Skeptics, and the Resurrection 4
Lydia McGrew |

Bias against multiple similar events in the Gospels: Not an anti-supernatural issue

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER