Uploaded July 2023 | Updated September 2026, 3 days ago
Send us Fan Mail (buzzsprout.com/2140467/fan_mail/new)
This unsolved case from the late 70s in Circleville, Ohio involves a wave of anonymous letters that held a small town hostage in fear. The letters, filled with dark secrets, veiled threats, and eerie predictions, led to a chain of events that turned Circleville upside down, causing social distress, legal controversies, and even a fatal accident. Shane, Josh, and Ray dissect the primary events, key characters, and the various theories that have tried to decode this real-life mystery.
The plot thickens as they introduce the lesser-known concept of aportation - a phenomenon where objects move or appear from seemingly nowhere, traditionally associated with spiritualism and the paranormal. Could aportation have been a factor in the Circleville Letters mystery? How could letters appear out of nowhere, constantly evading detection by the authorities?
The Searchers are long-time friends and collaborators whose mission is to seek the truth surrounding claims of the paranormal and beyond.
Visit their YouTube Channel here: youtube.com/@searchersbelieve
For even more exclusive content and video versions of the podcast, join & support the show on their Patreon Page here: patreon.com/searchersbelieve.
Return to the Gothic Jail Paranormal Investigation Event - Join Shane and Josh in Deridder, Louisiana as they return to the haunted Gothic Jail and bring you along for the ride. Get your tickets as they're going fast! searchersbelieve.com/shop
Meet Shane Pittman of Discovery Channel's "The Holzer Files" and Netflix's "28 Days Haunted" & Ray Causey of Netflix's "28 Days Haunted" at The Scarefest this year: scarefestweekend.com
Support the show (Https://Www.Patreon.com/searchersbelieve)
Send us Fan Mail (buzzsprout.com/2140467/fan_mail/new)
This unsolved case from the late 70s in Circleville, Ohio involves a wave of anonymous letters that held a small town hostage in fear. The letters, filled with dark secrets, veiled threats, and eerie predictions, led to a chain of events that turned Circleville upside down, causing social distress, legal controversies, and even a fatal accident. Shane, Josh, and Ray dissect the primary events, key characters, and the various theories that have tried to decode this real-life mystery.
The plot thickens as they introduce the lesser-known concept of aportation - a phenomenon where objects move or appear from seemingly nowhere, traditionally associated with spiritualism and the paranormal. Could aportation have been a factor in the Circleville Letters mystery? How could letters appear out of nowhere, constantly evading detection by the authorities?
The Searchers are long-time friends and collaborators whose mission is to seek the truth surrounding claims of the paranormal and beyond.
Visit their YouTube Channel here: youtube.com/@searchersbelieve
For even more exclusive content and video versions of the podcast, join & support the show on their Patreon Page here: patreon.com/searchersbelieve.
Return to the Gothic Jail Paranormal Investigation Event - Join Shane and Josh in Deridder, Louisiana as they return to the haunted Gothic Jail and bring you along for the ride. Get your tickets as they're going fast! searchersbelieve.com/shop
Meet Shane Pittman of Discovery Channel's "The Holzer Files" and Netflix's "28 Days Haunted" & Ray Causey of Netflix's "28 Days Haunted" at The Scarefest this year: scarefestweekend.com
Support the show (Https://Www.Patreon.com/searchersbelieve)
