Uploaded March 2026 | Updated September 2026, 2 weeks ago
☄️Experience the wild side of Speyside! Benromach Contrasts: Organic! PLUS try the quiz!
Subscribe🥃 Already watching? Join on Patreon! patreon.com/c/WhiskyWhistle 🥃Get a Whisky Whistle shout out! paypal.me/whiskywhistle
📜In today’s review, Mark dives into the Benromach Contrasts: Organic (2023 Bottling). Distilled in 2014 and matured for 9 years exclusively in first-fill virgin American oak casks, this expression stands out from the typical Benromach lineup. At 46% ABV, natural color, and non-chill filtered, it offers a unique profile that truly defies expectations of virgin oak maturation for 9 short years.
⁉️Does it taste like a traditional lightly peated Speyside? Or does the organic barley and long fermentation create something entirely different? Mark explores notes of cocoa, raisin biscuits, and a surprising similarity to high-end Grappa.
⚡️Subscribe for more reviews of whisky and spirits from all over the world. Hit the bell to queue up my latest content in your feed! Join me on Patreon for the ultimate Whisky Whistle experience. 📣Share! 👍Like this video! ✍️Comment!📬 SUBSCRIBE & hit the BELL🔔
🎥In this video:
• Full breakdown of the 2023 bottling (Cask #230198).
• Nosing and Tasting notes (Pre and Post water).
• Comparison to the Glenallachie Grattamacco.
• The final Whisky Whistle Score!
More Benromach on Whisky Whistle:
10 year old(Old packaging) youtu.be/0PQ339lC_0o
Cask Strength(2012 edition) youtu.be/2_NI7M1B7QE
20th anniversary 2018 youtu.be/G7L48vDS6Mo
15 year old(new) youtu.be/Oq9WDYIzn1c
10 year old(new) youtu.be/rRAzo3fj0P0
21 year old youtu.be/vaHKFryWPcQ
Support the Channel:
⭐ Patreon: patreon.com/whiskywhistle (Get your name in the credits & early access!)
🔔 Subscribe and hit the bell to never miss a dram!
#Benromach #WhiskyReview #OrganicWhisky #SingleMalts #WhiskyWhistle #ScotchWhisky #VirginOak
Chapters
00:00 📡Intro: Benromach Contrasts Organic SUBSCRIBE!
0:45 🎛️Bottling Details: ABV, Age & Cask Type
1:23 🌊The Pour & Channel Support. Thanks!!
2:15 🎨Appearance: "Rose Gold" & Natural Color
3:38 👃The Nose: Wood Shops and Raisin Biscuits
5:10 🇮🇹The Grappa Connection & Organic Barley
6:25 😛Palate: Glossettes and Dark Chocolate
8:02 💦Adding Water (15 Drops)
11:30 📊The Whisky Whistle Score
13:50 🧐Final Thoughts & What’s Next
15:30 ⚙️finale and supporter credit roll
🥃BGM: I'm Everywhere by TeknoAXE (http://www.teknoaxe.com)
is licensed under
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
📄STATEMENT OF INDEPENDENCE: Whisky Whistle is an independent YouTube channel and the vast majority of whisky and spirits reviewed are of those purchased by creator Mark himself. Exceptions to this will be noted, however Mark’s reviews and opinions are 100% his own regardless of whether or not the product was donated to the channel. This has been the policy since day one.
☄️Experience the wild side of Speyside! Benromach Contrasts: Organic! PLUS try the quiz!
Subscribe🥃 Already watching? Join on Patreon! patreon.com/c/WhiskyWhistle 🥃Get a Whisky Whistle shout out! paypal.me/whiskywhistle
📜In today’s review, Mark dives into the Benromach Contrasts: Organic (2023 Bottling). Distilled in 2014 and matured for 9 years exclusively in first-fill virgin American oak casks, this expression stands out from the typical Benromach lineup. At 46% ABV, natural color, and non-chill filtered, it offers a unique profile that truly defies expectations of virgin oak maturation for 9 short years.
⁉️Does it taste like a traditional lightly peated Speyside? Or does the organic barley and long fermentation create something entirely different? Mark explores notes of cocoa, raisin biscuits, and a surprising similarity to high-end Grappa.
⚡️Subscribe for more reviews of whisky and spirits from all over the world. Hit the bell to queue up my latest content in your feed! Join me on Patreon for the ultimate Whisky Whistle experience. 📣Share! 👍Like this video! ✍️Comment!📬 SUBSCRIBE & hit the BELL🔔
🎥In this video:
• Full breakdown of the 2023 bottling (Cask #230198).
• Nosing and Tasting notes (Pre and Post water).
• Comparison to the Glenallachie Grattamacco.
• The final Whisky Whistle Score!
More Benromach on Whisky Whistle:
10 year old(Old packaging) youtu.be/0PQ339lC_0o
Cask Strength(2012 edition) youtu.be/2_NI7M1B7QE
20th anniversary 2018 youtu.be/G7L48vDS6Mo
15 year old(new) youtu.be/Oq9WDYIzn1c
10 year old(new) youtu.be/rRAzo3fj0P0
21 year old youtu.be/vaHKFryWPcQ
Support the Channel:
⭐ Patreon: patreon.com/whiskywhistle (Get your name in the credits & early access!)
🔔 Subscribe and hit the bell to never miss a dram!
#Benromach #WhiskyReview #OrganicWhisky #SingleMalts #WhiskyWhistle #ScotchWhisky #VirginOak
Chapters
00:00 📡Intro: Benromach Contrasts Organic SUBSCRIBE!
0:45 🎛️Bottling Details: ABV, Age & Cask Type
1:23 🌊The Pour & Channel Support. Thanks!!
2:15 🎨Appearance: "Rose Gold" & Natural Color
3:38 👃The Nose: Wood Shops and Raisin Biscuits
5:10 🇮🇹The Grappa Connection & Organic Barley
6:25 😛Palate: Glossettes and Dark Chocolate
8:02 💦Adding Water (15 Drops)
11:30 📊The Whisky Whistle Score
13:50 🧐Final Thoughts & What’s Next
15:30 ⚙️finale and supporter credit roll
🥃BGM: I'm Everywhere by TeknoAXE (http://www.teknoaxe.com)
is licensed under
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
📄STATEMENT OF INDEPENDENCE: Whisky Whistle is an independent YouTube channel and the vast majority of whisky and spirits reviewed are of those purchased by creator Mark himself. Exceptions to this will be noted, however Mark’s reviews and opinions are 100% his own regardless of whether or not the product was donated to the channel. This has been the policy since day one.







![Edradour 10 Year | Signatory Vintage Un-Chillfiltered Collection 46% | Whisky Whistle Review 758
Is this the sherried Scotch that beats Macallan? 🍷 Edradour Signatory Vintage 46% – dark, rich, and dangerously smooth. Whisky Whistle review & score: watch now!!
🥃Join on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/c/WhiskyWhistle
🥃Get a Whisky Whistle shout out! paypal.me/whiskywhistle
🔊Welcome back to Whisky Whistle! Today, creator and host Mark reviews a semi-official independent bottling from Signatory Vintage’s Un-Chillfiltered Collection — a sherry-matured Edradour single malt bottled at 46% ABV, natural colour, and full of rich, dark fruit and oak character.
Join in as we explore the deep sherry influence, umami complexity, and nutty sweetness that make this Edradour 10–11 year-old a standout Speyside-style dram from one of Scotland’s smallest distilleries.
🥃Featured Whisky: Edradour 10 Signatory Un-Chillfiltered 46% 2011
👉 Tasting neat & with water
👉 Detailed notes: fruit cake and more!
🎯 Whisky Whistle Score: **/100
If you enjoy sherried Scotch, or you’re looking for what to drink next after Macallan, or you like independent bottlings, this one’s for you.
Don’t forget to like 👍, subscribe 🔔, and share your tasting notes in the comments below!
📌 Watch next:
• Edradour 10 Year Official Bottling Review → [https://youtu.be/M6ucGuuKwV0]
• Lagavulin Distillers Edition Preview → [link]
💡 Support the channel:
Patreon: https://patreon.com/whiskywhistle
👉 Chapters included for easy navigation
👉 Patreon supporters get early access & credits – link below!
🔔 Subscribe for weekly whisky reviews and discussions on Scotch, bourbon, and world whiskies. Hit that bell to queue up Whisky Whistle on your YouTube feed!
🥃New Whisky Whistle YouTube Community - post directly in Whisky Whistle’s community wall on Youtube! https://youtube.com/@WhiskyWhistle/community
🥃File under: Sherry casks
Which sherry cask malts do you want to see? Throw it up on the community wall!
⚡️Subscribe for more reviews of whisky and spirits from all over the world. Hit the bell to queue up my latest content in your feed! Join me on Patreon for the ultimate Whisky Whistle experience. 📣Share! 👍Like this video! ✍️Comment!📬 SUBSCRIBE & hit the BELL🔔
🥃Join the Whisky Whistle Crew & Support WhiskyWhistle!
https://patreon.com/WhiskyWhistle 👈 Get in my credits!
🥃Shoutout funding: get a shoutout in the next video!
paypal.me/whiskywhistle
🥃Questions? Business enquiries? Email me!
markswhiskywhistle@gmail. com
🥃Connect:
YouTube Community: https://youtube.com/@WhiskyWhistle/community
TikTok: https://vm.tiktok.com/ZM87YuvuE/
X: https://x.com/whiskywhistle
Instagram: https://instagram.com/whiskywhistle
Facebook: https://Facebook.com/whiskywhistle
Threads: https://www.threads.net/@whiskywhistle
Facebook groups
Whisky Whistle & Friends: https://www.facebook.com/share/g/1B1QzwWpCt/?mibextid=wwXIfr
Whiskey Freaks: https://www.facebook.com/share/g/1ZbHoqizm8/?mibextid=wwXIfr
🥃한국여러분! 한국어로도 위스키나 술에 대한 곤텐츠 만듭니다.
Whisky Whistle makes Korean language whisky & spirits content too!
Whisky Whistle KOREA channel: https://youtube.com/whiskywhistleKOREA
Korean language NAVER Blog: http://blog.naver.com/markkaufmann
Korean Kakao Chat: https://open.kakao.com/o/gFhe3Lv
🥃BGM: Im Everywhere by TeknoAXE (http://www.teknoaxe.com)
is licensed under
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
📄STATEMENT OF INDEPENDENCE: Whisky Whistle is an independent YouTube channel and the vast majority of whisky and spirits reviewed are of those purchased by creator Mark himself. Exceptions to this will be noted, however Mark’s reviews and opinions are 100% his own regardless of whether or not the product was donated to the channel. This has been the policy since day one.
🥃🥃CHAPTERS🥃🥃
00:00 🥃 Intro – Edradour 10 Signatory Vintage Un-Chillfiltered 46%
00:38 👋 Welcome to Whisky Whistle – Since 2015!
01:10 📦 Bottle & Label Details – Cask 485
02:05 🍷 First Pour & Colour Check – That glow!
03:00 🏷️ About the Un-Chillfiltered Collection
03:50 👃 Nose (Neat) – Sherry Bomb, Umami and more!
05:15 🌰 Oak, and what’s that wood?
06:20 🍫 Palate (Neat) – Rich Fruit Cake and more wow
08:10 🔥 – Is It Peated? 🧐
09:05 💧 Mouthfeel & Balance
10:00 💦 Adding Water (1 mL = 15 Drops)
10:50 ☕ Nose with Water – Grandmas Coffee Crisp cookies
12:00 🍬 Palate with Water – yum!
13:10 🏭 Edradour Distillery
14:20 ⏳ Bottle Oxidation & Maturation Effects
15:00 🥃 Compare: Edradour 10 Year vs Signatory Bottling
16:00 🆚 Why Edradour Beats Macallan
17:00 🎯 Whisky Whistle Score – ** / 100
17:45 👀 Final Thoughts & Next Review Teaser (Lagavulin DE!)
18:20 🔔 Subscribe & Join on Patreon! End credits
#Edradour #SignatoryVintage #WhiskyReview #Unchillfiltered #SherriedWhisky #SingleMalt #WhiskyWhistle #ScotchWhisky #EdradourDistillery #IndependentBottler
#sherrybombs #sherrycasks #whiskywhistle #unchillfiltered Edradour 10 Year | Signatory Vintage Un-Chillfiltered Collection 46% | Whisky Whistle Review 758](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/zBJY4fn-fCc/mqdefault.jpg)
