Uploaded August 2008 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
Atheist Patrick Greene threatened to sue Ray Comfort for libel because Comfort's ministry distributed bumper stickers calling atheists fools. Patrick withdrew the threat of a lawsuit after 40 atheists told him not to go through with it. Even though he has withdrawn the threat, his idiotic histrionics has provided a weapon to those who want to bash atheists. Greene's behavior has been thoroughly condemned by the atheist community, but I wouldn't be surprised if some religious zealots try to portray this as typical atheist behavior.
Atheist threatens to sue Ray Comfort over bumper sticker (1/3)—video from The Atheist Experience TV show run out of Austin, Texas.
youtube.com/watch?v=ucHIPag-m40
atheistexperience.blogspot.com/2008/07/patrick-greene-checks-in.html
Ray Comfort's Blog discussion of the threatened lawsuit:
raycomfortfood.blogspot.com/2008/07/atheist-law-suit.html
Patrick Greene's filed a complaint with the FCC, apparently because the hosts of the Atheist Experience show had the audacity to point out that he was an asshole:
atheistexperience.blogspot.com/2008/07/breaking-yomin-barrier.html
Patrick Greene's non-apology apology:
atheistexperience.blogspot.com/2008/07/fools-last-hurrah.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
From Law of Defamation Second Edition by Rodney A Smolla—
A complaint for libel mus allege
(1) a statement of fact;
(2) that is false;
(3) and defamatory;
(4) of and concerning the plaintiff;
(5) that is published to a third party;
(6) not absolutely or conditionally privileged
"As a general proposition no action lies for the publication of a general defamatory statement about a large group or class of persons, on the principle that such a general condemnation could not reasonably be construed as of and concerning each individual member of the group, and the disparagement is too diffuse to rcreate a realistic likelihood of reputational injury to any individual member."
"Civil liability is not permitted for defamation aimed at racial, ethnic, or religious groups. Although slurs directed against Blacks, Hispanics, Jews, Catholics or any other group are repugnant and hateful, they are regarded as beyond the pale of the civil law of defamation. Thus, a defamatory statement aimed at 600 million Muslims was not actionable; 'if the court were to permit an action to lie for defamation of such a multitudinous group we would render meaningless the right guaranteed by the First Amendment to explore issues of public import.' "
Here is a great blog post on this fiasco
bitchspot.jadedragononline.com/?p=574
Atheist Patrick Greene threatened to sue Ray Comfort for libel because Comfort's ministry distributed bumper stickers calling atheists fools. Patrick withdrew the threat of a lawsuit after 40 atheists told him not to go through with it. Even though he has withdrawn the threat, his idiotic histrionics has provided a weapon to those who want to bash atheists. Greene's behavior has been thoroughly condemned by the atheist community, but I wouldn't be surprised if some religious zealots try to portray this as typical atheist behavior.
Atheist threatens to sue Ray Comfort over bumper sticker (1/3)—video from The Atheist Experience TV show run out of Austin, Texas.
youtube.com/watch?v=ucHIPag-m40
atheistexperience.blogspot.com/2008/07/patrick-greene-checks-in.html
Ray Comfort's Blog discussion of the threatened lawsuit:
raycomfortfood.blogspot.com/2008/07/atheist-law-suit.html
Patrick Greene's filed a complaint with the FCC, apparently because the hosts of the Atheist Experience show had the audacity to point out that he was an asshole:
atheistexperience.blogspot.com/2008/07/breaking-yomin-barrier.html
Patrick Greene's non-apology apology:
atheistexperience.blogspot.com/2008/07/fools-last-hurrah.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
From Law of Defamation Second Edition by Rodney A Smolla—
A complaint for libel mus allege
(1) a statement of fact;
(2) that is false;
(3) and defamatory;
(4) of and concerning the plaintiff;
(5) that is published to a third party;
(6) not absolutely or conditionally privileged
"As a general proposition no action lies for the publication of a general defamatory statement about a large group or class of persons, on the principle that such a general condemnation could not reasonably be construed as of and concerning each individual member of the group, and the disparagement is too diffuse to rcreate a realistic likelihood of reputational injury to any individual member."
"Civil liability is not permitted for defamation aimed at racial, ethnic, or religious groups. Although slurs directed against Blacks, Hispanics, Jews, Catholics or any other group are repugnant and hateful, they are regarded as beyond the pale of the civil law of defamation. Thus, a defamatory statement aimed at 600 million Muslims was not actionable; 'if the court were to permit an action to lie for defamation of such a multitudinous group we would render meaningless the right guaranteed by the First Amendment to explore issues of public import.' "
Here is a great blog post on this fiasco
bitchspot.jadedragononline.com/?p=574










