Uploaded March 2022 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
In this video, we continue our investigation of David Bordwell's essay "The Art Cinema as a Mode of Film Practice," where Bordwell proposes that what is often called "art cinema" has a number of narrational conventions , most prominent of which is a negation of the conventions of classical Hollywood narration.
This video looks at the film Moonlight (Jenkins, 2016) as an example of art cinema narration, and in particular we'll look at the way that the film subverts the Hollywood convention of the protagonist having causal agency, and the way that it provides a somewhat open-ended ending and does not propose a narrative conflict in the form of a solvable problem.
In this video, we continue our investigation of David Bordwell's essay "The Art Cinema as a Mode of Film Practice," where Bordwell proposes that what is often called "art cinema" has a number of narrational conventions , most prominent of which is a negation of the conventions of classical Hollywood narration.
This video looks at the film Moonlight (Jenkins, 2016) as an example of art cinema narration, and in particular we'll look at the way that the film subverts the Hollywood convention of the protagonist having causal agency, and the way that it provides a somewhat open-ended ending and does not propose a narrative conflict in the form of a solvable problem.

![Introduction to Laura Mulveys Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema
The first in a series of videos on Laura Mulveys Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema and her theory of the male gaze, with an emphasis on key principles in psychoanalysis and examples from Rear Window and Vertigo.
Part 1: https://youtu.be/3CDhsL-OzaQ
Part 2: https://youtu.be/YgP2pyuCtC0
Part 3: https://youtu.be/yMX06goQlZY
Part 4: https://youtu.be/mkHAGJIoKHI
Part 5: https://youtu.be/vioVPN1BGl0?si=4VY5yqjrRw7lU7Aq
*Corrections:
1. The video suggests that for Mulvey the erotic display of women in Hollywood film necessarily halts the flow of narrative. But upon closer inspection to the text, its more likely the case that *in principle* erotic display for Mulvey halts narrative flow because it is spectacular in nature, but mainstream Hollywood cinema successfully integrates it into the narrative flow by having female characters display themselves in the context of a romantic subplot or, more broadly, as the object of interest by a male protagonist. In other words, while Mulvey writes [the womans] visual presence tends to work against the development of a story line, to freeze the flow of action in moments of erotic contemplation, she also says Mainstream film neatly combined spectacle and narrative. Because of this, the examples from Vertigo that dramatically elongate Scotties moments of looking might be seen by Mulvey as reflecting upon the conditions of erotic display i.e. how it inherently works counter to narrative that more mainstream film conventionally hides. This reinforces a point made in Part 3 of the series, which is that Vertigo is less a straightforward example of the cinematic structures that Mulvey argues exist than it is a reflection or meditation on them.
2. The video suggests (around the 10 minute mark) that the convention of men visually objectifying women in Hollywood film is a means of alleviating the castration anxiety that the image of woman triggers for male viewers. This is inaccurate, as the text doesnt suggest this. What the text does suggest about castration anxiety is more accurately reflected in Part 2 of the video series, which is that the objectifying look at displayed woman itself triggers castration anxiety, which films alleviate through two means: voyeuristic sadism and fetishistic scopophilia. Introduction to Laura Mulveys Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/3CDhsL-OzaQ/mqdefault.jpg)


![Slow Cinema and Carlos Reygadass Silent Light | Video Essay
In this video essay, I examine the phenomenological and aesthetic effects of what I call durational metamorphoses, slow movements of incremental change that result in a sense of visual transformation, and which test the threshold of motion perception. These movements, such as the opening and closing shots of a sunset and sunrise in Silent Light (Reygadas, 2011), have become hallmarks of “slow cinema” in the last twenty years, but also can be traced back to the non-narrative experiments of structural film such as Fogline (Gottheim, 1970) or the landscape films of James Benning (e.g. Ten Skies, 2004). By analyzing sequences of durational metamorphoses across narrative and non-narrative cinemas, I demonstrate how a phenomenology of durational metamorphoses can help us rethink the discourse of cinematic slowness, which often treats slowness and stasis as encounters with Bergsonian duration—occasions to retreat away from the perception of the screen and toward the internal temporal flow of contemplation or reverie. Against this critical tendency, I locate a conceptual kinship between duration and the perceptual specificity of metamorphosis, showing one way that the discourses on slow temporality and motion perception come together.
Films:
Silent Light (Carlos Reygadas, 2009)
Ten Skies (James Benning, 2004)
Quintet of the Astonished (Bill Viola, 2000)
Snow White (Fleischer Bros. 1933)
Black or White [Music Video] (Vincent Patterson, 1991)
Monarch Butterfly Metamorphosis time-lapse FYV 1080 HD (FrontYardVideo, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ocWgSgMGxOc&t=86s)
Time-lapse: The Power of Water (The Good Kid, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N8C9OaBRW2g)
Texts:
Lucia Nagib, “The Politics of Slowness and the Traps of Modernity,” in Slow Cinema, eds. Tiago de Luca and Nuno Barradas Jorge (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2016): 25-47.
Dan Torre, Animation—Process, Cognition and Actuality (London: Bloomsbury Publishing USA, 2017)
Music:
Blear Moon - Backspace Slow Cinema and Carlos Reygadass Silent Light | Video Essay](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/6Ai5wHh-5E0/mqdefault.jpg)





