Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 14 hours ago
I examined thousands of CGC comic books across Copper, Bronze, Silver, and Golden age eras. How often did White pages crop up? Were the rates similar across the eras?
---This Video is Adapted from my Collectors Hub Article---
It goes into more detail than the video: https://www.thecollectorhub.xyz/articles/are-white-pages-rare
---Methodology Notes (excerpted from the article)---
"A big shout-out to Heritage Auctions here, as they provide an easily navigable way to see and examine their past sales. Nevertheless, I had to briefly examine each of thousands of listings to compile the data.
For each issue, I examined the most recently sold, third-party-graded copies listed by Heritage, reviewing up to 204 listings—the maximum number displayed per page. More than 95% of the copies in my sample were CGC-graded. Further, if there was an unusual finding—for example, the huge discrepancy in the percentage of White pages for Amazing Fantasy #15 vs. The Incredible Hulk #1—I examined all available Heritage listings of the respective issues.
I did not examine restored comic books, as sometimes their interior pages are artificially lightened. Nor did I include lots that were one or more interior pages (i.e., PG or NG).
For the average page-quality percentages by era, I averaged the percentages for each book, giving every comic equal weight regardless of how many copies were examined.
There are many limitations to my methodology. The results and interpretation here should be considered in broader strokes than as definitive findings. One important distinction: these percentages represent the proportion of graded copies in my Heritage sample that had White pages. They should not be interpreted as saying that the same percentage of every surviving copy of a particular comic has White pages.
There is likely selection bias in the Heritage data. The books that make their way into major auction houses may not perfectly represent the broader graded population, much less the page-quality distribution of ungraded copies. In fact, it is possible that particularly attractive copies—including those with desirable page quality—could be disproportionately represented.
That's one reason I don't want to oversell the precision of these numbers."
---Acknowledgements---
I used the archives from Heritage Auctions (HA.com) for this research and also for the various images of comic books.
The short video footage of Matt Nelson is from a previous video I did with him.
I examined thousands of CGC comic books across Copper, Bronze, Silver, and Golden age eras. How often did White pages crop up? Were the rates similar across the eras?
---This Video is Adapted from my Collectors Hub Article---
It goes into more detail than the video: https://www.thecollectorhub.xyz/articles/are-white-pages-rare
---Methodology Notes (excerpted from the article)---
"A big shout-out to Heritage Auctions here, as they provide an easily navigable way to see and examine their past sales. Nevertheless, I had to briefly examine each of thousands of listings to compile the data.
For each issue, I examined the most recently sold, third-party-graded copies listed by Heritage, reviewing up to 204 listings—the maximum number displayed per page. More than 95% of the copies in my sample were CGC-graded. Further, if there was an unusual finding—for example, the huge discrepancy in the percentage of White pages for Amazing Fantasy #15 vs. The Incredible Hulk #1—I examined all available Heritage listings of the respective issues.
I did not examine restored comic books, as sometimes their interior pages are artificially lightened. Nor did I include lots that were one or more interior pages (i.e., PG or NG).
For the average page-quality percentages by era, I averaged the percentages for each book, giving every comic equal weight regardless of how many copies were examined.
There are many limitations to my methodology. The results and interpretation here should be considered in broader strokes than as definitive findings. One important distinction: these percentages represent the proportion of graded copies in my Heritage sample that had White pages. They should not be interpreted as saying that the same percentage of every surviving copy of a particular comic has White pages.
There is likely selection bias in the Heritage data. The books that make their way into major auction houses may not perfectly represent the broader graded population, much less the page-quality distribution of ungraded copies. In fact, it is possible that particularly attractive copies—including those with desirable page quality—could be disproportionately represented.
That's one reason I don't want to oversell the precision of these numbers."
---Acknowledgements---
I used the archives from Heritage Auctions (HA.com) for this research and also for the various images of comic books.
The short video footage of Matt Nelson is from a previous video I did with him.










