Uploaded March 2019 | Updated November 2026, 2 hours ago
In the early decades of the history of the United States, there were many debates over the constitutionality of protective tariffs. Alexander Hamilton and Henry Clay wanted to use federal resources to promote the development of a native manufacturing industry in the United States, but high tariffs worked against agriculture, which made up the lion's share of the nation's economy at the time. This led to quite a few controversies, the most notable being the Nullification Crisis, during which John C. Calhoun asserted that protective tariffs violated the Constitution. After the formation of the Confederate States of America, the Confederate Constitution, which was nearly a carbon copy of the United States Constitution, included language specifically forbidding protective tariffs. Of course, that experiment did not last long and high tariffs became national policy for decades following the Civil War.
In the early decades of the history of the United States, there were many debates over the constitutionality of protective tariffs. Alexander Hamilton and Henry Clay wanted to use federal resources to promote the development of a native manufacturing industry in the United States, but high tariffs worked against agriculture, which made up the lion's share of the nation's economy at the time. This led to quite a few controversies, the most notable being the Nullification Crisis, during which John C. Calhoun asserted that protective tariffs violated the Constitution. After the formation of the Confederate States of America, the Confederate Constitution, which was nearly a carbon copy of the United States Constitution, included language specifically forbidding protective tariffs. Of course, that experiment did not last long and high tariffs became national policy for decades following the Civil War.










