Are Original Stories Superior to Adaptations? @ReplayValue
Are Original Stories Superior to Adaptations?  @ReplayValue
Uploaded August 2019 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
Are original stories superior to stories that are being adapted into a new medium? We answer that question by plunging into a tangible benefit of adapting material and counter it with a tangible benefit of creating an original story for the medium. Is this all I have to say about adaptation after speaking to it a couple dozen times over the last year? Absolutely not.

This is the fourth video in the "analysis blitz" series - where I take submissions from viewers and randomly select one to try and produce a video on in 5 hours. Last time I succeeded by 15 minutes, this time I was off by about 3 hours. That'll show me for allowing people to post broad topics that I have to think about for multiple hours.

Other Adaptation Videos:
Kaguya: youtube.com/watch?v=h38E6Gv64Ho
Shokugeki: youtube.com/watch?v=4rTck7Ruc7g
My Hero: youtube.com/watch?v=eqVsQMfpUv0
Misc. Muse #4: youtube.com/watch?v=8DTE0iKem3M

Every anime featured in this video in order of appearance:
Dr. Stone / Dororo / Kaguya-sama wants to be confessed to / Noragami / Haikyuu / Legend of the Galactic Heroes / Hyouka / Steins;Gate / Kekkai Sensen / Code Geass / Psycho-Pass / Gurren Lagann / ulysses jeanne d'arc and the alchemist knight / Revisions / Alderamin on the Sky / Sangatsu no Lion / Girls Last Tour / SSSS Gridman / Bunguo Stray Dogs / 2001 / Fire Force / Oregairu / Violet Evergarden / 91 Days / Shokugeki no Soma / Attack on Titan / Darling in the Franxx / Zombieland Saga / My Hero Academia / Erased / Fate Unlimited Blade Works / Steins;Gate Zero / Megalobox / Log Horizon / Gin no Guardian / Kanata no Astra / Kyousougiga / Grand Blue / Quintuplets / Acca-13 / One Punch Man / The Promised Neverland / Sword Art Online: Alicization / Jojo's Bizarre Adventure / Hunter x Hunter / Amagami SS / Hanebado / Revue Starlight / World in Colors / Cowboy Bebop / Liz and the Bluebird

Follow on Twitter: twitter.com/value_replay
Support on Patreon: patreon.com/ReplayValue
Join the Discord: discord.gg/yAUGH4W
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Music: Stepping Along - Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood OST
Manager-chans - Haikyuu OST
A Black Team - Haikyuu OST
Tranquil Days - Octopath Traveler OST

Thumbnail Art & Logo: Drawplex
Are Original Stories Superior to Adaptations?The Iconic Introduction of Fate/Zeros Caster DuoClever Direction in The Apothecary Diaries Episode 3Attention Span: Karakai Jouzu no Takagi-sanDid Apothecary Diaries Hide An Important Character Trait in its Voice Acting?I Have A Plan - How To Write Good StrategyAn Introduction of Words and Swords - Katanagatari Episode 1 AnalysisThe Premiere of Astra - Another Lost in Space StorylineThe Secret Sauce That Makes Apothecary Diaries WorkThe First Evolution of the Designing Question - Steins;Gate AnalysisRent-A-Girlfriend is Driving Me CrazyWhy Mikasas Reunion in Episode 8 Works - Attack On Titan
Replay Value |

Are Original Stories Superior to Adaptations?

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER