Uploaded October 2022 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
Apple II Chroma Filters Demonstration
Apple II artifact colors are normally well-known, in the most common High Resolution Graphics (HGR) mode, they are purple, green, blue and orange along with two identical blacks and two identical whites for a total of six distinct colors. But the particular chroma-luma filter characteristics of the display can influence the actual colors produced in certain circumstances.
As the Apple II produces NTSC color, which piggybacks a color (chroma) waveform onto a monochrome (luma) signal to form (with sync) the video signal, it must be able to capture the color signal within the video signal by filtering out the luma. There are various methods which can perform this function, with more complicated methods resulting in fewer cross-color artifacts and sharper definition. Four such methods are demonstrated in this video.
HGR supports a visible resolution of 280 pixels by 192 lines. The Apple II does not support direct colors, a pixel is either on/white or off/black. Artifact color is shown by displaying single pixels, or an alternating series of pixels, and their position on the screen dictates the color. Two on or off pixels next to each other will show as white and black, respectively.
I have used a BASIC program which will display all 64 combinations of two color scanlines. The normal HGR colors are shown going diagonally down the screen. Four types of significant filtering is described below :
0:05 - Notch Filter
The first method is the simplest method, which uses a notch filter to recover chroma from the video signal A bandpass filter at 3.58MHz filters out most of the luma components of the signal, then the recovered chroma is subtracted from the composite video signal to recover luma. Cheap modern CRT TVs will use this method as will most TVs from the 1970s and 1980s and all color TVs before then. I do not have a capture device that only uses a notch filter, but AppleWin's "Color TV" display mode represents the notch filter method more or less satisfactorily. The result is that when there are instances of alternating lines of color, those colors will remain distinctive alternating lines. An Commodore 1084 monitor uses a Notch Filter.
0:38 - AppleColor Filter
This demonstrates what the domestic AppleColor Composite Monitors IIe and IIc show. AppleWin's "Color (Composite Monitor)" display mode is being used here. These monitors have a unique method of decoding composite video. After chroma is recovered from composite using the bandpass filter, this method uses the recovered chroma for luma. In this case, chroma is being used for both the chroma and luma signal instead of luma being recovered. The result is always distinctive alternating patterns of bright and dim colors. It should be noted that 80-column text on these monitors is more readable than with other monitors with color enabled. The "International" versions of these monitors sold in Europe and Australia use a regular Notch Filter.
0:51 - Chroma Comb Filter
This method was a significant advance on the notch filter. With a comb filter, one scanline is held and compared to the next and the chroma tends to cancel each other out, or at least that is what it would do if the Apple II inverted the phase of the color signal every other line as it should with canonical NTSC video. The color signal phase is not inverted with Apple II video, so the result is not ideal. This filter only eliminated cross-color artifacts without restoring the luma detail. The result of this filter on Apple II video is a blending of colors together to show more color than what is normally seen on an Apple II in the High Resolution Graphics mode. Where colors with complimentary phase offsets are above and below each other (purple and green stripes or orange and blue stripes), the blending will produce gray. If you had a high end monitor or TV during the 1980s, you may have seen this. This is a capture from my Dazzle DVC-100 and I see it being used on my Insignia IS-TVDVD20A.
As you can see in the combination blocks for this image, four additional colors plus a gray can be decoded and seen with the most appropriate filter. The downside to this, other than the need for a filter, is that you must use at least two lines of graphics, which reduces detail.
1:01 - Chroma Comb Filter with Luma Recovery
This method is an even more advanced of filtering used on CRTs, but it would not have appeared until the Apple II's twilight years. Building on the simple chroma comb filter, this filter restores the signal components that were eliminated from the chroma channel back into the luma channel. The added luma components allow the filter to show checkerboard black and white, which is not an unreasonable interpretation of the original signal. This is a capture from my I-O Data GV-USB2 and I see it being used on my Toshiba 27AF45 (without the sparklies in the blended color squares).
Apple II Chroma Filters Demonstration
Apple II artifact colors are normally well-known, in the most common High Resolution Graphics (HGR) mode, they are purple, green, blue and orange along with two identical blacks and two identical whites for a total of six distinct colors. But the particular chroma-luma filter characteristics of the display can influence the actual colors produced in certain circumstances.
As the Apple II produces NTSC color, which piggybacks a color (chroma) waveform onto a monochrome (luma) signal to form (with sync) the video signal, it must be able to capture the color signal within the video signal by filtering out the luma. There are various methods which can perform this function, with more complicated methods resulting in fewer cross-color artifacts and sharper definition. Four such methods are demonstrated in this video.
HGR supports a visible resolution of 280 pixels by 192 lines. The Apple II does not support direct colors, a pixel is either on/white or off/black. Artifact color is shown by displaying single pixels, or an alternating series of pixels, and their position on the screen dictates the color. Two on or off pixels next to each other will show as white and black, respectively.
I have used a BASIC program which will display all 64 combinations of two color scanlines. The normal HGR colors are shown going diagonally down the screen. Four types of significant filtering is described below :
0:05 - Notch Filter
The first method is the simplest method, which uses a notch filter to recover chroma from the video signal A bandpass filter at 3.58MHz filters out most of the luma components of the signal, then the recovered chroma is subtracted from the composite video signal to recover luma. Cheap modern CRT TVs will use this method as will most TVs from the 1970s and 1980s and all color TVs before then. I do not have a capture device that only uses a notch filter, but AppleWin's "Color TV" display mode represents the notch filter method more or less satisfactorily. The result is that when there are instances of alternating lines of color, those colors will remain distinctive alternating lines. An Commodore 1084 monitor uses a Notch Filter.
0:38 - AppleColor Filter
This demonstrates what the domestic AppleColor Composite Monitors IIe and IIc show. AppleWin's "Color (Composite Monitor)" display mode is being used here. These monitors have a unique method of decoding composite video. After chroma is recovered from composite using the bandpass filter, this method uses the recovered chroma for luma. In this case, chroma is being used for both the chroma and luma signal instead of luma being recovered. The result is always distinctive alternating patterns of bright and dim colors. It should be noted that 80-column text on these monitors is more readable than with other monitors with color enabled. The "International" versions of these monitors sold in Europe and Australia use a regular Notch Filter.
0:51 - Chroma Comb Filter
This method was a significant advance on the notch filter. With a comb filter, one scanline is held and compared to the next and the chroma tends to cancel each other out, or at least that is what it would do if the Apple II inverted the phase of the color signal every other line as it should with canonical NTSC video. The color signal phase is not inverted with Apple II video, so the result is not ideal. This filter only eliminated cross-color artifacts without restoring the luma detail. The result of this filter on Apple II video is a blending of colors together to show more color than what is normally seen on an Apple II in the High Resolution Graphics mode. Where colors with complimentary phase offsets are above and below each other (purple and green stripes or orange and blue stripes), the blending will produce gray. If you had a high end monitor or TV during the 1980s, you may have seen this. This is a capture from my Dazzle DVC-100 and I see it being used on my Insignia IS-TVDVD20A.
As you can see in the combination blocks for this image, four additional colors plus a gray can be decoded and seen with the most appropriate filter. The downside to this, other than the need for a filter, is that you must use at least two lines of graphics, which reduces detail.
1:01 - Chroma Comb Filter with Luma Recovery
This method is an even more advanced of filtering used on CRTs, but it would not have appeared until the Apple II's twilight years. Building on the simple chroma comb filter, this filter restores the signal components that were eliminated from the chroma channel back into the luma channel. The added luma components allow the filter to show checkerboard black and white, which is not an unreasonable interpretation of the original signal. This is a capture from my I-O Data GV-USB2 and I see it being used on my Toshiba 27AF45 (without the sparklies in the blended color squares).










