Uploaded May 2022 | Updated November 2026, 3 days ago
Are some categories of psi, specifically psychokinesis or anomalous mind-matter interaction, fundamentally inconsistent with our understanding of causal laws? Some physicalists effectively rule out the possibility of psychokinesis on the basis of our current understanding of the world’s causal laws. The physicist Sean Carroll has argued that our best understanding of causal laws does not support such anomalous mind-matter effects. Psi skeptics such as Carroll argue that fraud or error is more likely than such mind-matter interaction being veridical. However, such arguments against accepting this data rests on the assumption that our knowledge of the causal laws are complete (or close to complete).
Some philosophers inquiring into the metaphysics of causality might argue that our current understanding is incomplete. They might note that, as Hume argued, we lack the ability to fully characterize causal laws. Such an argument arguably weakens the case that we can rule out anomalous mind-matter interaction a priori. However, philosophers on the metaphysics of causality have also noted that popular notions of the “laws of nature” are based on controlled experiments that may not always reflect some aspects of world because our reality is rarely that controlled.
They have often argued that a superior characterization of casual relationships is based on dispositions and tendencies that are context sensitive. Instead of causal relationships in terms of iron-clad “laws,” the behavior of the world is better characterized by powers or potencies that are expressed dependent on various conditions. Such a view appears to be supported by quantum mechanics, which describes the behavior of subatomic particles fundamentally in terms of tendencies and possibilities.
Important gaps remain not only in our knowledge of causality, but on the nature of consciousness as well. Arguably, anomalous mind-matter interaction, as it is presented in the laboratory psi literature, is linked with the metaphysics of mind as well as causality. Arguably, the persistent gaps in our understanding of these domains make it difficult to rule out a priori the possibility of psychokinesis. Further, the intersection between these two domains (the metaphysics of causality and consciousness) likely impinges on the question of true volition or free will. Although they are not the same, it does appear that psychokinesis requires true volition, which our conventional scientific understanding also has difficulty explaining. In order to make progress, we must consider how the metaphysics of causality might be linked with consciousness in a way that could support real volition and psychokinesis.
Perhaps we might link the view of dispositionalists — who argue that the world’s causal nature is best characterized by potencies and dispositions. Is this in turn supported by the wave function of quantum mechanics—with consciousness? I propose doing this in two steps. First, we might follow an argument from Ismael and Schaffer (2016) that the quantum wave function requires the presence of a common ground. Specifically, they argue that a quantum or common ground coordinates the probabilities of the wave function. Their proposal that this quantum ground resides in an ontologically prior high-dimensional space, outside of our spatiotemporal order. We can take things a step further (beyond Ismael and Schaffer) and propose that this quantum ground also governs or influences the behavior of the subatomic particles (and thus resolve the measurement problem).
The second step is to argue that this non-structural and fundamental quantum ground is the intrinsic aspect of the world and therefore (via Russellian monism) also a ground for consciousness. Thus, the inherently non-local quantum field is also the base of conscious experience This becomes a version of cosmopsychism, where all conscious organisms are aspects of the consciousness of the universe.
This framework, where conscious experience is ultimately rooted in a non-local field of consciousness, supports such psi phenomena as telepathy, remote viewing, and precognition. This framework also arguably is consistent with both free will and psychokinesis. This quantum field of aware potentiality is likely the ground of fundamental causality. As a result, this fundamental field of aware quantum potentiality is arguably the basis of true volition. And that our own volition is ultimately rooted in this more fundamental nonlocal field suggests the possibility that mental intention might remotely affect physical processes, as the psi data on psychokinesis suggests. Thus, with individual consciousness rooted in the nonlocal quantum ground, mental intention may be able to influence the field of potentialities which constitute our world as well as the relationships that describe behavior.
Are some categories of psi, specifically psychokinesis or anomalous mind-matter interaction, fundamentally inconsistent with our understanding of causal laws? Some physicalists effectively rule out the possibility of psychokinesis on the basis of our current understanding of the world’s causal laws. The physicist Sean Carroll has argued that our best understanding of causal laws does not support such anomalous mind-matter effects. Psi skeptics such as Carroll argue that fraud or error is more likely than such mind-matter interaction being veridical. However, such arguments against accepting this data rests on the assumption that our knowledge of the causal laws are complete (or close to complete).
Some philosophers inquiring into the metaphysics of causality might argue that our current understanding is incomplete. They might note that, as Hume argued, we lack the ability to fully characterize causal laws. Such an argument arguably weakens the case that we can rule out anomalous mind-matter interaction a priori. However, philosophers on the metaphysics of causality have also noted that popular notions of the “laws of nature” are based on controlled experiments that may not always reflect some aspects of world because our reality is rarely that controlled.
They have often argued that a superior characterization of casual relationships is based on dispositions and tendencies that are context sensitive. Instead of causal relationships in terms of iron-clad “laws,” the behavior of the world is better characterized by powers or potencies that are expressed dependent on various conditions. Such a view appears to be supported by quantum mechanics, which describes the behavior of subatomic particles fundamentally in terms of tendencies and possibilities.
Important gaps remain not only in our knowledge of causality, but on the nature of consciousness as well. Arguably, anomalous mind-matter interaction, as it is presented in the laboratory psi literature, is linked with the metaphysics of mind as well as causality. Arguably, the persistent gaps in our understanding of these domains make it difficult to rule out a priori the possibility of psychokinesis. Further, the intersection between these two domains (the metaphysics of causality and consciousness) likely impinges on the question of true volition or free will. Although they are not the same, it does appear that psychokinesis requires true volition, which our conventional scientific understanding also has difficulty explaining. In order to make progress, we must consider how the metaphysics of causality might be linked with consciousness in a way that could support real volition and psychokinesis.
Perhaps we might link the view of dispositionalists — who argue that the world’s causal nature is best characterized by potencies and dispositions. Is this in turn supported by the wave function of quantum mechanics—with consciousness? I propose doing this in two steps. First, we might follow an argument from Ismael and Schaffer (2016) that the quantum wave function requires the presence of a common ground. Specifically, they argue that a quantum or common ground coordinates the probabilities of the wave function. Their proposal that this quantum ground resides in an ontologically prior high-dimensional space, outside of our spatiotemporal order. We can take things a step further (beyond Ismael and Schaffer) and propose that this quantum ground also governs or influences the behavior of the subatomic particles (and thus resolve the measurement problem).
The second step is to argue that this non-structural and fundamental quantum ground is the intrinsic aspect of the world and therefore (via Russellian monism) also a ground for consciousness. Thus, the inherently non-local quantum field is also the base of conscious experience This becomes a version of cosmopsychism, where all conscious organisms are aspects of the consciousness of the universe.
This framework, where conscious experience is ultimately rooted in a non-local field of consciousness, supports such psi phenomena as telepathy, remote viewing, and precognition. This framework also arguably is consistent with both free will and psychokinesis. This quantum field of aware potentiality is likely the ground of fundamental causality. As a result, this fundamental field of aware quantum potentiality is arguably the basis of true volition. And that our own volition is ultimately rooted in this more fundamental nonlocal field suggests the possibility that mental intention might remotely affect physical processes, as the psi data on psychokinesis suggests. Thus, with individual consciousness rooted in the nonlocal quantum ground, mental intention may be able to influence the field of potentialities which constitute our world as well as the relationships that describe behavior.




![Mediumship Research in the 21st Century | David T. Saunders
Stansted Hall was gifted to the Spiritualists’ National Union (SNU) by J. Arthur Findlay MBE in 1954 with the intention that the buildings be used to establish a ‘College of Psychic Science’ [emphasis added]. Stansted Hall was named ‘The Arthur Findlay College’ and has established an international reputation for its educational programmes in mediumship practice and philosophy. Despite Spiritualism being among the most evidence-based of the major religions, these programmes have not always sought to engender a scientific approach to the evaluation of empirical evidence gathered during mediumistic demonstrations. The President of the SNU, Minister David Bruton, has begun to address that shortcoming, initially by organizing a Science Day at the SNU’s Arthur Findlay Centre in 2013 that was intended to introduce the Spiritualist community to the scientific research that had been conducted on the subject of mediumship and to suggest ways in which they might adopt a more scientific approach to their own practice and experiences. Contributors included PA members Chris Roe, Elizabeth Roxburgh and Matt Smith. The event was extremely well received among practitioners, and as a consequence a ‘Science Week’ of workshops was run at Stansted Hall in 2014 that provided an opportunity for students to work with scientific methods ranging from controlled experiments incorporating EEG measures to more qualitative but still rigorous approaches including surveys and interviews. A condensed workshop programme was run at the SNUs Stafford Centre in 2015, and the authors contributed to residential weeks in 2016, 2017 and 2018. The ultimate aim of these initiatives is to encourage collaboration between the Spiritualist and scientific communities to further our understanding of the nature and phenomena of mediumship.
As a next step in the rapprochement between mediums and academics, the SNU Executive Committee agreed to convert space at the Arthur Findlay College into a permanent laboratory that could be used to conduct research with the community of mediums who attend programmes at the College. Funding from the Society for Psychical Research has enabled the space to be refurbished and for equipment to be procured. The intention is that the space would be made available to serious academics for them to conduct their own research (subject to approval from the SNU). To facilitate this, we identified a study of mediumship by Delorme, Beischel, Michel, Boccuzzi, Radin, and Mills (2013) that could showcase the technical facilities available at the lab and to encourage the wider academic community to make use of this resource.
Presented at the “62nd Annual Convention of the Parapsychological Association” on July 4, 2019, Paris, France; program chaired by Ramses D’Leon. Download the Abstracts at https://www.parapsych.org/articles/37/483/2019_pa_convention_abstracts_of.aspx
The Parapsychological Association is an international professional organization of scientists and scholars engaged in the study of psi (or psychic) experiences, such as telepathy, clairvoyance, psychokinesis, psychic healing, and precognition. The primary objective of the PA is to achieve a scientific understanding of these experiences.
A longer version of this convention video, including the Q&A period, is available to PA members-only at parapsych.org. There is a level of PA membership for everyone interested in the scientific and scholarly advancement of parapsychology. Learn more at: https://www.parapsych.org/join_the_pa.aspx
Find us:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ParapsychologicalAssociation/
Twitter - https://twitter.com/parapsych
Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/parapsychologicalassociation/
Donations to support the mission of the PA, including the funding of research initiatives, can be made by reaching office@parapsych.org or the Paypal Giving Fund: https://www.paypal.com/us/fundraiser/charity/153733
#ParisPA Mediumship Research in the 21st Century | David T. Saunders](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/ssTrGKuhn-U/mqdefault.jpg)





