Uploaded July 2024 | Updated November 2026, 4 days ago
In this video clip, world-renowned Scottish conductor and composer Sir James MacMillan and Margarita Mooney Clayton, an Associate Professor at Princeton Theological Seminary and the Founder and Executive Director of the Scala Foundation, discuss analogies between listening to music and Christian contemplative prayer.
“Lovers of music are transformed by music,” he stated. Similarly, in contemplative prayer, “you have to be open to the possibility of being changed through what happens in that silence.”
In Christian prayer, silent contemplation is a sacrifice of the self to encounter God. Similarly, with music, MacMillan described that “for complex music to speak to you, you need to open yourself to an objective authority. There’s no point in listening to a Beethoven symphony if you're going to do something else. That music is not going to reach you. Just like complex narratives in history have an authority that cannot be hurried, you must obey the structures and the timescale of these pieces of music. The listener cannot come into the presence of music in a state of defiance and resistance. You have to come in a state of openness, respect, and love.”
As with music, in contemplative prayer, “you have to sacrifice something of yourself; you have to give something of your ego. You can’t enter into the presence of God in a state of defiance and resistance. You must be open to the possibility of being changed through what happens in that silence.”
The full conversation can be seen here:
youtu.be/Gexj7JEVeS8
MacMillan spent two weeks in Princeton in June 2024 as part of a program hosted by the Catholic Sacred Music Project to provide master-apprentice training to young composers, conductors, and choristers. Scala co-sponsored the summer program. Two other conversations with MacMillan can be seen here:
youtu.be/l3dD8MT7eo8?feature=shared
and here: youtu.be/kX1F5bzYZZw
Music from the event can be seen on this playlist:
youtube.com/playlist?list=PLRZHnw30gpFcVenqvTUoK-HIvMw535_II
Learn More about The Scala Foundation
Scala was founded in 2016 by Margarita Mooney Clayton, a professor at Princeton Theological Seminary, who is the author of numerous books and popular articles, and an inspiring public speaker on topics such as education, culture, virtues and faith. Her husband, David Clayton, is an Artist-in-Residence for Scala and the Provost of Pontifex University, where he founded the Master of Sacred Arts Program. He is an internationally renowned iconographer and writer for various online publications about topics like the mathematics of beauty, liturgical art, and cultural renewal.
The Scala Foundation’s vision is to restore meaning and purpose to American culture by focusing on the intersection of art, liturgy and education Scala engages in deep work with students at Princeton and Oxford to bring together artists, students, teachers, and scholars. Scala also produces publications (books, blogs, articles, interviews), and hosts public events like conferences, webinars and campus lectures open to the public.
More Resources Can be Found on Scala’s Social Media and Websites
Scala Foundation: scalafoundation.org
David Clayton's blog and books: thewayofbeauty.org
Margarita Mooney Clayton's YouTube Channel:
youtube.com/channel/UCvvCBWH0LMe2i1-VLMaNEVQ
How to Support Scala
Find out how to donate to Scala here: scalafoundation.org/donate
The Fellowship of the Annunciation is a group of recurring donors to Scala that helps us in all our activities, notably by supporting apprenticeships for liturgical artists:
givebutter.com/fellowshipoftheannunciation
In this video clip, world-renowned Scottish conductor and composer Sir James MacMillan and Margarita Mooney Clayton, an Associate Professor at Princeton Theological Seminary and the Founder and Executive Director of the Scala Foundation, discuss analogies between listening to music and Christian contemplative prayer.
“Lovers of music are transformed by music,” he stated. Similarly, in contemplative prayer, “you have to be open to the possibility of being changed through what happens in that silence.”
In Christian prayer, silent contemplation is a sacrifice of the self to encounter God. Similarly, with music, MacMillan described that “for complex music to speak to you, you need to open yourself to an objective authority. There’s no point in listening to a Beethoven symphony if you're going to do something else. That music is not going to reach you. Just like complex narratives in history have an authority that cannot be hurried, you must obey the structures and the timescale of these pieces of music. The listener cannot come into the presence of music in a state of defiance and resistance. You have to come in a state of openness, respect, and love.”
As with music, in contemplative prayer, “you have to sacrifice something of yourself; you have to give something of your ego. You can’t enter into the presence of God in a state of defiance and resistance. You must be open to the possibility of being changed through what happens in that silence.”
The full conversation can be seen here:
youtu.be/Gexj7JEVeS8
MacMillan spent two weeks in Princeton in June 2024 as part of a program hosted by the Catholic Sacred Music Project to provide master-apprentice training to young composers, conductors, and choristers. Scala co-sponsored the summer program. Two other conversations with MacMillan can be seen here:
youtu.be/l3dD8MT7eo8?feature=shared
and here: youtu.be/kX1F5bzYZZw
Music from the event can be seen on this playlist:
youtube.com/playlist?list=PLRZHnw30gpFcVenqvTUoK-HIvMw535_II
Learn More about The Scala Foundation
Scala was founded in 2016 by Margarita Mooney Clayton, a professor at Princeton Theological Seminary, who is the author of numerous books and popular articles, and an inspiring public speaker on topics such as education, culture, virtues and faith. Her husband, David Clayton, is an Artist-in-Residence for Scala and the Provost of Pontifex University, where he founded the Master of Sacred Arts Program. He is an internationally renowned iconographer and writer for various online publications about topics like the mathematics of beauty, liturgical art, and cultural renewal.
The Scala Foundation’s vision is to restore meaning and purpose to American culture by focusing on the intersection of art, liturgy and education Scala engages in deep work with students at Princeton and Oxford to bring together artists, students, teachers, and scholars. Scala also produces publications (books, blogs, articles, interviews), and hosts public events like conferences, webinars and campus lectures open to the public.
More Resources Can be Found on Scala’s Social Media and Websites
Scala Foundation: scalafoundation.org
David Clayton's blog and books: thewayofbeauty.org
Margarita Mooney Clayton's YouTube Channel:
youtube.com/channel/UCvvCBWH0LMe2i1-VLMaNEVQ
How to Support Scala
Find out how to donate to Scala here: scalafoundation.org/donate
The Fellowship of the Annunciation is a group of recurring donors to Scala that helps us in all our activities, notably by supporting apprenticeships for liturgical artists:
givebutter.com/fellowshipoftheannunciation










