Analog or Digital | Assess and Caress with Donald Osborne | Jay Lenos Garage @jaylenosgarage
Analog or Digital | Assess and Caress with Donald Osborne | Jay Lenos Garage  @jaylenosgarage
Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
Analog or digital. Donald Osborne brings two very comfortable, very fast four-door sedans from two different eras to the Garage: a 1988 BMW M5 (E28) and a 2020 Mercedes-Maybach S560 4MATIC, both on loan from the Audrain Automobile Museum in Newport, Rhode Island.

The M5 was built by BMW's Motorsport division in limited numbers, with a manual gearbox and four-wheel disc brakes, at a time when you couldn't get a big, comfortable sedan with a stick in America. Jay calls today's Cadillac Blackwing its spiritual successor, and Donald brings up the M5 rival almost nobody remembers: the Ferrari-powered Lancia Thema 8.32.

Then the Maybach. Jay was there when Mercedes brought the name back, and he explains why the original relaunch had a "New Coke" problem, why Americans don't want to wait for a car, and what happened when Arnold Schwarzenegger took one up into the hills. Plus Honda vs. Acura, Nissan's "rocks and trees" Infiniti ads, and why US-spec bumpers are a sore subject for E28 owners.

Which sedan's value changed the most in five years? Watch to find out, then tell us in the comments: analog or digital?

Thanks to Reliable Carriers for bringing these cars out from the Audrain Automobile Museum.

Shop car care and detailing supplies from Jay Leno’s Garage: lenosgarage.com/shine

» Subscribe: bit.ly/JLGSubscribe

THE BEST OF JAY LENO'S GARAGE
» Exclusive First Looks: bit.ly/JLGExclusives
» Ultra Rare Supercars: bit.ly/JLGSupercars
» Jay's Book Club: bit.ly/JLGBookClub

JAY LENO'S GARAGE ON SOCIAL
Facebook: facebook.com/JayLenosGarage
Twitter: twitter.com/LenosGarage
Instagram: instagram.com/jaylenosgarage
TikTok: tiktok.com/@jaylenosgarageofficial

ABOUT JAY LENO'S GARAGE
A new video every Monday! Visit Jay Leno's Garage, the Emmy-winning series where Jay Leno gives car reviews, motorcycle reviews, compares cars, and shares his passion and expertise on anything that rolls, explodes, and makes noise. Classic cars, restomods, super cars like the McLaren P1, sports cars like Porsche 918 Spyder and Camaro Z28, cafe racers, vintage cars, and much, much more.
Analog or Digital | Assess and Caress with Donald Osborne | Jay Lenos GarageFERRARI IN A CADILLAC | Jay Lenos GarageWhy the Ford Jeep is the Greatest Vehicle Ever Made | Jay Lenos GarageCadillac F1 Drivers | Jay Lenos GarageHypercar Checklist | Jay Lenos GarageToo exepensive twice the price of a Nissan Z | Jay Lenos GarageThe Last Manual V8 Sedan: Why I’m Obsessed with This 900HP Cadillac CT5V | Jay Leno’s GarageCorvettes worst nightmare!!! | Jay Lenos Garage3.0L V12 Sounds Fast | Jay Lenos GarageA Gentlemans Agreement | Jay Lenos GarageJay Lenos Prankster Days... | Jay Lenos GarageJay Leno Goes Off-Road in the 544HP Polestar 4 Arctic Circle Rally EV! | Jay Lenos Garage
Jay Lenos Garage |

Analog or Digital | Assess and Caress with Donald Osborne | Jay Leno's Garage

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER