Uploaded June 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
In this episode, Carl Zha and Dr. Warwick Powell break down the growing crisis around AUKUS – the US-UK-Australia submarine deal that is rapidly unraveling. From second-hand nuclear subs to American bases on Australian soil, this is a masterclass in how the US extracts value from its "allies" while delivering nothing in return.
The New Reality in Asia
There are growing concerns that the United States is no longer a reliable defense or security partner. This isn't tomorrow's problem – the path has already been set. A new reality is emerging in Asia, and it's deeply discomforting for those who became comfortable with the old reality – whether in Taipei, Manila, Seoul, Tokyo, or Canberra.
The AUKUS Backtrack
At the Shangri-La Dialogue in Singapore, the Australian Defence Minister and Pete Hegseth announced a major change to AUKUS. Instead of new nuclear submarines, Australia will now receive possibly three "in-service vessels" – also known as second-hand boats.
This has set off a lively reaction in Australia. A former Labor Federal Minister and Midnight Oil lead singer, Peter Garrett, has announced a citizen's commission of inquiry into AUKUS – a civil society investigation in lieu of parliamentary oversight. There's no precedent for this in living memory.
Why the Original Deal Was Always Doomed
For the US to meet its own submarine targets, it would need to manufacture 2.3 Virginia-class submarines per year. The actual production rate? 1.2 to 1.3 per year – barely half of what America needs for itself.
The original AUKUS agreement always included a clause: provision of submarines to Australia was subject to the President deciding it didn't compromise America's own requirements. The submarines were never guaranteed to arrive.
The Orwellian Bureaucratese
When questioned in Senate estimates committee hearings, defense officials couldn't justify the backtrack. The original deal was described as the "optimal path." Now this is being called "constrained optimality." As one senator noted, if the first path was optimal, what does that say about this one?
Australia's Growing Tab
Australia has been:
Paying invoices to boost US submarine production (to little effect)
Financing facilities to accommodate submarines
Financing housing for American military personnel – while Australians face a housing affordability crisis
Second-Hand Subs, No Warranty
The second-hand vessels are in the tail end of their lives. Their reactors will expire. Maintenance is Australia's "sovereign responsibility" – but there's not even a warranty from the manufacturer. And when the reactors expire? Australia gets to deal with the nuclear waste.
The Capability Gap
The Collins-class submarines (Australia's current fleet) are designed for shallow waters around Australia – very different from nuclear subs. They're worn out and need to be put to pasture. The plan now? Extend their life for another five years at billions of dollars – like band-aiding a worn-out car hoping it doesn't die before the new one (that may never come) arrives.
If the nuclear boats never arrive, Australia hasn't just blown financial resources – it's blown 10 to 15 years of time to pursue real defense options.
From Security Umbrella to Extraction Racket
For four or five decades, the US provided a security umbrella and a prosperity well for its allies. Access to American markets. American capital building industries.
Not anymore. The US has shifted to extraction mode – extracting financial, personnel, and other resources from client states. And increasingly, the US is agreement incapable. You can't trust a word from any American politician.
John Mearsheimer once asked: why don't political leaders lie on the international stage? His answer: the gravity of international relations requires that leaders can at least depend on what's being said. That proposition no longer holds. Western political leaders now lie not only to their domestic populations – but to everyone else as well.
The Bottom Line
The US character in 2026 is a combination of extraction and perfidy – mistruths and misleading conduct vis-à-vis other nations, while seeking to extract its pound of flesh from its allies. The question for Australia, and for every US ally: how much national security risk are you willing to accept for a deal that may never deliver?
In this episode, Carl Zha and Dr. Warwick Powell break down the growing crisis around AUKUS – the US-UK-Australia submarine deal that is rapidly unraveling. From second-hand nuclear subs to American bases on Australian soil, this is a masterclass in how the US extracts value from its "allies" while delivering nothing in return.
The New Reality in Asia
There are growing concerns that the United States is no longer a reliable defense or security partner. This isn't tomorrow's problem – the path has already been set. A new reality is emerging in Asia, and it's deeply discomforting for those who became comfortable with the old reality – whether in Taipei, Manila, Seoul, Tokyo, or Canberra.
The AUKUS Backtrack
At the Shangri-La Dialogue in Singapore, the Australian Defence Minister and Pete Hegseth announced a major change to AUKUS. Instead of new nuclear submarines, Australia will now receive possibly three "in-service vessels" – also known as second-hand boats.
This has set off a lively reaction in Australia. A former Labor Federal Minister and Midnight Oil lead singer, Peter Garrett, has announced a citizen's commission of inquiry into AUKUS – a civil society investigation in lieu of parliamentary oversight. There's no precedent for this in living memory.
Why the Original Deal Was Always Doomed
For the US to meet its own submarine targets, it would need to manufacture 2.3 Virginia-class submarines per year. The actual production rate? 1.2 to 1.3 per year – barely half of what America needs for itself.
The original AUKUS agreement always included a clause: provision of submarines to Australia was subject to the President deciding it didn't compromise America's own requirements. The submarines were never guaranteed to arrive.
The Orwellian Bureaucratese
When questioned in Senate estimates committee hearings, defense officials couldn't justify the backtrack. The original deal was described as the "optimal path." Now this is being called "constrained optimality." As one senator noted, if the first path was optimal, what does that say about this one?
Australia's Growing Tab
Australia has been:
Paying invoices to boost US submarine production (to little effect)
Financing facilities to accommodate submarines
Financing housing for American military personnel – while Australians face a housing affordability crisis
Second-Hand Subs, No Warranty
The second-hand vessels are in the tail end of their lives. Their reactors will expire. Maintenance is Australia's "sovereign responsibility" – but there's not even a warranty from the manufacturer. And when the reactors expire? Australia gets to deal with the nuclear waste.
The Capability Gap
The Collins-class submarines (Australia's current fleet) are designed for shallow waters around Australia – very different from nuclear subs. They're worn out and need to be put to pasture. The plan now? Extend their life for another five years at billions of dollars – like band-aiding a worn-out car hoping it doesn't die before the new one (that may never come) arrives.
If the nuclear boats never arrive, Australia hasn't just blown financial resources – it's blown 10 to 15 years of time to pursue real defense options.
From Security Umbrella to Extraction Racket
For four or five decades, the US provided a security umbrella and a prosperity well for its allies. Access to American markets. American capital building industries.
Not anymore. The US has shifted to extraction mode – extracting financial, personnel, and other resources from client states. And increasingly, the US is agreement incapable. You can't trust a word from any American politician.
John Mearsheimer once asked: why don't political leaders lie on the international stage? His answer: the gravity of international relations requires that leaders can at least depend on what's being said. That proposition no longer holds. Western political leaders now lie not only to their domestic populations – but to everyone else as well.
The Bottom Line
The US character in 2026 is a combination of extraction and perfidy – mistruths and misleading conduct vis-à-vis other nations, while seeking to extract its pound of flesh from its allies. The question for Australia, and for every US ally: how much national security risk are you willing to accept for a deal that may never deliver?










