Catholic Answers | AMA: Catholicism | Catholic Answers Live | September 27, 2024 @catholiccom | Uploaded 2 weeks ago | Updated 2 hours ago
More Catholic Answers: catholic.com
Donate: givecatholic.com
TOPIC: Ask Me Anything: Catholicism
GUEST: Jimmy Akin
QUESTIONS ASKED:
00:00:00 - Waiting Music
00:00:20 - Introduction
00:03:02 - Was William Shakespeare a Recusant, or did he become a part of the Church of England at some point in his life?
00:11:43 - If our Lord instituted all Sacraments by commanding His apostles to do them and no one can usurp a Bishop or priest, if the person doesn’t have valid orders, to consecrate, give absolution, confirm, ordain, etc… then why is baptism the only sacrament where anyone can baptize another person?
00:11:44 - What exactly is the soul of a person?
00:14:47 - Is baptism the Mark of the Lamb?
00:18:19 - I’ve heard it said in support of the assumption that no Christian church has ever claimed to have Mary’s relics. Muslims claim to know where she is buried. Care to comment? We love Cy, jimmy, and the whole CA team.
00:21:47 - Would the infallibility of the Church be in doubt if it turned out that the whole Juan Diego, Our Lady of Guadalupe, etc. story was only legendary (i.e. lacked historicity)?
00:28:50 - Can Catholics watch Game of Thrones?
00:32:31 - What specifically in Thomistic metaphysics do you have the most trouble believing and why?
00:36:05 - Sikhism be said to worship the one true God?
00:38:25 - If public revelation has ended but the canonization of saints is an infallible act, does that make what the saints have revealed public revelation.
00:42:36 - Do I have to say the divine mercy as Jesus told St. Faustina or say the rosary every day as Our Lady told the children of Fatima? If I don't am I disobeying Jesus and his mother? And can private revelations contradict one another, and if so, which ones should I follow?
00:48:28 - What would someone like Lazarus’s marital status be after he was resurrected? Given that the marital bond is severed upon death would he still be obliged to his wife if he had one (or anyone else in Lazarus’s situation)
00:53:28 - Can a Protestant convert to Catholicism and be a faithful Catholic without practicing any devotion to Mary or the saints?
00:55:20 - 5-Minute Break
01:01:47 - What does a day-in-the-life of Jimmy Akin look like? I know so many of us are in awe of your depth and breadth of knowledge. It would be interesting to see how you structure your day with learning etc.
01:06:45 - It is said that Latin is especially efficacious for prayer and exorcisms because it is the official language of the church. My question is this, for an Eastern Rite Catholic, who would be under the authority of their church’s head (although the Pope’s authority is, of course, universal and preeminent) and have their own Codes of Canon Law, would the native language of that church be more efficacious or similar in efficacy to prayers in Latin? Or would this only apply to the ancient languages?
01:14:27 - What's your thoughts about whether animals and our pets can be in heaven with us or not?
01:19:00 - Does the church condone organ donation?
01:20:33 - Also should we vote for a candidate who is for abortion, when there is no one who is prolife. Should we vote for the lesser of two evils?
01:21:56 - What would you offer in scripture and the catechism to someone who identified as a furry?
01:28:43 - Given the tragic shortage of priests, what would you recommend to someone seeking a spiritual director who is having a hard time finding one?
01:32:13 - After hearing about Blessed Imelda my 9-year-old is scared that the Eucharist will kill her too. And for my own curiosity, do you know if this is a documented account or more of a pious legend?
01:37:44 - The strongest challenge I ever heard from a Protestant about the Assumption is, "How can the Catholic Church dogmatically declare that the Assumption was 'believed at all times by the Church', when there is literally no evidence anywhere in the Bible, Church Father writings or, apocryphal writings of the first Century?"
01:43:10 - What separates the "New Atheists" from the old Atheists?
01:45:31 - If there are many other planets with life, then how would they be saved? Did Christ death and resurrection count for them also and if so, how would they know. Or did God save each planet with aliens differently?
01:48:19 - What are some of the best ways to practice becoming as humble as possible, like Our Lady?
01:50:18 - Is it possible for your guardian angel to not like you or something about you? For example, maybe your guardian angel doesn’t like the same kind of music you listen to. I wonder if a guardian angel ever feels like they preferred getting someone else to guide
01:52:43 - Who would win in a fight, the Incredible Hulk or felony tax evasion?
01:53:48 - Why was it necessary for the Church to make the immaculate conception and assumption into dogmas (vs leaving them as non-mandatory for belief teachings)?
More Catholic Answers: catholic.com
Donate: givecatholic.com
TOPIC: Ask Me Anything: Catholicism
GUEST: Jimmy Akin
QUESTIONS ASKED:
00:00:00 - Waiting Music
00:00:20 - Introduction
00:03:02 - Was William Shakespeare a Recusant, or did he become a part of the Church of England at some point in his life?
00:11:43 - If our Lord instituted all Sacraments by commanding His apostles to do them and no one can usurp a Bishop or priest, if the person doesn’t have valid orders, to consecrate, give absolution, confirm, ordain, etc… then why is baptism the only sacrament where anyone can baptize another person?
00:11:44 - What exactly is the soul of a person?
00:14:47 - Is baptism the Mark of the Lamb?
00:18:19 - I’ve heard it said in support of the assumption that no Christian church has ever claimed to have Mary’s relics. Muslims claim to know where she is buried. Care to comment? We love Cy, jimmy, and the whole CA team.
00:21:47 - Would the infallibility of the Church be in doubt if it turned out that the whole Juan Diego, Our Lady of Guadalupe, etc. story was only legendary (i.e. lacked historicity)?
00:28:50 - Can Catholics watch Game of Thrones?
00:32:31 - What specifically in Thomistic metaphysics do you have the most trouble believing and why?
00:36:05 - Sikhism be said to worship the one true God?
00:38:25 - If public revelation has ended but the canonization of saints is an infallible act, does that make what the saints have revealed public revelation.
00:42:36 - Do I have to say the divine mercy as Jesus told St. Faustina or say the rosary every day as Our Lady told the children of Fatima? If I don't am I disobeying Jesus and his mother? And can private revelations contradict one another, and if so, which ones should I follow?
00:48:28 - What would someone like Lazarus’s marital status be after he was resurrected? Given that the marital bond is severed upon death would he still be obliged to his wife if he had one (or anyone else in Lazarus’s situation)
00:53:28 - Can a Protestant convert to Catholicism and be a faithful Catholic without practicing any devotion to Mary or the saints?
00:55:20 - 5-Minute Break
01:01:47 - What does a day-in-the-life of Jimmy Akin look like? I know so many of us are in awe of your depth and breadth of knowledge. It would be interesting to see how you structure your day with learning etc.
01:06:45 - It is said that Latin is especially efficacious for prayer and exorcisms because it is the official language of the church. My question is this, for an Eastern Rite Catholic, who would be under the authority of their church’s head (although the Pope’s authority is, of course, universal and preeminent) and have their own Codes of Canon Law, would the native language of that church be more efficacious or similar in efficacy to prayers in Latin? Or would this only apply to the ancient languages?
01:14:27 - What's your thoughts about whether animals and our pets can be in heaven with us or not?
01:19:00 - Does the church condone organ donation?
01:20:33 - Also should we vote for a candidate who is for abortion, when there is no one who is prolife. Should we vote for the lesser of two evils?
01:21:56 - What would you offer in scripture and the catechism to someone who identified as a furry?
01:28:43 - Given the tragic shortage of priests, what would you recommend to someone seeking a spiritual director who is having a hard time finding one?
01:32:13 - After hearing about Blessed Imelda my 9-year-old is scared that the Eucharist will kill her too. And for my own curiosity, do you know if this is a documented account or more of a pious legend?
01:37:44 - The strongest challenge I ever heard from a Protestant about the Assumption is, "How can the Catholic Church dogmatically declare that the Assumption was 'believed at all times by the Church', when there is literally no evidence anywhere in the Bible, Church Father writings or, apocryphal writings of the first Century?"
01:43:10 - What separates the "New Atheists" from the old Atheists?
01:45:31 - If there are many other planets with life, then how would they be saved? Did Christ death and resurrection count for them also and if so, how would they know. Or did God save each planet with aliens differently?
01:48:19 - What are some of the best ways to practice becoming as humble as possible, like Our Lady?
01:50:18 - Is it possible for your guardian angel to not like you or something about you? For example, maybe your guardian angel doesn’t like the same kind of music you listen to. I wonder if a guardian angel ever feels like they preferred getting someone else to guide
01:52:43 - Who would win in a fight, the Incredible Hulk or felony tax evasion?
01:53:48 - Why was it necessary for the Church to make the immaculate conception and assumption into dogmas (vs leaving them as non-mandatory for belief teachings)?
