Uploaded August 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
In this episode, we sit down with Dr. Madisson Whitman, Director of Undergraduate Studies and Assistant Director of Curriculum Development at Columbia University's Center for Science and Society, and Lecturer in the Department of Anthropology. Drawing on her work in Science and Technology Studies (STS), Whitman challenges one of the most pervasive assumptions of our moment: that AI in higher education is a foregone conclusion.
In her recent letter to the editor in the Columbia Spectator, Whitman offered a direct rebuttal to the sentiment that "AI is here to stay, so what does that mean for Columbia?" Instead, she invites us to resist the sense of "technological inevitability" that pervades so much of today's academic dialogue and to ask what we might be foreclosing when we don't question AI's presence in education.
Together, we trace the through-lines between pandemic-era surveillance, "dysfunction creep," and the quiet ways AI is being folded into the learning management systems. We also consider what it looks like to teach with AI rather than through it. Dr. Whitman reminds us that progress is never as linear as it's sold. Educators must keep learning at the center of the conversation, even when urgency and marketing do their best to crowd it out.
____________________________
Learn more about the "Dead Ideas in Teaching and Learning" podcast, and find a transcript and resources for this episode, on our website: https://ctl.columbia.edu/resources-and-technology/resources/podcast/
In this episode, we sit down with Dr. Madisson Whitman, Director of Undergraduate Studies and Assistant Director of Curriculum Development at Columbia University's Center for Science and Society, and Lecturer in the Department of Anthropology. Drawing on her work in Science and Technology Studies (STS), Whitman challenges one of the most pervasive assumptions of our moment: that AI in higher education is a foregone conclusion.
In her recent letter to the editor in the Columbia Spectator, Whitman offered a direct rebuttal to the sentiment that "AI is here to stay, so what does that mean for Columbia?" Instead, she invites us to resist the sense of "technological inevitability" that pervades so much of today's academic dialogue and to ask what we might be foreclosing when we don't question AI's presence in education.
Together, we trace the through-lines between pandemic-era surveillance, "dysfunction creep," and the quiet ways AI is being folded into the learning management systems. We also consider what it looks like to teach with AI rather than through it. Dr. Whitman reminds us that progress is never as linear as it's sold. Educators must keep learning at the center of the conversation, even when urgency and marketing do their best to crowd it out.
____________________________
Learn more about the "Dead Ideas in Teaching and Learning" podcast, and find a transcript and resources for this episode, on our website: https://ctl.columbia.edu/resources-and-technology/resources/podcast/




![Navigating HOT Moments in the Classroom | Columbia CTL
This video offers strategies for navigating heated, offensive, and tense (HOT) moments in the classroom. Strategies are presented within a response framework to identify what instructors can do before a class, either prior to or at the very beginning of a new semester, during the class, as the HOT moment occurs, or after the class, following a HOT moment. Throughout the video, there are shared guided reflective prompts, example phrases, and questions to consider.
[00:00 - 00:55]: Introduction
[00:55 - 04:32]: Before – strategies for before the semester begins
[04:33 - 07:26]: Before – strategies for early in the semester
[07:27 - 11:57]: During – strategies for responding as a HOT moment occurs
[11:28 - end]: After – strategies for following up after a HOT Moment
Find related resources on the Columbia University Center for Teaching and Learning website: http://ctl.columbia.edu Navigating HOT Moments in the Classroom | Columbia CTL](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/yY88npBpJyo/mqdefault.jpg)