Uploaded August 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 hour ago
I love a shanty mystery, especially one with an Irish connection. I have sung 'Leave her Johnny', but Carl Sandburg, in his 1927 book 'The American Songbag' claims that this song 'Across the Western Ocean' pre-dates 'Leave Her' and gave the tune to it. Furthermore, he claims this was an Irish emigrant song from around the time of the Irish Famine caused by the English in 1845:
archive.org/details/americansongbag0000carl
Unfortunately, Sandburn cites the Robert Winslow Gordon collection as the source, which is sadly not online.
Some of the lines overlap with The Blackball Line, here in Lubbock:
archive.org/details/westernoceanpack0000basi
and here in an article by Meade Minnigerode in 1921:
archive.org/details/newoutlook1271unse/page/174
and here:
archive.org/details/rollgosongsofame0000colc
The Western Ocean version appears in Whall in 1920:
archive.org/details/seasongsshanties00whal
And in Iron Men and Wooden Ships in 1924:
archive.org/details/iron-men-and-wooden-ships
So the mystery is, what evidence supports this being an earlier song, and the source of the melody to 'Leave her Johnny'.
Purchase my music:
ozfolklounge.bandcamp.com
Website (Lyrics and Chords):
folklounge.org/lyrics-and-chords
I love a shanty mystery, especially one with an Irish connection. I have sung 'Leave her Johnny', but Carl Sandburg, in his 1927 book 'The American Songbag' claims that this song 'Across the Western Ocean' pre-dates 'Leave Her' and gave the tune to it. Furthermore, he claims this was an Irish emigrant song from around the time of the Irish Famine caused by the English in 1845:
archive.org/details/americansongbag0000carl
Unfortunately, Sandburn cites the Robert Winslow Gordon collection as the source, which is sadly not online.
Some of the lines overlap with The Blackball Line, here in Lubbock:
archive.org/details/westernoceanpack0000basi
and here in an article by Meade Minnigerode in 1921:
archive.org/details/newoutlook1271unse/page/174
and here:
archive.org/details/rollgosongsofame0000colc
The Western Ocean version appears in Whall in 1920:
archive.org/details/seasongsshanties00whal
And in Iron Men and Wooden Ships in 1924:
archive.org/details/iron-men-and-wooden-ships
So the mystery is, what evidence supports this being an earlier song, and the source of the melody to 'Leave her Johnny'.
Purchase my music:
ozfolklounge.bandcamp.com
Website (Lyrics and Chords):
folklounge.org/lyrics-and-chords


![King Orfeo [ Child Ballad No. 19 ]
Only one variant in the Francis Child collection, and it is mostly in Norn:
https://archive.org/details/englishscottishp01chil_0/page/216/mode/2up
I had to look up the Norn language to try and make an understandable version of this:
https://archive.org/details/anetymodictofthenornlanginshet
Im not sold on the assertion that this is a retelling of the Orpheus and Eurydice story. I think the fairies stole my wife is common in Celtic mythology separate to the Greek myth.
Thumbnail is Joseph Patrick Haverty The Blind Piper (or possible a copy of it).
Purchase my music:
https://ozfolklounge.bandcamp.com/
Website (Lyrics and Chords):
https://www.folklounge.org/lyrics-and-chords/ King Orfeo [ Child Ballad No. 19 ]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/gJKrl8m71AM/mqdefault.jpg)







