Uploaded February 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
On January 7, 2026, an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agent named Jonathan Ross fatally shot Renee Good in the course of ICE’s deployment to Minneapolis to conduct immigration enforcement operations. Three weeks later, on January 24, ICE agents shot and killed Alex Pretti, another Minneapolis resident.
In the hours and days following each event, video footage capturing the shootings from different angles proliferated, sparking protests in Minneapolis and other American cities. A national conversation about ICE, President Trump’s immigration enforcement tactics, and the limits of federal authority followed. Were officers’ uses of force legal? Are ICE immigration raids in major metropolitan areas justified? Are protesters unlawfully obstructing federal agents in the execution of their duties? Should ICE be abolished, or is it necessary?
Follow along with the highlights on this Braver Angels debate here. Or view either (or both) rooms' full recording at the links below
Room 1: youtu.be/az0OfGfq6Xc
Room 2: youtu.be/9hZqXareunM
Join us at braverangels.org
On January 7, 2026, an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agent named Jonathan Ross fatally shot Renee Good in the course of ICE’s deployment to Minneapolis to conduct immigration enforcement operations. Three weeks later, on January 24, ICE agents shot and killed Alex Pretti, another Minneapolis resident.
In the hours and days following each event, video footage capturing the shootings from different angles proliferated, sparking protests in Minneapolis and other American cities. A national conversation about ICE, President Trump’s immigration enforcement tactics, and the limits of federal authority followed. Were officers’ uses of force legal? Are ICE immigration raids in major metropolitan areas justified? Are protesters unlawfully obstructing federal agents in the execution of their duties? Should ICE be abolished, or is it necessary?
Follow along with the highlights on this Braver Angels debate here. Or view either (or both) rooms' full recording at the links below
Room 1: youtu.be/az0OfGfq6Xc
Room 2: youtu.be/9hZqXareunM
Join us at braverangels.org










