A Twist on Nob Yoshigaharas Classic Decoy Puzzle @polymathematic
A Twist on Nob Yoshigaharas Classic Decoy Puzzle  @polymathematic
Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 days ago
What number belongs in the circle with the question mark? And no, the 9 in the last circle is not a mistake.

Check out the channel! @polymathematic

The puzzle is a chain of circles, each one fed by the circle before it and a new number on the side. Most people spot a pattern almost immediately. 792 divided by 33 is 24. 360 divided by 24 is exactly 15. Two in a row is a coincidence, but three's a trend, so the question mark should be 105 divided by 15, which is 7. Better still, that 7 keeps working: 91 divided by 7 is 13. Everything lines up beautifully, right up until the last step, where 104 divided by 13 is 8 and the circle says 9.

That 9 isn't a typo. The problem is that division was never the rule. It was a decoy.

The real rule treats the numbers as strings of digits rather than as quantities. Add up every digit in each row. In the first row, 3 + 3 from the 33, plus 7 + 9 + 2 from the 792, makes 24. In the next row, 2 + 4 + 3 + 6 + 0 makes 15. Follow the same rule into the mystery row and you get 1 + 5 + 1 + 0 + 5 = 12. Then check it: 1 + 2 + 9 + 1 = 13, and at the very end, 1 + 3 + 1 + 0 + 4 = 9. There's the 9.

The puzzle is a twist on a classic by the Japanese puzzle master Nob Yoshigahara. In his version, the decoy is subtraction instead of division: 99 minus 72 is 27, 45 minus 27 is 18, and the pattern holds right until the last circle, which says 7 where subtraction wants 8. The digit sum resolves that conflict too, and the missing number is also 12. This version was built by Rob Tanniru of Write Words Make Magic (@WriteWordsMakeMagic ) who swapped Nob's subtraction for division and went on to make a whole family of these puzzles, each with a different decoy.

Is it suspicious that two completely different rules can agree for four steps and then split apart at exactly the last moment? It feels like it should be nearly impossible to arrange. But look at it from the puzzle maker's side of the table. The maker gets to choose the numbers on the right-hand side, and there are infinitely many possible rules that could connect one circle to the next. With that much freedom, you can make almost any two rules agree for as long as you like and then disagree exactly when you want them to. The real craft is in choosing a decoy that's tempting enough to grab you and a true rule that's satisfying once you see it.

How would you build your own decoy puzzle?

#mathpuzzle #logicpuzzle #puzzles

Watch more Math Videos:
Math Minis: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jkQynJ5heNvSs72gCPj_hwj
Math Minutes: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jmVFYwHiuMzCYJ0y_yiwUge
Number Sense: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jksKkY_oarNFEFAHjrIV97U
MATHCOUNTS: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jlqDkZXtby9lnEaOBy7-ZY0

Follow Tim Ricchuiti:
TikTok: tiktok.com/@polymathematic
Mathstodon: https://mathstodon.xyz/@polymathematic
Instagram: instagram.com/polymathematicnet
Reddit: reddit.com/user/polymath-matic
Facebook: facebook.com/polymathematic
A Twist on Nob Yoshigaharas Classic Decoy PuzzleWhy You Don’t Always Need to Solve for XWhy 1 Isn’t a Prime Number (and Cant Be)How Thin Are Those Layers? Wedging Clay for MillionsWill GLP-1s Help Americans Lose 135 Billion Pounds? Let’s Do the Math.Lightsabers, Traffic Cones, and the Secret Shapes of Conic SectionsThe 100-Year-Old Algebra Question with a Surprisingly Simple SolutionWhy Its the Rule of 72 (and Not 69.3)The Fibonacci Secret Behind the Missing Square Puzzle #SoME5Algebra Without X: How to Solve Problems VisuallyThe One Way to Arrange NothingConic Sections Explained: What a Traffic Cone and a Lightsaber Can Teach You About Math
polymathematic |

A Twist on Nob Yoshigahara's Classic Decoy Puzzle

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER