A Skeptical Analysis of the 1917 Marian Apparitions and Miracle of the Sun @JamesFodor
A Skeptical Analysis of the 1917 Marian Apparitions and Miracle of the Sun  @JamesFodor
Uploaded June 2026 | Updated September 2026, 2 days ago
An analysis of the Marian apparitions at Fatima in 1917. I discuss both the appearances to the children and the subsequent 'miracle of the sun'. I highlight the likely roles of psychological factors such as religious absorption, suggestibility, and expectation and generating the Marian apparitions to the young children. I suggest that the reports of strange solar phenomena can be explained as optical illusions caused by high-altitude clouds and afterimages.

This video is a partial response to the blog post by Ethan Muse: motivacredibilitatis.substack.com/p/our-lady-of-fatima

Link the DCF document (Portugese): https://www.fatima.pt/files/upload/fontes/F001_DCF_selecao.pdf
A Skeptical Analysis of the 1917 Marian Apparitions and Miracle of the SunActual Reasons to be an Atheist - Responding to Capturing Christianity (again!)Heres what Craig will say about the Kalam Documentary...Responding to Inspiring Philosophy about Digital Physics and GodThe Case Against Theism - Refuting the Resurrection ArgumentInspiring Philosophy Still Misrepresents ScienceCameron asked about miracle claims. I answered.Reviewing Capturing Christianity on Prophecy, Incarnation, and the TrinityCar Chat 3: Lets Ground Morality without GodThe Problem of Evil - James Fodor vs Adi PurushaA Message for William Lane Craig (and other apologists)Post-Hospital Counter-Apologetics: Defeating Theism with One Arm and One Leg
James Fodor |

A Skeptical Analysis of the 1917 Marian Apparitions and Miracle of the Sun

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER