Uploaded September 2026 | Updated November 2026, 4 days ago
Dying messiah before Christianity? Dr. Richard Carrier joins Godless Engineer to present his case that some pre-Christian Jews could have expected a suffering and dying messiah.
Author’s publication announcement: https://godless.show/JewishExpectationsOfADyingMessiah
This guest presentation examines Jewish messianism, the Dead Sea Scrolls, and Christian origins through Carrier’s scholarly survey. He discusses Isaiah 53, Daniel 9, the Melchizedek scroll (11Q13), later Talmudic traditions, and arguments associated with John Collins, Bart Ehrman, and George Brooke. Along the way, he separates historical probability from plausibility and explains why this argument alone does not establish that Jesus never existed. The presentation closes with Brooke’s work and Carrier’s assessment of the evidence; the Q&A is not included here.
Subscribe for evidence-first conversations about biblical scholarship and Christian origins, so you can stand up and use your voice.
Paper discussed: Richard Carrier, “Did Any Pre-Christian Jews Expect a Dying-and-Rising Messiah?” Canadian-American Theological Review, vol. 14 (2025).
#JesusMythicism #ChristianOrigins #CounterApologetics
Original Video:
🔗 RELATED
▶️ Carrier vs Ehrman: “Did Jesus Really Exist?” Course Gets SHREDDED 🔥 — https://godless.show/CarrierShredsDidJesusReallyExistCourse
▶️ Two Mythicists Prove Mythicism Isn't a Conspiracy—Caller Gets DESTROYED 🤯 — https://godless.show/ProvingMythicismIsntAConspiracy
▶️ Do THESE Religious Artifacts Prove Jesus Historically Existed??? — https://godless.show/ReligiousArtifactsProveJesusExisted
Follow me everywhere:
🐦 Threads: https://godless.show/GEOnThreads
📘 Facebook: https://godless.show/GEOnFacebook
💬 Discord: https://godless.show/JoinGEDiscord
🎞️ Main Channel: https://godless.show/SubToGEOnYoutube
Join the Skeptic Mafia: https://godless.show/JoinTheSkepticMafia
Chapters
===============================
00:00 - Could a Dying Messiah Predate Christianity?
07:19 - The Paper’s Actual Thesis
11:02 - Three Claims Carrier Is NOT Making
14:39 - Carrier’s Survey of the Scholarship
17:54 - John Collins and the Dating Dispute
19:27 - Carrier Challenges Ehrman’s Argument
22:52 - Isaiah 53, Daniel 9 and Jewish Interpretation
25:33 - The Melchizedek Scroll: 11Q13
27:16 - Probably True vs. Plausibly Possible
30:36 - Why the Paper Focuses on the Messiah’s Death
32:29 - Does Daniel 9:25 or 9:26 Change the Case?
36:47 - Can the Talmud Preserve Earlier Traditions?
41:17 - George Brooke and Carrier’s Closing Case
Get Jesus From Outerspace Audiobook: https://godless.show/GetJesusFromOuterSpaceAudiobook
Merch
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Download CHRESTUS: ge.hopp.to/CHRESTUS
Get your "Citation Fucking Needed" Shirt: ge.hopp.to/citationfuckingneeded
"got evidence?" shirt: ge.hopp.to/GotEvidenceShirt
"btw, evolution is a fact" shirt: ge.hopp.to/BTWEvolutionIsAFact
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dying messiah before Christianity? Dr. Richard Carrier joins Godless Engineer to present his case that some pre-Christian Jews could have expected a suffering and dying messiah.
Author’s publication announcement: https://godless.show/JewishExpectationsOfADyingMessiah
This guest presentation examines Jewish messianism, the Dead Sea Scrolls, and Christian origins through Carrier’s scholarly survey. He discusses Isaiah 53, Daniel 9, the Melchizedek scroll (11Q13), later Talmudic traditions, and arguments associated with John Collins, Bart Ehrman, and George Brooke. Along the way, he separates historical probability from plausibility and explains why this argument alone does not establish that Jesus never existed. The presentation closes with Brooke’s work and Carrier’s assessment of the evidence; the Q&A is not included here.
Subscribe for evidence-first conversations about biblical scholarship and Christian origins, so you can stand up and use your voice.
Paper discussed: Richard Carrier, “Did Any Pre-Christian Jews Expect a Dying-and-Rising Messiah?” Canadian-American Theological Review, vol. 14 (2025).
#JesusMythicism #ChristianOrigins #CounterApologetics
Original Video:
🔗 RELATED
▶️ Carrier vs Ehrman: “Did Jesus Really Exist?” Course Gets SHREDDED 🔥 — https://godless.show/CarrierShredsDidJesusReallyExistCourse
▶️ Two Mythicists Prove Mythicism Isn't a Conspiracy—Caller Gets DESTROYED 🤯 — https://godless.show/ProvingMythicismIsntAConspiracy
▶️ Do THESE Religious Artifacts Prove Jesus Historically Existed??? — https://godless.show/ReligiousArtifactsProveJesusExisted
Follow me everywhere:
🐦 Threads: https://godless.show/GEOnThreads
📘 Facebook: https://godless.show/GEOnFacebook
💬 Discord: https://godless.show/JoinGEDiscord
🎞️ Main Channel: https://godless.show/SubToGEOnYoutube
Join the Skeptic Mafia: https://godless.show/JoinTheSkepticMafia
Chapters
===============================
00:00 - Could a Dying Messiah Predate Christianity?
07:19 - The Paper’s Actual Thesis
11:02 - Three Claims Carrier Is NOT Making
14:39 - Carrier’s Survey of the Scholarship
17:54 - John Collins and the Dating Dispute
19:27 - Carrier Challenges Ehrman’s Argument
22:52 - Isaiah 53, Daniel 9 and Jewish Interpretation
25:33 - The Melchizedek Scroll: 11Q13
27:16 - Probably True vs. Plausibly Possible
30:36 - Why the Paper Focuses on the Messiah’s Death
32:29 - Does Daniel 9:25 or 9:26 Change the Case?
36:47 - Can the Talmud Preserve Earlier Traditions?
41:17 - George Brooke and Carrier’s Closing Case
Get Jesus From Outerspace Audiobook: https://godless.show/GetJesusFromOuterSpaceAudiobook
Merch
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Download CHRESTUS: ge.hopp.to/CHRESTUS
Get your "Citation Fucking Needed" Shirt: ge.hopp.to/citationfuckingneeded
"got evidence?" shirt: ge.hopp.to/GotEvidenceShirt
"btw, evolution is a fact" shirt: ge.hopp.to/BTWEvolutionIsAFact
----------------------------------------------------------------------------










