Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 12 hours ago
An AI narration of the article 'A Critique of Roderick Long's Comments on Circumcision' by Jake Desyllas.
Libertarians hold every institution to a single test: does it violate objective property rights? Tradition, popularity and widespread acceptance are all beside the point — chattel slavery was ancient and universal, taxation is popular, and neither survives the test. So what happens when that test is applied to circumcision? Very few libertarian philosophers have taken up the question at all. Roderick Long is one of the few who touched it, in a passage condemning the genital cutting of girls as abusive, insisting on the word "mutilation" for it, and refusing to treat a grown woman's later endorsement as consent. Every one of those arguments applies just as directly to boys. This episode asks why Long stops short of saying so — and what that reticence tells us about the responsibilities of a libertarian philosopher.
Chapters:
0:00 Introduction 2:09 Roderick Long's Comment 2:51 Unpacking Long's Argument 5:10 The Philosopher's Responsibility
First published at jakedesyllas.com/blog/2025/9/10/a-critique-of-roderick-longs-comments-on-circumcision on 10 September 2025.
An AI narration of the article 'A Critique of Roderick Long's Comments on Circumcision' by Jake Desyllas.
Libertarians hold every institution to a single test: does it violate objective property rights? Tradition, popularity and widespread acceptance are all beside the point — chattel slavery was ancient and universal, taxation is popular, and neither survives the test. So what happens when that test is applied to circumcision? Very few libertarian philosophers have taken up the question at all. Roderick Long is one of the few who touched it, in a passage condemning the genital cutting of girls as abusive, insisting on the word "mutilation" for it, and refusing to treat a grown woman's later endorsement as consent. Every one of those arguments applies just as directly to boys. This episode asks why Long stops short of saying so — and what that reticence tells us about the responsibilities of a libertarian philosopher.
Chapters:
0:00 Introduction 2:09 Roderick Long's Comment 2:51 Unpacking Long's Argument 5:10 The Philosopher's Responsibility
First published at jakedesyllas.com/blog/2025/9/10/a-critique-of-roderick-longs-comments-on-circumcision on 10 September 2025.










