Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 16 hours ago
## The Case for Credobaptism: Why Faith Precedes Immersion
The doctrine of baptism is a cornerstone of Christian practice, but its application has been a subject of much discussion. This recent discussion, drawing from the works of Gary Crompton and Fred Malone, dives deep into the concept of **credobaptism** (baptism of believers) and contrasts it with paedobaptism (infant baptism).
Here's a breakdown of the key arguments presented:
**1. New Testament Data is Paramount:**
The Westminster Confession itself states that New Testament data determines who should be baptized. While Old Testament teachings remain binding unless abrogated, the New Testament authors clearly abrogate practices like circumcision.
**2. No Infant Baptism in the New Testament:**
Crucially, the Westminster Confession, chapter 2, finds no example of infant baptism in the New Testament. Every recorded water baptism in the New Testament is of believers, disciples, or confessors. The command is consistently: repent and be baptized, or believe and be baptized – never the reverse.
**3. The "Covenant of Grace" Misconception:**
The idea of a single "covenant of grace" with two administrations (Old and New Covenants) is not explicitly stated in scripture. Hebrews 8 highlights the incompleteness of the first covenant, necessitating a second. Entrance into the New Covenant is by being born again, through faith and repentance.
**4. Faith and Repentance are the Prerequisites:**
The Church of England, theologians like Karl Barth and Charles Hodge, all agree that New Testament baptism follows conscious faith and repentance. Baptism is an *answer* to the divine certainty and authority of the word already heard and accepted in faith. It's an appointed way to profess faith in Christ and allegiance.
**5. The Argument from Silence is a Fallacy:**
The case for infant baptism relies solely on an argument from silence – the absence of explicit prohibition. However, the New Testament's silence on infant baptism, when commands for baptism are so clear (repent and be baptized), strongly implies it is not to be practiced. If it were intended, it would have been explicitly stated.
**6. John the Baptist and Jesus' Ministry:**
John the Baptist's ministry marked a transition from the Old to the New Covenant. His baptism required repentance and confession of sins, and Abrahamic descent was not a qualification. Jesus himself emphasized a change of heart and repentance for entering the new covenant.
**7. The Great Commission:**
The Great Commission commands the baptism of *believers*. While children of believers who later profess faith should be baptized, the initial command is for those who have made a credible profession of faith.
**Key Takeaways:**
* **New Testament precedent is clear:** All New Testament baptisms are of believers, disciples, or confessors.
* **Faith and repentance precede baptism:** This is a consistent theme across various theological interpretations.
* **The absence of infant baptism is significant:** Scripture's silence on the matter is a strong indicator against its practice.
* **The New Covenant is based on personal faith:** Entrance is through grace by faith in the Messiah, not through lineage or ritual.
This discussion underscores the importance of grounding our practices in the clear teachings of Scripture, prioritizing the believer's conscious faith and repentance as the foundation for baptism.
#Credobaptism #baptism #theology #christianfaith #newtestament #faith #repentance #disciple #greatcommission
## The Case for Credobaptism: Why Faith Precedes Immersion
The doctrine of baptism is a cornerstone of Christian practice, but its application has been a subject of much discussion. This recent discussion, drawing from the works of Gary Crompton and Fred Malone, dives deep into the concept of **credobaptism** (baptism of believers) and contrasts it with paedobaptism (infant baptism).
Here's a breakdown of the key arguments presented:
**1. New Testament Data is Paramount:**
The Westminster Confession itself states that New Testament data determines who should be baptized. While Old Testament teachings remain binding unless abrogated, the New Testament authors clearly abrogate practices like circumcision.
**2. No Infant Baptism in the New Testament:**
Crucially, the Westminster Confession, chapter 2, finds no example of infant baptism in the New Testament. Every recorded water baptism in the New Testament is of believers, disciples, or confessors. The command is consistently: repent and be baptized, or believe and be baptized – never the reverse.
**3. The "Covenant of Grace" Misconception:**
The idea of a single "covenant of grace" with two administrations (Old and New Covenants) is not explicitly stated in scripture. Hebrews 8 highlights the incompleteness of the first covenant, necessitating a second. Entrance into the New Covenant is by being born again, through faith and repentance.
**4. Faith and Repentance are the Prerequisites:**
The Church of England, theologians like Karl Barth and Charles Hodge, all agree that New Testament baptism follows conscious faith and repentance. Baptism is an *answer* to the divine certainty and authority of the word already heard and accepted in faith. It's an appointed way to profess faith in Christ and allegiance.
**5. The Argument from Silence is a Fallacy:**
The case for infant baptism relies solely on an argument from silence – the absence of explicit prohibition. However, the New Testament's silence on infant baptism, when commands for baptism are so clear (repent and be baptized), strongly implies it is not to be practiced. If it were intended, it would have been explicitly stated.
**6. John the Baptist and Jesus' Ministry:**
John the Baptist's ministry marked a transition from the Old to the New Covenant. His baptism required repentance and confession of sins, and Abrahamic descent was not a qualification. Jesus himself emphasized a change of heart and repentance for entering the new covenant.
**7. The Great Commission:**
The Great Commission commands the baptism of *believers*. While children of believers who later profess faith should be baptized, the initial command is for those who have made a credible profession of faith.
**Key Takeaways:**
* **New Testament precedent is clear:** All New Testament baptisms are of believers, disciples, or confessors.
* **Faith and repentance precede baptism:** This is a consistent theme across various theological interpretations.
* **The absence of infant baptism is significant:** Scripture's silence on the matter is a strong indicator against its practice.
* **The New Covenant is based on personal faith:** Entrance is through grace by faith in the Messiah, not through lineage or ritual.
This discussion underscores the importance of grounding our practices in the clear teachings of Scripture, prioritizing the believer's conscious faith and repentance as the foundation for baptism.
#Credobaptism #baptism #theology #christianfaith #newtestament #faith #repentance #disciple #greatcommission










