Uploaded December 2022 | Updated September 2026, 1 week ago

---

More than simply, “in tune” or “out of tune” a temperament is a solution to the ancient problem of creating a circle out of a spiral. By the time Bach had his shake at this problem, the musical world had advanced far enough, setting the stage for his great mind to create a well-tempered solution that allowed him to compose in all 24 keys. Not all keys sound the same in the vast majority of temperaments, in fact, in only our modern equal-tempered one do we find all keys equal. Does our insistence on this system destroy the whole point of temperament? Or is it the most perfect arrangement of tones? 



Plus: 



-Actually listen to a pythagorean comma, the root of the problem...



-The circle of (pure) fifths



-Bach chorales in different temperaments



-The Art of Fugue, 6th fugue in a funky temperament



 



Try the frequencies experiment yourself! 



Pull up multiple windows on: onlinetonegenerator.com



 



Support us:



patreon.com/wtfbach



paypal.me/wtfbach



venmo.com/wtfbach



https://cash.app/$wtfbach



 



Complaints? Confusions? Want to sponsor us?



Write us:



bach (at) wtfbach (dot) com



 


Get full access to WTF Bach? at wtfbach.substack.com/subscribe (wtfbach.substack.com/subscribe?utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=CTA_4)