The Devils Advocates
The police department could have apprehended Rex Heuermann, the suspect, years ago. They possessed information pinpointing his location and vehicle. They knew he lived in Massapequa or Massapequa Park, yet failed to act on crucial leads. #RexHeuermann #MassapequaPark #truecrime #investigation #police
updated 1 year ago
From how we approach evidence and unanswered questions, to the way we handle sensitive material, victims, families, disagreement, and the broader true-crime community, there are certain principles that guide the way we cover cases.
Tonight, we’ll talk about those principles, the goals behind Devil’s Advocates, and what viewers can expect from us moving forward.
This isn’t about telling anyone else how to run their platform. It’s about explaining who we are, what matters to us, and the standards we want to hold ourselves to.
Join us LIVE for an open conversation about The DA Mission: What We Stand For.
Question Everything. Follow the Evidence.
🕘 Live at 5PM PST / 8PM EST.
Broken Plea by Christopher Whitcomb affiliate link: amzn.to/41PJurM
The Devil at His Elbow: amzn.to/4icJkUB
Records Requests Fees Go Fund me: gofund.me/baecf3ecb
One Nation Under Blackmail affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
John Grisham's "Framed" affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
Devil’s Advocates Original Music: open.spotify.com/playlist/7rJadHA7AnceZ7sCkCc99g?si=ca4feca3564a45b2&nd=1&dlsi=500c25a34fb94b9a
Check out my new Insta360 Ace Pro 2 Camera at the affiliate link: amzn.to/46W8eSH
Devil’s Advocates’ Venmo: https://account.venmo.com/u/devilsadv...
Devil’s Advocates’ Cash App: https://cash.app/$DevilsAdvocates2024
#CrimesAfterDark #DevilsAdvocates #TrueCrime #TrueCrimeCommunity
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6322776415535104
In this video, I break down the latest account of what allegedly happened that night, including new details from the young girl and her family, the confrontation involving Horsch’s green Jeep, his arrest, his Municipal Court conviction, and the unusual Pennsylvania procedure that allowed him to seek an entirely new trial in the Court of Common Pleas.
But the legal history may only be part of the story.
The original case was later expunged, critical records are difficult to obtain, and we are now trying to determine what documentation still exists — and whether some of it could be destroyed before the public ever gets a chance to see it.
We’ll examine:
What the new witnesses say happened in 2009
How Horsch was initially convicted
Why that conviction did not ultimately stand
What a Pennsylvania “trial de novo” actually meant
Why the victim would have been required to testify again
How the prosecution ultimately collapsed
What records may still exist
Our ongoing effort to preserve and obtain those records
The new questions this raises about Horsch’s history
As always, we’ll separate documented facts, witness accounts, unresolved questions, and speculation.
What happened in 2009 may matter much more today than anyone realized at the time.
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6322776415535104
Horsch claimed that the 2009 child-luring case that led to his conviction was essentially a misunderstanding — an innocent interaction that police and prosecutors interpreted in the worst possible way.
And I believed him.
Now, newly uncovered records are forcing me to go back and reconsider that story.
In this video, we dig into the actual circumstances surrounding the child-luring incident, what police said happened, what investigators reportedly found in Horsch’s vehicle, and how the case unfolded while he was still living at the Chalfont property that would be raided only months later.
We’ll also examine a larger question that has become increasingly important as new information continues to emerge:
If R.C. Horsch was able to make this incident sound innocent, how much of the rest of the story he told about his life should we now be questioning?
This is not about assuming guilt beyond what the evidence establishes. It is about comparing Horsch’s own version of events against the records that are now becoming available.
And in this case, those records tell a much more complicated story.
We’ll look at:
• The 2009 child-luring incident
• Horsch’s explanation of what happened
• What police reportedly found in his vehicle
• His eventual conviction
• The connection in time to the Chalfont house raid
• The unexplained walk-in safe built into the property
• And what these new records may tell us about the credibility of Horsch’s other claims
As always, we separate what is established, what is disputed, and what remains unknown.
#RCHorsch #RaymondHorsch #TrueCrime #Philadelphia #ChildLuring #DevilsAdvocates
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6322776415535104
In this video, I break down the images reportedly taken inside the property after foreclosure, including the unusual items found throughout the house, the basement, and one feature that immediately stands out: a heavy, sealed vault or panic-room-style space.
What was it used for? What, if anything, could still be behind it? And why has this property become increasingly important as investigators continue examining R.C. Horsch’s past?
We’ll go photo by photo, separate what we actually know from speculation, and look at why these images could matter to the broader Horsch investigation.
The photographs were reportedly taken in 2010 by Dave Speldos while working on the property and were later provided to law enforcement.
⚠️ Important: There is currently no public evidence establishing that the vault contains human remains, evidence of a homicide, or anything connected to the missing women investigation. Those questions remain unresolved.
If you’ve been following the Horsch case, this is one of the clearest looks yet at the Chalfont property during the period immediately following Horsch’s occupancy.
The Devil’s Advocates
True Crime • Real Questions • No Limits
devilsadvocates.info
#RCHorsch #EugeneHorsch #Chalfont #TrueCrime #Philadelphia #HouseOfHorrors
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6322776415535104
According to the Inquirer, multiple sources say Horsch had access to the crematorium, reportedly through an employee known as “George,” and that he photographed and filmed actual human remains there.
Investigators are now revisiting that history as part of the ongoing investigation into the women connected to 417 West Chew Avenue, where five urns containing cremated remains were recovered — two of which remained unidentified at the latest police briefing.
We’ll walk through the disturbing history of Liberty Cremations and the Garzone operation, what we know about Horsch’s reported access, who “George” may have been, the timeline, and why investigators are looking at this history now.
Most importantly, we’ll separate what has actually been established from what is based on witness accounts and sources — and examine the questions that remain unanswered.
IN THIS VIDEO:
📌 The new Philadelphia Inquirer investigation and its key revelations
📌 Horsch’s reported access to a Kensington crematorium
📌 Who “George” was and what sources say about his role
📌 The Liberty Cremations / Garzone body-parts scandal involving more than 240 corpses
📌 Horsch’s 2014 Papermill exhibition and footage involving human remains
📌 Five urns recovered at 417 W. Chew Avenue — two still unidentified at the latest briefing
📌 Why investigators are examining the crematorium connection now
📌 The timeline and why the dates matter
📌 What is confirmed, what is reported, and what we still don’t know
IMPORTANT: There is currently no evidence that Horsch participated in the Garzone body-parts trafficking operation, nor is there evidence that the missing women at the center of the current investigation were taken to Liberty Cremations. The known timelines make such a direct connection problematic. We discuss the evidence and those limitations in detail.
READ THE PHILADELPHIA INQUIRER REPORT:
inquirer.com/news/raymond-horsch-missing-women-kensington-bodies-crematorium-20260921.html
FOLLOW OUR HORSCH RESEARCH & MASTER TIMELINE:
devilsadvocates.info
This is a developing investigation. We’ll continue following new court filings, police announcements, public records and credible reporting as additional information becomes available.
⚠️ This video is presented for news, educational, research and commentary purposes. Allegations and reported information are identified as such. Everyone accused of a crime is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in a court of law.
If you enjoy true crime coverage built around original research, primary documents, critical thinking and asking the uncomfortable questions, please LIKE, COMMENT and SUBSCRIBE.
THE DEVIL’S ADVOCATES
True Crime. Real Questions. No Limits.
#Horsch #RCHorsch #EugeneHorsch #PhillyHouseOfHorrors #TrueCrime #Philadelphia #LibertyCremations #Garzone #Kensington #MissingWomen #417WestChew #DevilsAdvocates
At the center of it is a $400 million claim and a newly filed legal document arguing that the plaintiffs’ negligence theory fails as a matter of law. I’ll walk through the filing in plain English, explain what WSU means when it argues there was no legally actionable duty based on alleged nonfeasance, and look at why the university is asking the court to dismiss the lawsuit with prejudice.
We’ll review the actual legal arguments, separate what the filing claims from what has actually been decided, and discuss just how significant this motion could be for the Goncalves family’s case.
Tonight we’re covering: the $400M demand, WSU’s motion to dismiss, the negligence/nonfeasance argument, what “with prejudice” actually means, and whether this lawsuit could potentially be thrown out before discovery and a trial ever happen.
Crimes After Dark — legal documents, receipts, and the details behind the headlines.
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6322776415535104
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6322776415535104
Records Requests Fees Go Fund me: gofund.me/baecf3ecb
One Nation Under Blackmail affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
John Grisham's "Framed" affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
Devil’s Advocates Original Music: open.spotify.com/playlist/7rJadHA7AnceZ7sCkCc99g?si=ca4feca3564a45b2&nd=1&dlsi=500c25a34fb94b9a
Check out my new Insta360 Ace Pro 2 Camera at the affiliate link: amzn.to/46W8eSH
Devil’s Advocates’ Venmo: https://account.venmo.com/u/devilsadv...
Devil’s Advocates’ Cash App: https://cash.app/$DevilsAdvocates2024
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6322776415535104
And the deeper we look into that house, the stranger the story becomes.
In this episode, we dig into the history of R.C. and Eugene Horsch’s former Chalfont home, including a childhood friend’s recollections that the house burned and was rebuilt, that numerous blue 55-gallon drums were kept on the property, and that a large steel door was installed in the foundation during reconstruction.
Today, current and former owners have described something even more intriguing: a large safe reportedly built into the foundation and now concealed behind a finished wall.
So what is actually behind that wall?
We examine what we can document about the property, the 2009 police search, the IDs reportedly belonging to women that a former police chief says were recovered there, the home’s ownership history, and photographs showing what the property looked like shortly after the Horsch family lost possession of it.
We’ll also separate what is confirmed, what comes from witness recollections, and what remains speculation.
The existence of a safe does not establish that it contains evidence or that anything criminal occurred there. But with investigators now examining decades of R.C. Horsch’s history, the unanswered questions surrounding the Chalfont property deserve a closer look.
What was the safe built for?
Why was it sealed behind a wall?
And could anything still be inside?
We’re following the records wherever they lead.
#EugeneHorsch #RCHorsch #PhillyHouseOfHorrors #TrueCrime #Philadelphia #Chalfont #DevilsAdvocates
We’ll catch up on several case updates, discuss what we’ve learned so far, and dig into some of the questions that continue to surround Raymond “R.C.” Horsch, the Chew Avenue property, and the women connected to this investigation.
This one is also about conversation. We want to hear what YOU think as we work through the evidence, reporting, timelines, and unanswered questions together.
As always, we’ll separate what’s confirmed from allegations and speculation—and probably wander down a few interesting rabbit holes along the way. 😈
🕘 Live at 5PM PST / 8PM EST.
Broken Plea by Christopher Whitcomb affiliate link: amzn.to/41PJurM
The Devil at His Elbow: amzn.to/4icJkUB
Records Requests Fees Go Fund me: gofund.me/baecf3ecb
One Nation Under Blackmail affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
John Grisham's "Framed" affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
Devil’s Advocates Original Music: open.spotify.com/playlist/7rJadHA7AnceZ7sCkCc99g?si=ca4feca3564a45b2&nd=1&dlsi=500c25a34fb94b9a
Check out my new Insta360 Ace Pro 2 Camera at the affiliate link: amzn.to/46W8eSH
Devil’s Advocates’ Venmo: https://account.venmo.com/u/devilsadv...
Devil’s Advocates’ Cash App: https://cash.app/$DevilsAdvocates2024
The Devil’s in the Details.
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6322776415535104
As the images begin circulating and discussion around them grows, some important questions are being raised—not only about the leak itself, but about what happens once sensitive material makes its way into the public sphere.
Where do we draw the line?
Tonight, we’ll talk about what’s happening, the concerns surrounding the images, and some of the larger questions this situation raises for true-crime coverage.
We’ll also explain where The Devil’s Advocates stands and how we’ve decided to handle the situation moving forward.
Join us LIVE tonight for the discussion and let us know where you think the line should be drawn.
Question Everything. Follow the Evidence.
🕘 Live at 5PM PST / 8PM EST.
Broken Plea by Christopher Whitcomb affiliate link: amzn.to/41PJurM
The Devil at His Elbow: amzn.to/4icJkUB
Records Requests Fees Go Fund me: gofund.me/baecf3ecb
One Nation Under Blackmail affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
John Grisham's "Framed" affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
Devil’s Advocates Original Music: open.spotify.com/playlist/7rJadHA7AnceZ7sCkCc99g?si=ca4feca3564a45b2&nd=1&dlsi=500c25a34fb94b9a
Check out my new Insta360 Ace Pro 2 Camera at the affiliate link: amzn.to/46W8eSH
Devil’s Advocates’ Venmo: https://account.venmo.com/u/devilsadv...
Devil’s Advocates’ Cash App: https://cash.app/$DevilsAdvocates2024
#Idaho4 #CrimesAfterDark #DevilsAdvocates #TrueCrime
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6322776415535104
Some of what investigators revealed is genuinely new — including details that were not publicly known before today.
But there’s another part of this story: information that has already been publicly reported, documented, and independently verified that authorities still refuse to discuss.
In this video, I break down the entire announcement and separate it into three categories: what we already knew, what investigators still aren’t acknowledging, and the major new details revealed today.
We’ll also examine a bigger question about transparency in high-profile criminal investigations.
Why will authorities release certain new facts while declining to confirm information that is already in the public record? Who decides when the public is “allowed” to know something? And what happens when reporters and independent journalists uncover information before law enforcement is prepared to discuss it?
We’ll discuss the relationship between law enforcement, the FBI, traditional media, independent journalists, public records, and the public’s right to understand an investigation — while also recognizing the legitimate need to protect evidence and an active case.
The goal isn’t to simply accept the official narrative or automatically reject it.
It’s to follow the evidence, compare what we’re being told with what is already documented, and ask the questions that still haven’t been answered.
PHILLY HOUSE OF HORRORS — MASSIVE CASE UPDATE
New details. Hidden details. And a lot of unanswered questions.
#PhillyHouseOfHorrors #RCHorsch #EugeneHorsch #FBI #TrueCrime #Philadelphia #BreakingNews #DevilsAdvocates
We’ll move from case to case, looking at new filings, major updates, unanswered questions, and anything that could shift how these stories are being understood.
Some updates may be big. Some may be subtle. But if it matters to the case, we want to talk about it.
Join us LIVE tonight as we get everyone caught up, compare notes, and dig into the stories still developing.
Question Everything. Follow the Evidence.
🕘 Live at 5PM PST / 8PM EST.
Broken Plea by Christopher Whitcomb affiliate link: amzn.to/41PJurM
The Devil at His Elbow: amzn.to/4icJkUB
Records Requests Fees Go Fund me: gofund.me/baecf3ecb
One Nation Under Blackmail affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
John Grisham's "Framed" affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
Devil’s Advocates Original Music: open.spotify.com/playlist/7rJadHA7AnceZ7sCkCc99g?si=ca4feca3564a45b2&nd=1&dlsi=500c25a34fb94b9a
Check out my new Insta360 Ace Pro 2 Camera at the affiliate link: amzn.to/46W8eSH
Devil’s Advocates’ Venmo: https://account.venmo.com/u/devilsadv...
Devil’s Advocates’ Cash App: https://cash.app/$DevilsAdvocates2024
#TrueCrime #CrimesAfterDark #DevilsAdvocates #CaseUpdates #TrueCrimeCommunity
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6322776415535104
Nicole Amanda Fusaro disappeared from Kensington in 2018. Investigators now believe Horsch killed her inside the Chew Avenue home and recorded the killing. Her body has never been recovered.
We’ll discuss Nicole’s story, the latest reporting, and the larger questions her identification raises. How many other women could be connected to this house? What does the growing timeline tell us? And what, if anything, did Eugene Horsch know about what was happening inside the property he shared with his father?
As always, we’ll separate confirmed facts from allegations, theories, and unanswered questions as this active investigation continues.
Join us live and bring your questions. The Devil’s in the Details.
🕘 Live at 5PM PST / 8PM EST.
Broken Plea by Christopher Whitcomb affiliate link: amzn.to/41PJurM
The Devil at His Elbow: amzn.to/4icJkUB
Records Requests Fees Go Fund me: gofund.me/baecf3ecb
One Nation Under Blackmail affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
John Grisham's "Framed" affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
Devil’s Advocates Original Music: open.spotify.com/playlist/7rJadHA7AnceZ7sCkCc99g?si=ca4feca3564a45b2&nd=1&dlsi=500c25a34fb94b9a
Check out my new Insta360 Ace Pro 2 Camera at the affiliate link: amzn.to/46W8eSH
Devil’s Advocates’ Venmo: https://account.venmo.com/u/devilsadv...
Devil’s Advocates’ Cash App: https://cash.app/$DevilsAdvocates2024
#RaymondHorsch #RCHorsch #NicoleFusaro #NicoleAmandaFusaro #EugeneHorsch #HorschCase #HorschInvestigation #PhillyHouseOfHorror #PhiladelphiaHouseOfHorror #417WestChewAvenue #ChewAvenue #PhiladelphiaTrueCrime #KensingtonPhiladelphia #MissingWomenPhiladelphia #PhiladelphiaMissingPersons #TrueCrimeInvestigation #TrueCrimeLive #CrimesAfterDark #DevilsAdvocates
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6322776415535104
In this long-form episode, I take a close look at the new reporting, Nicole’s timeline, who she was, how her family searched for answers, and how her identification changes the larger investigation surrounding 417 W. Chew Avenue.
But Nicole’s identification raises even bigger questions.
How many other women may have died in that house? How much did R.C. Horsch’s son, Eugene, know about what was happening there? Could multiple women have disappeared or died at a property shared by father and son without Eugene understanding what was going on—or does the evidence eventually point somewhere else?
We separate what is established from what remains allegation, theory, or unanswered question. Eugene Horsch has not been charged with any homicide and, as of this video, law enforcement has not publicly linked him to Nicole’s death. The purpose here is to examine the evidence and ask what investigators still need to establish.
I also walk through the Devil’s Advocates Master Timeline, where we are building a research resource covering the Horsch investigation, the women connected to the Chew Avenue property, court records, law-enforcement developments, and other sourced events.
Research the case:
devilsadvocates.info
Article discussed in this episode:
The Philadelphia Inquirer — “Nicole Fusaro, missing since 2018, identified as woman who police believe Raymond Horsch killed”
inquirer.com/crime/raymond-horsch-olney-nicole-fusaro-missing-20260911.html
This remains an active investigation. Police have said investigators are continuing to review a massive collection of digital evidence recovered from the property.
#NicoleFusaro #RCHorsch #EugeneHorsch #PhillyHouseOfHorrors #TrueCrime #Philadelphia #MissingPersons #DevilsAdvocates
Some nights we come in with a case file.
Other nights, we open the doors and see where the conversation takes us.
Tonight is one of those nights.
We’re going LIVE to talk about the cases, developments, questions, and controversies that have the true crime community talking. From the Idaho 4 and other cases we’ve been following to new developments, unanswered questions, viewer theories, and whatever rabbit holes the panel manages to fall into along the way—nothing is necessarily off the table.
And tonight, YOU help drive the conversation.
Bring your questions. Bring the stories you think deserve more attention. Challenge the panel. Tell us what you want investigated next. And if you've got something for Ask DA, send it our way.
No script. No predetermined conclusions. Just the Devil’s Advocates doing what we do best: digging into the details, debating the possibilities, and probably disagreeing with each other at least once. 😈
Come hang out with us LIVE on Crimes After Dark.
Because sometimes the best conversations are the ones we didn't plan.
Question Everything. Follow the Evidence.
🕘 Live at 5PM PST / 8PM EST.
Broken Plea by Christopher Whitcomb affiliate link: amzn.to/41PJurM
The Devil at His Elbow: amzn.to/4icJkUB
Records Requests Fees Go Fund me: gofund.me/baecf3ecb
One Nation Under Blackmail affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
John Grisham's "Framed" affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
Devil’s Advocates Original Music: open.spotify.com/playlist/7rJadHA7AnceZ7sCkCc99g?si=ca4feca3564a45b2&nd=1&dlsi=500c25a34fb94b9a
Check out my camera: Insta360 Ace Pro 2 Camera: amzn.to/46W8eSH
Devil’s Advocates’ Venmo: https://account.venmo.com/u/devilsadv...
Devil’s Advocates’ Cash App: https://cash.app/$DevilsAdvocates2024
#CrimesAfterDark #DevilsAdvocates #TrueCrime #Idaho4 #AskDA #TrueCrimeCommunity
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6322776415535104
There are moments in history that divide our lives into before and after.
September 11, 2001 was one of them.
For those old enough to remember that morning, there is one question almost everyone can answer:
Where were you when you heard?
Tonight, Crimes After Dark is doing something different.
We’re remembering September 11 through the experiences of the people who lived it—not only the images the world watched unfold, but the phone calls, the confusion, the fear, the silence afterward, and the ordinary moments that suddenly became memories we would carry for the rest of our lives.
And we want to hear your story.
Where were you? Who were you with? How did you find out? What moment from that day has stayed with you for the past 25 years?
For those who were too young to remember—or weren't yet born—we want you there too. Twenty-five years later, what does 9/11 mean to a generation that knows it as history rather than memory?
Tonight isn't about politics.
It's about people. Memory. Loss. Courage. And a day none of us should ever forget.
Come share your memories, listen to those of others, and help us remember the nearly 3,000 lives lost that day.
September 11, 2001 — September 11, 2026
Where were you?
We Remember.🎙️ 🕘 Live at 5PM PST / 8PM EST.
Broken Plea by Christopher Whitcomb affiliate link: amzn.to/41PJurM
The Devil at His Elbow: amzn.to/4icJkUB
Records Requests Fees Go Fund me: gofund.me/baecf3ecb
One Nation Under Blackmail affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
John Grisham's "Framed" affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
Devil’s Advocates Original Music: open.spotify.com/playlist/7rJadHA7AnceZ7sCkCc99g?si=ca4feca3564a45b2&nd=1&dlsi=500c25a34fb94b9a
Check out my new Insta360 Ace Pro 2 Camera at the affiliate link: amzn.to/46W8eSH
Devil’s Advocates’ Venmo: https://account.venmo.com/u/devilsadv...
Devil’s Advocates’ Cash App: https://cash.app/$DevilsAdvocates2024
New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6322776415535104
Last time, we began working through what Saylor told investigators and examining her statements in the context of the other interviews, timelines, reports, and information surrounding the Idaho 4 case.
Tonight, we pick up where we left off.
As the interview continues, we’ll look closely at the questions investigators ask, the details Saylor provides, and anything that stands out when compared with what we’ve learned from the broader investigative record.
Does the second half add important context to what we heard in Part 1? Does anything raise new questions? And what does the complete interview tell us that individual clips or excerpts might miss?
Join us LIVE tonight as we finish Saylor O’Kelley’s interview and put the entire conversation into context.
Question Everything. Follow the Evidence.
🕘 Live at 5PM PST / 8PM EST.
Broken Plea by Christopher Whitcomb affiliate link: amzn.to/41PJurM
The Devil at His Elbow: amzn.to/4icJkUB
Records Requests Fees Go Fund me: gofund.me/baecf3ecb
One Nation Under Blackmail affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
John Grisham's "Framed" affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
Devil’s Advocates Original Music: open.spotify.com/playlist/7rJadHA7AnceZ7sCkCc99g?si=ca4feca3564a45b2&nd=1&dlsi=500c25a34fb94b9a
Check out my new Insta360 Ace Pro 2 Camera at the affiliate link: amzn.to/46W8eSH
Devil’s Advocates’ Venmo: https://account.venmo.com/u/devilsadv...
Devil’s Advocates’ Cash App: https://cash.app/$DevilsAdvocates2024
#Idaho4 #SaylorOKelley #BryanKohberger #CrimesAfterDark #DevilsAdvocates #Idaho4Interviews
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6322776415535104
First, we examine the rumors and suspicions that circulated after Stephen Smith was found dead along a rural South Carolina road in 2015. His death generated years of speculation, including rumors involving members of the Murdaugh family. But rumors are not evidence, and in this episode we look carefully at what was actually said, what was documented, and why the Murdaugh name became connected to the case in the first place.
Then we turn to Gloria Satterfield—the longtime Murdaugh housekeeper who spent years helping raise Paul and Buster, caring for the family while earning roughly $10 an hour without the kinds of benefits most people would associate with working for a wealthy and powerful family.
When Gloria suffered a fatal fall at the Murdaugh home, a natural question followed:
Would the family she had spent so many years caring for now take care of hers?
Would her sons receive the financial security that was supposedly being arranged for them after their mother’s death?
Or would Gloria Satterfield’s tragedy eventually reveal something much darker about the way Alex Murdaugh operated?
These chapters force us to look beyond the murders that ultimately made the Murdaugh name infamous and ask a broader question:
What happened to the ordinary people who found themselves depending on this extraordinarily powerful family?
This is part of my ongoing chapter-by-chapter deep dive into Valerie Bauerlein’s The Devil at His Elbow: Alex Murdaugh and the Fall of a Southern Dynasty, where we examine the history, evidence, allegations and unanswered questions surrounding the Murdaugh family.
As always, allegations and rumors are presented as such unless supported by established evidence or court findings.
#AlexMurdaugh #StephenSmith #GloriaSatterfield #Murdaugh #TheDevilAtHisElbow #ValerieBauerlein #TrueCrime #MurdaughMurders #BookReview #LegalAnalysis
We’ll listen to what Saylor told investigators, examine the questions she was asked, and look at the details she provided about the victims, their relationships, and the people and events surrounding 1122 King Road.
As we work through the interview, we’ll compare her statements with other interviews, timelines, reports, and information that have emerged since the earliest days of the investigation.
What did investigators seem most interested in? What details stand out now with the benefit of everything we’ve learned since? And does her interview help fill in any pieces of the larger picture—or raise new questions?
As always, we’ll separate what we know from what we think and follow the information wherever it leads.
Join us LIVE tonight for another Idaho 4 interview breakdown on Crimes After Dark.
🕘 Live at 5PM PST / 8PM EST.
Question Everything. Follow the Evidence.
Broken Plea by Christopher Whitcomb affiliate link: amzn.to/41PJurM
The Devil at His Elbow: amzn.to/4icJkUB
Records Requests Fees Go Fund me: gofund.me/baecf3ecb
One Nation Under Blackmail affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
John Grisham's "Framed" affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
Devil’s Advocates Original Music: open.spotify.com/playlist/7rJadHA7AnceZ7sCkCc99g?si=ca4feca3564a45b2&nd=1&dlsi=500c25a34fb94b9a
Check out my new Insta360 Ace Pro 2 Camera at the affiliate link: amzn.to/46W8eSH
Devil’s Advocates’ Venmo: https://account.venmo.com/u/devilsadv...
Devil’s Advocates’ Cash App: https://cash.app/$DevilsAdvocates2024
#Idaho4 #SaylorOKelley #BryanKohberger #CrimesAfterDark #DevilsAdvocates #Idaho4Interviews
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6322776415535104
Was Horsch really the calculating supervillain he portrayed himself to be—or was he simply a petty criminal with delusions of being something far more dangerous?
🎙️ TAKE THE MIC: Want me to answer your question on a future show? Leave a voice or written question here: form.jotform.com/262474382236056
In Part 4 of The Voice of a Killer, we examine one of the darkest turning points in the Horsch family story: the death of R.C.’s second wife. Did witnessing her death trigger something inside R.C. and contribute to the man he later became? Did it create a need to seek out women who reminded him of her—as if he were repeatedly trying to save the woman he could not save?
Or did that event leave its deepest mark on the young son who witnessed it, Eugene Horsch?
This episode explores the disturbing stories R.C. told about himself, the mythology he constructed around his life, and a central question that may help us understand what came later:
Did her death create a monster—and if so, which Horsch did it create?
This video contains mature subject matter and is intended for adults only. The psychological interpretations discussed are theories based on the available accounts and are not presented as established fact.
#RCHorsch #EugeneHorsch #PhillyHouseOfHorrors #TrueCrime #VoiceOfAKiller
Tonight, we’re putting YOUR questions front and center.
We recently launched our new Ask DA feature, giving you a place to send us the questions you want the Devil’s Advocates team to tackle—and you guys wasted absolutely no time. 😂 We already have a host of questions waiting for us, and who knows how many we’ll have by showtime!
Tonight we’ll dig into your questions, give you our individual perspectives, debate where we disagree, and probably wander down a few rabbit holes along the way. Nothing is off the table just because the answer might be complicated.
Have something you want us to tackle? Ask DA! Your question could be next.
Join us LIVE tonight for a different kind of Crimes After Dark—one driven by you.
You Asked. We Answer.
Question Everything. Follow the Evidence.
#CrimesAfterDark #AskDA #DevilsAdvocates #TrueCrime #QandA
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6322776415535104
🎙️ TAKE THE MIC: Want me to answer your question on a future show? Leave a voice or written question here: form.jotform.com/262474382236056
By the end of this episode, I explore a new possibility: Was R.C. Horsch’s public identity an elaborate performance? Did he spend his life constructing a cinematic persona—borrowing characters, stories, and fantasies from the movies he watched and then casting himself as the villain?
Where does the real R.C. Horsch end and the character begin?
This series contains mature subject matter and is intended for adults only.
#RCHorsch #TrueCrime #PhillyHouseOfHorrors #VoiceOfAKiller #TrueCrimeAnalysis
0:00 The villain persona
6:03 Film career and cynicism
14:29 Black Mass and satanism
21:44 Counterfeiting and prison
37:39 Life as a fugitive
50:33 Chemistry and reinvention
57:42 The myth of RC Horsch
🎙️ TAKE THE MIC: Want me to answer your question on a future show? Leave a voice or written question here: form.jotform.com/262474382236056
Were these remarkable experiences entirely true, carefully embellished—or part of the mythology Horsch constructed around himself?
In Part 2, we also investigate one of his most provocative claims: Did R.C. Horsch really shoot his first adult film, Erotic Memoirs of a Male Chauvinist Pig, in 1973—and did it involve the wife of a district attorney, filmed inside the district attorney’s own office?
In this episode, we begin separating documented fact from unverifiable storytelling as we examine the life R.C. Horsch described in his own words.
⚠️ This video is intended for viewers 18 and older. It contains discussion of adult entertainment, sexual subject matter, violence and other disturbing topics. Viewer discretion is advised.
The claims discussed in this video are attributed to R.C. Horsch and should not automatically be understood as independently verified facts.
#RCHorsch #VoiceOfAKiller #TrueCrime #FactOrFiction #PhillyHouseOfHorrors
We’ll listen closely to what Stacey told investigators, the questions police chose to ask, and the information she provided about Connor, the victims, and the people and events surrounding the case.
As we work through the interview, we’ll compare her statements with other interviews, timelines, documents, and information that have become available since the investigation began. What stands out now? Does anything take on new significance when viewed through the much larger body of information we have today? And what can this interview tell us about the direction investigators were taking at the time?
As always, we’ll separate what we know from what we think and let the interview speak for itself.
Join us LIVE tonight for another Idaho 4 interview deep dive.
Question Everything. Follow the Evidence.
🕘 Live at 5PM PST / 8PM EST.
Broken Plea by Christopher Whitcomb affiliate link: amzn.to/41PJurM
The Devil at His Elbow: amzn.to/4icJkUB
Records Requests Fees Go Fund me: gofund.me/baecf3ecb
One Nation Under Blackmail affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
John Grisham's "Framed" affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
Devil’s Advocates Original Music: open.spotify.com/playlist/7rJadHA7AnceZ7sCkCc99g?si=ca4feca3564a45b2&nd=1&dlsi=500c25a34fb94b9a
Check out my new Insta360 Ace Pro 2 Camera at the affiliate link: amzn.to/46W8eSH
Devil’s Advocates’ Venmo: https://account.venmo.com/u/devilsadv...
Devil’s Advocates’ Cash App: https://cash.app/$DevilsAdvocates2024
#Idaho4 #StaceyChestnut #ConnorChestnut #BryanKohberger #CrimesAfterDark #DevilsAdvocates #Idaho4Interviews
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6322776415535104
At the time, listeners could have dismissed much of this as the calculated performance of an aging underground filmmaker cultivating his own mythology. Today, the interview carries a far darker significance.
Authorities investigating the Philadelphia “House of Horrors” have reportedly recovered video showing Horsch strangling a woman to death. Horsch died in 2025 and was never prosecuted for that killing, but investigators are now examining his possible connection to other women who disappeared or died under suspicious circumstances.
In Part One of The Voice of a Killer: R.C. Horsch in His Own Words, we listen carefully to what Horsch said about his sexual history and analyze his statements in light of what investigators have since uncovered.
This series contains frank discussions of sexual behavior, violence and other disturbing adult subject matter. Viewer discretion is strongly advised.
Neither R.C. Horsch nor Eugene Horsch should be attributed responsibility for any additional disappearance or death unless supported by evidence. This series distinguishes Horsch’s own claims, established facts, reported investigative findings and unresolved questions.
Original interview:
“The Rialto Report — Ray Horsch: Sociopathic Villain”
Published December 15, 2013
therialtoreport.com/2013/12/15/ray-horsch
#RCHorsch #HouseOfHorrors #TrueCrime #Philadelphia #TheVoiceOfAKiller
First, we’ll examine the interview with Stacey Chestnut, the mother of Connor Chestnut, and look closely at what she told investigators, the questions police asked, and any details that stand out when compared with the other interviews and information we’ve reviewed.
Then we’ll turn to Riley Moreland, a friend of the victims, and walk through her interview with investigators. What did Riley know about the victims, their relationships, and the circumstances surrounding that weekend? And does anything she said take on greater significance when viewed alongside everything we know today?
As always, we’ll separate what we know from what we think, compare these interviews with the broader record, and discuss the details together.
Join us LIVE tonight for a double interview deep dive on Crimes After Dark.
Question Everything. Follow the Evidence.
🕘 Live at 5PM PST / 8PM EST.
Broken Plea by Christopher Whitcomb affiliate link: amzn.to/41PJurM
The Devil at His Elbow: amzn.to/4icJkUB
Records Requests Fees Go Fund me: gofund.me/baecf3ecb
One Nation Under Blackmail affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
John Grisham's "Framed" affiliate link: bit.ly/48ndGP9
Devil’s Advocates Original Music: open.spotify.com/playlist/7rJadHA7AnceZ7sCkCc99g?si=ca4feca3564a45b2&nd=1&dlsi=500c25a34fb94b9a
Check out my new Insta360 Ace Pro 2 Camera at the affiliate link: amzn.to/46W8eSH
Devil’s Advocates’ Venmo: https://account.venmo.com/u/devilsadv...
Devil’s Advocates’ Cash App: https://cash.app/$DevilsAdvocates2024
#Idaho4 #RileyMoreland #StaceyChestnut #BryanKohberger #CrimesAfterDark #DevilsAdvocates #Idaho4Interviews
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6322776415535104


