Australian Institute of International Affairs
A Strategic Analysis of the Russo-Ukraine War | Richard Iron CMG OBE
updated
The underlying issues surrounding Israel's place in its regional environment have been largely unchanged and unresolved since Israel's establishment three quarters of a century ago.
We are privileged to welcome the Hon Bob Carr, former Australian foreign minister and Premier of New South Wales, to offer us his analysis of the situation.
In this presentation we consider insights from a five-year research project "Geopolitical Change and the Antarctic Treaty System". We explore concerns over increased geopolitical tension in the Antarctic and Southern Ocean and suggest options for management of these tensions.
Find out more about the AIIA National Conference at aiianationalconference.org
Or be part of Australia's largest public conversation on international affairs: join the AIIA today! internationalaffairs.org.au
Given its pivotal role in the functioning of society worldwide, it is important that a governance framework for space exists that appropriately finds a balance between all of these perspectives.
This talk by Professor Steve Freeland will address some of the significant challenges to the applicability and further development of the legal regulation of outer space activities, particularly in the currently rapidly changing technological, geopolitical and commercial contexts
The challenges for Australia and its allies are immense. Amongst the complications are that the two sides are planning to fight quite different types of war, they have different strengths and weaknesses, they are at different states of preparation and they are focusing on fighting for very different periods.
This presentation will briefly address the issues and options for Australian and allied decision-makers.
The presentation analyses five major developments and trends to elucidate China's engagement in Asia, emphasizing the need for strategic cooperation and alternative approaches to ensure sustainability and prosperity in the Asia-Pacific region. The outcome of these efforts will determine whether China's ambitions align with addressing climate change collaboratively or preparing for potential conflict.
Currently, civil society in Ukraine is keeping authoritarianism at bay: fighting against external pressure but struggling to move further toward democracy due to a lack of security in the society and low institutional trust. Furthermore, public understanding of the rule of law is low due to the threats coming from the post-totalitarian state.
This talk offers Ukrainian sociologist Viktoriya Bryndza's viewpoint on Ukraine's democratisation efforts and progress. She considers historical and geographical aspects and modern generation and informational shifts in Ukraine society as a part of her research.
Why is it important to keep supporting Ukraine? What is needed for the country to evolve into a fully functional democratic society? What will a democratic Ukraine look like? AIIA VIC warmly invites you to join this thought-provoking discussion on Ukraine's path to democracy.
Even before Sean Turnell spent 650 days of wrongful imprisonment in Myanmar, his story was remarkable.
From humble working-class beginnings in the suburbs of Sydney, Sean followed his humanitarian heart and become a world-class expert on the Burmese economy, believing that the right economic policies could provide prosperity for its suffering people. It was this reputation and philosophy that led him to becoming the economic advisor of Myanmar’s democratically elected leader, Aung San Suu Kyi.
Three days after Suu Kyi was deposed in a military coup and arrested, Sean was placed in solitary confinement by armed military police under fabricated charges. During his long imprisonment in Myanmar, friends, fellow economists, institutions, and governments from around the world rallied together in a remarkable campaign for his release.
Join Professor Sean Turnell for the 2023 Plimsoll lecture, and listen to his extraordinary story of hope, resilience, and the power of friends. What unfolds in this conversation will be more than just personal reflections, but also deep insights into the dynamics of international relations, the role of civil society, and the power of unity in promoting democratic values worldwide.
Southeast Asia and the Pacific has been radically overlooked in the first seven years of the Youth, Peace and Security agenda despite being one of the youngest regions in the world with a median age of 28 years old. Recently, regional momentum for the agenda has accelerated, including attention from the ASEAN and the adoption of a National Action Plan on Youth, Peace and Security by the Philippines in 2022 (only the fourth globally). This talk examines how youth have come to be taken seriously by institutions internationally, before highlighting some key tensions and opportunities that have emerged with the agenda and pointing to possible directions in the region. Paying meaningful attention to youth leadership in peacebuilding offers opportunities for building more durable, inclusive peace in our region and beyond
The Climate Overshoot Commission is a group of world leaders that was tasked by the Paris Peace Forum with the goal of recommending a comprehensive strategy to limit harms during the period of overshoot beyond agreed warming goals. Last month, the Commission released its final report in which it makes recommendations concerning the potential role of four kinds of responses to climate overshoot: cutting emissions to mitigate warming; adapting to the changing climate; removing carbon that is already in the atmosphere or ocean; exploring interventions to limit warming by intentionally reflecting sunlight into space. In this talk, Dr Jonathan Symons examines the international political controversies associated with these four possible climate responses, and asks how global climate politics is changing in the lead-up to COP28 (UAE).
This talk will focus on the situation inside Russia. It will survey the effect sanctions have had on the economy and on the population, and it will survey the political landscape in the wake of the crack down on opposition that has occurred associated with the war. The situation in the ruling elite will also be broached, including the meaning and fallout from the Wagner mutiny and the strength of the position of Vladimir Putin.
In his new book The Echidna Strategy (Black Inc. Books, August 2023), Sam Roggeveen – director of the Lowy Institute's International Security Program – overturns the conventional wisdom about Australia's security.
He argues that America's security is not threatened by China's rise, and that once Australia accepts that conclusion, the entire edifice on which its security has been built shifts, requiring a fresh approach. And that despite the rapid growth of China's military, defending Australia need not be particularly difficult.
The Echidna Strategy sheds new light on the contest for leadership in Asia and the strategy Australia needs to thrive. This includes a radically different approach to defence. Above all, it means a bolder Australian foreign policy, with three goals: leadership in the Pacific; a much stronger relationship with Indonesia; and a regional order centred on a gathering of its great powers. In the wake of a shift in the global power balance, how can Australia best protect itself?
Since the implosion of that state in 1991, Ukraine has developed a vibrant, if often troubled, democracy. For an increasingly dictatorial Russian political elite, including but not limited to Vladimir Putin, Ukraine has appeared more and more threatening. Humiliated by the degradation of Russia's international standing, feeling betrayed by an expanding NATO and anxious about democratic revolutions in the former Soviet space, Putin and his allies have increasingly retreated into a resentful ultra-nationalism. Dreams of past imperial glory stand in place of any attempt to solve the problems of the present.
Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine came as a shock to most of the world. In order to understand why this happened, a growing army of self-declared experts provided explanations often mis-representing the history of Ukraine and of Russia and mis-representing the pre-history of this war and the role of outside forces. As a historian of the Soviet Union and its successor states, Mark felt compelled to set the record straight. Watching this talk will provide insight into one of the most geopolitically significant and complex conflicts of our time.
From the Mino, the all-female army that protected Dahomey from the West for two hundred years to the Night Witches, Soviet flying aces that decimated the Nazis; from the real story of Joan of Arc to the cross-dressing soldiers whose disguises were so effective the men around them never realized who they were fighting with, Sarah Percy shines a fascinating new light on the history of warfare. And against a backdrop of sieges and desperate battles, rebellions and civil wars, a series of extraordinary women come alive on the page, determined not to be passive victims.
Every country has their tomb to the unknown warrior, picking out one unnamed body to represent the sacrifices of thousands of others. As Forgotten Warriors shows, those overlooked soldiers could well be female. Their heroic and compelling stories need to be heard.
Professor MacIntyre's work has revealed a recurrent theme of denial, silence and cover-up around unnatural epidemics, along with the powerful vested interests at play. Drawing on quantum advances in genetic engineering and synthetic biology, she calls for a cross-disciplinary, global approach to safeguarding our future. She envisages a future where human genome editing and the resurrection of extinct viruses might be the norm.
Professor MacIntyre argues that the solution to the existential threat we face from biotechnology will not come from scientists, but from the community having a voice in the future of the planet and of humanity.
It is holding presidential and parliamentary elections in January, whose outcome is difficult to forecast. Its ruling Democratic Progressive Party is by no means assured of victory in either poll. Today, only about 4 per cent of people in Taiwan view themselves as exclusively Chinese. But the People's Republic of China wishes – with ever-increasing intensity – to subsume Taiwan.
How can – or should – Australia and Australian institutions relate to Taiwan? What might happen in the event of conflict – in whatever form – across the 180km-wide Taiwan Strait? Does the Ukraine war offer insights? What deterrents might prove most effective to prevent conflict and support the status quo? What impact might Taiwan's fate have on Australia's?
Mongolia has an internationally recognized nuclear-weapon free zone status. The country has promoted the denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula through its Ulaanbaatar Dialogue which serves as a confidence-building measure to bring together other stakeholders.
Richard Iron will explore the effectiveness of Ukrainian counter offences and the consequences of the battle over the Black Sea, an increasingly important area of military and geopolitical tensions. He will look particularly at the state of Russian internal politics, Putin's authority after the Wagner Group mutiny and the possibility of regime collapse.
Can either side achieve their military goals? How is Western support for Ukraine holding up in light of recent events? What does this mean for Ukraine's future?
Queensland is committed to the region and will drive international trade and investment – with both legacy and sustainability. The Trade Commissioner will discuss the ways that Queensland is engaging with the Pacific, working with 'Team Australia', the opportunities and delivering on the Pacific trade strategy.
Relations between Latin America and the Asia-Pacific region are at a crossroads. It took less than 20 years for Asia to become Latin America's second largest economic partner. With the emergence of new trade arrangements, such as the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) in 2020, Latin American countries have an opportunity to deepen trade and investment links with Asia even further. At the same time, competition between the US and China in the Asia-Pacific is heightening regional security concerns. How will Latin American countries address trade barriers, promote diversified relationships and deal with rising strategic tension in the Asia-Pacific? What are the prospects that the Pacific Alliance, formed in 2012 and comprising Chile, Colombia, Mexico, and Peru - with Ecuador a prospective member, can serve as a bridge linking Asia and the Americas?
Join us for a lively discussion about Latin America's perspectives on the Asia-Pacific region with a panel of Ambassadors from Ecuador and Chile and the Chargé d'Affaires of Colombia.
Mohammad Chowdhury's new book Border Crossings: My Journey as an Outsider (NewSouth Books, July 2023) is a thrilling ride from the city of minarets to the heights of picture-perfect skyscrapers. A journey of finding one's own identity, it is the story of a British born, Bangladeshi man of Muslim faith, trying to reconcile his western and eastern identities and the inconsistencies between the two.
Hustling his way through days and nights negotiating one cultural micro-adjustment after another, Chowdhury's story reflects our own struggles to find a place where we truly belong.
AIIA Victoria invites you to join author Mohammad Chowdhury and The Honorable Jaala Pulford for an intimate fireside chat as he discusses his journey across cultures and the journey of someone living and growing up in diaspora.
Join Griffith Asia Institute and AIIA Queensland for an event that brings together Dame Meg Taylor, an esteemed member of the Pacific Elders Voice and former Secretary-General of the Pacific Islands Forum, and Stefan Armbruster, Griffith Pacific Hub industry fellow, award winning journalist and SBS correspondent for Queensland who has a longstanding record of Pacific coverage and reporting.
Its strategic location, thriving industries, energetic workforce, and commitment to peace demonstrate its potential to emerge as a key player in the Asia-Pacific region.
Critical minerals have been making the headlines as Western and allied nations race to increase their sovereign capability and secure their downstream manufacturing sectors' needs. The 'criticality' of metals and mineral varies from country to country based on a nation's industrial, defence and economic strategies. Sudden supply shocks and geopolitical disturbances can swiftly shift the criticality of a commodity.
Critical mineral supply chains, from mine to end-product, are vulnerable to supply chain disruptions due to heavy monopolisation, particularly in the midstream processing and refining space. As a result, both the miners and the manufacturers are reliant on China for a steady supply of refined critical materials. China's export ban on rare earths to Japan following a political dispute was one example of how vulnerable many nations are to securing critical minerals for end products such as electric vehicles, phones, and wind turbines that our society and economies are now relying on. Australia plays an important role in this geopolitical puzzle – containing almost all the critical minerals required for future technologies. Australia's approach to supporting its critical minerals industry will shape not only our new energy future but also have a significant impact on the world's supply.
Meeting these challenges requires reflection on what the system was designed to do and what it has achieved, then rethinking what the system should look like going forward: a process of repurposing the system and realigning its objectives. Do we want a mechanism to strictly enforce the rules? What policy space do governments need? Where is the boundary of the system? The process of reconstructing the global trading system must be driven by governments collectively, with a genuine and sustained political will for cooperation. The system's continued effectiveness and legitimacy will require a delicate balance between law and diplomacy working jointly in response to changing circumstances and new challenges.
Culture is the perfect vehicle for diplomacy. The Consulate General of Canada has long partnered with Australian organisations to enhance our relationships and promote trade interests. As well as acting as a connector for diverse communities, the creative sector is a thriving industry that drives employment, innovation and global opportunity.
At this event André François Giroux, Consul General of Canada in Sydney, will explore Canada's experiences of a hybrid approach to diplomacy and creative industries.
Jerome de Baecque, Director of APAC for Moment Factory, will join the Consul General at this event to speak about Moment Factory's growth in the region.
Indeed, from the Maute Matriarchs to recruiters and mothers, women have played key roles in political violence across the region. Drawing on field research and my experiences working in Mindanao, I explore the gendered dynamics of violent extremism and peacebuilding across the BARMM, and the key challenges facing the region over the next three years of the transition extension.
The Palestine Laboratory shows in depth and for the first time how Israel has become a leader in developing spying technology and defence hardware that fuels some of the globe's most brutal conflicts — from the Pegasus software that hacked Jeff Bezos's and Jamal Khashoggi's phones, and the weapons sold to the Myanmar army that has murdered thousands of Rohingyas, to the drones being used by the European Union to monitor refugees in the Mediterranean who are left to drown.
In a global investigation that uncovers secret documents, based on revealing interviews and on-the-ground reporting, Antony Loewenstein shows how, as ethno-nationalism grows in the 21st century, Israel has built the ultimate tools for despots and democracies.
Cooperation between the Gulf Monarchies
The Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) aims to effect 'coordination, cooperation and integration' between its members on regional economic, political and security issues. The Gulf monarchies are, however, increasingly foregoing shared approaches in favour of pursuing unilateral policies, particularly in response to regional conflict. This presents a puzzle as to why states within an organisation, which seeks to foster unity between them, are pursuing contradictory projects across the Arabian Peninsula and Horn of Africa. Roisin Browne seeks to answer this by drawing on recent events in Yemen.
The Global Diffusion of Net Zero Emissions Pledges
Pledges to net zero emissions have rapidly become the key mechanism through which countries and businesses aim to limit dangerous climate change. The number of countries with 'net zero targets' rose dramatically from 24 in 2018 to almost 150 by the end of 2021. Today, 88% of emissions, 92% of GDP and 89% of the population are covered by a 'net zero' target. The quick emergence and voluntary nature of pledges has seen them differ discursively and behaviourally between actors. Isobel Logan will explore the state of net zero pledges, the key political challenges that are faced and what this means for the ability of the international system to address climate change over the next 30 years.
Interdependence between the United States and China in the technology sector
Ryan Lung will discuss the symbiosis between the technology industries of the United States and China. For the past two decades, ideas and capital have flowed freely between Silicon Valley and China's technology sector, with significant benefits for both parties. Rising geopolitical tensions between the US and China may, however, unravel this relationship. Concerns from the United States government about US capital and expertise being used to aid its main geopolitical rival has led to discussion about significant restrictions on American investment in China. These developments raise important questions about the role of innovation and technology in the US-China rivalry.
The Future of China and the Global Financial System
China is at the global forefront in digital currency development. The digital yuan will bring a period of historic change in the global financial system, improving the efficiency of financial flows and slowly challenging US dollar hegemony. Nadia Maunsell asks how China might leverage the e-CNY to increase its influence in the global economy and grapple with questions of privacy, trust in Chinese institutions, and foreign exchange controls. As China's share in the world's foreign reserves increases, how might other nations respond?
National Security and International Trade: A New Battleground for China and Western Powers
In recent years the security exception within the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade has become more prominent in international trade disputes with the WTO's multilateral trading system. Global powers are beginning to utilise this security exception to further strengthen their national security agendas. Recent cases have begun to suggest the potential scope and application of this exception. Ella Whitehurst will outline and discuss these developments and discuss them in relation to recent trade conflicts between the China and the West, as well as identifying future challenges for the WTO in managing the interplay between security and economics.
They included a former Shanghai policeman, a convicted (and habitual) criminal, a glamorous polyglot Russian, and a future member of the Australian Intelligence Corps and also British Force 136. This talk will be devoted to the backstory of the Chungking Legation, illustrated with photographs many of which have not hitherto been seen in Australia.
A new "dark fleet" of ageing tankers with obscure ownership, flying flags of convenience, has emerged in response to Western sanctions to ship oil from Iran, Venezuela and Russia around the world.
4 million barrels of oil are being shipped daily through some of the world's busiest waterways on largely elderly, unregulated vessels exploiting gaps in maritime conventions and undermining the integrity of global trade, with little knowledge or understanding of the environmental and safety risks posed.
What exactly is a "dark" tanker? What are the characteristics and business models used by shipowners to obfuscate their involvement, and track the unprecedented impact this is having on crude shipping markets? What are the potential environmental consequences?
AIIA Victoria invites you to join energy commodities and shipping analyst Michelle Wiese Bockmann to discuss this issue and its implications.
Revealing Secrets: An Unofficial History of Australian Signals Intelligence and the Advent of Cyber (UNSW Press, May 2023) is a comprehensive account of Australian Signals intelligence, its efforts at revealing the secrets of other nations, and keeping ours safe.
John Blaxland and Clare Birgin explore the royal commissions and reviews that shaped Australia's intelligence community in the 20th century, reveal what can be told without access to secret records, and consider the advent and the impact of cyber.
Why does Australia have a national signals intelligence agency? What does it do and why is it controversial? And how significant are its ties with key partners, the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada and New Zealand, to this arrangement?
AIIA Victoria welcomes Professor the Hon Gareth Evans to introduce authors Professor John Blaxland and Clare Birgin as they discuss the history of Australian Signals intelligence and the extraordinary challenges posed by the new cyber universe. Copies of the book will be available for sale and for signing.
Sport has the power to change lives and Australia is committed to using the power of sport to promote gender equality, diversity and inclusion. These international events present Australia with a unique opportunity to showcase a modern and diverse nation – with approximately a quarter of its people born overseas and representing 200 different ancestries.
As a socially and culturally diverse nation how do we ensure that we use the common language of sport to strengthen our connections with our regional and global partners and how significant are the challenges in current dialogue around Gender equality, First Nations representation and our relationships with Asian and Pacific neighbours?
What is the Legacy of the Green and Gold Decade - How do we make a real impact?
Policymakers have increasingly spoken of the need to use "all the tools of statecraft" in Australia's international engagement. The idea has taken hold that in a difficult and contested times, we need all the different elements that connect Australia to the world to be pushing in the same direction. No one doubts the scale of international challenges. Australia is only one country among many, but the multiplying effects of having different instruments working in concert means Australia can do more with relatively less.
Panellists will outline Australia's tools of statecraft and outline a strategy for encouraging defence, foreign affairs, development, trade, immigration, education, energy, and other policy areas to work together to contribute to Australia's capacity to influence the world around it. They will draw on a recent report by the Asia-Pacific Development, Diplomacy & Defence Dialogue (AP4D) which is the result of consultations with dozens of current and former officials working across Australian foreign, trade, development, intelligence, and defence policy.
In an ideal world, parallel operations would be carefully integrated with UN peace operations, leveraging their comparative advantages.
Unfortunately, the conditions under which peacekeepers deploy and the volatile environments they operate in, are far from ideal. Instead, multiple actors are deployed ad hoc into conflicts, usually without formal structures for integrating or aligning their objectives. In some cases, these actors find ways to work together, becoming stronger and more effective through their cooperation. In other cases, poor communication, contradictory priorities, and conflicting political objectives result in peacekeepers and parallel operations actively undermining each other's efforts.
To understand the dynamics between parallel forces, Dr Shannon Zimmerman examines the two most recent UN Peace Operations, the UN multidimensional Integrated Stabilization Mission in Mali (MINUSMA) and the UN Multidimensional Integrated Stabilization Mission in the Central African Republic (MINUSCA). Both missions deployed alongside parallel French Forces and European Union Training Missions. How can the interactions between the UN forces and the parallel French and EU forces be assessed? What synergies, and conversely what obstacles were identified? What are the recommendations for future parallel deployments?
AIIA Victoria welcomes back Dr Shannon Zimmerman to discuss her upcoming research on the dynamics between parallel forces in UN peace operations.
Previously Will served as Premier of Tasmania for six years, leading a government that took Tasmania's economy from the worst performing in the nation to the best for the first time ever, and one of the first places on the planet to achieve zero net emissions.
Prior to entering Parliament Will practised law as a barrister and solicitor in Australia and the United Kingdom, including as a criminal lawyer and prosecuting cases of child abuse.
The submarine plan is just one part of the proposed deepening of security collaboration among the three countries. The agreement also covers 'Pillar II' which covers improved technological capacity and information sharing.
What will cooperation on hypersonic missiles, cyber operations, quantum computing and other technological innovation mean for security in the region? And does this mean the military hardware may turn out to be of secondary importance to the agreement's role as a broader advanced technology accelerator?
Join us to discuss the foundational agreement and geopolitical implications, the risks, and advantages for each of the countries involved and the impact in the wider Indo-Pacific region.
Co-hosting with the AUKUS Forum, AIIA Victoria invites you to this expert panel in the first of a series on AUKUS to discuss the geopolitical implications.
AIIA Victoria gratefully acknowledges the Walter Trust fund for their support of our young members.
The previous LNP government had determined that the long-held assumption of a 10-year warning of high-intensity military conflict was no longer true. The Australian Defence Force might now be called on to fight a war at much shorter notice. Moreover, coercive grey zone actions had already begun. Accordingly, the review was designed to propose how "to optimise Defence capability and posture to meet the nation's security challenges over the period 2023-24 to 2032-33 and beyond."
In a time of geostrategic uncertainty and possible dangers, this is an important aim but has it been, or rather, can it be achieved? Is the review able to "underpin our Defence policy for decades to come," as Deputy Prime Minister Marles claims?
Revealing Secrets is a compelling account of Australian Signals intelligence, its efforts at revealing the secrets of other nations, and keeping ours safe. It brings to light clever Australians whose efforts were for so long entirely unknown or overlooked. Blaxland and Birgin traverse the royal commissions and reviews that shaped Australia's intelligence community in the 20th century and consider the advent and the impact of cyber.
Drawing on insights and anecdotes from the book, they will discuss how signals intelligence and its practitioners have influenced international affairs and continue to do so today. They will explore the secrecy around signals intelligence, along with the need for the right balance of oversight and accountability. Finally, they will touch on what the history of signals intelligence means for Australia and Australians.
As the Indo-Pacific becomes an arena of power competition with the potential of military escalation, trying to highlight the resemblance in the challenges faced by Australia and Israel might add relevant insights to the Australian evolving geo-strategic framework.
In Turkey's Political Leaders: Authoritarian Tendencies in a Democratic State (Edinburgh University Press, April 2023) Dr Tezcan Gümüş examines the role of the political leaders in Turkey's democratic system. He argues that the leaders' values, beliefs and practices underwritten by authoritarianism have resulted in the tenuous existence of democracy, oscillating between simply enduring and failure during the periods they occupied the seats of political power.
What are the implications of the 14 May Turkish elections? How will this reflect the way in which Turkish democracy is influenced as an institution? What lessons and insights can be learned from the role that political leaders play in the survival or failure of democracy?
AIIA Victoria invites you to join Dr Tezcan Gümüş in conversation with Dr David Tittensor, as he discusses his recently published book.