Its all about the entropy | #CORE1Gabriele Carcassi2026-11-21 | Its all about the entropy | #CORE1Why space is three dimensionalGabriele Carcassi2025-01-01 | We explore the argument from Reverse Physics that links the number of dimensions of space to the number of conjugate quantities for each degree of freedom. More details about this argument are available in our open access book assumptionsofphysics.org/bookClassical entanglement and other quantum analoguesGabriele Carcassi2024-12-01 | We show how some of the weirdness of quantum mechanics can actually be already found by combining classical statistical mechanics with the lower bound on entropy given by the third law of thermodynamics.
Intro (0:00) Quantum uncertainty principle (0:23) Classical mechanics + thermodynamics (1:08) Classical uncertainty principle (3:05) Diffraction (10:15) Interference (13:27) Entanglement (15:35) Purification (20:09) Recap (23:02) Conclusion (24:32)The constitutive assumptions of Hamiltonian mechanicsGabriele Carcassi2024-11-01 | What does Hamiltonian mechanics represent at the mathematical, geometrical and physical level? Here are we show that Hamiltonian mechanism is exactly the deterministic and reversible evolution of a system described by independent DOFs. This can be understood mathematically, geometrically and physically.
Previous video on a single DOF: youtu.be/OhH7OYon0LE #classicalmechanics #hamiltonian #symplecticgeometry #determinismThe most fundamental structure in physicsGabriele Carcassi2024-10-01 | In this video will see how the logic of experimentally verifiable statements gives us the most basic structure of physical theories. In other videos we will see how it connects to topologies and sigma-algebra, other foundational structures on top of which all other mathematical structures we use in physics are built.The line between math and physicsGabriele Carcassi2024-09-01 | Can we create a formal system for all of physics, like we have for mathematics or computer science? Like many physicists, I used to think we can't. Turns out that we can, provided we understand what parts can and cannot be formalized. This video will go through the main problems in creating a formal system that can work for all of physics.
#foundationsofphysics #assumptionsofphysics #physics #formalsystemsHamiltonian mechanics in 12 equivalent characterizationsGabriele Carcassi2024-08-01 | What does Hamiltonian mechanics represent at the mathematical, geometrical and physical level? Here are 12 equivalent characterizations of Hamiltonian mechanics for one degree of freedom, that shows how the flow of states is the gradient of the Hamiltonian rotated 90 degrees, is incompressible, preserves area and, physically, it corresponds to deterministic and reversible evolution.
#classicalmechanics #hamiltonian #symplecticgeometry #determinismNo dissipative Lagrangians (or Hamiltonians)Gabriele Carcassi2024-07-01 | Can Lagrangian (or Hamiltonian) mechanics really describe dissipative forces? What about time varying Lagrangians/Hamiltonians? In this video we show how some Lagrangians/Hamiltonians recover the kinematics of a dissipative system, but not the dynamics.
#classicalmechanics #lagrangian #hamiltonian #newtonianmechanics #determinism #dissipativeforcesNewtonian/Lagrangian/Hamiltonian mechanics are not equivalentGabriele Carcassi2024-06-01 | Are the three formulations of classical mechanics really equivalent? In this video we go through some arguments and examples that show that this is not the case.
#classicalmechanics #lagrangian #hamiltonian #newtonianmechanics #determinismNew channel - crowdresearch for Assumptions of Physics?Gabriele Carcassi2024-05-21 | I am opening a new channel www.youtube.com/@AssumptionsofPhysicsResearch for the actual research: I'll post open problems and conjectures... and maybe someone will help? With actual pointers to solutions? Will it work? Or, most likely, will I only get messages about multiverses and "this ONE trick"? Subscribe here www.youtube.com/@AssumptionsofPhysicsResearch to find out!Mathematics is meaninglessGabriele Carcassi2024-05-06 | Clip from the comedy lecture "An engineer in the foundations of physics."
#mathematics #physics #comedyAn engineer in the foundations of physics - a comedy lecture by Gabriele CarcassiGabriele Carcassi2024-05-01 | Gabriele Carcassi, lead of the project Assumptions of Physics, will offer a lighthearted glimpse of the technical – but mainly sociological – challenges within the foundations of physics. Through original music and stolen jokes, he will lift the rug and shed light on those questions that were swept there. Can they be answered? Join us to find out!
Recording of the April 19, 2024 performance at the University of Michigan.A no-go theorem for psi-ontic modelsGabriele Carcassi2024-04-01 | This video shows how psi-ontic model cannot reproduce results from quantum statistical mechanics and quantum information theory. The issue is that the ontological model are too classical as the assume that quantum statistical ensembles are equivalent to classical ensembles over the space of ontic states.
This is part of our more general project, Assumptions of Physics ( assumptionsofphysics.org ).How quantum mechanics requires non-additive measuresGabriele Carcassi2024-03-01 | This video shows how a quantum analogue of the count of states must be non-additive: the total number of states is not necessarily the sum of disjoint subsets. The non-additivity appears because of contextuality: not all states are counted at all-else-being-equal. Quantization can be understood as imposing a count of states that is finite on finite continuous sets and is unitary on each single state.
Preview (0:00) Intro (1:13) 1. To understand quantum mechanics, we need the right interpretation (2:34) 2. Explanations must be about mechanisms (7:24) 3. The laws of physics are the laws of the universe (14:35) 4. The laws of physics are found experimentally (22:00) 5. Mathematical details are for mathematicians to worry about (29:57) 6. There is only one correct way to do mathematics (35:46) 7. A theory of everything is the right foundation for physics (39:58) A different approach to the foundations of physics (41:06) Conclusion (48:53)Assumptions of Physics - 2023-24 statusGabriele Carcassi2024-01-01 | Status and overview of the Assumptions of Physics project as of December 2023.Channel/project news: 2023 in review - Q&A on foundations?Gabriele Carcassi2023-12-15 | Channel news. Review progress for channel and Assumptions of Physics project. Should we start Q&A videos on topics on the foundations of physics?Infinite dimensional spaces in quantum mechanicsGabriele Carcassi2023-12-01 | In this video we will explore the issue of infinite dimensional spaces in quantum mechanics. There are some technical and conceptual issue that make the topic... a bit of a mess! We will see how completeness under Cauchy sequences define superposition over infinite states, while also including states within infinite expectation values. We will see that Hilbert spaces for discrete and continuous variables are mathematically the same space. We will briefly see Schwartz spaces and "rigged" Hilbert spaces.
Intro (0:00) Infinite dimensions (1:13) Hilbert spaces (2:22) Cauchy sequences (3:28) Infinite/undefined expectation (7:29) Continuous observables (11:20) Delta-Dirac not in Hilbert (14:46) Wavefunctions have countable bases (17:30) Rigged Hilbert spaces (22:39) Conclusion (27:18)Understanding the space of quantum mixed statesGabriele Carcassi2023-11-01 | In this video we will explore the geometry of the space of quantum mixed states/ensembles. While most people concentrate on the pure states and the complex vector space, a good understanding of the space of mixtures is crucial to understand quantum mechanics. We will see the space of both classical and quantum ensembles, see how they compare, and develop a parallel between quantum mechanics and thermodynamics.
Intro (0:00) Superposition vs mixed states (1:08) Classical finite (3:42) Classical infinite discrete (11:28) Classical continuum (13:59) Classical recap (18:42) Quantum mixtures (19:31) Evolutions of ensembles (29:35) Thermodynamic analogies (32:33) Quantum infinite case (39:55) Classical vs quantum (42:47) Conclusion (44:30)Understanding vector spaces in quantum mechanicsGabriele Carcassi2023-10-01 | In this video we will explore the geometry of quantum states. While these are usually represented by vectors in Hilbert spaces, the true space is the projective space (the space of the "rays", one-dimensional sub-spaces). We will also see what is the difference between a complex vector space and a real vector space with double dimensions.
Intro (0:00) States are "rays" (1:11) Real projective line (3:08) Real projective plane (8:44) Real vs Complex vector spaces (13:20) Complex projective line (18:40) Bloch sphere (23:40) Superposition (29:35) Time evolution (32:06) Physicality of superposition (38:16) Conclusion (45:00)No such thing as quantum logicGabriele Carcassi2023-09-01 | We show that the arguments that claim that quantum mechanics requires a departure from classical logic are based on misleading claims. Similar claims can be made for classical mechanics. We also go through the mathematical structure of quantum logic, and show that is neither "quantum" (i.e. it is not specific to quantum mechanics) nor a "logic" (i.e. it does not contain all the statements required to describe quantum systems).
Relevant papers: Reverse Physics: From Laws to Physical Assumptions ( doi.org/10.1007/s10701-022-00555-z ) From physical assumptions to classical and quantum Hamiltonian and Lagrangian particle mechanics ( doi.org/10.1088/2399-6528/aaba25 )Action principle: geometric and physical interpretationGabriele Carcassi2023-03-18 | Every wondered what is the Lagrangian? What is the action? What does the action means physically? Whether there is a geometrical interpretation for the action principle? I certainly have for a long time!
Intro (0:00) Geometrical insight (1:27) L ≠ T - V (6:19) Hamiltonian (Det/Rev) flow (8:18) Action principle explained (15:22) Conclusion (20:03)What is a number? (Discussions on the Foundations of Physics and Mathematics)Gabriele Carcassi2022-10-25 | How do mathematicians define numbers? Do the definitions match to what we want to describe in physics? Are these definitions always valid? How are these questions relevant to the mathematical foundation of our physical theories?
Intro (0:00) Peano's axioms for the naturals (2:10) Von Neumann ordinals - Naturals in set theory (6:47) Integers in set theory (11:59) Rationals in set theory (14:30) Reals in set theory - Dedekind cuts (18:17) Discussion on set theoretical definitions (22:55) Intro to algebraic structures (25:44) Monoids (29:47) Groups (32:36) Rings and fields (34:33) Discussion on algebraic definitions (39:14) Numeric quantities in physics (43:07) Linear (total) orders (48:24) Classifying orders (52:05) Numbers as orders (56:44) Physical assumptions for orders (1:00:26) What about complex numbers?!? (1:06:14) Units and vector spaces (1:08:47) Groups, fields as transformations (1:16:40) Wrapping up (1:18:47)Time as an operational definitionGabriele Carcassi2022-07-20 | Presentation given in 2022 at the:
Lisbon-Lausanne Workshop “On Time in the Foundations of Physics” Gabriele Carcassi
Intro (0:00) What is time (3:45) A metrological model of time (21:24) The inevitable failure of time ordering (31:14) Conclusions (42:16)Reverse Physics: From Laws to Physical AssumptionsGabriele Carcassi2022-03-10 | Video presentation of our paper:
Reverse Physics: From Laws to Physical Gabriele Carcassi and Christine A. Aidala
Intro (0:00) Reversing classical mechanics (3:15) Uncertainty principle in classical and quantum mechanics (13:39) The third law of thermodynamics revisited (19:40) Discussion and conclusions (23:25)What we learned from proving a quantum postulate redundantGabriele Carcassi2022-01-10 | Video presentation of our paper:
Four Postulates of Quantum Mechanics Are Three Gabriele Carcassi, Lorenzo Maccone, and Christine A. Aidala Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 110402 – Published 16 March 2021
Intro (0:00) The setup (2:21) The proof (13:58) The commentary (30:40)All quantum states are equally undetermined (Quantum Essentials)Gabriele Carcassi2021-11-09 | ...Quantum states are equilibria (Quantum Essentials)Gabriele Carcassi2021-11-02 | ...Divisible vs Reducible vs Decomposable (Quantum Essentials)Gabriele Carcassi2021-10-26 | ...What is a quantum system (Quantum Essentials)Gabriele Carcassi2021-10-19 | ...Wrong Classical-Quantum Comparisons (Quantum Essentials)Gabriele Carcassi2021-10-12 | ...Why Classical Mechanics Fails (Quantum Essentials)Gabriele Carcassi2021-10-05 | In this video we explore how classical mechanics fails at a conceptual level. Classical mechanics implicitly assumes perfect isolation at all scales, which is a problematic.Understanding Shannon entropy: (6) Connection to physicsGabriele Carcassi2020-08-31 | In this series of videos we'll try to bring some clarity to the concept of entropy. We'll specifically take the Shannon entropy and: * show that it represents the variability of the elements within a distribution, how different are they from each other (general characterization that works in _all_ disciplines) * show that this variability is measured in terms of the minimum number of questions needed to identify an element in the distribution (link to information theory) * show that this is related to the logarithm of the number of permutations over large sequences (link to combinatorics) * show that it is not in general coordinate independent (and that the KL divergence does not fix this) * show that it is coordinate independent on physical state spaces - classical phase space and quantum Hilbert space (that is why those spaces are important in physics) * show the link between the Shannon entropy to the Boltzmann, Gibbs and Von Neumann entropies (link to physics)
Most of these ideas are from our paper: arxiv.org/abs/1912.02012 which is part of our bigger project Assumptions of Physics: assumptionsofphysics.orgUnderstanding Shannon entropy: (5) invariant distributionsGabriele Carcassi2020-08-24 | In this series of videos we'll try to bring some clarity to the concept of entropy. We'll specifically take the Shannon entropy and: * show that it represents the variability of the elements within a distribution, how different are they from each other (general characterization that works in _all_ disciplines) * show that this variability is measured in terms of the minimum number of questions needed to identify an element in the distribution (link to information theory) * show that this is related to the logarithm of the number of permutations over large sequences (link to combinatorics) * show that it is not in general coordinate independent (and that the KL divergence does not fix this) * show that it is coordinate independent on physical state spaces - classical phase space and quantum Hilbert space (that is why those spaces are important in physics) * show the link between the Shannon entropy to the Boltzmann, Gibbs and Von Neumann entropies (link to physics)
Most of these ideas are from our paper: arxiv.org/abs/1912.02012 which is part of our bigger project Assumptions of Physics: assumptionsofphysics.orgUnderstanding Shannon entropy: (4) continuous distributionsGabriele Carcassi2020-08-17 | In this series of videos we'll try to bring some clarity to the concept of entropy. We'll specifically take the Shannon entropy and: * show that it represents the variability of the elements within a distribution, how different are they from each other (general characterization that works in _all_ disciplines) * show that this variability is measured in terms of the minimum number of questions needed to identify an element in the distribution (link to information theory) * show that this is related to the logarithm of the number of permutations over large sequences (link to combinatorics) * show that it is not in general coordinate independent (and that the KL divergence does not fix this) * show that it is coordinate independent on physical state spaces - classical phase space and quantum Hilbert space (that is why those spaces are important in physics) * show the link between the Shannon entropy to the Boltzmann, Gibbs and Von Neumann entropies (link to physics)
Most of these ideas are from our paper: arxiv.org/abs/1912.02012 which is part of our bigger project Assumptions of Physics: assumptionsofphysics.orgUnderstanding Shannon entropy: (3) permutations and variabilityGabriele Carcassi2020-08-10 | In this series of videos we'll try to bring some clarity to the concept of entropy. We'll specifically take the Shannon entropy and: * show that it represents the variability of the elements within a distribution, how different are they from each other (general characterization that works in _all_ disciplines) * show that this variability is measured in terms of the minimum number of questions needed to identify an element in the distribution (link to information theory) * show that this is related to the logarithm of the number of permutations over large sequences (link to combinatorics) * show that it is not in general coordinate independent (and that the KL divergence does not fix this) * show that it is coordinate independent on physical state spaces - classical phase space and quantum Hilbert space (that is why those spaces are important in physics) * show the link between the Shannon entropy to the Boltzmann, Gibbs and Von Neumann entropies (link to physics)
Most of these ideas are from our paper: arxiv.org/abs/1912.02012 which is part of our bigger project Assumptions of Physics: assumptionsofphysics.orgUnderstanding Shannon entropy: (2) variability and bitsGabriele Carcassi2020-08-03 | In this series of videos we'll try to bring some clarity to the concept of entropy. We'll specifically take the Shannon entropy and: * show that it represents the variability of the elements within a distribution, how different are they from each other (general characterization that works in _all_ disciplines) * show that this variability is measured in terms of the minimum number of questions needed to identify an element in the distribution (link to information theory) * show that this is related to the logarithm of the number of permutations over large sequences (link to combinatorics) * show that it is not in general coordinate independent (and that the KL divergence does not fix this) * show that it is coordinate independent on physical state spaces - classical phase space and quantum Hilbert space (that is why those spaces are important in physics) * show the link between the Shannon entropy to the Boltzmann, Gibbs and Von Neumann entropies (link to physics)
Most of these ideas are from our paper: arxiv.org/abs/1912.02012 which is part of our bigger project Assumptions of Physics: assumptionsofphysics.orgUnderstanding Shannon entropy: (1) variability within a distributionGabriele Carcassi2020-07-27 | In this series of videos we'll try to bring some clarity to the concept of entropy. We'll specifically take the Shannon entropy and: * show that it represents the variability of the elements within a distribution, how different are they from each other (general characterization that works in _all_ disciplines) * show that this variability is measured in terms of the minimum number of questions needed to identify an element in the distribution (link to information theory) * show that this is related to the logarithm of the number of permutations over large sequences (link to combinatorics) * show that it is not in general coordinate independent (and that the KL divergence does not fix this) * show that it is coordinate independent on physical state spaces - classical phase space and quantum Hilbert space (that is why those spaces are important in physics) * show the link between the Shannon entropy to the Boltzmann, Gibbs and Von Neumann entropies (link to physics)
Most of these ideas are from our paper: arxiv.org/abs/1912.02012 which is part of our bigger project Assumptions of Physics: assumptionsofphysics.orgOn experimental verificationGabriele Carcassi2020-07-13 | ...What is mass?Gabriele Carcassi2020-07-06 | ...The laws of physics are not the laws of the universeGabriele Carcassi2020-06-29 | ...p is not mvGabriele Carcassi2020-06-22 | In this short video we talk about the difference between conjugate momentum p and kinetic momentum mvOn mathematical precision and physical theoriesGabriele Carcassi2020-06-15 | ...No attractors in Hamiltonian mechanicsGabriele Carcassi2020-06-08 | Hamiltonian systems cannot have attractors (i.e. stable regions) and therefore cannot describe dissipative systems.Update 06-2020Gabriele Carcassi2020-06-01 | Channel update and plans for 06/2020
Facebook: facebook.com/Assumptions-of-Physics-107629167617556 Project website: assumptionsofphysics.orgUnderstanding Lagrangian mechanics: (3) The physical motivationGabriele Carcassi2018-05-14 | A way to understand the geometry of Lagrangian mechanics and its physical significance.Understanding Lagrangian mechanics: (2) The geometryGabriele Carcassi2018-04-17 | A way to understand the geometry of Lagrangian mechanics and its physical significance.Understanding Lagrangian mechanics: (1) The mathGabriele Carcassi2018-04-11 | A way to understand the geometry of Lagrangian mechanics and its physical significance.Understanding Vector Calculus: (3) Divergence and volumesGabriele Carcassi2015-05-31 | A review of vector calculus that presents the geometrical meaning of all the operators and helps understand their connection to each other. See all videos in the series: