In this third discussion with Lori, we continue from the idea that space may have real physical properties, and ask what follows for special relativity.
The central question is not whether the mathematics of special relativity works - it clearly does. The question is whether there is a simple mechanical way to understand why moving clocks tick more slowly, why moving rods contract, and why the measured two-way speed of light comes out the same for every observer.
We start with the same minimal assumption as before: suppose there is some kind of elastic continuum that supports transverse waves. We do not need to specify what this medium is made of, whether it is continuous or granular, or what its microscopic structure might be. For this episode, the important point is just that waves in such a medium have a characteristic speed determined by stiffness and density.
From there, we look again at refraction and matter waves, using simple visualizations like people walking in grass and mud. The goal is to make clear why not only light waves, but also localized matter-like wave patterns, would bend toward regions where the effective wave speed is lower.
Then we turn to SR itself. A moving light clock has a longer diagonal path, so it ticks more slowly. This gives the usual Lorentz factor from simple geometry. We also discuss why this is not special pleading with "light clocks": if matter and clocks are ultimately wave-based, then their internal processes are governed by the same wave speed.
The next step is length contraction. We also revisit the Michelson-Morley experiment and why the null result does not rule out a medium; it rules out a naive rigid-body ether model.
The later part of the conversation looks at several attempts to detect a hidden medium frame. Each time, the same pattern appears: once rods, clocks, and signals are all treated as wave-based systems, the ordinary special-relativistic cancellations reappear.
The medium frame is useful as a mechanical explanation, but it remains hidden from ordinary special-relativity experiments because the measuring devices co-transform with the waves they measure. Not needing the medium in the equations is not the same as proving that such a medium cannot exist.
References: * Elastic waves steered by a reconfigurable medium / elastic wave refraction example: pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4830996 * Phononic-crystal Luneburg lens for elastic-wave focusing and energy harvesting: https://tol.engin.umich.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/416/2021/02/Phononic-crystal-Luneburg-lens-for-omnidirectional-elastic-wave-focusing-and-energy-harvesting.pdf * Robert A. Close - The Other Meaning of Special Relativity: classicalmatter.org/Physics/ClassicalTheory/OtherRelativity.pdf
In this third discussion with Lori, we continue from the idea that space may have real physical properties, and ask what follows for special relativity.
The central question is not whether the mathematics of special relativity works - it clearly does. The question is whether there is a simple mechanical way to understand why moving clocks tick more slowly, why moving rods contract, and why the measured two-way speed of light comes out the same for every observer.
We start with the same minimal assumption as before: suppose there is some kind of elastic continuum that supports transverse waves. We do not need to specify what this medium is made of, whether it is continuous or granular, or what its microscopic structure might be. For this episode, the important point is just that waves in such a medium have a characteristic speed determined by stiffness and density.
From there, we look again at refraction and matter waves, using simple visualizations like people walking in grass and mud. The goal is to make clear why not only light waves, but also localized matter-like wave patterns, would bend toward regions where the effective wave speed is lower.
Then we turn to SR itself. A moving light clock has a longer diagonal path, so it ticks more slowly. This gives the usual Lorentz factor from simple geometry. We also discuss why this is not special pleading with "light clocks": if matter and clocks are ultimately wave-based, then their internal processes are governed by the same wave speed.
The next step is length contraction. We also revisit the Michelson-Morley experiment and why the null result does not rule out a medium; it rules out a naive rigid-body ether model.
The later part of the conversation looks at several attempts to detect a hidden medium frame. Each time, the same pattern appears: once rods, clocks, and signals are all treated as wave-based systems, the ordinary special-relativistic cancellations reappear.
The medium frame is useful as a mechanical explanation, but it remains hidden from ordinary special-relativity experiments because the measuring devices co-transform with the waves they measure. Not needing the medium in the equations is not the same as proving that such a medium cannot exist.
What does spin-½ actually mean? Why does a spinor need 720° to return to its original state, and could this strange property have a physical explanation in an elastic medium?
In this episode of The Mechanical Universe, we explore spin-½ as a continuous motion in a hypothetical elastic continuum. Starting from experimental evidence, we use interactive simulations to investigate how the same kind of connected wave motion might relate to angular momentum, magnetism and interference.
We explore: - The Einstein–de Haas effect and why spin carries real angular momentum - Neutron interferometry and the 360° sign change / 720° return - The belt trick and how twisting a connected medium produces spin-½ geometry - Maxwell's mechanical model of magnetism and magnetic attraction/repulsion - Distributed spin fields, wave propagation and double-slit interference - Quaternions, rotations and their connection to spinors and the Dirac equation
The simulations demonstrate possible geometries and kinematics; deriving the dynamics, stability and interactions of such a medium remains an open problem.
### INTERACTIVE SIMULATIONS
Complete library (including the demos shown here): https://mechanical-universe-lab.korosten.chatgpt.site/
In this fourth discussion with Lori, we ask a basic question: if light is a real wave in an elastic medium, what do we actually mean by a "photon"?
We begin with phonons - quantized vibrational modes in ordinary solids. Phonons are called quasiparticles, but we know they are collective waves. They can interfere, pass through double-slit arrangements, undergo quantum-erasure experiments, and produce discrete detector clicks. This gives us a useful mechanical comparison for light.
We then look at quantization as a natural property of trapped waves. A string, drumhead, or spherical wave supports only certain stable modes. Matter waves and electron orbitals can be viewed through the same language of standing waves and spherical harmonics, with transitions between modes taking place continuously.
The main focus is the photoelectric effect. Using resonance, detector thresholds, and Fermi's Golden Rule, we explore how a continuous electromagnetic wave can drive an electron between discrete energy levels. Frequency selects which transitions are possible, while intensity affects the transition rate. The resulting electron emission is a discrete detection event even if the incoming light is a wave.
We also discuss single-emission pulses, double-slit detection patterns, the Wiener experiment, Compton scattering, Planck's constant, uncertainty as a Fourier property of localized waves, and matter-antimatter annihilation as one wave pattern cancelling into another. The proposal explored here is that a photon need not be an infinitesimal point particle: it can be understood as an emission or detection event associated with a real electromagnetic wave.
In this second discussion with Lori, we continue from the basic idea that space may have real physical properties, and ask what follows from that for general relativity.
The main question is very simple: if space behaves like an elastic medium, could gravity be understood as refraction? We go step by step through the logic. First, we talk about why transverse gravitational waves and electromagnetic waves suggest that the medium must support shear, and therefore must in some sense be elastic.
From there, I use several simple visualizations - including marching people walking from grass into mud - to show how a wave bends whenever its speed changes across a gradient. That gives a very intuitive picture of refraction, and from that, a simple way to think about gravitational bending of light.
We then connect this to clocks, time dilation, and the metric tensor. The core idea is that if the wave speed changes locally because density or elasticity changes, then light clocks slow down as well. In this view, the metric tensor is not something mysterious - it is simply a way to describe local stretching, compression, and distortion of the medium.
We also talk about gravitational redshift, optical black-hole analogies, the photon sphere, and why refractive models of gravity are not new. Newton already suggested something very similar, and later work by people like Kleinert and Robert Close explored related ideas in more detail.
We also discuss he river model of gravity, Halton Arp and redshift, analog black holes, and possible medium models. Throughout the discussion, the focus stays on one basic question: if space has physical qualities, can general relativity emerge naturally from an elastic-medium picture?
This is the start of a new 11-episode discussion series with Lori, where we go through the big picture step by step - from the basic question of whether space has properties, all the way to GR, SR, light, matter, spin 1/2, charge, Maxwell, and quantum mechanics.
In this first episode, we talk about why it is even worth asking these questions in the first place. Why we are not satisfied with just the equations? Why do we keep looking for a mechanical explanation? And why do we think it is reasonable to take the idea of an elastic medium seriously? We also talk about Einstein’s ether quote, the Michelson-Morley experiment, why it only ruled out certain naive ether models, and why a wave-based picture of matter changes the logic. Then we look at elasticity, transverse waves, the speed of light, and what kind of medium could in principle support such behavior. Lori also brings in her own perspective from ultrasound and wave propagation in real materials, and we briefly touch on different possibilities for what the deeper medium might be.
So this episode is really about motivation, assumptions, and the first basic question: if space can curve, stretch, and support waves, what kind of thing might it be?
Elasticity: 1D jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/pbzhdy5x 3D (springs): jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/rehu530tThe Mechanical Universe S01E1: Properties of SpaceRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2025-11-29 | Does space have properties? We all grow up seeing those famous images where spacetime is drawn as a stretchy grid that bends under planets and stars. But when you ask what is that grid actually made of, the usual answer is: nothing. It’s “just geometry.” And if you ask how this abstract geometry can physically bend light and change clock rates… things get hand-wavy fast. In this first episode, we dig into a simple but surprisingly powerful idea: What if space (or the medium of space, or the ether if you like that word) actually has physical properties – the way real materials do?
Throughout the episode, we explore interactive simulations, visual demos, and hands-on examples – all designed to make these ideas intuitive rather than mystical.
This season is all about the big picture. After laying the groundwork with the properties of space, we’ll dive into many core topics – general relativity, special relativity, spin 1/2, charge, electromagnetism, photons, matter waves, and more. Each episode focuses on one core idea at a time, building toward a coherent mechanical view of physics.
About my co-host / listener: Throughout the series, I’m joined by James Ellias from Inductica. James is known for his clear, philosophical approach to physics and for digging into the underlying mechanisms behind fields, forces, and measurement. He offers great questions, pushes back where needed, and keeps the discussions grounded and lively. His role in these episodes is to act as the curious, critical listener - helping unpack the ideas, challenge assumptions, and make the explanations sharper and more intuitive for everyone watching.
Moving Beyond Spacetime Geometry: The conventional view holds that the Lorentz transformations, which govern changes in length and time, are derived directly from the postulate that the speed of light (c) is constant for all inertial observers. However, this paper demonstrates that Lorentz invariance is actually a general property of waves. The Lorentz transformations can be obtained for any type of wave simply by defining distance as proportional to wave propagation time. This suggests that relativistic effects are not innate properties of non-Euclidean space-time, but rather result from the methods used to measure time and distance. The Soliton Hypothesis: If the Lorentz transformations apply to waves in general, what makes light special? The paper argues that the distinguishing feature of light is that measurements made using light propagation correspond exactly with those made by material rulers and clocks. Taking this equivalence as an alternative postulate, the paper proposes that matter consists of soliton waves propagating at the speed of light. This approach is consistent with the de Broglie wave hypothesis and the Dirac velocity operator of quantum mechanics. The famous mass-energy relation (E=mc 2 ) is shown to follow directly from treating the matter particle as a wave packet, simply by applying the Pythagorean theorem to its wave vector components. Key Takeaways: This alternative interpretation suggests that the observed constancy of the speed of light arises because the measuring instruments (which are themselves matter waves propagating at c) and the light waves are equally affected by motion through the vacuum. This perspective is entirely consistent with classical notions of absolute space and time, offering a unique lens through which to view Special Relativity. Furthermore, it implies that matter and antimatter can transform into photons because photons and matter are simply different packets of the same type of wave.Bell Violation without EntanglementRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2025-08-07 | This paper describes an experiment that challenges the long-held assumption that quantum entanglement is necessary for violating Bell's inequality, a fundamental principle in quantum mechanics that differentiates between classical and quantum correlations. The authors demonstrate that quantum indistinguishability, specifically through multi-photon frustrated interference, can also lead to a violation of this inequality. Their setup uses four unentangled photons generated from non-linear crystals, where the paths of photon generation are made indistinguishable. By analyzing four-fold coincidence counts and applying a modified Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) Bell test, they observe a significant violation, exceeding four standard deviations. This research suggests a new perspective on the origins of quantum correlations and their conflict with local realism, moving beyond entanglement as the sole explanation.
A recording of a talk at the PAMO conference in München, June 2025, organized by Dialect (youtube.com/@dialectphilosophy)
The Mechanical Universe: Rethinking Spin, Charge, and Gravity in an Elastic Solid
Can the universe be modeled as an elastic solid? In this talk, we explore a provocative alternative to modern quantum and relativistic physics: a mechanical model where matter and fields are real vibrations in a continuous elastic medium.
Building on the work of Robert Close, Sergey Rashkovskiy, Marek Danielewski and others, we revisit quantum phenomena like spin-½, the photoelectric effect, and the Stern-Gerlach experiment. We show how spin can emerge from classical field dynamics, how the Dirac equation arises from elastic wave motion, and how the mysterious wave-particle duality resolves when waves - not particles - interact with detectors.
We reinterpret general relativity as a theory of refraction: gravity as a change in the elastic properties of space, not a geometric curvature. The constancy of light speed, time dilation, and mass-energy equivalence all follow from the wave nature of matter.
From classical torsion waves to topological defects as electric charge, this model offers a unifying, intuitive framework grounded in mechanics.
This research article derives a nonlinear generalization of Maxwell’s equations from a variational approach, when the action measures the variability of the metric tensor. The proper space is a Weyl space, where the covariant derivative of the metric tensor does not need to vanish. The Lorentz force law is derived from the same metrics as a geodesic equation. The charge density is shown to obey a covariant wave equation, which indicates that charge density is a field, which propagates at the speed of light. This viewpoint promotes the wave-picture of the electron. The results indicate that the Dirac equation is a geometric equation as well. As the electrodynamic force, i.e. the Lorentz force can be related directly to the metrical structure of spacetime, it directly leads to the explanation of the Zitterbewegung phenomenon and quantum mechanical waves as well.The Mechanical UniverseRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2025-03-09 | This has resulted in a much larger discussion presented here: Playlist with James (Inductica): youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDIKbbZkdruVFKYPulOOpVfVes9jQrMNc Playlist with Lori (FractalWoman): youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDIKbbZkdruVjdIFwPbfIA4ZbPajrqoKo
In this video I give an overview of how an elastic solid model of the universe could explain electromagnetic fields, electromagnetic forces, general relativity, special relativity, and can account for the mechanics of spin 1/2 particles.
Inductica: youtube.com/@InducticaNewton’s aether model (elastic solid)Red Pill (Chantal Roth)2024-12-03 | Newton’s aether model Paper by Eric Baird Isaac Newton is usually associated with the idea of absolute space and time, and with ballistic light-corpuscle arguments. However, Newton was also a proponent of wave/particle duality, and published a “new” variable-density aether model in which light and matter trajectories were either bent by gravitational fields, or deflected by an aether density gradient. Newton’s (flawed) aether model can be considered as an early attempt at a curved-space model of gravity.
Special relativity as an emergent phenomenon of any wave based system
A very simple explanation (elementary and high school level) explanation of how special relativity arises from any (pure) wave based system.
A few references mentioned in the presentation:
M. Danielewski: “The Planck-Kleinert Crystal”, Z. Naturforsch. 62a, 564-568 (2007).
Hagen Kleinert: Gravity as Theory of Defects in a Crystal with Only Second-Gradient Elasticity, Annalen der Physik, Bd. 44, 1987, S. 117,http://www.scielo.br/pdf/bjp/v35n2a/a22v352a.pdf
H. Kleinert & J. Zaanen, „Nematic world crystal model of gravity explaining absence of torsion in spacetime”, Physics Letters A 324 (2004) 361–365. QM Seminar: http://th.if.uj.edu.pl/~dudaj/QMFNoT
A few of the features and concepts: Quantum Number Adjustment: Modify the principal quantum number (n), azimuthal quantum number (l), and magnetic quantum number (m) to see how the wave functions change in real time.
Scalar and Vector Harmonics: Switch between scalar and vector spherical harmonics to explore different aspects of quantum wave functions.
Spin-1/2 Transformation: Apply spinor transformations to visualize the effects of spin on quantum states, demonstrating concepts like spin precession.
Charge Wave Transformation: Observe the dynamics of plus and minus charge waves and how they influence the overall wave function.
Highlighted Points with Trails: Highlight multiple random points within the simulation and track their motion over time in an elastic solid with trailing paths, enhancing the understanding of particle dynamics.
Slicing and Visualization Options: Slice the visualization along different axes (X, Y, Z) to examine cross-sectional views and adjust color schemes based on amplitude or phase for better clarity.
Relevant Concepts and Formulas: Spherical Harmonics: Mathematical functions that arise in solving the angular part of Laplace's equation in spherical coordinates. They are crucial in quantum mechanics for describing angular momentum states.
Spin (Physics): An intrinsic form of angular momentum carried by elementary particles, composite particles (hadrons), and atomic nuclei. Spin-1/2 particles, like electrons, have unique quantum properties.
Radial Wave Functions: Solutions to the radial part of the Schrödinger equation for a spherically symmetric potential. They describe how the amplitude of the wave function varies with distance from the nucleus.
Associated Legendre Polynomials: Functions used in the solution of the angular part of Laplace's equation. They are essential in computing spherical harmonics.
Spinor Transformations: Mathematical operations that describe the spin state of particles. Spinors are used to represent the state of spin-1/2 particles in quantum mechanics.
* re charge: this is speculation, I am not certain if this is what it "looks" like, but it is the only solution I have seen so far that is perfectly radially symmetrical and has exactly two possibilities (plus and minus)A problem with the conservation law observed in macroscopic quantum phenomenaRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2024-10-12 | This paper argues that the conventional theory of superconductivity contradicts the correspondence principle, which states that quantum mechanics should converge to classical mechanics at macroscopic levels. The author uses the example of persistent currents in superconducting rings to demonstrate that the correspondence principle is violated when dealing with macroscopic quantum phenomena. They claim that the angular momentum of mobile charge carriers changes by a macroscopic amount due to quantization, and this contradiction is further exacerbated by the Meissner effect, which violates Faraday's Law and the law of angular momentum conservation. Additionally, the author criticizes the conventional theory of superconductivity for contradicting the second law of thermodynamics, specifically by failing to explain how the persistent currents are annihilated before the material becomes resistive.
Please feel free to comment! There is also a simulation on charge... which, in contrast to spin 1/2, is spherically symmetrical: youtu.be/lAVTwKLFbOgCharge in an elastic solidRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2024-10-04 | This simulates charge in an elastic solid using harmonic bulk oszillation. The key point here is that in contrast to spin 1/2, charge is spherically symmetrical. So the markers rotate in the same direction regardless of how the scene is rotated. (There is a second way to model charge, which I will explain shortly)
Created with notebooklm.google.com and https://make.headliner.app/A Time Traveler’s History of PhysicsRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2024-09-29 | The source, titled "A Time Traveler’s History of Physics," attempts to present a logical, rather than chronological, history of physics by reexamining accepted beliefs about the aether, electromagnetism, relativity, and quantum mechanics. The author argues that many common misconceptions about physics persist, and that these misconceptions can be revealed by imagining how our understanding of these concepts would change if historical events had occurred in a different order. The author uses this method to develop a new framework for understanding these concepts, one that emphasizes the wave nature of matter, the role of the aether, and the importance of rotational waves in understanding fundamental particles.
Created with notebooklm.google.com and https://make.headliner.app/The Different Meanings of “Spin”Red Pill (Chantal Roth)2024-09-29 | This paper explores the multifaceted meaning of the term "spin" in physics and mathematics, outlining three distinct interpretations: kinetic spin, referring to the angular velocity of an object or fluid; geometric spin, quantifying the pointwise symmetry of basis states under rotations; and dynamic spin, representing the intrinsic angular momentum associated with the rotational motion of a medium. The paper provides mathematical descriptions of these different meanings, including explanations of integer and half-integer spins. The authors argue that spin is not a mysterious quantum property but rather a fundamental aspect of classical angular momentum, often misinterpreted as a result of the wave nature of objects in modern physics.
Created with notebooklm.google.com and https://make.headliner.app/Predictions and Validations of an Elastic Solid Aether ModelRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2024-09-29 | This text is an excerpt from a paper titled "AetherValidations.pdf" by Robert Close, PhD, which argues for the existence of an elastic solid aether. The paper aims to demonstrate that various phenomena in physics, including the Michelson-Morley experiment, the Doppler effect, and the bending of light around massive objects, are consistent with this model. Close argues that light and matter consist of waves propagating through this aether, providing a theoretical basis for a wide range of physical phenomena. The paper also examines the implications of the aether model for quantum mechanics, particularly the nature of spin and the exclusion principle.
Created with notebooklm.google.com and https://make.headliner.app/Hagen Kleinerts World CrystalRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2024-09-29 | https://hagenkleinert.de/documents/articles/359.pdf
In his paper, written by H. Kleinert, proposes that Einstein's theory of gravity can be understood as arising from defects in a "world crystal". The world crystal is a hypothetical structure with a lattice spacing on the order of the Planck length, which is the smallest possible length scale in physics. This means that the crystal's lattice structure would be undetectable at macroscopic scales. The paper explains how the distortion of this world crystal through displacement fields can lead to the emergence of gravitational forces. The paper also introduces the concept of "plastic" deformations in the world crystal, which create defects that act as sources of gravity. By introducing the concept of plastic deformations, Kleinert shows how the interaction of defects in the world crystal can be expressed in a form resembling the linearized Einstein-Hilbert action, which describes gravity. Finally, the paper briefly discusses how matter can be incorporated into this model, suggesting that matter is made up of particles that are tightly bound to the atoms of the world crystal and can only move by tunneling.
This research paper proposes a method to simulate the effects of a black hole using optical materials. The authors build upon previous work by creating an optical analogue of the Kerr–Newman black hole, which includes not only mass, but also angular momentum and electric charge. They propose and simulate the use of a gradient-index material with a scalar refractive index profile to mimic the null geodesic trajectories of light around a Kerr–Newman black hole. The paper also presents simulations of light around an optical Schwarzschild black hole, which is a special case of the Kerr–Newman black hole with no charge or angular momentum. These simulations suggest that it is possible to construct these analogues with conventional materials and metamaterials, paving the way for experimental verification of the theoretical predictions.
This paper argues that the Evans-Rosenquist formulation of the optical-mechanical analogy can be used to describe the motion of massless particles in the Schwarzschild field of general relativity. The authors show that the familiar equations for light orbit and radar echo delay, which are considered to be exclusive tests of Einstein's field equations, can be derived using the optical-mechanical analogy, which treats gravity as a refractive medium. They demonstrate this by deriving the equations using the appropriate refractive index for the Schwarzschild field, and then comparing these results to the well-known GR equations. They conclude that the optical-mechanical analogy provides a useful tool for understanding and visualizing the motion of light in a gravitational field.
Created with notebooklm.google.com and https://make.headliner.app/Classical-field model of the hydrogen atomRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2024-09-22 | This paper proposes a new classical-field model of the hydrogen atom that seeks to explain quantum phenomena without resorting to quantization. The author, Sergey A. Rashkovskiy, argues that the electron should be considered a classical wave field, rather than a particle, and that the atom can be represented as an open volume resonator where this wave field is held by the electrostatic field of the proton. The paper examines the implications of this model for spontaneous emission and the statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics. It explores the nonlinear Schrodinger equation, arguing that it is necessary to account for the inverse action of the emitted electromagnetic wave on the electron wave. The author concludes that quantum mechanics should be considered a classical theory of wave fields, capable of explaining quantum phenomena without the need for particles or quantization. S.A. Rashkovskiy
This is a "podcast" based on a paper by S.A. Rashkovskiy entitled Classical-field model of the hydrogen atom arxiv.org/pdf/1602.04090
Created with notebooklm.google.com and https://make.headliner.app/The other meaning of special relativityRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2024-09-22 | This paper proposes an alternative interpretation of special relativity, arguing that the Lorentz transformations arise from the wave nature of matter rather than the geometry of spacetime. It suggests that matter consists of soliton waves that propagate at the speed of light, a hypothesis consistent with the de Broglie wave hypothesis and the Dirac velocity operator. The author argues that the constancy of the speed of light arises from the method of measurement rather than being a fundamental property of spacetime.
Created with notebooklm.google.com and https://make.headliner.app/Are there Photons in fact?Red Pill (Chantal Roth)2024-09-22 | This paper argues that photons do not exist and that light is a continuous classical electromagnetic wave. The author presents several examples of quantum phenomena, including the double-slit experiment, the photoelectric effect, and the Compton effect, which can be explained within the framework of classical electrodynamics without quantizing radiation. He further explains that the wave-particle duality of light can be explained without invoking photons using Fermi's golden rule, and that the Heisenberg uncertainty principle has a simple classical interpretation and does not necessitate the existence of photons. Finally, the author concludes that the concept of the photon is superfluous in explaining light-matter interactions and that the electromagnetic radiation is a continuous classical wave.
Created with notebooklm.google.com and https://make.headliner.app/Classical Field Theory of the Photoelectric EffectRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2024-09-21 | This source examines the photoelectric effect through the lens of classical field theory, suggesting that a quantum interpretation of light and matter isn't necessary to explain this phenomenon. The author argues that viewing light as a classical electromagnetic wave and electrons as continuous wave fields provides a complete description of the photoelectric effect, without needing the concept of photons. The author critically reviews previous explanations of the photoelectric effect and other quantum phenomena, presenting a classical approach to understand light-atom interaction. S.A. Rashkovskiy
This is a "podcast" based on a paper by Sergey A. Rashkovskiy entitled Classical Field Theory of the Photoelectric Effect arxiv.org/pdf/1603.02102/1000
Created with notebooklm.google.com and https://make.headliner.app/Quantum Mechanics without QuantaRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2024-09-20 | The sources argue that quantum mechanics can be understood as a classical field theory, eliminating the need for particles like photons and electrons. The authors contend that light is a continuous electromagnetic wave and the "quantum" behavior observed in experiments like the double-slit experiment arises from the interaction of this wave with the discrete structure of matter. Similarly, the electron is proposed as a continuous wave field described by the Dirac equation, with its properties like spin and charge being inherent to the field itself, rather than intrinsic to individual particles. This perspective removes the need for wave-particle duality, offering a classical explanation for quantum phenomena and reinterpreting the Born rule and the Heisenberg uncertainty principle as consequences of the wave nature of these fields.
This is a "podcast" based on a paper by Sergey A. Rashkovskiy entitled Quantum mechanics without quanta arxiv.org/abs/1507.02113
Created with notebooklm.google.com and https://make.headliner.app/Disentangling the EntanglementRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2024-09-20 | This text discusses the concept of "entanglement" in quantum mechanics, focusing on its controversial nature and exploring potential explanations for the phenomenon. The author, through a series of simulations and experiments, explores the possibility of "entanglement" being explained by a lack of complete information about the system rather than an inherently inexplicable quantum effect. They discuss the "detection loophole" as a possible explanation for the observed correlations in experiments, arguing that a more complete understanding of the detection process might remove the need for a purely quantum explanation. The author emphasizes that conclusive evidence about the true nature of entanglement is still lacking, and that the current debate necessitates further research and investigation
Created with notebooklm.google.com and https://make.headliner.app/Foundations of Quaternion Quantum MechanicsRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2024-09-20 | This research paper proposes a new framework for quantum mechanics based on quaternions, a mathematical concept that extends complex numbers. The authors argue that quaternion quantum mechanics (QQM) is grounded in the classical theory of elasticity developed by Augustin Cauchy, where physical phenomena are described using field variables representing compression and twist. By applying quaternion algebra to Cauchy's theory, the authors derive the quaternion forms of the Klein–Gordon and Schrödinger equations, demonstrating the connection between quantum mechanics and the physical reality of elastic continua. QQM is presented as a more comprehensive and physically interpretable theory compared to conventional quantum mechanics, offering an alternative understanding of the origin of complex numbers and wave functions. The paper proposes experimental verifications to test the validity of QQM and highlights the potential for further generalization and extension of the framework.
Created with notebooklm.google.com and https://make.headliner.app/The Blackbody spectrum – Averting the CatastropheRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2024-09-19 | The text explores the "ultraviolet catastrophe," a problem in physics that emerged in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Classical physics predicted that a black body would emit radiation with infinite power, contradicting experimental observations. Max Planck resolved this issue by introducing the concept of quantization, where energy is emitted or absorbed in discrete packets rather than continuously. This groundbreaking idea paved the way for quantum mechanics and accurately explained the blackbody spectrum. The text then explains that the quantization of energy levels in atoms, specifically the electrons, is responsible for preventing the ultraviolet catastrophe. This understanding emerged from the work of Bohr and others, and is based on the solutions to the Schrödinger equation, which describe electron energy levels as spherical harmonics.
Created with notebooklm.google.com and https://make.headliner.app/The Photoelectric effectRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2024-09-19 | The text explores the photoelectric effect through a lens of resonance. It begins by defining and explaining resonance through several examples like microwave ovens, guitar strings, and MRI machines. It then applies the concept of resonance to the photoelectric effect, arguing that the energy of light waves must match the energy difference between electron energy levels in a metal to cause an electron to be ejected. This energy difference is called the work function. The text also discusses the implications of both frequency and intensity on the photoelectric effect, noting that while intensity affects the number of electrons ejected, only frequency determines the energy of the ejected electrons. The sources then go on to explore alternative perspectives that explain the photoelectric effect without resorting to the concept of photons.
A "podcast" created from askingwhy.org/blog/first-puzzle-just-a-probability/the-photoelectric-effect Created with notebooklm.google.com and https://make.headliner.app/Concerning the Aether (Einstein)Red Pill (Chantal Roth)2024-09-19 | The provided text is an excerpt from a speech given by Albert Einstein in 1920, entitled "Äther und Relativitätstheorie." In the speech, Einstein explores the concept of the "ether" and how it has been understood throughout the history of physics. He discusses how the idea of a medium that carries light waves was initially developed, but later challenged by the theory of special relativity. Einstein argues that while the ether cannot be understood as a substance with physical properties like a gas or liquid, the general theory of relativity necessitates the existence of an ether, but one that has no motion and is inextricably linked to the fabric of spacetime.
A "podcast" created from askingwhy.org/blog/first-puzzle-just-a-probability/puzzle-piece-3-whats-special-about-special-relativity Created with notebooklm.google.com and https://make.headliner.app/The Meaning of Wave Mechanics (Schrödinger)Red Pill (Chantal Roth)2024-09-19 | Erwin Schrödinger, a pioneer of quantum mechanics, expresses his dissatisfaction with the "probability interpretation" of the wave function, which posits that the wave function represents the probability of finding a particle in a particular state. He argues that this interpretation contradicts the fundamental principles of wave mechanics, which he believes should be based on real waves, not probabilistic ones. Schrödinger criticizes the "probability interpretation" for its reliance on "dice-miracles" and its failure to explain phenomena like the photoelectric effect. He believes that a more sophisticated wave theory based on second quantization and the non-individuality of particles can provide a more consistent and complete understanding of quantum mechanics.
A "podcast" created from askingwhy.org/blog/speeches-of-einstein-and-schrodinger/the-meaning-of-wave-mechanics-schrodinger Created with notebooklm.google.com and https://make.headliner.app/Quantum Mechanics: Strange Particle Theory or Classical Field Theory? (Sergey Rashkovskiy (RAS))Red Pill (Chantal Roth)2023-07-16 | This talk is part of our mini conferences listed here: http://th.if.uj.edu.pl/~dudaj/QMFNoT From Sergey: I show that we can avoid the QM-paradoxes if we consider some classical wave field (“an electron wave”) instead of electron as a particle and consider the wave equations (Dirac, Klein-Gordon, Pauli and Schrödinger) as the field equations for an electron field similar to Maxwell equations for the electromagnetic field. I show that such an electron field has an electric charge, an intrinsic angular momentum (spin) and an intrinsic magnetic moment continuously distributed in the space. In the framework of classical electrodynamics, we obtained the nonlinear Schrödinger equation, which accounts for the inverse action of self-electromagnetic radiation of the electron wave. I show that this equation completely and consistently describes all known properties of the hydrogen atom within the framework of classical field theory without any quantization and additional hypothesis: namely, the stability of an atom, the nature and regularities of the spontaneous emissions of an atom, a light-atom interactions, the photoelectric effect, the Compton effect, the thermal radiation, etc. In particular, Planck’s law for the spectral energy density of thermal radiation and the Einstein A-coefficient for spontaneous emission are derived in the framework of classical field theory without using the concept of “photon”. I show that the conventional corpuscular-statistical interpretation of atomic phenomena is only a misinterpretation of continuous deterministic processes. These results show that quantum mechanics must be considered to be not a theory of particles but a classical field theory in the spirit of classical electrodynamics. In conclusion, I show how Dirac equation can be coupled with Maxwell equation in order to construct the self-consistent Maxwell-Dirac theory.Quantum Mechanics from a Holographic Principle (Russell Thompson)Red Pill (Chantal Roth)2023-03-27 | Title: Quantum Mechanics from a Holographic Principle
Abstract: In 1953, Richard Feynman introduced a mathematical trick through which quantum mechanical many-body problems could be solved using classical statistical mechanics by treating the inverse of the thermal energy in the partition function as an imaginary time dimension (a Wick rotation). This opened the door for modern quantum simulation methods such as path integral Monte Carlo, centroid molecular dynamics and ring polymer molecular dynamics which are solved classically by using the extra, fictitious, dimension. Practitioners of this quantum-classical isomorphism often refer to the quantum particles they are simulating as “ring polymers” since the imaginary time parameter describes a one-dimensional trajectory that starts and stops at the same position in space, forming a closed loop when projected into 3D. It has been shown that polymer self-consistent field theory (SCFT) also obeys the quantum-classical isomorphism, and is, under the right conditions, also equivalent to quantum density functional theory (DFT). Since the theorems of DFT guarantee equivalence between the predictions of DFT and those of of quantum mechanics, the mathematics of SCFT in a 5D thermal-space-time must be dual to those of 4D non-relativistic quantum mechanics — a holographic principle. This requires speculating that Feynman’s thermal dimension is physically real instead of just a trick of the math. The 5D picture requires fewer postulates than most descriptions of quantum mechanics and uses only classical concepts, albeit in a higher dimensional space. I will give an introductions to the SCFT approach, show some numerical solutions to the non-linear SCFT equations, and consider the prospects, applications and significant limitations of the methodology. Articles: journals.aps.org/pra/pdf/10.1103/PhysRevA.102.012813 , link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10773-022-05274-9
http://th.if.uj.edu.pl/~dudaj/QMFNoT researchseminars.org/seminar/QMFNoTA Universal Particle Structure that gives all Particles Their Properties (Vivian Robinson)Red Pill (Chantal Roth)2023-03-12 | Abstract: This presentation expands on the work of Williamson and van der Mark, that electrons were photons of the appropriate energy making two revolutions per wavelength. It uses only three space dimensions and time, as well as known physical properties and constants. It shows how that structure gives all particles such properties as mass, dimensions, the physical relationship between energy and mass given by E = mc2 and the special relativity corrections with velocity. It introduces a fourth correction. It also shows the physical origins of charge, magnetic moment, spin half-hbar, spin superposition, intrinsic spin hbar, zitterbewegung, the particle’s de Broglie wavelength of particles, and similar, as appropriate.
http://th.if.uj.edu.pl/~dudaj/QMFNoT researchseminars.org/seminar/QMFNoTParticles as Maxwellian Solitons (Anton Vrba)Red Pill (Chantal Roth)2023-02-25 | Anton Vrba, Particles as Maxwellian Solitons This talk shows that EM-field waves can travel on closed and curved 3-dimensional paths and proposes EM-potential and EM-flux waves. The new insight developed here could provide a tool box to envision Maxwellian solitons, a possible aid to further the understanding of particles. The talk presents the proof that the simultaneous vector cross product equations { E = u × B; u = (B×E)/∥B∥^2; B= ( E×u)/∥u∥^2} --- (1) are a powerful reformulation of the Maxwell equations in vacuum, if u , B and E are functions of time only. The velocity vector u can now describes EM-waves in 1D (radio waves and photons), 2D and 3-dimensions (particles). The fundamental nature of (1) is demonstrated by a purely mathematical derivation for ϵ _0 and μ_0, in terms of e and h. Leveraging (1) to describe flux-waves requires the equivalent expressions for ϵ_f and μ_f, and after deriving these the Planck energy equivalence E=hf emerges from (1). The solutions to (1) set in flux are easily quantifiable; for the 3D-wave the following are identifiable: up/down, spin on two axes, charge polarity, and path closure 2nπ, with n an integer and OAM for photons. The proposed description for particles is congruent to the Bohm ˗de Broglie interpretation of quantum mechanics and a nonlocal hidden variable; this is discussed too. slides: neophysics.org/presentation/particles-as-maxwellian-solitons articles: neophysics.org/p/1673 Conference page: http://th.if.uj.edu.pl/~dudaj/QMFNoTBell Mini Conference Feb 11 2023Red Pill (Chantal Roth)2023-02-12 | Abstracts, materials, answers: https://www.dropbox.com/s/z6g4neihovi... 0:00:10 Marc Fleury, Review of Isolation achieved in the Aspect and Zeilinger experiments. The case of standing waves 0:33:10 Richard Gill, Myths and misunderstandings. Bell’s “Reply to critics” said it all 1:01:50 Jarek Duda, Boltzmann vs Feynman path ensemble - Born rule and Bell violation in Ising model 1:28:50 Álvaro García, Correlation and contextuality loopholes are equivalent 2:04:40 Robert Close, Geometrical Model of Bell Inequality Violation 2:26:20 James Tankersley, Faking Bell 2:58:20 Tim Palmer, Is Superdeterminism really such a ridiculous idea? then discussionA new relativistic quantum mechanicsRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2023-01-15 | Dirac's theory has been the "gold standard" of relativistic quantum mechanics (RQM) for more than ninety years. During that time the quantum mechanics used in the imagining and engineering of quantum devices has been in the realm of, almost exclusively, the non-relativistic Schrödinger theory using complex wave-functions. The merely complex is, however, too simple to properly represent covariant, relativistic wave-functions. Furthermore, the merely complex cannot properly represent intrinsic relativistic quantum properties such as the intrinsic spin. If one does not have the proper theory, the internal behaviour of the elementary particles, their mutual inter-actions, and the very quantum properties of collective quantum systems, such as high-temperature superconductors, cannot be properly thought about at all. The new theory presented here aims to rectify those deficiencies: it treats the elementary particle masses in a fundamentally different way to Dirac, incorporating them as a pair of elements within a hypercomplex algebra including both the complex algebra, and the quaternion algebra as sub-algebras. This allows a simpler, and even more beautiful equation than the Dirac or Maxwell equations to be written down, which yet contains them both. This equation may be written simply as dG=C, where "d" is a relativistic space-time derivative, "G" is a sixteen component multi-vector, and "C" is a sixteen component array of real constants, most of which are zero.The new theory opens up new vistas, new thinking, and new connections. It provides an underlying basis to the theory of Quantum ElectroDynamics, encompasses the Newton, Maxwell and Einstein, and removes all of the outstanding problems in RQM. The talk will focus on answering the list of questions posed by the group (repeated below), as well as a set of further fundamental questions, including the origin of the g-2 term in the theory. This will include the nature of the "generations" of particles in the standard model. It is argued that the addition of this new element to the "standard model" will allow one to promote to a "standard theory" fit for progressing the new challenges of the 21st century. quicycle.com/quicyclejournalModels of particles (mini) conferenceRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2023-01-08 | Recording of a mini-conference about models of particles, about fundamental questions like: • Why is electric charge quantized (no half-electron)? • Where does the Coulomb interaction come from? • How to prevent infinites e.g. of electric field of point charge? • Spin, magnetic dipole, angular momentum, zitterbewegung/clock of electron? • Why do we have 3 leptons? Where does their difference come from? • What are neutrinos, baryons, mesons, strangeness? • Why proton is lighter than neutron? Deuteron than n+p? • What holds nuclei together against Coulomb? Neutrons in halo nuclei? • How to get gravity, Newton force for particles? • Why does the model behave quantum mechanically not classically? • What photon is? What prevents its dissipation? What is its energy distribution?
16:00 John Macken, “The wave-based model of the universe” 16:20 Alexander Burinskii, "Gravitating electron formed by Kerr-Newman black hole solution" 16:40 Manfried Faber, "A geometric model in 3+1D space-time for electrodynamic phenomena" 17:00 Jarek Duda, Exploring resemblance between liquid crystal topological defects and particle physics 17:20 Chantal Roth, Visualizations of spin ½ 17:40 Robert Close, Elastic Solid Model of the Universe Then a few hours of discussion mainly around the above questions - attached abstracts and short answers by some participants.Quaternion Quantum MechanicsRed Pill (Chantal Roth)2021-01-04 | This has resulted in a much larger discussion presented here: Playlist with James (Inductica): youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDIKbbZkdruVFKYPulOOpVfVes9jQrMNc Playlist with Lori (FractalWoman): youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDIKbbZkdruVjdIFwPbfIA4ZbPajrqoKo
I think the paper below by Marek Danielewski is quite fundamental and important, so I thought I would try to "narrate" it and put it on youtube :-). For any details (in particular the math!), I would encourage you to read the paper - I focus mainly on the main concepts to hopefully get accross what this is all about.
Abstract: We show that quaternion quantum mechanics has well-founded mathematical roots and can be derived from the model of the elastic continuum by French mathematician Augustin Cauchy, i.e., it can be regarded as representing the physical reality of elastic continuum. Starting from the Cauchy theory (classical balance equations for isotropic Cauchy-elastic material) and using the Hamilton quaternion algebra, we present a rigorous derivation of the quaternion form of the non- and relativistic wave equations. The family of the wave equations and the Poisson equation are a straightforward consequence of the quaternion representation of the Cauchy model of the elastic continuum. This is the most general kind of quantum mechanics possessing the same kind of calculus of assertions as conventional quantum mechanics. The problem of the Schrödinger equation, where imaginary ‘i’ should emerge, is solved. This interpretation is a serious attempt to describe the ontology of quantum mechanics, and demonstrates that, besides Bohmian mechanics, the complete ontological interpretations of quantum theory exists. The model can be generalized and falsified. To ensure this theory to be true, we specified problems, allowing exposing its falsity.
M. Danielewski, “The Planck-Kleinert Crystal”, Z. Naturforsch. 62a, 564-568 (2007). H. Kleinert & J. Zaanen, „Nematic world crystal model of gravity explaining absence of torsion in spacetime”, Physics Letters A 324 (2004) 361–365.