Communion in Both Kinds: A Catholic Response Since Thirty Three 2026-09-21 | Communion in Both Kinds: A Catholic Response
St. Augustine Denied Mary Was Born with Original Sin #sacredscriptures #history #bible #catholic Since Thirty Three 2025-09-14 | St. Augustine on Mary and Original Sin
Eastern Orthodox Saint on the Immaculate Conception! #sacredscriptures #history #catholic #orthodoxy Since Thirty Three 2025-09-13 | Eastern Orthodox saint affirms the Immaculate Conception
Gavin Ortlund Misreads THIS Verse Since Thirty Three 2025-09-04 | On Acts 10, St. Cornelius, and BaptismTimestamps:00:00 Acts 10 and Cornelius03:10 The TRUTH About Cornelius04:38 Grace in Acts 10
Do Lutherans and Catholics Agree on BAPTISM?! (w/ @ScholasticLutherans) Since Thirty Three 2025-09-03 | Discussing the Lutheran/Catholic differences on baptism.🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/5513340640952320
The Immaculate Conception in the Early Church Since Thirty Three 2025-08-28 | A study of St. Augustine on the question of the Immaculate Conception.00:00 What is original sin?09:00 St. Augustine on Mary20:30 The Immaculate Conception26:45 Other Church Fathers
The Bereans were not Church members! #bible #history #sacredscriptures #catholic Since Thirty Three 2025-08-26 | ...
5k Subscriber Stream! (Q+A) Since Thirty Three 2025-08-24 | Celebrating 5k subscribers.🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/5513340640952320
The Council of Trent Was Right... (Matrimony) Since Thirty Three 2025-08-14 | An interesting case study on exegesis during the Protestant Reformation regarding matrimony.🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/5513340640952320
You’ve Been LIED TO About Purgatory! Since Thirty Three 2025-08-13 | The truth about purgatory's pains, their cause, and more. Subscribe, like, and share. God bless you!Timestamps:00:00 Is purgatory purification?06:39 The holy soul after death15:45 Temporal punishment21:50 The pains of purgatory25:14 The Glory of God in purgatory
Want to Read the Church Fathers? Watch THIS! Since Thirty Three 2025-08-05 | Will be sharing how to easily browse Migne's PL and PG. (Yes, I know that newer critical editions exist. PL and PG remain classics that are mostly correct and very easy to browse).🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/5513340640952320
Accept Vatican 2 Or Else The Muslims Are Right... (Dialogue w/ @TheO-BroShow) Since Thirty Three 2025-08-05 | A dialogue with @TheO-BroShow on Islam, Vatican 2, and whether Muslims "worship the one God".Timestamps:00:00 Introduction05:50 The "same" God?17:17 Why Nostra Aetate?25:20 Why Muslims are wrong43:00 Looking at Scripture
The Immaculate Conception and Sacred Scripture Since Thirty Three 2025-08-03 | Going over the Biblical texts on the Immaculate Conception.🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/5513340640952320
John 6 REFUTES Protestants and Orthodoxy Since Thirty Three 2025-07-18 | A response to the common argument from Eastern Orthodox and Protestants on John 6. Here I focus on an explication brought forward by Johann Gerhard from John 6. As a Lutheran, he does not particularly see John 6 as referring to sacramental eating, but he entertains the argument regardless and argues similarly to other Reformed Protestants and Eastern OrthodoxFind the article here:sincethirtythree.wordpress.com/2025/06/09/john-6-and-communion-in-both-kinds
Anglican Priest DEBUNKS Protestants Since Thirty Three 2025-07-13 | Going over William Robert's defense of the jure Divino episcopacy.🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/5513340640952320
This ALONE Ends Sola Scriptura Since Thirty Three 2025-07-10 | We need to stop speaking about the Bible canon in terms of infallibility. That is not really the issue. The real question to ask is not, "Can you have a fallible list of infallible books?" but "Is the fact of inspiration revealed for each book?" Protestants cannot answer "Yes" because many books of Scripture are not attested to being inspired (e.g. Philemon) and so this revelation, if it exists, is not in Scripture.Timestamps:00:00 Infallibility is NOT the problem02:00 What is inspiration?06:38 Analogy with Christ's Divinity11:53 Inspiration must be revealed. Protestants don't have this revealed
Protestant Doctrines Before the Reformation? Since Thirty Three 2025-06-26 | A clip from my recent stream with Christian Wagner where we discussed the difference between how Catholics and Protestants approach the Church Fathers.
Church Fathers and Marys Sinlessness #bible #history #catholic #faith #church Since Thirty Three 2025-06-26 | When Protestants bring up fathers who said Mary sinned.
St. Augustine, Catholicism, and Protestantism w/ Christian Wagner (@MilitantThomist) Since Thirty Three 2025-06-25 | Talking about the doctor of grace.🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/5513340640952320
Papal Infallibility #bible #history #spanishcatholic #catholic Since Thirty Three 2025-06-23 | St. Augustine
The Trinitarian Mystery of the Eucharist Since Thirty Three 2025-06-23 | A short reflection on John 6:57.
Purgatory and the Mass in the Early Church #bible #catholic #faith #Christian Since Thirty Three 2025-06-20 | Purgatory
Defending Sola Scriptura!? Since Thirty Three 2025-06-19 | w/ Taylor Barrett on how Catholics make weak arguments against Sola Scriptura.🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/5513340640952320
Jay Dyer Doesnt Want You To Know This #orthodoxy #catholic #church #faith Since Thirty Three 2025-06-18 | Orthodox Patriarch agrees with us...
Test Stream... Finally... Since Thirty Three 2025-06-18 | Just a test🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/5513340640952320
Did He Debunk the Immaculate Conception? Since Thirty Three 2025-06-06 | Reviewing Cleave's video on the immaculate conception and Catholic Answers
All Protestants Got THIS Wrong (The Eucharist) Since Thirty Three 2025-06-04 | Guys I mean *almost* all. There are like 3 rare Anglicans still alive who wouldn't disagree with me here. So I think it's fair to say "all".Timestamps:00:00 Christ's perpetual presence in the Eucharist03:16 The Protestant position10:00 Lutheran contradiction11:56 Biblical proof (The Catholic position)18:07 Patristic evidence25:19 The Pre-Sanctified Liturgy27:24 Chemnitz's objections
On the Ascension of Christ and John 6 Since Thirty Three 2025-05-30 | Discussing the Ascension of Christ and John 6:62
Did Jesus institute Anointing of the Sick? #history #bible #cathecism #christianbible #eucharist Since Thirty Three 2025-05-29 | Did Christ institute anointing of the sick?
Vatican 2 VINDICATED on ISLAM Since Thirty Three 2025-05-05 | Do Muslims worship the same God as Christians?@vaticancatholic-dimond @CleavetoAntiquity Timestamps00:00 The question: do they worship the same God?05:47 The philosophical argument07:20 Biblical proof for Vatican 2 (1 Corinthians 10)17:20 The REAL traditional view on Jews/Muslims23:00 Vatican 2 vindicated24:28 ObjectionsRead more about sense and reference here: https://iep.utm.edu/frege/#H4:~:text=4.-,The%20Theory%20of%20Sense%20and%20Reference,-Frege%E2%80%99s%20influential%20theoryHere is the full letter of Pope St. Gregory VII:LETTER XXI. TO ANZIR, KING OF MAURETANIA Gregory writes that he has consecrated Bishop Servandus at the king's request. He thanks him for the gifts sent and for releasing Christian captives. He commends certain individuals sent to the king by Alberic and Cincius from Rome.GREGORY, Bishop, Servant of the Servants of God, to ANZIR (also spelled ANAZIR), King of Mauretania in the Province of Sitifensis, Africa, greetings and apostolic blessing.Your noble self sent us letters this year requesting that we ordain Servandus, a presbyter, as bishop according to Christian practice. Since your request seemed just and worthy, we made efforts to fulfill it.You also sent us gifts, and, out of reverence for Saint Peter, the Prince of the Apostles, and love for us, you released the Christians who were being held captive among you. Moreover, you promised to release others as well. This goodness of yours was inspired in your heart by the Creator of all things—God—without whom we can do no good, nor even think rightly. He, who enlightens every person coming into this world, has enlightened your mind in this very intention.For Almighty God, who wills all people to be saved and none to perish, finds nothing more acceptable in us than when a person, out of love for Him, loves another human being, and refrains from doing to others what he would not wish done to himself. This love, then, is something we and you owe to each other more than to other peoples, since we believe in and confess the one God—though in different ways—and daily praise and revere Him as the Creator of the ages and Ruler of this world.As the Apostle says: “He is our peace, who has made both one.”And this grace that God has granted you is known by many of the Roman nobility through us; they altogether admire and praise your goodness and virtues. Among them are two of our close associates, Alberic and Cincius, who were raised with us almost from their youth in the Roman palace. Greatly desiring to enter into your friendship and love, and eager to serve you in those things that pleased our forefathers, they are sending their own men to you, so that through them you may understand how highly they esteem your wisdom and nobility, and how willingly and ably they desire to serve you.We commend these men to your majesty, and we ask that the same love we always wish to show you and yours, you would in turn show to them for our sake and as a reward for their loyalty.For God knows that we love you purely for His honor, and that we desire your well-being and salvation in this life and in the life to come. And so we pray with heart and voice that God Himself may, after the long course of this life, lead you into the bosom of blessedness, into the embrace of the most holy patriarch Abraham."Pope St. Gregory VII, Epistola XXI. ad Anzir Regem Mauritanie (PL 148, 450).
Donatism and the TRUE Church Since Thirty Three 2025-04-29 | The true Church in the Donatist controversies.
The Power of the Sacraments flow from the Cross! #bible #history #cathecism #eucharist #faith #truth Since Thirty Three 2025-04-16 | Watch the full video on a brief description of how Christ's passion saves us.
How Christs Death Saves Us Since Thirty Three 2025-04-13 | A brief summary of how Christ's Passion procures our salvation by atoning for sin, meriting grace, and drawing us to Him.Timestamps:00:00 The Incarnation is an instrument02:40 Forgiveness of sins04:08 Merit of grace06:28 How the Cross indirectly saves us
Concomitance in Scripture #bible #history #cathecism #truth #eucharist #faith Since Thirty Three 2025-04-05 | Scripture teaches us that the whole Christ is present by way of natural concomitance in the Holy Eucharist.
Purgatory in the Fathers: St. Ambrose (Final Response to Anglican Aesthetics) Since Thirty Three 2025-04-03 | St. Ambrose on post-mortem punishments for the saved (response to Sean Luke).Timestamps:00:00 Introduction02:00 Critique of Sean's arguments05:35 Post-mortem temporal suffering08:00 This burning is *punitive*
Undeniable PROOF for the Assumption of Mary Since Thirty Three 2025-03-24 | The Assumption of Mary is an Apostolic tradition. In this video I respond (and concede) the Protestant argument against the Assumption which appeals to the lack of historic evidence.God bless! Sancta Maria, ora pro nobis.Timestamps:00:00 Purpose for the video02:00 Lack of historical evidence06:40 Why the Protestant argument fails11:20 Proof for the Assumption from Tradition20:20 The absurd Protestant position22:30 The consensus of the Church docendi and discendi
Response to Anglican Aesthetics (Sean Luke) on Purgatory and St. Ambrose Since Thirty Three 2025-03-15 | On St. Ambrose and Purgatory. Ultimately, I don't think it's a good argument to conclude St. Ambrose denied purgatory from funeral orations. I have heard modern Catholic priests speak in the same way and yet we don't conclude they deny purgatory. Also, let’s look at the quotes in Ambrose and see the type of “punishments” he speaks of. He writes:Here you have the days of rest from penalties, for they contain the punishment decreed against the thorns of this life, the cares of the world, and the pleasures of riches which shut out the Word. Death is given for a remedy, because it is the end of evils. For God said not, ‘Because you have hearkened to the voice of the woman you shall return to the earth’, for this would have been a penal sentence, as this one is, ‘The earth under curse shall bring forth thorns and thistles to you’; but He said: ‘In sweat shall you eat your bread until thou return to the earth.’ You see that death is rather the goal of our penalties, by which an end is put to the course of this life.On the Death of Satyrus II, 38 (PL 16, 1325B).Hence, the “punishments” St. Ambrose speaks of are not temporal punishments for venial sins. They are the punishments that fall upon all of mankind after the fall, regardless of venial sins. This is akin to a sick man who suffers from a disease for years and, when he dies, others can now say “He now suffers no more.” That has nothing to do with whether or not they are suffering temporal punishments for venial sins.Timestamps:00:00 St. Ambrose's funeral orations12:25 Purgatory in St. Ambrose**Sean and I are cool. The thumbnail is merely comedic.*** Here is Sean's article: anglicanaesthetics.substack.com/p/a-propitiating-priesthood?r=3weavl&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&triedRedirect=true#_ftnref63And here is my response article: sincethirtythree.wordpress.com/2025/03/15/st-ambrose-on-purgatory-response-to-anglican-aesthetics-sean-luke
St. Augustine on Purgatory Since Thirty Three 2025-03-01 | St. Augustine on how Christian offerings help the souls of the deceased
The Eucharist as spiritual food #eucharist #catholic #bible #faith #protestant Since Thirty Three 2025-02-08 | John of St. Thomas O.P.
Lutheranism and A BIG Eucharistic Error Since Thirty Three 2025-02-03 | In this video, I cover the historic Protestant belief on what constitutes worthy preparation for the Eucharist. The Lutherans in particular believe the Eucharist was instituted for mortal sins and so that we may have assurance of their forgiveness. Unfortunately, this is not what the Bible teaches nor what the early Church believed.Timestamps:00:00 What is the Eucharist for?03:25 Bad exegesis on the Last Supper06:05 The Catholic teaching12:04 Partaking of the Eucharist unworthily (1 Cor 11)16:30 Mortal sins, the Eucharist, and confession23:10 St. Paschasius28:09 The first grace (per accidens)
Do Protestants WORSHIP God? The Answer Is Psalm 51 (@TheCounselofTrent and @TruthUnites ) Since Thirty Three 2025-01-09 | I think Catholics often overstate themselves when they say Protestants do not worship God. I distinguish (distinguo) between internal/personal worship and external/communal worship. I also push back against Dr. Ortlund and Sean Luke since their responses seem to be falling into the same error as the Catholic voices: an either/or paradigm. Ps. 51, which still speaks to us today, solves this either-or problem by stressing both the importance of a contrite heart and sacrifice.Response to @TruthUnites @TheCounselofTrent Timestamps:0:00 Introduction01:00 Catholic critique04:10 Biblical evidence09:38 What is the "Mass"?11:20 Psalm 51
Lutheran Error | St. Augustine and Purgatory Since Thirty Three 2025-01-04 | A careful reading of St. Augustine shows that he was certain about post-mortem punishments for venial sins and speculative about post-mortem suffering for losing worldly attachments. However, in the history of Protestant-Catholic polemics, Protestants have usually (though not unanimously) misunderstood St. Augustine. St. Augustine uses language like "it is not to be doubted" regarding the fact that the whole Church observed offering the Mass and alms as "propitiations" to reduce punishment for venial sins in purgatory.I hope this video was helpful. God bless.Timestamps:00:00 Introduction to St. Augustine01:40 Protestant reading of Augustine03:55 Doubts about purgatory's details08:10 Temporal punishments AFTER death16:04 Speculation about purgatory's nature19:16 Prayers for the dead21:00 Mass is a "propitiation" to forgive sins in purgatory23:20 UNIVERSAL Church practiceMusic:"Don't Let Me Go" by IVN"lucid dreaming" by Bokoven Beats
Marriage Is Intrinsically Religious Since Thirty Three 2024-12-23 | During the Reformation, Protestants accused the Church of adopting matrimony as a sacrament in order to keep its control over its legislation. Instead, the Protestants taught that marriage is secular (Vermigli compared it to shaking dust off your feet; Luther compared it to clothing and food; Calvin compared it to agriculture and shoemaking, etc.). However, if spouses hand over their bodily rights to one another, then the authority of marriage is religious and not secular...Timestamps:00:00 The Protestant Position01:45 Church authority over marriage02:05 What is marriage?03:40 Marriage is not secular
Did Christ Die For ALL Men? Since Thirty Three 2024-12-19 | A brief Biblical and traditional survey of the scope of Christ’s atonement. The Catholic tradition has always held Christ’s sufficient atonement for all but efficacious atonement for the elect.Timestamps:00:00 Introduction00:58 1 Timothy 2:1-403:08 The will of God05:00 Universal atonement07:38 ProtestantsMusic: Vacay by WavyMason
The Great Mystery in the Bible | Full Dogmatic Documentary Since Thirty Three 2024-12-17 | In this video, I go over the Biblical and traditional argument for why matrimony is a sacrament.Timestamps:00:00 Introduction01:45 Natural marriage08:11 Marriage as a sacrament11:17 Biblical argument21:40 Tradition (Liturgy & Fathers)27:38 Scholastic teaching34:56 Objections39:03 ConclusionMusic:"Suite" by WaVyMason"lucid dreaming" by Bokoven Beats
St. Augustine on the Sacrament of Matrimony Since Thirty Three 2024-12-10 | Here, I summarize St. Augustine's teaching on the sacrament of matrimony. St. Augustine sees Christian matrimony as:1. a sign of the union between Christ and the Church2. for the first reason, indissoluble3. akin to baptism and ordination due to the permanent effect (although it does not imprint a character)4. superior to matrimony in the Old Testament and among pagans, serving as a remedy among Christians.Music:"Sorry" by Bailey Daniel"nostalgia" by Bcnny876Timestamps:00:00 Introduction01:45 Matrimony is a sacrament among Christians only03:00 Sanctity of the sacrament04:22 Comparison to baptism and ordination05:50 Grace in matrimony
Sacrament of Matrimony (Biblical Proof) Since Thirty Three 2024-12-03 | The Biblical case for the sacrament of matrimony. I will upload two more videos on this topic soon with more formal editing. Subscribe, like, and share!Timestamps:00:00 The Protestant question04:10 Protestant objections04:58 Marriage's sacramental character06:25 Are all marriages sacraments?07:35 What is a sacrament?08:53 Conclusion#catholicism #protestant #faith #bible #apologetics
Spiritual Presence of Christ in the Eucharist Since Thirty Three 2024-11-07 | Saying Catholics believe *only* in transubstantiation as opposed to Reformed Protestants is incorrect... In truth, the spiritual presence of Christ in the Eucharist is an originally Catholic doctrine.Timestamps:00:00 Introduction02:18 Reformed view on the main effect of the Eucharist03:49 Protestant mistake concerning the Catholic view05:45 The Catholic view07:11 John 6 and feasting on Christ08:54 Do unbelievers receive Christ?11:45 Is Christ spiritually present?Music: "Origami" by 3 AM
