JohntheDuncanHow is knowledge created online? How do the structures and pressures of the profit driven youtube algorithm affect knoweldge on these platforms? In this video I argue firstly that these platforms push creators to produce more and more work with less and less attention to sound knowledge creation. This has led to the proliferation of debate culture. I then in turn argue that this debate culture privileges certain forms of knowledge over other - that it has certain "epistemic ideals". Finally, I argue that these epistemic ideals are actually just developments of deeply embedded western ideals of knowledge creation which should be challenged by the left...I also try to make some jokes throughout to keep you entertained like the platform logic demands...damn I'm part of the system!
*NOTE* the creator we're in hell features in this video. at the time we were friends but he has since sexually assaulted someone, lied to others and myself about pursuing rehabilitative justice and engaged in common abuse tactics to silence his victim. i no longer associate with him or his channel and would encourage others tk unsubscribe
Until March 2023 use the discount code DUNCAN50 to get 50% off at books from the radical publisher Pluto Press plutobooks.com many of the books I use are from there!
Bibliography in the pinned comment
Thanks to Aranock, and Lilah (@leechwaifu on twitter) for their beautiful line readings in this!
and thanks to Prod. Riddiman for the use of their music
Debate Me! How To Know Things on YoutubeJohntheDuncan2021-06-11 | How is knowledge created online? How do the structures and pressures of the profit driven youtube algorithm affect knoweldge on these platforms? In this video I argue firstly that these platforms push creators to produce more and more work with less and less attention to sound knowledge creation. This has led to the proliferation of debate culture. I then in turn argue that this debate culture privileges certain forms of knowledge over other - that it has certain "epistemic ideals". Finally, I argue that these epistemic ideals are actually just developments of deeply embedded western ideals of knowledge creation which should be challenged by the left...I also try to make some jokes throughout to keep you entertained like the platform logic demands...damn I'm part of the system!
*NOTE* the creator we're in hell features in this video. at the time we were friends but he has since sexually assaulted someone, lied to others and myself about pursuing rehabilitative justice and engaged in common abuse tactics to silence his victim. i no longer associate with him or his channel and would encourage others tk unsubscribe
Until March 2023 use the discount code DUNCAN50 to get 50% off at books from the radical publisher Pluto Press plutobooks.com many of the books I use are from there!
Bibliography in the pinned comment
Thanks to Aranock, and Lilah (@leechwaifu on twitter) for their beautiful line readings in this!
and thanks to Prod. Riddiman for the use of their music
Secularism, Capitalism, Socialism Part 1: youtu.be/8g2Ku4i7l6ADegrowth is fake?JohntheDuncan2024-10-15 | ...Is degrowth communism degrowth colonising communism? #degrowth #lefttube #ecologyJohntheDuncan2024-10-11 | ...Degrowth is Fake?JohntheDuncan2024-10-09 | It turns out Degrowth is fake? Well, according to a recent review of the literature. But how good is this review really? Well, it turns out it's not very good. I went through the paper and discovered it is filled with lies and I'm making that your problem.
Buhr, K., Isaksson, K. and Hagbert, P., 2018. Local interpretations of degrowth—actors, arenas and attempts to influence policy. Sustainability, 10(6), p.1899.
Cakar, K. and Uzut, I., 2020. Exploring the stakeholder’s role in sustainable degrowth within the context of tourist destination governance: The case of Istanbul, Turkey. Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing, 37(8-9), pp.917-932.
Colombo, L.A., Bailey, A.R. and Gomes, M.V., 2024. Scaling in a post-growth era: Learning from Social Agricultural Cooperatives. Organization, 31(6), pp.907-928.
Kallis, G., Varvarousis, A. and Petridis, P., 2022. Southern thought, islandness and real-existing degrowth in the Mediterranean. World development, 157, p.105957.
O’Manique, C., Rowe, J.K. and Shaw, K., 2021. Degrowth, political acceptability and the Green New Deal. Journal of Human Rights and the Environment, 12(2), pp.254-276.
Pansera, M. and Owen, R., 2018. Innovation for de-growth: A case study of counter-hegemonic practices from Kerala, India. Journal of Cleaner Production, 197, pp.1872-1883.
Savin I, van den Bergh J. Reviewing studies of degrowth: Are claims matched by data, methods and policy analysis?. Ecological Economics. 2024 Dec 1;226:108324.
Schmid, B., 2018. Structured Diversity: A Practice Theory Approach to Post-Growth Organisations. management revue, 29 (3), 281–310.
Xue, J., 2015. Sustainable housing development: decoupling or degrowth? A comparative study of Copenhagen and Hangzhou. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy, 33(3), pp.620-639.Just another JtD Stream!JohntheDuncan2024-09-13 | It's not that hot anymore! Let's have some drinks, make some music, and talk about the last two videos (both the wisecrack video and the Malthus one)Is degrowth malthusian?JohntheDuncan2024-09-04 | ...Degrowth must be communistJohntheDuncan2024-09-02 | ...Limits: Why Malthus Was Wrong and Why Environmentalists Should Care by Giorgos Kallis - Book ReviewJohntheDuncan2024-09-01 | Support me on Patreon: patreon.com/johntheduncan
Ji, M., 2020. With or without class: Resolving Marx’s Janus-faced interpretation of worker-owned cooperatives. Capital & Class, 44(3), pp.345-369.
Jossa, B., 2005. Marx, Marxism and the cooperative movement. Cambridge Journal of Economics, 29(1), pp.3-18.
McNally, D., 1993. Against the market: Political economy, market socialism and the Marxist critique. Verso.
O'neill, J., 1991. Exploitation and Workers’ Co‐operatives: a reply to Alan Carter. Journal of Applied Philosophy, 8(2), pp.231-235.
Resnick, S.A. and Wolff, R.D., 2013. Class theory and history: Capitalism and communism in the USSR. Routledge.
Smith C. Marx at the Millennium. Pluto Press; 1996.
Vrousalis, N., 2018. Capital without wage-labour: Marx’s modes of subsumption revisited. Economics & Philosophy, 34(3), pp.411-438.I found a book with lots of terrible gender. Lets read some!JohntheDuncan2024-08-02 | It's so hot I might die. Let's streamA (new) New Labour governmentJohntheDuncan2024-08-01 | Just some gin some chat and making some music on stream!richard Wolff just wants to recreate capitalismJohntheDuncan2024-07-15 | ...Class Theory and History by Richard D. Wolff and Stephen Resnick: Book ReviewJohntheDuncan2024-07-13 | Starting off a new type of video book reviews with a review of Richard Wolff and Stephen Resnick's Class Theory and History. It is an odd book with odd interpretations of Marx
Hall, S., 2003. Marx's notes on method: a'reading'of the'1857 introduction'. Cultural studies, 17(2), pp.113-149.
Lebowitz, M.A., 2006. The politics of assumption, the assumption of politics. Historical Materialism, 14(2), p.29.
Mau, S., 2023. Mute compulsion: A Marxist theory of the economic power of capital. Verso books.
Resnick, S.A. and Wolff, R.D., 2013. Class theory and history: Capitalism and communism in the USSR. Routledge.A (new) New Labour governmentJohntheDuncan2024-07-10 | Just some gin some chat and making some music on stream!Theres a new (New) Labour governmentJohntheDuncan2024-07-10 | Let's do a stream and chat about the last few weeks!9 July 2024JohntheDuncan2024-07-09 | ...we deserve a better apocalypseJohntheDuncan2024-07-03 | ...We Need to Talk About KeirJohntheDuncan2024-06-28 | There's an election on so I guess let's talk about how bad it is. I'm also gonna talk about how fascism is a seed inside liberalism
Support me on Patreon: patreon.com/johntheduncan Or a tip via payapal https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/johnt...
(Sky News) Rogers, A. (2024) Rachel Reeves: Everything you need to know about the former chess champion vying to be the UK’s first female chancellor, Sky News. Available at: news.sky.com/story/amp/rachel-reeves-everything-you-need-to-know-about-the-former-chess-champion-vying-to-be-the-uks-first-female-chancellor-13059462 (Accessed: 27 June 2024).Red wine and streaming timeJohntheDuncan2024-06-14 | Let's do a stream and chat about the last few weeks!Harassment, wine, and terrible labour party developmentsJohntheDuncan2024-05-31 | Let's do a stream and chat about the last few weeks!Does intent Matter in GenocideJohntheDuncan2024-05-17 | The role of "special intent" has been raised many times since October 7th. This video looks at the apparently simple story that genocide requires a very high bar of special intent. Is it this simple?
Support me on Patreon: patreon.com/johntheduncan Or a tip via payapal https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/johnt...
UN General Assembly, Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, United Nations, Treaty Series, vol. 78, p. 277, 9 December 1948, refworld.org/legal/agreements/unga/1948/en/13495.First stream of my dreaded 30sJohntheDuncan2024-05-17 | I turned 30 a few weeks ago so lets all commiserate togetherherbicidal warfare in VietnamJohntheDuncan2024-04-29 | ...making money on the side doing bank advertsJohntheDuncan2024-04-28 | ...Making the desert bloom #palestinianJohntheDuncan2024-04-22 | ...capitalism produces ecocide. full video on my channelJohntheDuncan2024-04-20 | ...New video is out so lets have a wee streamJohntheDuncan2024-04-19 | Join me for a normal stream where I'll drink some beer tonight and make some tunesalways sad to see two collegues fightingJohntheDuncan2024-04-19 | ...Ecocide: From Vietnam to Palestine full video on my channelJohntheDuncan2024-04-18 | ...Ecocide: From Vietnam to PalestineJohntheDuncan2024-04-17 | This video explores ecocide. First it describes the emergence of the term in relation to the use of Agent Orange in Vietnam, the reinterpretation of it in light of capitalist colonial extraction, and the combination of both in Palestine
Support me on Patreon: patreon.com/johntheduncan Or a tip via payapal https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/johnt...
Foster, J.B., 2013. Marx and the Rift in the Universal Metabolism of Nature. Monthly review, 65(7), pp.1-19.
Gauger, A., Rabatel-Fernel, M.P., Kulbicki, L., Short, D. and Higgins, P., 2012. Ecocide is the missing 5th crime against peace.
Higgins, P., Short, D. and South, N., 2013. Protecting the planet: a proposal for a law of ecocide. Crime, Law and Social Change, 59, pp.251-266.
Holleman, H. in Schmidt, I. and Fanelli, C., 2017. Reading Capital today: Marx after 150 years. Pluto.
Jaber, D. A. (2018). Settler colonialism and ecocide: case study of Al-Khader, Palestine. Settler Colonial Studies, (), 1–20. doi:10.1080/2201473X.2018.1487127
Lemkin, R., 2008. Axis rule in occupied Europe: Laws of occupation, analysis of government, proposals for redress. The Lawbook Exchange, Ltd..
Molavi, S.C. (2024) Environmental warfare in Gaza: Colonial violence and new landscapes of resistance. London: Pluto Press. Whyte, D. (2020). Ecocide: Kill the Corporation Before It Kills Us. Manchester, UK: Manchester University Press
Zierler, D., 2011. The invention of ecocide: Agent Orange, Vietnam, and the scientists who changed the way we think about the environment. University of Georgia Press.A stream for the ages (just a normal stream)JohntheDuncan2024-04-05 | Join me for a normal stream where I'll drink some wine and make some tunesI got a haircut, and smashed my thumb in a dishwasher so lets see if I can still play musicJohntheDuncan2024-03-22 | Let's have some wine, make some music, and talk some nonsenseSam Reich would have to use the Benny Gesserit voice on me to stop me looking at that beautiful pigJohntheDuncan2024-03-17 | ...chicken run 2 is about mass consumerism full video on youtubeJohntheDuncan2024-03-11 | ...jacobin denying Palestinian colonisation makes it complicity part 3 of 3JohntheDuncan2024-03-11 | ...jacobin denying Palestinian colonisation makes it complicit. Part 2 of 3JohntheDuncan2024-03-11 | ...jacobin publishing denial of Palestines colonisation makes it complicit. part 1 of 3JohntheDuncan2024-03-11 | ...Post Chicken Run streamJohntheDuncan2024-03-08 | Let's have some wine, make some music, and talk about the last videothe changing nature of the chicken farm represents the change of capitalist developmentJohntheDuncan2024-03-06 | ...ia chicken run 2 communist? full video on my channelJohntheDuncan2024-03-04 | ...Is It Communist? Chicken Run 2: Dawn of the NuggetJohntheDuncan2024-02-26 | Today we are answering one of the most important questions of the age: Is Chicken Run 2: Dawn of the Nugget Communist? I am treating this very earnestly!
Until June 2024 you can get 50% of pluto press books with the discount code: DUNCAN50
Brathwaite, V. (2012) Totalitarianism, technology, and the threat of dystopia in the early 1960’s: Inspirations for rising against authority, The Museum of Film History. Available at: eng3122.wordpress.com/group-5-main/1960-to-1965/theearly1960s (Accessed: 05 February 2024). Chayt, E.B., 2014. Disaster, dystopia, and exploration: science-fiction cinema 1959-1971 (Doctoral dissertation).
Kizer, Z.A., 2018. The future is today: a Burkean/Marxist analysis of Modern times & Soylent green.
O'Brien, M.E., 2022. FAMILY ABOLITION: Capitalism and the Communizing of Care. Pluto Press.
Robinson, J. (2023) ‘Chicken run 2: Dawn of the nugget’: Everything you need to know, What’s on Netflix. Available at: whats-on-netflix.com/news/chicken-run-dawn-of-the-nugget-netflix-release-date-what-we-know-so-far-12-2023 (Accessed: 26 February 2024).Im BackJohntheDuncan2024-02-23 | Back after events prevented the last stream. Join for some music, chill, and drinkdoes youtube produce intellectuals? full video on channelJohntheDuncan2024-02-05 | ...New Me!JohntheDuncan2024-01-26 | First stream of the new year! Wine chat and music as ever!Using #andor to explain Gramsci (full video on youtube) #starwars #leftistJohntheDuncan2024-01-08 | ...Can we Save the Public IntellectualJohntheDuncan2023-12-21 | The youtube sphere has been rocked recently. Hbomberguy's plagiarism video has exposed scammers on the scene. But youtube isn't the only place with a crisis of public intellectualism. Academia and journalism have failed to stand up for the oppressed everywhere. This video asks, what even is a public intellectual? Is it worth saving them? Can we even do so?
Atherton, C., 2015. ‘Very Inflated Rhetoric, Polysyllables and So On’: The Public Intellectual and Jargon in the Academy. Media International Australia, 156(1), pp.98-107.
Calavita, K., 2002. Engaged research, Goose bumps, and the role of the public intellectual. Law & Soc'y Rev., 36, p.5.
Crick, N., 2006. Rhetoric, philosophy, and the public intellectual. Philosophy & rhetoric, 39(2), pp.127-139.
Crociani-Windland, L. and Yates, C., 2020. Masculinity, affect and the search for certainty in an age of precarity. Free Associations, (78), pp.119-140.
Fraser, H. and Taylor, N., 2016. Neoliberalization, universities and the public intellectual: Species, gender and class and the production of knowledge. Springer.
Giroux, H.A., 2003. Betraying the intellectual tradition: Public intellectuals and the crisis of youth. Language and intercultural communication, 3(3), pp.172-186.
Johansen, M.B., 2021. Public intellectuals on new platforms: constructing critical authority in a digital media culture. Rethinking cultural criticism: New voices in the digital age, pp.17-42.
Mayo, P., 2014. Gramsci and the politics of education. Capital & Class, 38(2), pp.385-398.
Ochieng, O., 2016. WEB Du Bois and the imagination of the public intellectual. African Journal of Rhetoric, 8(1), pp.27-44.
Said, E.W., 2012. Representations of the Intellectual. Vintage.
Scripps, J., 2020. Podcasting and the Rise of the Public Intellectual: Viewing an Emergent Group of Media Personalities Through the Prism of Antonio Gramsci’s “The Intellectuals” (Doctoral dissertation, University of Nevada, Reno)..
van de Ven, I. and van Gemert, T., 2022. Filter bubbles and guru effects: Jordan B. Peterson as a public intellectual in the attention economy. Celebrity Studies, 13(3), pp.289-307.