Hannah Spier, MD
Why Women Are Being Misdiagnosed as AuDHD — And What It Really Is
updated
Why have so many women instinctively identified with Clancy? Why does female wrongdoing so often get reframed through suffering, victimhood and diminished agency? And what happens when a culture validates female rage while becoming increasingly reluctant to demand accountability from women?
We use the Clancy case as a starting point for a much broader conversation about feminism, motherhood, resentment, female moral innocence, the empathy gap, and the ideas Janice traces throughout her book.
But the book “The Goddess that Failed”:
amazon.co.uk/Goddess-That-Failed-Feminisms-Civilization-ebook/dp/B0H1YTX9BM
——-
Subscribe of substack for more psychobabble and ad-free episodes!
open.substack.com/pub/hannahspier
———
00:00 Stream Setup & Intro Remarks
01:10 Welcoming Janice Fiamengo & Gratitude
01:48 Overview of 'The Goddess That Failed'
02:30 The Lindsay Clancy Case & Cultural Victimhood
03:54 The Cultivation of the Female Victim Mentality
05:56 Juror Reactions & Preserving Narrative Frameworks
07:00 Origins of Feminist Grievance (Seneca Falls, 1848)
10:03 Why Men Historically Acceded to Feminist Claims
12:40 Escalating Demands: Why Support Is Never "Enough"
13:40 How Feminist Ideology Impacts Female Accountability
17:21 Historical Perspectives on Infanticide & Female Violence
19:37 Case Study: Sarah Jane Whitling (1888) & Legal Defenses
23:00 Examining the Insanity Defense in Maternal Crimes
24:00 Asymmetry in How Society Views Male vs. Female Violence
26:50 Statistical Realities of Filicide and Infanticide
28:30 Performative Outrage, Victimhood, & Cultural Incentives
30:43 Case Study: Lorena Bobbitt & Double Standards
34:00 Sentencing Disparities & Legal Leniency for Female Offenders
36:55 Cultural Contempt & Devaluation of Male Sexuality
39:58 Media Reactions to Male Harm & Double Standards
41:45 Evaluating Feminist Ideology’s Place in Society
44:20 Can We Deprogram Feminism Through Information?
47:11 Re-establishing Incentives and Boundaries
51:00 Critical Evaluation of Alternative Ideologies & Scapegoats
53:10 Western Civilization, Empathy, & Restoring Motherhood
56:18 Marxist Frameworks & Economic Devaluation of Family
58:04 The Paradox of Decreasing Female Happiness
01:00:00 Navigating Current Cultural Discussions & Trans Issues
01:02:28 Closing Remarks & Preview of Upcoming Content
We get into the unstable self, mirroring and attachment, whether borderline manipulation is conscious, the overlap between BPD and vulnerable narcissism, and the increasingly complicated relationship between borderline traits, autism and ADHD. We also debate trauma versus temperament, why certain men are drawn to borderline women, the relationship between attractiveness and instability, and whether modern culture is removing the guardrails that once helped people regulate difficult temperaments.
Edward Dutton / The Jolly Heretic: jollyheretic.com
Borderline Genius, Borderline Insane: us.amazon.com/Borderline-Genius-Insane-Understanding-Personality-ebook/dp/B0HGGGWYGP
Don’t sleep on [@ultrapouches]. New customers get 15% Off with code HANNAH at https://takeultra.com! #UltraPouches #ad
0:00 The problem with the victim model
0:23 Edward Dutton & Borderline Genius, Borderline Insane
3:16 The nine traits of borderline personality
4:47 Neuroticism, creativity and the unstable self
7:42 Mirroring, identity and attachment
14:25 Personality, status and the people who reach the top
17:00 Borderline women, powerful men and history
23:25 Is borderline manipulation conscious?
24:46 Borderline vs vulnerable narcissism
30:04 Autism or borderline personality?
35:27 Is BPD hiding under autism and ADHD?
38:45 Trauma, genetics and the family environment
44:12 Eating disorders, tattoos and identity
45:24 The men who end up with borderline women
48:05 Do men trade mental stability for beauty?
55:35 Are we failing to teach emotional regulation?
58:32 Borderline traits and political extremes
60:41 Edward’s book & where to find him
----------------------
Plus, stick around for a preview of Thursday's upcoming conversation with Ed Dutton, where we will discuss borderline women, autism, trauma, and their influence on powerful people.
--------------------
00:00 - Introduction: Social Contagions and the Lindsay Clancy Trial
01:08 - The "Same Lindsay" Viral Trend: Normalizing Extreme Outcomes
02:50 - Courtroom Rallies: Protecting the Image of Female Moral Purity
06:40 - Feminism, Spiritual Superiority, and Erasing the Crime
07:53 - Public Reactions: Excluding Men and the "Women Just Know" Narrative
09:50 - Shifting Goalposts: Blaming the Husband, the Attorney, and Medication
12:49 - The Psychological Glitch: Motherhood, Violence, and the Female In-Group
14:15 - Why We Actually Need Social Guardrails and Mental Health Stigma
16:11 - Weaponized Fragility and the Pursuit of Corporate Power
17:18 - Outro & Upcoming Episode: Ed Dutton on Borderline Traits
What is the difference between this case and what the Handmaid's Tale spent six seasons asking us to recoil from?
In this episode, I look at what this case reveals about commercial surrogacy. I also bring in The Handmaid’s Tale because the show is a pure dramatization of the feminist id and spends six seasons asking us to recoil at a world where women’s reproductive bodies are used to produce children for other people. More powerful people. At the expense of women. The comparison becomes uncomfortable when we ask what really changes once the woman is paid, signs a contract and then changes her mind.
What happens when two women both claim what we have told them are their reproductive rights but only one of them can get what she wants? What does this reveal about the nature of feminism?
For more Psychobabble and ad-free episode, subscribe on Substack: substack.com/@UCZlHNlu2CVjcPy9sA8iBHkQ
LIVE STREAM WITH JANICE FIAMENGO: 14th of September at noon ET.
-----------------
0:00 What If Gilead Paid the Handmaids?
0:20 The McKenna West Surrogacy Case
2:10 The Court Takes the Baby Away
2:57 The Judgment of Solomon
4:08 Sued for $100,000 for Changing Her Mind
5:24 What The Handmaid’s Tale Got Right
8:53 Janine, Charlotte and McKenna’s Baby
10:05 What If Gilead Used Artificial Insemination?
13:45 What The Handmaid’s Tale Gets Wrong About the Bible
15:02 Feminism’s Organizing Principle
17:24 When Two Women Want Opposite Things
18:37 How the Media Reframed the Story
21:05 When Children Become Products
22:48 Upcoming Episodes & Closing
The movement's greatest strength is this rhetorical sleight of hand. The ability to morph and redefine itself on demand lets it avoid any point of attack and makes it immune to criticism.
For the full episode go to the Psychobabble Channel
In this episode, the four investigate a new crop of feminist buzzwords — and the much more serious ideas hiding behind them.
From himpathy and medical misogyny to vicarious violence and leg harrassment and gender washing, many of these terms are presented as ways of describing injustice. But what happens when subjective feelings of grievance are turned into categories of harm.
Some of the examples are easy to laugh at but others are already moving from academia into journalism, government policy and legislation.
Announcement:
Hannah will be speaking at the **Parental Alienation Study Group conference in Australia this October**. Details here: eecw.eventsair.com/pasg2026
Guests:
Janice Fiamengo: fiamengofile.substack.com
Jim Nuzzo: jameslnuzzo.substack.com
Tom Golden: menaregood.substack.com
Please like, subscribe and share the episode if you find Psychobabble valuable!
Chapters:
0:00 When Buzzwords Become More Than Words
2:03 “Himpathy”: Is Empathy for Men a Problem?
6:00 What Happened to the Presumption of Innocence?
10:05 The Empathy Gap Between Men and Women
13:32 “Leg Hair Harassment” Is Apparently Real
18:05 When Discomfort Becomes Oppression
20:29 The Rise of “Medical Misogyny”
27:00 What the Medical Misogyny Data Actually Shows
30:10 When Not Getting a Diagnosis Becomes Discrimination
35:03 Why Psychiatry Needs to Be Able to Say “No”
36:44 Feminism’s War Over Trans Women
42:01 Is the Trans Debate Breaking Feminism?
48:02 “Vicarious Violence” — The Most Serious Buzzword Yet
52:33 When the Victim Can Only Be a Woman
55:24 “Substantive Equality” and the End of Equal Treatment
1:02:39 What Is “Gender Washing”?
1:06:04 How Buzzwords Make Dissent Immoral
1:07:51 Hannah Is Going to Australia
In this episode of Psychobabble, psychiatrist Dr. Hannah Spier breaks down the Midwest Safety bodycam footage of Ms. Choi to reveal a terrifying, counterintuitive psychological mechanism: for individuals with an extreme lack of neurotic containment, finding a boundary is often the ultimate goal. Because they cannot self-regulate, they push and provoke until the environment enforces a boundary to make them feel emotionally safer.
If you are dealing with this type of triangulation in a relationship, custody battle, or workplace, Dr. Spier explains why simply holding firm isn't a long-term solution—and the one crucial step you must take to protect yourself.
-----------------------------------
For more Psychobabble go to Substack: substack.com/@psychobabblewithspier
Book a session: https://tr.ee/b1Fn-G88hO
------------------------------------
00:00 The Boundary Paradox in Modern Therapy
00:30 Bodycam Analysis: The Case of Ms. Choi
02:02 Projecting Brittle Authority
04:04 Searching for a Boundary That Holds
05:26 The Coercive Power of the "Primal Scream"
07:33 Rapid Cycling Through Defenses
10:22 Panic & Overwriting Reality
11:34 Appealing to Trauma When the Boundary Holds
12:38 Weaponized Piousness & Fake Prayer
13:48 Triangulation: Why the Act Suddenly Stops
15:09 The Core Lesson: Meeting an Unenforceable "No"
15:36 Document Everything: Protecting Yourself
16:35 Upcoming Panel Announcement
---------------------------------------------
Thanks to Midwest Safety: youtube.com/@MidwestSafety/featured
Subscribe for more Psychobabble with Spier:
hannahspier.substack.com
CHAPTERS
00:00 When “quiet” BPD isn’t quiet
00:28 What is Quiet BPD?
04:24 What actually defines borderline personality
05:59 Who is affected by the “quiet” symptoms?
07:48 The seven signs of Quiet BPD
11:00 “Apologizing for existing”
12:45 Extreme emotions nobody sees?
14:35 Relationship tests and walking on glass
15:44 Psychologists are promoting the label
17:39 The problem with “high-functioning BPD”
19:03 When harmful behavior becomes “suffering”
20:16 What does the research actually show?
This is not an attempt to diagnose a stranger from bodycam footage. Instead, Hannah uses the interaction to show a behavioral pattern often seen in significant Cluster B pathology: what happens when increasingly intense attempts to control another person stop working and the external boundary refuses to move.
The most important question is not whether someone meets a particular diagnosis. It is whether you recognize the pattern in your own relationships: when accountability approaches, does the other person become so distressed, helpless or injured that you suddenly find yourself comforting the person whose behavior you were originally trying to address?
------------------------
For more content and ad-free epsiodes check out the Psychobabble Substack:
substack.com/@psychobabblewithspier
-------------------------
Original video from Law and Crime Network: youtu.be/PNcbEC-S7Vg?si=dnPSFyyCKbyLLMTU
------------------------
00:00 Intro: The Cluster B Epidemic
02:18 Stage 1: Charm & Cooperation
05:21 Stage 2: Bargaining & Control
07:51 Stage 3: Emotional Manipulation
12:04 Stage 4: Aggression & Escalation
21:54 Stage 5: Parental Rescue
26:03 Stage 6: Physical Regression & Victim Reversal
As a psychiatrist, watching the public reaction to the Lindsay Clancy case has been deeply revealing. We automatically reach for medical excuses to avoid an uncomfortable truth: women have both the capacity to nurture and the capacity to destroy. It's time we stop the moral laundering of female violence.
📺 Watch the full psychological breakdown: "Why We Want Lindsay Clancy to Be the Victim"
In this episode, psychiatrist Hannah Spier examines the psychiatric arguments at the center of the ongoing Lindsay Clancy trial: what an acute psychotic break actually looks like, the unusual timing of the alleged postpartum psychosis, the claim of an undiagnosed bipolar disorder, the long list of psychiatric medications Clancy was prescribed, and the argument that she could appear completely normal while experiencing severe psychosis.
But the case raises a larger question. Why are we so quick to search for an external explanation when a mother commits an horrific act? At what point does psychiatric explanation begin to erase moral agency?
This episode discusses disturbing material involving the deaths of children.
Subscribe for more Psychobabble with Spier!
Read Psychobabble and become a Psychobabble Insider on Substack for articles, sources, exclusive lives and access to the full Psychobabble library.
substack.com/@psychobabblewithspier
---------------------
0:00 How Convenient
0:32 The Lindsay Clancy Case
2:02 “The System Broke Her”
3:39 What the Prosecution Says Happened
5:02 The Postpartum Psychosis Defense
6:25 What Psychosis Actually Looks Like
11:14 Lindsay Clancy vs. Other Filicide Cases
14:42 The Defense’s Hybrid Psychiatric Explanation
15:50 Bipolar Disorder and the Medication Theory
19:15 Thirteen Psychiatric Medications?
21:16 Prescribed Is Not the Same as Ingested
24:55 Did Psychiatric Drugs “Flip a Switch”?
27:24 Can Postpartum Psychosis Be Masked?
32:25 Responsibility and Female Agency
33:39 Intrusive Thoughts, Psychosis and Altruistic Filicide
36:10 Did the System Actually Fail Her?
37:52 The Moral Laundering of Female Violence
40:50 Women Can Nurture—and Destroy
Join the conversation in the comments, subscribe for more Psychobabble, and find the written version and sources on Substack. substack.com/@psychobabblewithspier
----------------------------
A viral voice memo has everyone arguing about timing, pressure and consent. But the real issue is something else entirely. It exposes how ridiculous the conversation around sex and dating has become.
Join the conversation in the comments, subscribe for more Psychobabble, and find the written version and sources on Substack. substack.com/@psychobabblewithspier
----------------------
00:21 The viral voice memo
00:57 What he actually asked for
02:10 The problem with “sexual compatibility”
02:25 Dating experts make the obvious confusing
03:09 Why sex is not a fixed compatibility trait
04:07 The sexual compatibility hoax
04:31 Why women are really angry
05:04 Why the timing argument misses the point
05:31 What made the memo so triggering
06:14 Therapy culture’s advice about sex
07:02 What Hannah would teach her daughter
07:29 Why Voice Memo Guy was actually wrong
08:22 The compatibility industry
08:56 Believe men when they tell you what they want
09:15 The uncomfortable responsibility women avoid
But this “main character energy” isn't actually building confidence. Instead, it’s teaching a generation of women that any form of compromise is a betrayal of their authenticity. It destroys our ability to connect, adapt, and build healthy, lasting relationships. It's time to stop glorifying toxic advice.
📺 Watch the full breakdown on how modern culture is setting women up for conflict: youtu.be/jE0IauEQC74
#relationshipadvice #psychology #modernwomen #toxicpositivity #hannahspier #datingadvice #culture
-----------------------------------------
Girls were taught to speak up, resist influence, reject criticism and never change for anyone. But what happens when every part of culture—film, advertising, social media, schools and psychology—pushes in the same direction?
This episode examines how efforts to make girls tougher may also have discouraged compromise, accommodation and agreeableness, leaving many women trained to approach relationships as power struggles rather than cooperation.
Want to watch the episodes ad-free? Upgrade on Substack and get every epsiode and other benefits like Google Meets and Exclusive Live Videos:
substack.com/@psychobabblewithspier
-----------------------------------------
00:00 Women Acting Like Men
00:24 A Lifetime of “Empowerment”
01:41 How Assertiveness Became Liberation
02:47 Self-Esteem and the Extroverted Ideal
03:34 How Film and Television Changed Women
05:49 When Female Coldness Became Powerful
07:37 The Rise of the Female Antihero
08:47 Wednesday, Disney and Emotional Detachment
10:08 Sponsor: Looki L1
10:59 Advertising, Girl Power and Self-Worth
12:21 Social Media’s Terrible Relationship Advice
13:43 How Schools Trained Girls to Assert Themselves
15:39 The Problem With Social-Emotional Learning
17:37 Why “Prosocial Behaviour” Can Hide Aggression
18:07 Extroversion Versus Agreeableness
19:06 What Girls Were Taught to Prioritize
20:18 How This Undermines Intimacy
21:11 Can You Respect a Man You Were Taught to Fight?
There is a difference between possessing feminine traits and learning to perform their signals like a costume.
Watch the full breakdown in the episode!
In this episode, psychiatrist Hannah Spier explains how modern dating coaches rebrand narcissistic behavior as femininity, confidence and self-worth.
Chapters:
00:00 The “high-value woman” playbook
01:25 Standards, femininity and low agreeableness
03:32 Strategic dating and playing hard to get
05:43 Who actually earns “high value”?
06:26 Boundaries, self-love and manufactured scarcity
08:40 Narcissism disguised as confidence
09:32 No second chances and relationship failure
12:28 Treating yourself like Harvard
13:45 Cosplaying innocence and fake femininity
14:47 Feminism, entitlement and the soft life
16:28 Why the strategy fails long term
16:50 Final thoughts
Watch the full episode of Psychobabble on my channel!
#MentalHealth #HighFunctioningDepression #Psychobabble #MentalHealthMyths #Adulthood
In this episode, I react to young women presenting normal functioning as “high-functioning depression,” insisting that invisible distress cannot be questioned, and using suicidal language to make disagreement morally dangerous. I explain how mental-health labels can turn basic responsibilities into acts of bravery, confer moral authority and eventually become leverage over everyone around them.
Do you think mental-health awareness has gone too far—or are these videos helping people feel less alone? Let me know in the comments.
Please like, subscribe and share the episode!
Head on over to Substack and upgrade to watch the episodes ad-free!
hannahspier.substack.com
#MentalHealth #TherapyCulture #Psychology
---------------------------
0:00 Why suffering has become a performance
1:27 Mental illness as moral authority
3:24 The problem with “high-functioning depression”
5:00 When basic functioning becomes bravery
6:59 What if you are simply well?
7:48 The inflation of suffering
9:17 “You can never tell”
10:18 Suicide as emotional leverage
10:49 Can awareness increase contagion?
11:33 What happened to personal responsibility?
12:15 TikTok rewards suicidal content
12:51 Agency, gratitude and growing up
Watch the full breakdown in the episode linked! Subscribe to Psychobabble for more!
In this episode, psychiatrist Hannah Spier examines the evidence behind DID, the limitations of self-reported amnesia and diagnostic interviews, and the difficulty of distinguishing separate “identities” from shifting emotional states, trauma responses, borderline personality traits, and identity disturbance.
Finally, Hannah looks at the history of multiple personality disorder—from mesmerism and hypnosis to *The Three Faces of Eve*, *Sybil*, *Split*, and TikTok—and offers advice for parents whose children return from therapy with a new DID diagnosis.
Read Hannah’s articles and join exclusive live discussions on Substack!
substack.com/@psychobabblewithspier
--------------------------------
00:00 Dissociation is real—but what is DID?
01:39 Where psychology may be overreaching
02:20 Identity disturbance and borderline personality traits
03:02 Alters, systems, and the desire to feel special
05:05 Emotional states versus separate identities
06:23 The risks of reinforcing a fragmented identity
07:12 Examining a supposed personality “switch”
08:43 Self-report, amnesia, and the diagnosis of DID
09:41 What the research does—and does not—prove
10:44 Therapist bias and suggestibility
12:10 How a DID diagnosis can be introduced and reinforced
16:29 Trauma theory and the lack of childhood diagnoses
16:59 The cultural history of multiple personality disorder
19:02 Advice for parents
19:34 Closing and next episode
------------------
In this episode, we look at the Mackenzie Shirilla case as a starting point for a broader question: how do we understand female physical violence?
The discussion moves from the details of the case — including Shirilla’s behavior before and after the crash, the public reaction, and the question of remorse — into a wider examination of how female aggression is often framed culturally. We tend to associate men with physical violence and women with relational aggression, but the evidence around intimate partner violence, family violence, elder abuse, and child homicide complicates that picture.
-----------------------
Chapters
00:00 — Are women less physically violent?
00:38 — The Mackenzie Shirilla case
03:41 — Cluster B traits and interpersonal dominance
08:56 — Female sociopathy and violent women
09:10 — The myth of domestic violence as male-only
09:26 — Intimate partner violence data
10:12 — Why female violence is often framed as self-defense
10:41 — Why women report using physical aggression
10:56 — Gender symmetry in older violence studies
11:35 — Teen boys and dating violence victimization
11:49 — The problem with using general crime statistics
12:22 — Violence in female-dominated settings
12:37 — Elder abuse and female perpetrators
12:50 — Mothers, filicide, and neonaticide
13:41 — How society interprets male vs female violence
In this episode, I look at the inflation of chivalry: the way ordinary courtship has turned into elaborate performance, “princess treatment,” promposals, expensive dates, and endless proof of male devotion. What is the problem with this?
In this episode, I look at the inflation of chivalry: the way ordinary courtship has turned into elaborate performance, “princess treatment,” promposals, expensive dates, and endless proof of male devotion. What is the problem with this?
We also look at the rise of “the ick,” and what that signifies.
Subscribe on Substack for more Psychobabble!
Paid subscribers get ad-free episodes, articles, Google Meets, and exclusive community discussions on Substack:
hannahspier.substack.com
--------------------------
00:40 The Cost of Modern Dating for Men
02:09 No Effort, No Reciprocity
03:00 Promposals and Princess Treatment
04:22 What Chivalry Was Supposed to Be
05:27 The Rise of “The Ick”
06:17 The Train Ticket Example
07:01 When Men Stop Performing
08:22 Women Want Permanent Courtship
09:00 Male Vulnerability and the Collapse of Empathy
10:11 Consuming Relationships Instead of Building Them
10:38 Fragile Narcissism and Modern Intimacy
--------------------------
On June 3, 1968, Valerie Solanas walked into Andy Warhol's studio and shot him. Decades later, she has become a feminist icon, her SCUM Manifesto is taught in universities, and Hollywood celebrated her life in a major film that is now returning to theaters in a new restoration.
How did an attempted murderer become a cultural hero?
In this episode I'm joined by Janice Fiamengo, Tom Golden, and Jim Nuzzo to explore one of the most striking double standards in modern culture: why female violence is so often explained, romanticized, and even celebrated, while male violence is treated as evidence of innate evil.
-------------------------------
Follow them here:
Janice Fiamengo: substack.com/@fiamengofile
James Nuzzo: substack.com/@jameslnuzzo?utm_source=global-search
Tom Golden: substack.com/@menaregood?r=1rqrel&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=stories&shareImageVariant=blur
----------------------------
🔴 Tonight: Live Google Meet for paid subscribers: hannahspier.substack.com
Tonight at 3:00 PM Eastern I'll be hosting our exclusive monthly Google Meet for paid subscribers.
We'll be discussing fathers, masculinity, and what is happening to men in modern society, with plenty of time for questions and discussion.
If you'd like to join, upgrade now. You'll immediately gain access to the paid subscriber chat, where the Google Meet link has already been posted. I'll also send an email with the meeting link to all paid subscribers before we go live.
I hope to see many of you there.
------------------------------
00:00 Valerie Solanas and the Attempted Murder of Andy Warhol
01:06 Introducing the Panel
01:37 Why Is Valerie Solanas Being Celebrated?
05:16 Hollywood's Romanticization of Female Violence
11:48 The SCUM Manifesto and Feminist History
17:00 Did Feminism Embrace Valerie Solanas?
22:49 Was Valerie Solanas Mentally Ill?
25:15 Why Society Excuses Female Violence
30:01 Feminist Utopias and Anti-Male Ideology
34:17 Is Feminism a Public Health Problem?
36:33 Female Violence and the Double Standard
40:35 Why We Don't Excuse Violent Men
42:29 Gynocentrism and Cultural Bias
46:39 Protection vs Special Treatment
49:00 Why We Ignore Violence by Women
52:00 Final Thoughts
But pop culture rewrite history officially after Solanas was made something t of a folk hero for her manifesto SCUM in academic womens studies. In 1996, Hollywood turned Solanas's story into a biopic, elevating her from a paranoid attempted murderer to a radical philosopher.
And now, thirty years later, the film is getting a 4K restoration and a "triumphant return" to theaters a good example of how our culture bends over backwards to excuse, and even romanticize, female violence.
Tune In on Thursday for the reaction to this new movie!
In this discussion, I sit down with J.D. Haltigan to examine the evidence surrounding Long COVID, Fibromyalgia, and Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (ME/CFS). We discuss why these diagnoses overlap so extensively, the role of psychiatric comorbidity and personality, why "it's all in your head" is often misunderstood, and how identity, politics, and social media have shaped the public conversation around chronic illness.
Follow J.D Haltigan: https://x.com/JDHaltigan
---------------------
00:00 Introduction
01:38 Meet J.D. Haltigan
04:00 What Are Long COVID, Fibromyalgia & ME/CFS?
08:45 Why Long COVID Lacks Discriminant Validity
11:18 Biomarkers, Inflammation & Psychiatry
14:07 Why These Diagnoses Overlap
17:32 Symptom Clusters and Patient Populations
21:21 The Politics of Long COVID
27:55 Why These Conditions Affect More Women
29:20 Psychiatric History and Comorbidity
36:13 What "It's All in Your Head" Really Means
38:21 Correlation vs. Causation
41:10 Illness Identity and Pragmatism
55:56 Post-Exertional Malaise and Deconditioning
1:01:01 The "Yes, But" Loop
1:05:17 Activism, Hostility & Diagnosis
1:11:59 Final Thoughts
It's also a disorder of instability.
So why do we expect validation alone to produce stability?
One patient taught me a very different lesson.
Full episode ↓
I don't think it's scientifically justified, and I think it's one of the reasons we've struggled to treat Borderline Personality Disorder effectively.
----------------------------------------
Most treatments for Borderline Personality Disorder focus on emotional dysregulation. The goal is to reduce distress, self-harm, anxiety, and crises. But that misses the mark.
In this episode, I argue that modern psychiatry has adopted a model of Borderline Personality Disorder that is incomplete. By focusing almost exclusively on suffering, it neglects the maladaptive strategies harm others.
I also examine the striking contrast between how psychiatry approaches Borderline Personality Disorder—predominantly diagnosed in women—and Antisocial Personality Disorder, diagnosed predominantly in men. Why do we define one disorder primarily by the patient’s suffering and the other by the harm inflicted on others? And what has this double standard done to treatment?
In the second half of the episode I outline what I believe a more realistic treatment model would look like.
If you’ve ever wondered why Borderline Personality Disorder remains so difficult to treat, this episode offers a very different way of thinking about the problem.
----------------------
Join my Google Meets and exclsuive live sterams on substack: substack.com/@psychobabblewithspier
-------------------
00:22 The Flaws in Standard BPD Treatment
02:02 The Exploitation Aspect of Intense Emotions
03:48 -The Mistake in Measuring Therapeutic Improvement
04:55 Comparing Borderline and Antisocial Personality Disorders
06:53 Discrepancies in Treatment Guidelines and Empathy
08:13 The Trauma Narrative and Modern Psychiatry
12:14 What To Do
12:50 Measure Social Functioning
13:26 Use Leverage
14:11 Threats Should Not Suspend Obligations
15:03 Expectations for Benefits
17:24 Restrictions, Not Attention
17:47 Parents Must Stop Rewarding It
19:17 Change the Environment
21:44 Confront Them With Reality
24:22 Conclusion
After a recent article I published sparked intense online backlash, activist mobilization, and even threats to my medical license, we decided to dig our heels in. Why does a clinical discussion around these diagnoses evoke such a highly polarized, emotionally hyperbolic response?
We talk about the psychometrics and statistics behind these conditions, dissecting the lack of “discriminant validity” that separates long COVID from generalized, nonspecific post-viral symptomatology. We look at large population datasets to explore the psychological underpinnings of chronic suffering: trait neuroticism, emotional dysregulation, the culture-bound nature of functional somatic disorders, and the secondary gains that risk turning a medical illness into a permanent personal identity.
Is it truly compassionate to leave patients waiting for a medical miracle cure, or do we already have the framework to help them rebuild their agency and live a functioning life?
Thank you and many others for tuning into my live video! Join me for my next live video in the app.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
01:31 – Introducing Dr. J.D. Haltigan
02:08 – The Social Media Blowup
03:37 – Defining the Conditions: Long COVID, Fibromyalgia, and ME/CFS
06:01 – Setting the Boundaries: nonspecific Symptoms vs. Pathology
08:34 – The Measurement Science: What is Construct & Discriminant Validity?
11:58 – Neuroinflammation: The Biology of Suffering vs. Psychiatric Controls
14:56 – Big Dataset Psychometrics vs. Individual Clinical Anecdotes
21:18 – Internet Chat Rooms & The Origin Narrative of Long COVID
26:51 – Demographic Asymmetries: Sex Ratios & Gender-Identity Distress
29:19 – Prior Psychiatric History and Comorbidity in the Clinic
31:02 – What Comes First? Internalizing Problems vs. Chronic Pain
33:53 – The Stress-Diathesis Model & The Psychology of Hyper-Masking
36:10 – “Are You Saying It’s All in My Head?”
41:53 – The Pragmatic Approach: Is the “Mysterious Illness” Narrative Compassionate?
46:39 – When Diagnoses Become Personal Identities & Personality Personae
49:03 – The Role of Trait Neuroticism & Emotional Dysregulation
51:10 – The Leftist Political Project of Neurodiversity & Victimhood Culture
55:51 – Post-Exertion Malaise (PEM) vs. Depressive Deconditioning
01:01:00 – The “Yes, But” Game & Acceptance Commitment Therapy (ACT)
01:03:32 – Working with Brittle Personality Structures & Cluster B Hijacking
01:05:03 – Receiving Death Threats for Publishing Balanced Research
01:07:47 – Secondary Gains & How Chronic Illness Changes Personalities
01:12:53 – Audience Q&A, Haldol Comments, and Wrap-Up
01:14:49 – Preview: Takedown of DBT & Treating Borderline Personality Disorder
--------------------------------------
Postpartum depression is real, and in some cases it can be severe and even dangerous. Mothers who are struggling deserve compassion, support, and proper care. But what happens when a normal, difficult transition into motherhood increasingly becomes viewed through the lens of pathology?
In this episode, I explore the rise of postpartum depression as a cultural phenomenon, the expansion of screening and diagnosis, and whether we are sometimes pathologizing experiences that previous generations understood differently. I also examine the role of feminism, women's media, and modern therapeutic culture in shaping how women anticipate and experience motherhood.
Chapters:
00:00 Coming Up
00:14 Motherhood as a Risk State
01:35 The Rise of Postpartum Depression
02:37 From Motherhood to Pathology
03:02 Screening Mothers Everywhere
04:16 The Baby Blues vs Postpartum Depression
05:03 What the Data Actually Shows
06:54 Why Diagnoses Feel Validating
07:49 Anticipating Illness and Self-Fulfilling Prophecies
08:24 How Women's Media Shapes Expectations
08:48 "Women's Magazines Don't Just Report It, They Stage It"
10:03 The Isolation of Modern Mothers
11:47 Does Feminism Really Care About Mothers?
12:35 Final Thoughts
🎧 Listen to Psychobabble on your favourite podcast platform:
Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/0bhfvlkw5nuHJ63jqo5bCU
Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/psychobabble/id1677100656
📰 Subscribe to Psychobabble:
hannahspier.substack.com
---
If you enjoyed this episode, please like, subscribe, and leave a comment. I read as many comments as I can and would love to hear your thoughts.
#Motherhood #PostpartumDepression #Psychology #Psychiatry #Feminism #MentalHealth
Evolutionary psychologist Dr Dani Sulikowski joins me to discuss one of the most provocative theories I have encountered: that feminism may be best understood as a form of intrasexual competition between women.
Let me know what you think in the comments.
Follow Dr. Dani Sulikowski:
https://x.com/DrDaniS
substack.com/@drdanis
CHAPTERS:
01:05 Feminism as a form of female competition
02:02 How feminism suppresses female reproductive success
03:07 The attack on attractiveness and femininity
04:22 Body positivity and competitive strategies
04:39 "Feminism was always intersexual competition"
05:05 Was feminism ever about motherhood?
06:09 Ancient Rome and declining birth rates
07:43 My challenge: is this really about resentment?
09:40 Why feminism targets desirable men
12:33 "It's not suicidal empathy, it's homicidal virtue signalling"
21:56 Feminist mothers and transing children
29:35 Activism, status, and moral superiority
32:32 Competitive strategies vs evolutionary adaptations
33:35 The attack on masculinity and femininity
39:15 Does this theory remove female agency?
58:30 Final reflections
01:00:32 "That wasn't the answer I was hoping for"
#Feminism #EvolutionaryPsychology #Psychology #DaniSulikowski #FemalePsychology
Tomorrow, evolutionary psychologist Dr Dani Sulikowski joins me to argue that feminism may be better understood as an intrasexual competitive strategy between women.
New episode drops tomorrow.
Subscribe now so you don't miss it.
Women are taught from very early on to speak the language of empathy, compassion, healing, boundaries, emotional safety and self-awareness. But that does not necessarily mean the underlying personality is agreeable, sacrificial or kind. In many cases, the narcissism is simply cloaked differently.
#personalitydisorders #narcissism
Women are taught from very early on to speak the language of empathy, compassion, healing, boundaries, emotional safety and self-awareness. But that does not necessarily mean the underlying personality is agreeable, sacrificial or kind. In many cases, the narcissism is simply cloaked differently.
------------------
This Sunday at 3 PM Eastern, paid subscribers on Substack are invited for a Google Meet where we will talk about he effect of having been raised by a feminist. Subscribe on Substack and find the link in the Chat or get it on mail!
substack.com/@psychobabblewithspier
----------------------
00:00 Intro: Narcissism in women
04:05 Red flag 1: Watch what she does, not what she says
05:17 Red flag 2: “I’m just being real”
06:42 Red flag 3: Therapy language as an excuse
07:35 Red flag 4: Getting diagnoses
09:35 Red flag 5: Diagnosis without responsibility
09:49 Red flag 6: Giving bad advice to girlfriends
11:06 Red flag 7: How other women act around her
11:56 Red flag 8: How you feel around her
12:22 Red flag 9: How she handles social discomfort
13:05 Red flag 10: What type of man she thinks she deserves
13:42 Red flag 11: Status-seeking causes
14:36 Red flag 12: Instagram morality and “healing” language
15:34 Red flag 13: Lack of humility
16:11 Red flag 14: Narcissism in motherhood
18:03 Red flag 15: Contempt for ordinary female duties
19:55 Red flag 16: Public sacrifice, private neglect
20:51 Red flag 17: Mother getting diagnosis for kids
21:27 Red flag 18: Diagnosis without treatment
21:46 Red flag 19: “How does this affect me?”
22:40 What to look for instead
23:07 Outro
Watch the full episode for the breakdown on the Psychobabble Channel!
#psychology #psychopath #personalitydisorders
In this episode, I respond to Dr. Ramani’s claim that “psychopaths are born and sociopaths are made” and explain why that framing is far too simplistic. I also explain why cold psychopaths unsettle us so much and how antisocial personality disorder fits into this,.
Join Psychobabble on Substack for paid subscriber Google Meets, live sessions, and ad-free episodes:
hannahspier.substack.com
--------------------------------------------
00:00 Forensic psychiatry and the fascination with psychopaths
01:17 Psychopaths, sociopaths, and antisocial personality disorder
03:53 What they all share
04:20 Cold psychopathy and hot psychopathy
06:00 The problem with “wired differently”
09:13 The myth of born versus made
10:18 Early signs and extreme trait expression
10:44 The cold psychopath profile
11:30 Why cold psychopaths unsettle us
12:00 Hot psychopathy
13:00 The Dark Tetrad
16:17 Why psychopaths seem inhuman
18:01 ASPD versus psychopathy
19:05 Why sociopathy is not a separate diagnosis
19:57 Male bias in the discussion of psychopathy
Watch the full breakdown on the Psychobabble Channel!
We also look at mental load, weaponized incompetence, motherhood, marriage, feminist wellbeing research, and the way clinical language has given female resentment a kind of scientific authority.
The problem is not that women are never treated unfairly. The problem is what happens when unfairness becomes the organizing principle of female identity.
Join Psychobabble Insiders for live streams and discussions on Substack. hannahspier.substack.com
--------------------------
00:32 The mechanisms behind female grievance culture
01:31 Marriage, fertility and adult adjustment
02:26 How motherhood became framed as burden
02:56 Mechanism 1: Externalizing blame
04:27 Mechanism 2: Victimhood and suspicion
05:13 Mental load and the grievance lens
06:37 Are fathers really doing less?
07:28 Marriage as a zero-sum game
08:12 The burdens fathers carry
09:20 Interpersonal victimhood and personality
10:23 When grievance becomes identity
11:02 Mechanism 3: Rewarded antagonism
12:05 Why suspicion is treated as intelligence
13:32 Female venting, validation and social media
14:47 Therapy-speak and the female psyche
16:36 The three mechanisms together
17:28 What feminist wellbeing research misses
We’ve traded traditional support systems for a "boost of anger" labeled as empowerment. But anger is only a temporary fix. It doesn't help with the long-term adjustment to adult life.
Are we actually "empowered," or are we just being conditioned to be exhausted?
Watch the full breakdown on my channel (link in bio).
Watch the full episode on the Psychobabble Channel!


