Uploaded March 2025 | Updated September 2026, 2 weeks ago

---

Joe Folley, host of the YouTube channel Unsolicited Advice, published a three-pronged critique of the fine-tuning argument. Here I respond to those criticisms, showing that the FTA survives. The best argument for God lives to fight another day.

Joe's original video: youtube.com/watch?v=SxBwRAjTFcc

Joe's YouTube channel: youtube.com/@UCW71hQg1kDxmFIfijA8dL0Q

Matthew Adelstein's article looking at the "too much wasted space" objection to theism: benthams.substack.com/p/the-argument-from-scale-is-an-own

My brief overview of the FTA: youtube.com/watch?v=80BSNMb_6j4&t=292s

00:00:00 Introduction
00:01:34 Objection 1 - Of Puddles and People
00:01:49 "Life is Not Special"
00:03:08 "Anthropic Objection"
00:09:58 Objection 2 - The Art of the Possible
00:10:09 "Probability 0"
00:11:55 "Physical Necessity"
00:18:08 "God Wouldn't Fine-Tune"
00:18:56 Objection 3 - Psychoanalyzing God