FCisNotScience
Why Camera Angles Matter in Detecting Facilitator Behaviors that Influence Letter Selection
updated
Time Stamps
0:00 Introduction
0:49 Goals of this video
1:12 Observations from a former facilitator
1:48 What FC workshop leaders didn't tell us
3:45 The Telepathy Tapes
5:07 Facilitator-dependent techniques
6:24 Role of facilitators
8:15 FC and Telepathy
9:05 Testing for facilitator cues
11:01 A Telepath Test: IZARD
15:56 Summary
18:19 The Science
FMI about FC, please visit http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
Controlled Studies
facilitatedcommunication.org/controlled-studies
Systematic Reviews
facilitatedcommunication.org/systematic-reviews
Opposition Statements
facilitatedcommunication.org/organizations-opposing-fc
Time stamps:
0:00 Introduction
0:49 Goals of this video
1:15 Observations from a former facilitator
3:47 The Telepathy Tapes
5:10 Facilitator-dependent techniques
6:29 Role of Facilitators
8:23 FC and Telepathy
9:19 Testing for facilitator cues
11:21 A Telepathy Test: Random Numbers
15:23 A Telepathy Test: Uno
19:30 Summary
22:06 The Science
FMI about FC: http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
Ideomotor Response: facilitatedcommunication.org/ideomotor-response
Controlled Studies: facilitatedcommunication.org/controlled-studies
Systematic Reviews: facilitatedcommunication.org/systematic-reviews
Opposition Statements: facilitatedcommunication.org/organizations-opposing-fc
Time Stamps
0:00 Introduction
0:47 Goals of this video
1:08 Observations from a former facilitator
1:42 What workshop leaders didn't tell us
3:37 The Telepathy Tapes
4:58 Facilitator-dependent techniques
6:16 Role of Facilitators
8:15 FC and Telepathy
9:06 Testing for facilitator cues
11:09 A Telepathy Test: Crew Cards
18:49 Summary
21:30 The Science
FMI about FC:
http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
Controlled Studies
facilitatedcommunication.org/controlled-studies
Systematic Reviews
facilitatedcommunication.org/systematic-reviews
Opposition Statements
facilitatedcommunication.org/organizations-opposing-fc
Timestamps
0:00 Introduction
0:48 Goals of this video
1:13 Observations from a former facilitator
1:45 What FC workshop leaders didn't tell us
3:48 The Telepathy Tapes
5:13 Facilitator-dependent techniques
5:35 Two main categories of FC
6:26 Role of facilitators
8:18 FC and telepathy
9:13 Testing for facilitator cues
11:17 A telepathy test
13:37 Facilitator behaviors during the spelling session
19:41 Summary
22:10 The science
FMI, please visit http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
Controlled Studies
facilitatedcommunication.org/controlled-studies
Systematic Reviews
facilitatedcommunication.org/systematic-reviews
Opposition Statements
facilitatedcommunication.org/organizations-opposing-fc
Check out the Telepathy Tapes playlist on my Youtube channel for more analysis of tests of telepathy and individuals being subjected to FC/S2C/RPM
Time Stamps
0:00 Introduction
0:52 Goals of this video
1:18 Observations from a former facilitator
1:53 What FC workshop leaders didn't tell us
4:02 The Telepathy Tapes
5:30 Facilitator-dependent techniques
5:57 Two main categories of FC
6:50 Role of Facilitators
8:47 FC and Telepathy
9:43 Testing for facilitator cues
11:47 A telepathy test
13:16 "Double Blind" test
14:56 Facilitator Behaviors: Eye Contact w/letter board
17:14 Facilitator Behaviors: Letter board drift
18:14 Facilitator Behaviors: Physical touch
19:39 Facilitator Behaviors: Verbal cues
23:18 Summary
26:19 The Science
FMI about FC: http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
Controlled Studies: facilitatedcommunication.org/controlled-studies
Systematic Reviews: facilitatedcommunication.org/systematic-reviews
Opposition Statements: facilitatedcommunication.org/organizations-opposing-fc
Timestamps:
0:00 Introduction
0:52 Goals of this video
1:20 Observations from a former facilitator
1:56 What FC workshop leaders didn't tell us
4:03 The Telepathy Tapes
5:29 Facilitator-dependent techniques
5:50 Two main categories of FC
6:49 Role of facilitators
8:50 FC and Telepathy
9:47 Testing for facilitator cues
11:57 A telepathy test
13:27 Facilitator Behaviors: Visual and Physical Cues
13:37 Facilitator Behaviors: Verbal Cues
15:17 Awareness of the problem of cueing in FC
16:49 Summary
19:01 The Science
FMI about FC, please visit http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
Controlled Studies
facilitatedcommunication.org/controlled-studies
Systematic Reviews
facilitatedcommunication.org/systematic-reviews
Opposition Statements
facilitatedcommunication.org/organizations-opposing-fc
FMI about Facilitated Communication and its variants: facilitatedcommunication.org
Systematic Reviews: facilitatedcommunication.org/systematic-reviews
Controlled Studies: facilitatedcommunication.org/controlled-studies
Opposition Statements: facilitatedcommunication.org/organizations-opposing-fc
Time Stamps
0:00 Introduction
0:57 Goals of this video
1:33 Observations from a former facilitator
2:08 What FC workshop leaders didn't tell us
3:54 The Telepathy Tapes
5:21 Facilitator-dependent techniques
5:43 Two Main Categories of FC
6:51 Role of Facilitators
8:48 FC and Telepathy
9:53 Testing for facilitator cues
12:08 A Telepathy Test
13:43 Facilitator Behaviors
15:39 Summary
18:24 The Science
Previous critiques of the facilitator/client pair featured in this video
The Video Critique the Telepathy Tapes Didn't Want You To See | Facilitator Cueing in FC: youtube.com/watch?v=NW1zUCg7tjM&t=2s
Time stamps
0:00 Introduction
0:38 Goals of this video
1:12 Observations from a former facilitator
1:53 What FC workshop leaders didn't tell us
4:06 The Telepathy Tapes
4:49 Facilitator-dependent techniques
6:15 Two main categories of FC
7:18 Role of Facilitators
9:19 FC and Telepathy
10:18 Testing for facilitator cues
11:48 Purpose of cueing
12:30 A telepathy test
14:11 A new frontier or the same old story?
15:54 Summary
FMI about FC: http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
Controlled Studies
facilitatedcommunication.org/controlled-studies
Systematic Reviews
facilitatedcommunication.org/systematic-reviews
Opposition Statements
facilitatedcommunication.org/organizations-opposing-fc
Video Critique of Episode 1 of the Telepathy Tapes: youtube.com/watch?v=b4TAoQ88pp8&t=1s
Many organizations oppose the use of FC/S2C/RPM, citing lack of scientific evidence, facilitator cueing and control, prompt dependency, potential harms, including false allegations of abuse, and lost opportunity costs as individuals are prevented from accessing legitimate, evidence-based forms of Augumentative and Alternative Communication (AAC).
Recently the Telepathy Tapes podcast has made claims that individuals being subjected to FC have telepathic abilities. This video discusses a recent attempt by the Telepathy Tapes to silence my critique of one of their telepathy test sessions.
Time Stamps
0:00 Introduction
1:20 Info workshop leaders didn't tell us
4:58 Copyright strike on YouTube
7:28 Two main categories of FC
10:04 Proving telepathic abilities in FCed individuals
13:33 A telepathy test
14:34 Facilitator behaviors
15:19 Constant eye contact with the letter board
16:20 Hand gestures and body movements
17:39 Synchronized movements
19:06 Summary
FMI about FC, please visit: http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
Systematic Reviews
facilitatedcommunication.org/systematic-reviews
Controlled Studies
facilitatedcommunication.org/controlled-studies
Opposition Statements
facilitatedcommunication.org/organizations-opposing-fc
False Allegations of Abuse
facilitatedcommunication.org/false-allegations
Today's critique includes a clip from The Telepathy Tapes podcast (2024)
Timestamps:
0:00 Start
0:44 Observations of a former facilitator
1:43 Information workshop leaders didn't tell us
3:10 Proving telepathic abilities in FCed individuals
4:57 A Telepathy Test
5:37 The Book Test
6:26 Facilitator control over letter selection
7:09 Facilitating the word "pirate"
7:39 "Mind blowing" example of telepathy
8:01 Facilitator behaviors
8:20 Letter board drift
9:13 Physical touch
10:34 Testing FC under reliably controlled conditions
11:45 Summary
To date, there is no reliably controlled evidence that FC-generated messages are independent and represent the thoughts of those being subjected to its use. Rather, the facilitators, and not their clients or loved ones, author the messages (often inadvertently) through physical, visual, and auditory cues.
FMI about FC, visit http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
Systematic Reviews: facilitatedcommunication.org/systematic-reviews
Controlled Studies: facilitatedcommunication.org/controlled-studies
Opposition Statements: facilitatedcommunication.org/organizations-opposing-fc
Many organizations oppose the use of FC/RPM, citing: lack of scientific evidence, prompt dependency, facilitator cueing and control, potential harms (including false allegations of abuse), and lost opportunity costs for students who are denied access to legitimate, evidence based forms of Augmentative and Alternative Communication (AAC).
The clips used in this video is from this RPM session: youtube.com/watch?v=lPU38u8Ar-c
For more information about FC/RPM, including systematic reviews, controlled studies, opposition statements and more, please visit: http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
The original video is available at this link: youtube.com/watch?v=pXOF-MeTyO4
There is no reliably controlled evidence to prove proponent claims that FC/RPM are independent forms of communication. Instead, these test show that facilitator and not their clients are producing the messages through visual, auditory, and physical cueing. Organizations such as American Speech/Language/Hearing Association, American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities and others oppose its use citing lack of scientific evidence, prompt dependency, facilitator cueing and control over letter selection and other harms such as false allegations of abuse.
For more information about FC, including systematic reviews, controlled studies, oppositions statements and more, please check out our website at http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
To date, there is no reliably controlled evidence to show that FC-generated messages are produced independently and free from facilitator cueing and control. Facilitators may be unaware of the extent to which they use physical, visual, and auditory cues to influence letter selection.
Many major organizations, like ASHA and AAIDD, oppose the use of FC/S2C/RPM citing as their reasons: lack of scientific evidence, prompt dependency, facilitator cueing and control, and potential harms (including false allegations of abuse).
FMI about FC, including systematic reviews, controlled studies, opposition statements, and more, please visit: http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
Reliably controlled testing shows that facilitators, not those being subjected to FC/S2C/RPM are controlling letter selection through visual, auditory and physical cues. Often the facilitator is unaware of the extent to which he or she controls letter selection.
Major organizations, like the American Speech Language Hearing Association (ASHA) oppose the use of FC/S2C/RPM and other facilitator-dependent techniques.
The clips in this video were taking from a public post on the social media platform "X" by Marie Lee.
FMI about FC, including systematic reviews, controlled studies, oppositions and more, please visit: http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
Many autism, behavioral, and speech/language organizations oppose the use of FC/S2C/RPM, citing lack of scientific evidence, facilitator control, prompt dependency, and other harms (including false allegations of abuse).
Clips used in the video came from the following sources:
Frontline's Prisoners of Silence (1993): archive.org/details/PrisonersofSilence
Meet Joshua, a 21-year-old autistic who uses spelling to communicate. AZPM YouTube Channel: tinyurl.com/y8y8fe4s
FMI about FC, including controlled studies, systematic reviews, opposition statements and more, please visit http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
FC is a discredited technique and is opposed by major speech/language, behavior, and autism organizations.
facilitatedcommunication.org/organizations-opposing-fc
Controlled studies show that facilitators, not the individuals being subjected to FC, are authoring the messages.
facilitatedcommunication.org/controlled-studies
Some facilitator cueing can be explained by the ideomotor response (or non-conscious muscle movements)
facilitatedcommunication.org/ideomotor-response
FMI about FC, including systematic reviews, controlled studies, opposition statements and more:
facilitatedcommunication.org
Information contained in this video includes clips from a 1991 Syracuse University promotional video presented by FC founder Douglas Biklen.
FMI about FC, controlled studies, systematic reviews, opposition statements, and more, please visit http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
A popular podcast, the Telepathy Tapes, features parents of nonspeaking autistic children claiming that their children have telepathic abilities, but downplays or ignores the fact that these children are being subjected to FC.
Reliably controlled testing shows that facilitators, not their clients are controlling letter selection during the FC sessions. Telepathic abilities cannot be investigated until facilitator authorship is ruled out.
FMI about FC, including controlled studies, systematic reviews, opposition statements by major speech/language, behavioral, and autism organizations, please visit http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
Prisoners of Silence (PBS Documentary) archive.org/details/PrisonersofSilence
FMI about FC and its variants, controlled studies, systematic reviews, opposition statements, and more: facilitatedcommunication.org
This video focuses on one person's journey from FC Believer to Skeptic. Janyce Boynton is among the few facilitators who speak out publicly against FC (in all its variant forms).
Many organizations, including the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association, American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities, American Psychological Association and more, oppose the use of FC/S2C/RPM, citing lack of scientific evidence, facilitator control, prompt dependency, opportunity and financial costs, and potential harms (including false allegations of abuse).
For more information about FC, research studies, systematic reviews, opposition statements, reports of harm, and more, please check out our website at http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org.
This educational video is intended to draw attention to the problem of facilitator cuing in Facilitated Communication (FC). FC is also known as Spelling to Communicate (S2C), Rapid Prompting Method (RPM), and, as seen in this video, Speaking With Eyes.
In 2018, the Department for International Disabilities posted a YouTube video featuring Jonathan Bryan and two facilitators spelling out a message using a plastic letter board held in the air. They claim that Jonathan can "speak with his eyes," but who is really doing the communicating?
Ace Centre Video: youtube.com/watch?v=cuwgD8YZD3k
Compass AAC Video: youtube.com/watch?v=X0iyOm1tzV4
To date, there is no reliably controlled evidence to prove proponent claims of independent communication. Rather, research shows that facilitators and not their clients are controlling the FC-generated messages.
Organizations such as the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA) and the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities (AAIDD), among others, oppose the use of FC/S2C/RPM, citing concerns about facilitator control, prompt dependency, lack of scientific evidence, financial and opportunity costs, and potential harms (including false allegations of abuse).
FMI about the ideomotor response:
facilitatedcommunication.org/ideomotor-response
FMI about opposition statements:
facilitatedcommunication.org/organizations-opposing-fc
FMI about systematic reviews:
facilitatedcommunication.org/systematic-reviews
FMI about a wide range of topics regarding FC/S2C/RPM:
facilitatedcommunication.org
This educational video is intended to draw attention to the problem of facilitator cuing in Facilitated Communication (FC). FC is also known as Spelling to Communicate (S2C), Rapid Prompting Method (RPM), and many other names.
In this video, Dr. Sarathy and her son, Sid, use Spelling to Communicate, as featured in the movie "Spellers." Dr. Sarathy appears to understand that FC is has no scientifically rigorous proof to back up proponent claims of independence, but she uses it anyone. But, is does a belief in FC adequately prevent facilitator control and cuing during letter selection?
To date, there is no reliably controlled evidence to prove that FC/S2C/RPM or any of their variants produce independent communication. Rather, research shows that facilitators, not the individuals being subjected to it, control FC-generated messages.
Organizations such as the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA) and the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities oppose its use, citing lack of scientific evidence, facilitator control, prompt dependency, financial and opportunity costs, and other harms.
Clever Hands: Uncontrolled Intelligence in Facilitated Communication: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12872881
Wheeler, DL, Jacobson, JW, Paglieri, RA, and Schwartz, AA. (1993). An experimental assessment of facilitated communication. Mental Retardation. Vol 31 (1), 49-60.
FMI: Controlled Studies: facilitatedcommunication.org/controlled-studies
FMI about systematic reviews, opposition statements, controlled studies, FC in the legal system and more: http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
Rapid Prompting Method (RPM) is a form of Facilitated Communication (FC) in which individuals with complex communication needs are "supported" by a facilitator to "spell" using a plastic letter board or stencil. But, who is controlling the messages?
To date, there is no reliably controlled testing to prove proponent claims of independent communication. In fact, these tests show that facilitators, not their clients, are controlling the FC-generated messages. Organizations such as the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA) and American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities (AAIDD) have statements opposing its use, citing concerns about facilitator cuing, prompt dependency, lack of scientific evidence, lost opportunity and financial costs, and potential harms (including false allegations of abuse).
Katharine Beal's book (mentioned in the video) is: Students with Autism: How to Improve Language, Literacy and Academic Success
Get in touch with Susan Gerbic at Psychics Explained: youtube.com/@UCOcc0SV5i6ZGOok86JIce2A
And Adrienne Hill at Zone Giggler: zonegiggler.ca
More information about the topics covered in this video can be found at http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
The movie, written and directed by Michael Bergmann, attempts to legitimize FC use despite the fact that FC has been discredited and reliably controlled tests show that the facilitators, and not their clients, are authoring the messages.
Organizations such as the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA) and the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities (AAIDD) oppose the use of FC/S2C/RPM, citing lack of scientific evidence, facilitator control, prompt dependency, and other potential harms (including false allegations of abuse).
Part of the reason the letter board moves in the air is because of the ideomotor response, or small often non-conscious muscle movements. Most facilitators are unaware of the extent to which this aids in letter selection. They move the board up and down, backwards and forwards to position it near what they believe is the target letter. It's a well-documented phenomenon sometimes called the "Ouija board effect," because of its association with using a planchette on an Ouija board, dowsing, and automatic writing. More information about FC and the ideomotor response can be found at this link: facilitatedcommunication.org/ideomotor-response
Information about controlled studies, systematic reviews, critiques of FC, organizations opposing FC/S2C/RPM, and more, please visit our website at http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
In this video, Ben Breaux and his facilitator, Sara, participated in an Autism Society of America interview using FC. The translucent letter board allows viewers to see where Ben touches the letter board with his outstretched finger. The question is: Do the letters/words called out by the facilitator match where Ben touched on the board?
To date, there is no scientific evidence that proves proponent claims of independent communication. On the contrary, reliably controlled tests show that facilitators, and not their clients, are controlling the messages obtained using these techniques.
Many organizations, including the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA) and the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities (AAIDD) oppose FC/S2C/RPM, citing concerns about facilitator control, lack of scientific evidence, prompt dependency. lost opportunity and financial costs, and potential harms (including false allegations of abuse).
FMI, please visit our website at http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
In this video, Soma Mukhopadhyay works with a student, Samantha, for the first time. She starts by trapping Samantha in a corner. What lesson is Samantha supposed to learn from this lesson?
To date, there is no reliably controlled evidence proving that FC/S2C/RPM or any of their variants produce independent communications. On the contrary, facilitators, not their clients, are the most likely sources of the messages obtained using these techniques.
Organizations such as the American Speech Language Hearing Association and the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities, among others, oppose their use, citing lack of scientific evidence, prompt dependency, facilitator cuing, and potential harms (such as false allegations of abuse) as just some of the reasons for their position.
FMI about controlled studies, systematic reviews, organizations opposing FC/S2C/RPM and more, please check out our website at http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
In this Autism Society of America interview, a facilitator, Sara, uses Rapid Prompting Method (RPM) with her client, Ben Breaux. As they answer a question about Ben's experiences with Facebook, Sara holds a plastic letter board in the air. Ben points to it with an outstretched finger, but do the letters and words Sara calls out accurately reflect his selections?
To date, there is no reliably controlled evidence proving that FC/S2C/RPM or any of their variants produce independent communications. On the contrary, facilitators, not their clients, are the most likely sources of the messages obtained using these techniques.
Organizations such as the American Speech Language Hearing Association and the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities, among others, oppose their use, citing lack of scientific evidence, prompt dependency, facilitator cuing, and potential harms (such as false allegations of abuse) as just some of the reasons for their position.
For more information about the ideomotor response and FC, please check out this link: facilitatedcommunication.org/ideomotor-response
FMI about controlled studies, systematic reviews, organizations opposing FC/S2C/RPM and more, please check out our website at http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
In this Autism Society of America interview, a facilitator, Sara, uses Rapid Prompting Method (RPM) with her client, Ben Breaux. As they answer a question about Ben's experiences with Facebook, Sara holds a plastic letter board in the air. Ben points to it with an outstretched finger, but do the letters and words Sara calls out accurately reflect his selections?
To date, there is no reliably controlled evidence proving that FC/S2C/RPM or any of their variants produce independent communications. On the contrary, facilitators, not their clients, are the most likely sources of the messages obtained using these techniques.
Organizations such as the American Speech Language Hearing Association and the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities, among others, oppose their use, citing lack of scientific evidence, prompt dependency, facilitator cuing, and potential harms (such as false allegations of abuse) as just some of the reasons for their position.
For more information about the ideomotor response and FC, please check out this link: facilitatedcommunication.org/ideomotor-response
FMI about controlled studies, systematic reviews, organizations opposing FC/S2C/RPM and more, please check out our website at http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
In this video, a King5 reporter covers a news story about a family who believes their special needs student is being discriminated against by a school system who will not allow S2C. The reporter included a brief statement by the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA), but did he go far enough in explaining why ASHA opposes its use?
Edmonds parents say school district is denying special needs son his right to an education:
king5.com/article/news/education/edmonds-parents-school-district-denying-son-education/281-c057934c-3403-4943-9a1a-4f399a83c524?fbclid=IwAR2N5ucKIhjYCy8e7jrNhejwkRuz6XovlGXZQYCbPa0edTvt8ahaKhA5Zy0
To date, there is no reliably controlled evidence to prove proponent claims that FC/S2C/RPM is an independent form of communication. In fact, testing shows that it's the facilitators and not their clients who control letter selection during the typing activity.
Links to information in the video:
Controlled Studies: facilitatedcommunication.org/controlled-studies
Opposition Statements: facilitatedcommunication.org/organizations-opposing-fc
Systematic Reviews: facilitatedcommunication.org/systematic-reviews
Facilitated Communication is a Cult that Won't Die slate.com/technology/2015/11/facilitated-communication-pseudoscience-harms-people-with-disabilities.html
Double Talk: Syracuse University Institute continues to use discredited technique with dangerous effects: dailyorange.com/2016/04/double-talk-syracuse-university-institute-continues-to-use-discredited-technique-with-dangerous-effects
What Schools Can Learn About S2C from the Lower Merion School District: facilitatedcommunication.org/blog/what-schools-can-learn-about-s2c-from-the-lower-merion-school-district
Science Prevails in Another Victory for a Pennsylvania School District: facilitatedcommunication.org/blog/another-victory-for-science
Review of "Spellers": facilitatedcommunication.org/blog/a-review-of-the-movie-spellers-a-documercial-for-spelling-to-communicate
Review of "Underestimated": facilitatedcommunication.org/blog/review-of-jb-handleys-underestimated-an-autism-miracle
FMI, please check out our website at http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
In this video, we look at a clip from the documercial "Spellers" where Dawnmarie Gaivin holds a plastic stencil letter board in the air for her client, Aydan, to spell out "Great life is ahead." But, who is controlling the communication tools?
For a review of the movie "Spellers," please check out this link: facilitatedcommunication.org/blog/a-review-of-the-movie-spellers-a-documercial-for-spelling-to-communicate
For more information about the ideomotor response and FC, please check out the resources at this link: facilitatedcommunication.org/ideomotor-response
To date, there is no reliably controlled evidence that proves messages obtained using FC, S2C, RPM or any of their variants produces independent communication. Rather, research shows that facilitators and not their clients are controlling the messages.
Organizations such as the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association and the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities, among others, oppose its use, citing lack of scientific evidence, facilitator cuing, prompt dependency, and potential harms (e.g. false allegations of abuse).
FMI about controlled studies, systematic reviews, opposition statements, and more, please check out our website at http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
In this video, we analyze a spelling session from a video called "Rachel Tells it All: Autism 101 Explained by an Autistic Advocate." During this session, a facilitator holds a plastic letter board in the air while Rachel points to it. But, are the letter selections free from facilitator influence and control?
To date, there is no scientifically reliable evidence that proves FC, S2C, RPM or any of their variants are free from facilitator control. In fact, controlled studies show that facilitators, and not those being subjected to FC, are controlling the messages.
Many organization, including the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association and the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities, have positions against its use, citing facilitator cuing, lack of scientific evidence, prompt dependency, and other harms (such as false allegations of abuse).
FMI about controlled studies, systematic reviews, organizations opposing FC and more, please check out our website at http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org.
In this video, we explore the Facilitated Communication Institute of Syracuse University's claims of typing that is "free from physical touch," as depicted in their documentary "Inside the Edge: A Journey to Using Speech Through Typing." At the time of the documentary, student Jamie Burke had been subjected to FC for 10 years.
Also referenced in the critique is this article:
Broderick, A., and Kasa-Hendrickson, C. (2001). "Say Just One Word at First": The Emergence of Reliable Speech in a Student Labeled with Autism. JASH. Vol 26 (1), 13-24.
To date, there is no reliably controlled evidence to prove proponent claims of independent communication. In fact, the research shows that facilitators, not their clients, are controlling the typing by providing physical, visual, and auditory cues.
Many organizations, including the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA) and the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities (AAIDD) oppose its use due to prompt dependency, facilitator influence, lack of scientific evidence, and potential harms (e.g., false allegations of abuse).
FMI: http://wwwfacilitatedcommunication.org
In this video, CBS LA reported on a non-verbal student attending classes at UCLA using a form of Facilitated Communication (FC) called Rapid Prompting Method (RPM). A close analysis of an FC session included with the news report, however, raises questions about authorship.
To date, there is no reliably controlled evidence to show that FC-generated messages are independent. Rather, the research shows that facilitators, and not those being subjected to FC, are controlling the written output. Most facilitators are well-meaning and unaware of the extent to which they are doing so.
Groups like the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association and the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities have statements opposing its use.
FMI: http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
This video critiques a clip from a 1991 Syracuse University Training video promoting FC. In it, a student, Daniel, is being facilitated by one of the Facilitated Communication Institute's trained facilitators. Questions arise as to facilitator control as Daniel turns his body away from the typing activity while the facilitator continues to hold his hand and type.
To date, there is no reliably controlled evidence to prove proponent claims that facilitator-generated messages are the independent thoughts of those being subjected to its use.
Many organizations, such as the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA) and the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities (AAIDD) oppose its use.
FMI: http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
In this video, Sara Chan and her son, Tim, demonstrate an FC session. An FC-generated message claims that Sara is not cuing her son by holding onto his shoulder during typing session. A closer look raises questions about (inadvertent) cuing.
To date, there is no reliably controlled evidence to prove proponent claims that FC or any of its variants are independent forms of communication. Instead, the evidence shows that it is the facilitators, and not their clients, controlling the typed messages. Organizations such as the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA) and the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities (AAIDD), among others, oppose the use of FC/S2C/RPM because of concerns of prompt dependency, facilitator cuing, lack of scientific evidence, and potential from harm (including false allegations of abuse).
For information about Systematic Reviews, Controlled Studies, Opposition Statements, and more, please visit our website: http://www.faciltiatedcommunication.org
In this video, a facilitator demonstrates how her student selects letters from alphabet letter stencils by poking at the holes with a pencil. Question arise regarding independence when the facilitator using physical and verbal cues to help aid in letter selection and when the student appears not to be able to spell out the target word.
To date, there is no scientific evidence to prove proponent claims of independent communication using these techniques. Reliably controlled studies show the facilitators, and not their clients, are producing the typed, facilitated messages.
Many organizations such as the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA) and the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities (AAIDD) have statements opposing its use.
FMI on systematic reviews, controlled studies, organizations opposing FC, and more: http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
In this video, Tracy Kedor and her son Ido, use FC to communicate both on a stationary keyboard and with a letter board held in the air. The question addressed is "Can facilitators influence their clients' interaction with a letter board or keyboard without physical touch?
To date, there is no reliably controlled evidence to prove FC/S2C/RPM are independent forms of communication. Rather, the evidence weights heavily in the direction of facilitator cuing, which can be inadvertent, subtle, and sometimes difficult to detect without appropriate, blinded testing, put in place. Most facilitators, though well-meaning, are not aware of the extent to which they cue their clients.
FMI: http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
Proponents claim in this clip that facilitated communication was needed to assist in writing this man's books. However, a close analysis of the person being facilitated raises questions about which letters were selected and whose words are being recorded.
To date, there is no reliably controlled evidence to prove that claims of independent communication are true. Rather, the facilitators, not those being subjected to FC, are authoring the messages.
FMI: http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
To date, there is no reliably controlled evidence to prove that the use of FC produces independent communications. Rather, tests show that the facilitators, not their clients are typing out the words.
FMI: http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org
This critique features a video clip from a movie called "The Reason I Jump" where a mother and daughter sit on a park bench facilitating. While the mother calls out letters, her daughter says "No more! No More!." Why, we ask, are the daughter's verbal requests being ignored?
To date, there are no reliably controlled studies to prove proponent claims of independent communication. Like with FC, which has been thoroughly discredited, concerns about facilitator control over letter selection arise when a letter board is held in the air and the facilitator uses hand signals (and other physical, visual and auditory cues) to aid in letter selection.
Organizations like the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA) and the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities (AAIDD) opposes the use of FC/S2C/RPM citing concerns over facilitator control, prompt dependency, lack of scientific evidence, financial and opportunity costs, and potential harms, including false allegations of abuse.
Controlled studies, systematic reviews, opposition statements, and other information regarding FC/S2C/RPM are available on the website facilitatedcommunication.org.
This video features a Vermont artist, Larry Bissonnette, and his facilitator, Pascal Cheng. The two were featured in the pro-FC films "My Classic Life as an Artist: Portrait of Larry Bissonette" and "Wretches and Jabberers." Despite being able to complete many fine and gross motor tasks independently, Larry's facilitators claim he needs their physical support to select letters on a keyboard. This raises the question: Are Larry's facilitated words his own?
To date, there is no reliably controlled evidence proving proponent claims that FC-generated messages are independently produced. Tests show that facilitators, and not their clients, are producing the messages.
Organizations such as the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA) and the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities (AAIDD) oppose FC/S2C/RPM, citing concerns about facilitator control, prompt dependency, lack of scientific evidence, lost financial and opportunity costs, and potential harms (including false allegations of abuse).
For controlled studies, systematic reviews, opposition statements regarding FC and more, please check out our website at: www.facilitatedcommunication.org
To date, there is no reliably controlled studies that prove proponent claims of independent communication.
FMI: http://www.facilitatedcommunication.org


