How @EmersonGreen Became an Atheist Fuad Harahap 2024-04-04 | Emerson Green (@EmersonGreen ) is a youtuber and podcaster that tackles issues such as being an agnostic, free will, countering apologetics, and moral philosophy. In this podcast, we discuss about His motivations and thought processesTime Stamps :00:00 - Intro01:07 - Is Emerson Green a philosopher?03:59 - Free will08:10 - Genetical influence on people's decisions12:22 - Leaving religion20:16 - Between atheism and agnosticism26:09 - Arguments from morality31:01 - Life after death37:17 - Countering apologetics43:17 - Apologetics46:42 - Skeptics community51:40 - Criticizing skeptics01:03:25 - The future moralMy other channels!Sejarah 🎙️ : youtube.com/channel/UCg-bL9t2JII8CW4cdL8y6JABass Covers 🎸 : youtube.com/channel/UCSTUlHv7QNbF66smHpIDctgMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fuushin12
The Weird Musical Metaphysics of Djent Fuad Harahap 2026-09-07 | I always argue that music hides deep and profound metaphysical aspect, and the way we understand it, reveals a deep mystery of our own capacity as intelligent beingTime Stamps:00:00 - Intro00:34 - Pattern recognition04:35 - Logic08:27 - Metric modulation11:41 - Philosophical evaluation14:41 - OutroReferences:1. youtube.com/shorts/H-JB8JM9R0g2. youtube.com/shorts/O-Il5zfEwoM3. MazbouQ’s channel : youtube.com/@MazbouQ4. Adam Neely’s channel : youtube.com/@AdamNeely5. youtube.com/watch?v=IO-JbFtgeX46. youtube.com/watch?v=-k9qDxyxS3s7. youtube.com/watch?v=sLPesxVAysg8. youtube.com/watch?v=9Y_g1qPETh89. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11043425
Theism Tier List with Dr Ryan Mullins (Bonus Podcast) Fuad Harahap 2026-08-06 | R.T. Mullins (PhD, University of St Andrews, Dr. Habil. University of Helsinki) is a lecturer in philosophy and theology at the University of Lucerne, and a research fellow at the Polin Institute. He has published over 60 essays on various topics in philosophical theology and published multiple books. In short, He’s a real philosophical badass. But in this conversation we would utilize His skill in an underwhelming fashion where I urge Him to rank theism models in a tier listTime Stamps:00:00 - Intro01:13 - Classical Theism10:22 - Deism20:50 - Panentheism
What If Arceus is Actually God? Fuad Harahap 2026-07-16 | Arceus is often called the God of the Pokémon world. But what if we took that claim seriously? In this video, I explore a strange philosophical question: what actually qualifies something as a god? Drawing from Pokémon lore, classical theology, metaphysics, and philosophy of religion, we'll examine whether the line between "fictional deity" and "real deity" is as obvious as it first appears. This is not a defense of any particular religion, nor is it an attack on one. Instead, it's a thought experiment about divinity, existence, and the assumptions hidden inside our concept of God.Time Stamps:00:00 - Intro00:45 - Lore04:32 - Ontology and Philosophy08:30 - OutroReferences:1. Anselm of Canterbury. (1078). ''Proslogion''. Translated by Sidney Norton Deane. Open Court Publishing, 1962.2. Plantinga, Alvin. (1974). ''The Nature of Necessity''. Oxford: Clarendon Press.3. Meinong, Alexius. (1904). ''Über Gegenstandstheorie'' [On Object Theory]. In ''Untersuchungen zur Gegenstandstheorie und Psychologie''. Leipzig: Barth.4. Marek, Johann. "Alexius Meinong." In ''The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy'', edited by Edward N. Zalta and Uri Nodelman.5. Wittgenstein, Ludwig. (1953). ''Philosophical Investigations''. Oxford: Blackwell.6. Eliade, Mircea. (1958). ''Patterns in Comparative Religion''. New York: Sheed & Ward.7. Kripke, Saul. (1980). ''Naming and Necessity''. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.8. Zalta, Edward N. (1983). ''Abstract Objects: An Introduction to Axiomatic Metaphysics''. Dordrecht: D. Reidel Publishing Company.9. == Primary Pokémon Sources ==10. Pokémon Diamond. Nintendo DS. Nintendo / Game Freak, 2006.11. Pokémon Pearl. Nintendo DS. Nintendo / Game Freak, 2006.12. Pokémon Platinum. Nintendo DS. Nintendo / Game Freak, 2008.13. Pokémon Legends: Arceus. Nintendo Switch. Nintendo / Game Freak, 2022.14. Pokémon: Arceus and the Jewel of Life. Directed by Kunihiko Yuyama. OLM, Inc., 2009.15. == Further Reading ==16. Plantinga, Alvin. (1974). ''God, Freedom, and Evil''. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans.17. Parsons, Terence. (1980). ''Nonexistent Objects''. New Haven: Yale University Press.18. Derrida, Jacques. (1967). ''Of Grammatology''. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.19. Otto, Rudolf. (1917). ''The Idea of the Holy''. Oxford University Press.20. Campbell, Joseph. (1949). ''The Hero with a Thousand Faces''. Princeton University Press.Pic Credit:1. @Ruyinnu Instagram
Indonesia’s History is One Giant Teleological Fallacy Fuad Harahap 2026-07-04 | For generations, Indonesians have been taught to see the past as though it had always been leading toward one inevitable destination: Indonesia... but is it tho?Time Stamps:00:00 - Intro00:47 - The Teleological fallacy07:14 - How we failed to see ourselves09:03 - Conclusion#Indonesia #History #Historiography #Nationalism #Philosophy #Teleology #Nusantara #Majapahit #Sriwijaya #VideoEssayReferences:1. Imagined Communities — Benedict Anderson. Revised Edition. Verso, 2006.2. The Invention of Tradition — Eric Hobsbawm and Terence Ranger (eds.). Cambridge University Press, 1983.3. Nations and Nationalism — Ernest Gellner. Cornell University Press, 1983.4. Nationalism — Anthony D. Smith. Polity Press, 2001.5. What Is History? — E. H. Carr. Penguin Books.6. Metahistory — Hayden White. Johns Hopkins University Press, 1973.7. The Idea of History — R. G. Collingwood. Oxford University Press.8. The Shape of Time — George Kubler. Yale University Press, 1962.9. A History of Modern Indonesia Since c.1200 — M. C. Ricklefs.10. Indonesia: Towards Democracy — Taufik Abdullah.11. The Indonesian National Revolution, 1945–1950 — Anthony Reid.12. Southeast Asia in the Age of Commerce, 1450–1680 — Anthony Reid.13. The Contest for North Sumatra: Atjeh, the Netherlands and Britain, 1858–1898 — Anthony Reid.14. Nusa Jawa: Silang Budaya — Denys Lombard.15. The Poverty of Historicism — Karl Popper.16. Truth and Method — Hans-Georg Gadamer.17. Time and Narrative — Paul Ricoeur.
Why We Misunderstand Ancient Science. A Conversation with Dr. Richard Carrier Fuad Harahap 2026-06-28 | Dr. Richard Carrier is a historian of antiquity and the author of Science in the Early Roman Empire. His research focuses on the intellectual history of the Greco-Roman world, including ancient science, philosophy, and early Christianity. In this conversation, we explore how science actually worked in the Roman Empire, why philosophy and science eventually diverged, and how political and religious institutions influenced the pursuit of knowledge.Links to Dr. Carrier:Blog: richardcarrier.infoFb: facebook.com/richard.carrier.phdTime Stamps:00:00 - Intro01:35 - Why Dr Carrier wrote Science in the Early Roman Empire13:21 - Relationships between scientists and their surroundings in Roman Empire28:20 - Why did early Christians so hostile against science, unlike their Pagan counterparts35:08 - Its not about the teaching, its about maintaining power39:33 - Plato, Sokrates, and Aristoteles45:07 - Why Timaeus a terrible book49:04 - Is Aristotelian tradition empirical53:01 - Setting the records straight about empiricsm01:0042 - The separation between philosophy and science
This Meme Is Doing Illegal Philosophy Fuad Harahap 2026-06-21 | A YouTube comment claimed: "AI slop implies AI gem". Instead of ignoring it like a normal person, I spent several days thinking about modal ontology. This video is the result.Special thanks to the anonymous commenter who accidentally transformed internet slop into a discussion of metaphysics.#philosophy #ai #metaphysics #modalontology #davidlewis #camus #artificialintelligence #videoessay #brainrot #memes Time Stamps:00:00 - Intro00:45 - Essay03:20 - ConclusionReferences:1. Lewis, David K. (1986). On the Plurality of Worlds. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.2. Kripke, Saul A. (1980). Naming and Necessity. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.3. Russell, Bertrand (1905). "On Denoting." Mind, Vol. 14, No. 56, pp. 479–493.4. Hume, David (1748). An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding.5. Original video (and thumbnail idea): youtube.com/watch?v=Cag0vz0ban0&list=RDCag0vz0ban0&start_radio=1
The Philosophical (and Theological) Contradiction Behind the Foundation of Indonesia Fuad Harahap 2026-05-24 | Indonesia is like a country being founded on a philosophical debate nobody even care to finish. At one hand, we have a theological ideology of - “the belief in the one and only God” - that infringes on others rights of religious expression // on the other, we have a very problematic unifying slogan “Unity in Diversity” - that is historically proven to be fictitious#decolonial #decolonisation #decolonizationTime Stamps:00:00 - Intro01:19 - Monotheist dictatorship08:29 - Why should monotheist be the status quo?15:22 - Bhinneka Tunggal Ika20:08 - Unity based on colonial hatred23:32 - OutroReferences:1. The Jakarta Charter of June 1945 by Endang Saifuddin Anshari (classic study on the Jakarta Charter debate)2. Nationalism and Revolution in Indonesia by George McTurnan Kahin3. The Ideology of Indonesia: History of the Pancasila by Bernard Dahm4. Speech of Sukarno, 1 June 1945 (birth of Pancasila)5. Memoirs of Mohammad Hatta discussing the removal of the Jakarta Charter clause6. Islam and the Secular State in Indonesia by Luthfi Assyaukanie7. Civil Islam by Robert W. Hefner8. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Preparatory_Committee_for_Indonesian_Independence9. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jakarta_Charter10. Elson, R. E. (2009). "Another Look at the Jakarta Charter Controversy of 1945" (PDF). Indonesia. 88 (88): 105–130. Retrieved 21 December 2018.11. Mpu Tantular (1975). Santoso, Soewito (ed.). Sutasoma, a Study in Old Javanese Wajrayana. International Academy of Culture. p. 9.12. Zulfikar, Fahri. "Bhinneka Tunggal Ika bagi Bangsa Indonesia, Ini Artinya". detikedu (in Indonesian). Retrieved 30 September 2021.13. Waskito (1 February 2020). Nuraini, Ratna (ed.). "Sebuah Filsafat Perenialisme Tertua". indonesia.go.id (in Indonesian). Retrieved 10 November 2021.14. Kinney, Ann R.; Klokke, Marijke J.; Kieven, Lydia (2003). Worshiping Siva and Buddha: The Temple Art of East Java. University of Hawaii Press. ISBN 9780824827793.15. historia.id/article/melacak-jejak-kerajaan-panai-di-tanah-batak16. Munoz, Paul Michel (2006). Early Kingdoms, Indonesian Archipelago & the Malay Peninsula.17. youtu.be/J_tl8cTqvIA?si=RFG42stvuZh9b6Nh18. id.wikipedia.org/wiki/Willem_Iskander19. id.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad_Kaharuddin_III20. Thornton, David Leonard (1972). Javanization of Indonesian politics. The University of British Columbia.21. instagram.com/p/DPWAYwigDHD/?igsh=MXhja2RmMXZ1MWZmeg==22. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sang_Hyang_Widhi_Wasa23. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catholic_Church_in_Timor-Leste24. International Humanist and Ethical Union (10 December 2012). "Freedom of Thought 2012: A Global Report on Discrimination Against Humanists, and the Nonreligious" (PDF). IHEU. Retrieved 8 August 2023.25. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Majapahit26. Hadler, Jeffrey (2008). "A Historiography of Violence and the Secular State in Indonesia: Tuanku Imam Bondjol and the Uses of History"27. Dobbin, Christine (1983). Islamic Revivalism in a Changing Peasant Economy: Central Sumatra, 1784-1847.28. id.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaum_Padri#cite_note-FOOTNOTEEnsiklopedia_Islam200266-629. https://agrarianstudies.macmillan.yale.edu/sites/default/files/files/Zakaria%20-%20Landscapes%20and%20Conversions%20during%20the%20Padri%20Wars.pdf30. historia.id/article/ketika-hantu-kolera-mengamuk-di-tanah-batak-pg8my31. en.wikipedia.org/wiki32. media.neliti.com/media/publications/445533-none-bbc882fa.pdf33. Majapahit: Reflection of the Religious Life, Deny Yudo Wahyudi(B ) and Agus Aris Munandar, Department of Archaeology, Faculty of Humanities, Universitas Indonesia, Depok, Indonesia34. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hinduism_in_Indonesia35. https://humanists.international/wp-content/uploads/IHEU%20Freedom%20of%20Thought%202012.pdf36. "Nationality, Citizenship, and Religion". Government of Timor-Leste. 25 October 2015. Archived from the original on 14 July 2019. Retrieved 29 January 2020.37. media.neliti.com/media/publications/445533-none-bbc882fa.pdf
Understanding Classical Arguments for God Strengthens My Doubts Fuad Harahap 2026-05-06 | I thought the deeper I study arguments for God, the more cases I could made for beliefs. Turns out I was wrongTime Stamps:00:00 - Intro01:46 - Cosmological argument04:57 - Teleological argument07:33 - All roads lead to Aquinas11:39 - Philosophical analysis16:09 - Logos20:01 - Asomatos22:06 - Creatio ex nihilo25:17 - 2nd philosophical analysis28:28 - Modern apologetics31:49 - OutroReferences:- Aristotle. Physics and Metaphysics.- Aristotle, De Caelo, I.9, 279 a17–30- Plato. Timaeus.- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_constant- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. “Teleological Arguments for God’s Existence.”- https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/teleological-arguments/- philopedia.org/arguments/teleological-argument- Al-Ghazali. The Incoherence of the Philosophers.- Darwin, Charles. On the Origin of Species. London: John Murray, 1859.- Thomas K. Johansen. 2014. "Why the Cosmos Needs a Craftsman: Plato, Timaeus 27d5-29b1,"- Paley, William. Natural Theology. London, 1802.- Avicenna. The Book of Healing.- https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/cosmological-argument/- https://iep.utm.edu/cosmological-argument/- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_argument- Aquinas, Thomas. Summa Theologiae.- Aristotle. Nicomachean Ethics.- Augustine. Confessions; City of God.- Plato. Euthyphro; Republic.- https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/moral-arguments-god/- https://iep.utm.edu/moral-arguments-for-gods-existence/- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_morality- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_argument- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logos_(Christianity)- John 1:1 NIV- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logos_(Christianity)- youtube.com/watch?v=_4C_yLvioUA- Cambridge Dictionary of Philosophy (2nd ed): Heraclitus, (1999)- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rationes_seminales- Adam Kamesar (2004). "The Logos Endiathetos and the Logos Prophorikos in Allegorical Interpretation: Philo and the D-Scholia to the Iliad" (PDF). Greek, Roman, and Byzantine Studies. 44: 163–181. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2015-05-07.- Martyr, Justin. 1 Apology- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Apology_of_Justin_Martyr#cite_note-9- McClellan, Dan. The Bible Says So- Stavrakopoulo, Francesca. God: The Anatomy- Origen. On First Principles- QS Ali Imran 190-191, QS Yunus 101, QS Al-Ghasyiyah 17-20, QS Fussilat 53, QS Al-Baqarah 164- youtube.com/watch?v=qzEOnAw1qqE&t=529s- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Batak_mythology- youtube.com/watch?v=fM2UrEk4qvk- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Documentary_hypothesis- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biblical_inerrancyMy other channels!Bass Covers 🎸: youtube.com/@TheHistoryMaxxerSupport Me! 💰Karyakarsa: karyakarsa.com/fubilosophyPatreon: patreon.com/fubilosophyMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fubilosophy
Agnosticism In Depth Fuad Harahap 2026-01-15 | What is agnosticism, and why do we need to understand it differentlyTime Stamps:00:00 - Intro00:45 - What is agnosticism05:38 - Misunderstanding agnosticism11:39 - The God of Thunder Dilemma16:06 - The Permission to Fuck Your Woman Slave Dilemma20:32 - What does it take for me to belief23:41 - OutroReferences:1. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occam%27s_razor#:~:text=In%20philosophy%2C%20Occam's%20razor%20(also,rigorous%20arbiter%20between%20candidate%20models.2. youtube.com/watch?v=qeFjLcQNqV03. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poetic_Edda4. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_views_on_concubinage5. https://www.brandeis.edu/projects/fse/muslim/slavery.html6. unesco.org/en/memory-world/abolition-slavery-tunisia-1841-1846#:~:text=Tunisia%20was%20the%20first%20country,the%20permanent%20abolition%20of%20slavery.7. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/312597938. I use help form google AI to differentiate believe and belief9. 5 Historical Religious Facts that Shattered My Faithyoutu.be/LvvRtvscTCMOriginal Script! 📝My other channels!Bass Covers 🎸: youtube.com/@TheHistoryMaxxerSupport Me! 💰Karyakarsa: karyakarsa.com/fubilosophyPatreon: patreon.com/fubilosophyMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fubilosophy
Beyond Stoicism with Massimo Pigliucci Fuad Harahap 2025-12-18 | Massimo Pigliucci is a philosopher and biologist known for His works combining Stoicism and science, and bringing it to modern life. He’s also recognized for His works in philosophy of science. In this podcast, we’re discussing what is stoicism from the point of view of real philosopher who studies and embodies the idea. I’m also assisted by my friend, Steve Laurent Montong, who is a philosophy undergraduate at Gajah Mada University, in which He interviewed Professor Pigliucci’s work regarding pseudoscienceTime Stamps:00:00 - Intro01:26 - What is Stoicism09:49 - Stoicism beyond just “way of life”20:18 - The difference between ancient and modern Stoicism30:33 - Why Stoicism is so compelling42:49 - What is Broicism52:40 - (Steve) On the demarcation problem01:08:14 - (Steve) The criteria on demarcation problem01:18:12 - (Steve) The difference between science and pseudoscience01:29:50 - (Steve) Scientism on moral values01:37:00 - Why every politician should read SenecaMy other channels!Bass Covers 🎸: youtube.com/@TheHistoryMaxxerSupport Me! 💰Karyakarsa: karyakarsa.com/fubilosophyPatreon: patreon.com/fubilosophyMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fubilosophy
Discussing the New Logics with Graham Priest Fuad Harahap 2025-11-20 | Graham Priest is an Australian-British philosopher and logician known for his work on non-classical logics, metaphysics, and Buddhist philosophy. He is best known for his development of dialetheism, something that I will be going to talk a lot (with the help of Aqil from Intuisionistik ID) hereThis podcast is a collaboration with Intuisionistik ID. An Indonesian philosophy collective that focuses on logicVisit Intuisionistik ID at:instagram.com/intuisionistik?igsh=cHM1OG02b213dTdjTime Stamps:00:00 - Intro06:00 - What is Logic15:57 - What is Paraconsistent Logic26:13 - (Aqil) On substructural logic33:28 - (Aqil) On proof theory and simplicity argument46:20 - (Aqil) Logicians from Australia, UK, and the US58:00 - (Aqil) Different Philosophy traditions in the west01:09:59 - (Aqil) Is Intuitionist Logic based on intuition?01:21:03 - What made Graham Priest interested in Eastern Philosophy01:25:33 - What did the west miss out from not learning Eastern Philosophy01:30:42 - (Ahnaf) Rebuilding logic in IndonesiaMy other channels!Bass Covers 🎸: youtube.com/@TheHistoryMaxxerSupport Me! 💰Karyakarsa: karyakarsa.com/fubilosophyPatreon: patreon.com/fubilosophyMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fuushin12
I Dont Take Religion Seriously - John W Loftus Fuad Harahap 2025-10-29 | John W Loftus is a philosopher and author. His works mainly about atheism and debunking religion, and He has a doctorate in philosophy and theologt to back it up. But here, we’re not talking about God and or God arguments. Instead we talk about His book, “Unapologetic”, and why He shows little respect towards religion there!#atheism #philosophy Time Stamps:00:00 - Intro11:40 - Why John wrote Unapologetic20:31 - Why the harshness of language30:31 - Emperor's Invisible Clothes32:14 - Why John doesn't take religion seriously33:26 - Philosopher's and Personal God36:05 - Is it necessary to be knowledgeable in religion before rejecting it?39:46 - What is wrong with Philosophy of Religion44:13 - Why John respects Graham Oppy50:16 - Philosophers that John respect58:26 - The future of Philosophy of ReligionMy other channels!Bass Covers 🎸: youtube.com/@TheHistoryMaxxerSupport Me! 💰Karyakarsa: karyakarsa.com/fubilosophyPatreon: patreon.com/fubilosophyMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fuushin12
Deconstructing Indonesia with Derrick Gozal Fuad Harahap 2025-08-08 | Derrick Gozal is an Indonesian historian from Columbia University, and one of the founder of @deconstructindo, which is an intellectual movement aimed at informing knowledge about social histories, and the birth of a nation that both of us love, IndonesiaTime Stamps:00:00 - Intro01:52 - Why Deconstructing Indonesia?04:19 - Derrick and Fuad getting nerd mode with history14:45 - Derrick’s favorite historical figure17:00 - What does “deconstruction” even mean?19:24 - Goal of Deconstructing Indonesia22:52 - Misrepresented Indonesia’s histories?27:02 - The lost of nuance29:30 - How much involvement the colonial had in shaping Indonesia’s history32:53 - How much accurate do we Indonesian think of our history36:27 - Derrick’s thoughts of current Indonesian government40:40 - How Deconstructing Indonesia could help46:04 - What’s the point of learning history48:57 - What Derrick love the most about IndonesiaMy other channels!Bass Covers 🎸: youtube.com/@TheHistoryMaxxerSupport Me! 💰Karyakarsa: karyakarsa.com/fubilosophyPatreon: patreon.com/fubilosophyMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fuushin12
Professor Dave Explains Many Things Fuad Harahap 2025-05-25 | Dave Farina, a.k.a. @ProfessorDaveExplains is probably YouTube’s bigger science communicator that’s famous because of His constant fight against misinformation and pseudoscience that run rampant in our society nowadays. In this podcast, I ask something that rarely talked about. His deeper insights about science communication, and His own interest in lifeTime Stamps :00:00 - Introduction01:33 - The most dangerous idea07:24 - Call to action speech?10:36 - Professor Dave's favorite topic15:06 - Most favorite scientist16:04 - New knowledge for the future19:17 - Future topics for Professor Dave's channel20:27 - Professor Dave's thought about philosophy21:42 - Professor Dave's thought about religion23:42 - Music content for the future?27:42 - Relationship between music and scienceMy other channels!History Education (in Bahasa) 🎙️ : youtube.com/channel/UCg-bL9t2JII8CW4cdL8y6JABass Covers 🎸 : youtube.com/channel/UCSTUlHv7QNbF66smHpIDctgSupport Me..! 💰Karyakarsa : karyakarsa.com/fubilosophyPatreon : patreon.com/fubilosophyMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fuushin12
5 Historical Religious Facts that Shattered My Faith Fuad Harahap 2025-04-25 | So, let's talk about historical facts, and how does it connected to faith, both as a metaphysical truth, and as a personal oneTime Stamps :00:00 - Teaser00:14 - Intro03:55 - Caveat04:53 - God's Wife09:32 - YHWH Retconned13:18 - Satan the Accuser17:36 - Jahannam21:56 - Borrowed Motifs26:24 - Philosophical Investigations30:36 - Occam's Razor34:08 - OutroReferences :Intro- Eiseman Jr, Fred B. (1990). Bali, sekala and niskala. Periplus Editions. pp. 38–39. ISBN 0-945971-03-6.- McDaniel, June (2013), A Modern Hindu Monotheism: Indonesian Hindus as 'People of the Book'. The Journal of Hindu Studies, Oxford University Press, doi:10.1093/jhs/hit030Epistemic Axiom :- Qur’an 10:15Asherah- Francesca Stavrakopoulou, God an Anatomy (2021)- youtube.com/watch?v=CnLSbIivz0M- youtube.com/watch?v=MdRL1E7SUo0- William Devers, "Did God Have a Wife?" Eerdmans, 2005YHWH Retconned- Francesca Stavrakopoulou, God an Anatomy (2021)- Deuteronomy 33.2-3Satan the Accuser- youtube.com/watch?v=5sYhbtk8jJc- Samuel 29:4Jahannam- youtube.com/watch?v=s25-6Fq7PM8- Richard P. Taylor (2000). Death and the Afterlife: A Cultural Encyclopedia.- Daniel 2:12- pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/apocalypse/primary/white.html#:~:text=The%20Greek%20word%20apokalypsis%20(from,eventually%20be%20punished%20by%20God.- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apocalypticism- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Jerusalem_(70_CE)Borrowed Myths- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flood_myth- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dionysus- youtube.com/watch?v=B9XDf1YrKqc&t=2125s- youtube.com/watch?v=gHJzbmmdZFg- youtube.com/watch?v=R2FYaTgVLggPhilosophical Investigations- Qur’an 2:75 & 2:79 (About old scriptures being corrupted)- Qur’an 9:30 (where it claims that Jews worshipped Ezra. But the fact that Jews never worshipped Ezra, shows that perhaps Jews deliberately changed the scriptures so it sounds as if it’s not the case)- Qur’an 3:3-4, 7:157, 61:6, 5:47, 5:68 (About the trustworthiness of the old scriptures)- Qur’an 6:115 5:101 (About not questioning Qur’an)My other channels!History Education (in Bahasa) 🎙️ : youtube.com/channel/UCg-bL9t2JII8CW4cdL8y6JABass Covers 🎸 : youtube.com/channel/UCSTUlHv7QNbF66smHpIDctgSupport Me..! 💰Karyakarsa : karyakarsa.com/fubilosophyPatreon : patreon.com/fubilosophyMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fuushin12
The Dangers of Apologetics, with James Fodor Fuad Harahap 2025-04-05 | @JamesFodor is a PhD student at University of Melbourne and a YouTuber that frequently engages in counter-apologetics, and especially what I call : Rationality communicator. He also wrote a book “Unreasonable Faith” where He criticize William Lane Craig arguments for (His) God’s existence Here we talk about the risk apologetics and apologists such as William Lane Craig could pose towards human rationality and critical thinking in generalTime Stamps :00:00 - Intro01:12 - Why did James Wrote Unreasonable Faith04:55 - James’ Thoughts on Apologetics09:13 - Economical Motivation in Apologetics Ministries11:45 - Counter Apologetics Ministry?13:43 - The Dangers of Apologetics19:20 - The Effect Donald Trump has on Anti-Science Movements27:45 - Combatting Anti-Science Institutions37:06 - Good and Bad Researches46:14 - Good and Bad God Arguments52:01 - Are the Skeptics Winning or Losing?55:38 - The Future of James Fodor57:58 - Closing QuestionMy other channels!History Education (in Bahasa) 🎙️ : youtube.com/channel/UCg-bL9t2JII8CW4cdL8y6JABass Covers 🎸 : youtube.com/channel/UCSTUlHv7QNbF66smHpIDctgSupport Me..! 💰Karyakarsa : karyakarsa.com/fubilosophyPatreon : patreon.com/fubilosophyMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fuushin12
The Coolest, Most Obnoxious Argument for God Fuad Harahap 2025-03-15 | Gödel Ontological Proof or GOP is the hardest and most complicated ontological argument (and all argument) for the existence of God. One does not simply come and decipher this argument, let alone criticizing it. Yet, here I am, doing exactly thatTime Stamps :00:00 - Teaser00:46 - Intro03:16 - Goals & Caveats04:42 - Explaining the Argument13:42 - “Ontological Collapse”22:07 - OutroDISCLAIMER!!In 11:27 I said that the argument is valid. I made a mistake. There is actually paradox within the argument. in Axiom 3 where it states that 5 star itself is positive property and then in Definition 1 where it says a hotel is 5 star if and only if it has all the positive property….. put together, these two arguments created a paradox, specifically Russell’s Paradox which states that “the set of all sets that do not contain themselves as members leads to a contradiction, regardless of whether the set itself is a member of that set.”Basically, in definition 1, the argument states that 5 star is the result of a hotel having all positive property. So, if a hotel lack even 1 positive property, then the hotel cannot be 5 star. But, in Axiom 3, the argument states that 5 star hotel is positive property… this leads to a paradox : how can a hotel be a 5 star hotel, if the requirement of a 5 star hotel, is to be a “5 star hotel” ??With this, I want to modify my statement in that minute from "the argument is valid" to, the argument is 80% valid. Thanks xoxoMy other channels!History Education (in Bahasa) 🎙️ : youtube.com/channel/UCg-bL9t2JII8CW4cdL8y6JABass Covers 🎸 : youtube.com/channel/UCSTUlHv7QNbF66smHpIDctgSupport Me..! 💰Karyakarsa : karyakarsa.com/fubilosophyPatreon : patreon.com/fubilosophyMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fuushin12
Misquoting Bart Ehrman, with Bart Ehrman Fuad Harahap 2025-01-15 | @bartdehrman I guess needs no introduction. As one of the most popular New Testament scholar in the internet, and the author of many best selling books such as Misquoting Jesus and How Jesus Became God, Dr Ehrman often invited as a speaker and debater in those fields. Frankly, aside from being a very exceptional historian, He’s also a great speaker and debater. But of course, today we’re not going to discuss any of it. Instead, I’m trying to probe His insights about His life as a scholar, in the traditional and online senseTime Stamps :00:00 - About Bart Ehrman and His Dark Christmas course02:03 - King Herod, the worst slandered historical figure ever existed?05:55 - Courses and lectures07:27 - How does Dr Ehrman fees being as superstar figure in New Testament studies19:10 - How Dr Ehrman deals with people of other religion28:02 - Dr Ehrman as a YouTuber34:41 - What makes a good scholar?38:07 - Controversial New Testament ideas42:04 - What does Dr Ehrman think about God and Christianity50:46 - Have Dr Ehrman ever mistaken about somethingMy other channels!History Education (in Bahasa) 🎙️ : youtube.com/channel/UCg-bL9t2JII8CW4cdL8y6JABass Covers 🎸 : youtube.com/channel/UCSTUlHv7QNbF66smHpIDctgSupport Me..! 💰Karyakarsa : karyakarsa.com/fubilosophyPatreon : patreon.com/fubilosophyMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fuushin12
Finding Commonality Between Ancient Assyria and Modern Life with Megan Lewis of @DigitalHammurabi Fuad Harahap 2024-12-05 | Megan Lewis is more known as a wife of Dr Joshua Bowen that's popular within the YouTube ancient history community as the counter-apologetics focusing on the issue of biblical slavery. But to me, Megan is a very good historian in the topics of ancient Assyria, and a very good podcast host too! In this podcast we discuss a lot of things ranging from ancient Assyria, YouTube history community, Her experience interviewing Bart Ehrman, and of course, what lesson could we learn from the ancient people to weather modern life... Oh, and guess what?? We don't discuss anything about biblical history XPTime Stamps : 00:00 - Intro02:10 - What is Digital Hammurabi11:15 - Megan's take on YouTube history channels15:12 - What makes people like Paulogia and Derek Lambert of Mythvision trustworthy20:15 - What kind of topic that Megan thinks She would discuss were She to become popular24:14 - Difference between historian and archaeologist34:52 - What is the problem of people of the past that still existent today46:08 - How does knowledge of history changed Megan's worldview59:56 - Megan's favorite historical site01:01:04 - Why there are so many online courses nowMy other channels!History Education (in Bahasa) 🎙️ : youtube.com/channel/UCg-bL9t2JII8CW4cdL8y6JABass Covers 🎸 : youtube.com/channel/UCSTUlHv7QNbF66smHpIDctgSupport Me..! 💰Karyakarsa : karyakarsa.com/fubilosophyPatreon : patreon.com/fubilosophyMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fuushin12
“Philosophy is a JOKE!!” Fuad Harahap 2024-09-10 | Cristobal Ramirez a.k.a. @the_philofficer (instagram.com/the_philofficer) is a teacher and philosopher who runs a philosophy meme page with the same name. Today we’re talking about how philosophy meme could serve both as a niche comedy and a tool to spread philosophy literacy towards the masses. We also talk about pop culture and how memefying it could also help general public understand philosophy moreTime Stamps :00:00 - Intro03:13 - How to Prove that Neither of is Robot05:33 - Why Created “the_philofficer”07:36 - Why Philosopher Treat Themselves Very Seriously10:46 - Jordan Peterson15:08 - Informing Philosophy Through Memes19:23 - Philosophical Aesthetic of Brainrot Memes24:50 - How Philosophy and Psychology Relate28:07 - How Philosophy and Science Relate31:08 - How Theology Relate to Both Science and Philosophy38:06 - Existential Angst, De-Conversion, and God Questions49:18 - Cris’s View on the God Arguments52:18 - Cris’s Favorite and Least Liked Philosopher58:03 - If Socrates is a Pokémon, Who’d He be01:01:05 - Who’s the Philosopher that Would Cris’s Resurrect and Have a Chat WithMy other channels!History Education (in Bahasa) 🎙️ : youtube.com/channel/UCg-bL9t2JII8CW4cdL8y6JABass Covers 🎸 : youtube.com/channel/UCSTUlHv7QNbF66smHpIDctgSupport Me..! 💰Karyakarsa : karyakarsa.com/fubilosophyPatreon : patreon.com/fubilosophyMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fuushin12
The Problem of Evil is Also for Atheists - Yujin Nagasawa Fuad Harahap 2024-08-20 | Professor Yujin Nagasawa is Kingfisher College Chair of the Philosophy of Religion and Ethics at the University of Oklahoma. Known for His contribution in the world of philosophy of religion, today we’re discussing about problem of evil, in which He asserts that this problem also something that nonbeliever also haveLink to the book : academic.oup.com/book/56378Time Stamps :00:00 - Intro01:10 - Yujin Nagasawa & philosophy03:12 - Cultural Difference in Learning Philosophy10:50 - Is Prof Yujin a Proponent of the Ontological Argument?13:54 - Global Philosophy of Religion Project17:21 - Encounter with Sufism18:18 - What Prof Yujin Thinks About Pantheism & Panentheism21:27 - “The Problem of Evil for Atheist?”23:45 - How Most People Have to Deal with Problem of Evil?29:30 - Could Naturalist be an Optimist?32:05 - Axiological Expectations in Problem of Evil35:33 - Divinity Problem for Pantheists40:00 - Why Should God be All Good?42:20 - Asma ul-Husna in Islam49:27 - What Extinct Religion Would You Like to See Coming for the Next Global Philosophy of Religion Project?55:57 - Robert Lawrence Kuhn & Closer to Truth01:01:42 - How Philosophy of Religion Changed YouMy other channels!History Education (in Bahasa) 🎙️ : youtube.com/channel/UCg-bL9t2JII8CW4cdL8y6JABass Covers 🎸 : youtube.com/channel/UCSTUlHv7QNbF66smHpIDctgSupport Me..! 💰Karyakarsa : karyakarsa.com/fubilosophyPatreon : patreon.com/fubilosophyMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fuushin12
Interviewing Michael Shermer, the Atheist that Inspired Me to Leave Religion Fuad Harahap 2024-07-05 | Michael Shermer is a well-known American science writer, historian of science, and publisher of @skepticmagazine. But to me, Michael Shermer is a staunch skeptic-atheist who managed to inspire me to finally embrace my non-religiosity. For most of the time I know Him, He’s my hero. But today, He’s my guestTime Stamps00:00 - Intro01:39 - What does it Feel to be Left Out of the 4 Horsemen of Atheism?06:05 - What Makes So Many People Find it Hard to Leave Religion11:04 - Dr Shermer’s Relationship with Another New Atheist Figures12:45 - Is Dr Shermer a New Atheist?13:30 - Criticism of New Atheism18:35 - Technical Error23:28 - What does it Mean to be a Skeptic28:40 - Most Fun Pseudoscience being Debunked by the Skeptic Magazine35:18 - Dr Shermer’s View on American Politics43:26 - Future of Democracy49:41 - Dr Shermer’s Debate Opponents59:36 - Facing Up Mortality01:04:20 - Facing Up Mortality 2Michael Shermer’s LinksTwitter 🐤 : https://x.com/michaelshermer?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5EauthorWebsite 🛜 : michaelshermer.comMagazine 📘 : skeptic.comMy other channels!History Education (in Bahasa) 🎙️ : youtube.com/channel/UCg-bL9t2JII8CW4cdL8y6JABass Covers 🎸 : youtube.com/channel/UCSTUlHv7QNbF66smHpIDctgSupport Me..! 💰Karyakarsa : karyakarsa.com/fubilosophyPatreon : patreon.com/fubilosophyMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fuushin12
Alex Malpass Explains the Grim Reaper Paradox Until I Understand Fuad Harahap 2024-06-30 | Dr Alex Malpass is a british philosopher. A master of logic, He helps me understand the Grim Reaper Paradox, and why causal finitism won't solve the paradox. He even went so far to use football terms and Manchester United as analogies so I can understand this complex philosophical problemTime Stamps :00:00 - Intro00:46 - Alex's take on EURO 202402:22 - The Grim Reaper Paradox10:49 - The paradox explained in footballing term12:21 - What is Causal Finitism, and why it doesn't solve the paradox25:45 - This is an issue about logic, not metaphysics. Why?41:31 - The anticipation from the interlocutors50:30 - Why is Kalam Cosmological Argument so easy to understand yet so hard to refute52:08 - Petition to change philosopher name into "metaphysicist"My other channels!History Education (in Bahasa) 🎙️ : youtube.com/channel/UCg-bL9t2JII8CW4cdL8y6JABass Covers 🎸 : youtube.com/channel/UCSTUlHv7QNbF66smHpIDctgSupport Me..! 💰Karyakarsa : karyakarsa.com/fubilosophyPatreon : patreon.com/fubilosophyMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fuushin12
Why David Litwa Wants to Make Bible Education Available for All Fuad Harahap 2024-05-20 | Doctor M David Litwa, Ph.D. (@m.davidlitwa) is arguably one of the best when it comes to the Historicity of early Christian, New Testament, Nag Hammadi Library, and Gnostic Christian. There are literally hundreds of His appearances online teaching His courses and attending podcasts about it. What is not so well known about Him is His fight to make this kind of studies available into the masses without have to facing formal academic barriers. His fight, while commendable in spirit, also beautiful in His personal reasonsHere’s how You can reach out to Doctor Litwa :🛜 His website : mdavidlitwa.com/about📖 His patreon : patreon.com/mdavidlitwa?utm_source=search🎥 His Youtube : youtube.com/@m.davidlitwa?si=GRSO1yFkQ5qA5DXLPlease consider donating to Him guys 🙏🏽Time Stamps :00:00 - Intro00:11 - New Topics for the Podcast00:44 - Dr Litwa’s Background02:08 - What Got Dr Litwa Into the History of Christianity04:04 - Dr Litwa’s Academic Journey06:51 - Liberalizing Bible Education10:02 - Dr Litwa’s Colleagues’ Reactions Towards His Online Contents12:31 - Fuad’s Sympathy Towards Dr Litwa’s Goals14:01 - Difference Between Teaching Online and Offline16:54 - Dr Litwa’s Way of Engaging People to Learn Ancient Culture22:21 - Fuad’s Story of Finding Marcion25:09 - Dr Litwa’s Surprising New Knowledge28:51 - Dr Litwa’s Faith (or Lack thereof)31:05 - Dr Litwa’s Opinion in Marcion33:57 - Fuad’s Take on Marcion and New Testaments’ Canonization34:43 - Dr Litwa Explains About the Context Within the Canonization36:30 - Had Marcion Never Exist….38:45 - Was Marcion Really Think that the Old Testament’s God is Evil?40:19 - Why It’s Evil42:18 - Fuad’s Take on Marcion’s View of the God of the Old Testament, and Dr Litwa’s Responses44:12 - Dr Litwa’s Take Whether Marcion Should be Taught in Schools45:10 - Where Can We Find Dr Litwa46:44 - “M” David Litwa?My other channels!History Education (in Bahasa) 🎙️ : youtube.com/channel/UCg-bL9t2JII8CW4cdL8y6JABass Covers 🎸 : youtube.com/channel/UCSTUlHv7QNbF66smHpIDctgSupport Me..! 💰Karyakarsa : karyakarsa.com/fubilosophyPatreon : patreon.com/fubilosophyMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fuushin12
Graham Oppy Reminding Me of Acceptance and Humility Fuad Harahap 2024-03-01 | While most conversations with Professor Graham Oppy always revolve around atheism, arguments, and metaphysics, in this conversation I tried to discuss with Him about something that most people don’t realize He possesses in abundance : humility and acceptanceTime Stamps :00:00 - Intro00:58 - Why Professor Graham Chose Philosophy03:53 - Regarding The Label of “Atheism”06:07 - Graham Oppy’s Experience as an Philosopher That is Atheistic08:37 - Graham’s Strategy of Engaging in Debates12:35 - The Philosopher That Doesn’t Debate14:43 - William Lane Craig’s Best Ideas16:30 - Professor Oppy’s Thoughts on New Atheism20:19 - Professor Oppy’s Thoughts About Aayan Hirshi Ali’s Conversion22:18 - On Naturalism25:00 - The Problem of Naturalism26:41 - Professor Oppy’s Thoughts on Values29:21 - The Obsession for Answers33:06 - Professor’s Contention With Controversial Positions35:13 - Is it Okay, if In the End We Won’t Know Everything37:29 - Knowledge That is Not Worth Having40:37 - Professor’s Thoughts on Homoscientia45:34 - On Omniscience50:41 - Freeman Dyson’s Idea of Terraforming53:03 - Knowledge of Irreversible Extinction55:12 - Philosophy’s Role in Professor’s Opinions57:20 - Bears in Lombok01:00:48 - Mysteries That Professor’s Hoped Uncovered In the Future01:01:46 - The Future of PhilosophyDukung saya di Karyakarsa 💰karyakarsa.com/fuushin12Channel Lain Saya!Edukasi 🎙️ : youtube.com/channel/UCg-bL9t2JII8CW4cdL8y6JABass 🎸 : youtube.com/channel/UCSTUlHv7QNbF66smHpIDctgMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fubidon
Interviewing the Philosophy Wonderkid: Joe Schmif of @MajestyofReason Fuad Harahap 2023-12-11 | Today I'm having a great conversation with fellow philosopher Joe Schmid from @MajestyofReason, the objectively best philosophy YouTube channel (that is IF hasn't surpassed by mine, lol). We talk a lot about God, metaphysics, the utility of philosophy, and also about our love of football (international version of course)Dukung saya di Karyakarsa 💰karyakarsa.com/fuushin12Channel Lain Saya!Edukasi 🎙️ : youtube.com/channel/UCg-bL9t2JII8CW4cdL8y6JABass 🎸 : youtube.com/channel/UCSTUlHv7QNbF66smHpIDctgMore of Me at 🌲https://linktr.ee/fuushin12
