PianoCurioRodion Shchedrin (b. 1932) Humoresque for piano (1957) PianoCurio, pf Instrument: Bösendorfer 280VC (Pianoteq)
One of the few humoresques that is seriously humorous, rivaling even Mozart's most inappropriate musical pranks. I can't immediately think of a funny piano piece that is as goofy as this one, especially when used as a musical foil to lighten up the audience after a performance.
The most unserious piano piecePianoCurio2024-11-11 | Rodion Shchedrin (b. 1932) Humoresque for piano (1957) PianoCurio, pf Instrument: Bösendorfer 280VC (Pianoteq)
One of the few humoresques that is seriously humorous, rivaling even Mozart's most inappropriate musical pranks. I can't immediately think of a funny piano piece that is as goofy as this one, especially when used as a musical foil to lighten up the audience after a performance.
Check out smalin’s animation of this performance here: youtu.be/zHZbJNQRgVU?si=edUKny6qvhBElP6tWhen popular 1820s piano music is surprisingly well-craftedPianoCurio2025-01-25 | Ignaz Moscheles (1794–1870) Rondoletto for piano based on a favorite theme by Ferdinando Paër, op. 61 (c. 1823)
[A first recording made especially for this video]
I stumbled across this score on IMSLP several months ago. On its face, it looked like a standard 1820s rondo for piano—but as I played through it for the first time, I was surprised by how well-crafted it was, every idea derived organically from its main theme, there was no technical excess and yet it somehow felt brilliant to play. I couldn't find a recording anywhere, so I made this one.
This Rondoletto for piano, op. 61, published around 1823, was composed by Ignaz Moscheles, a protégé of Beethoven and one of the most famous pianists of that decade. When most people think of 1820s piano music, they imagine the late sonatas of Beethoven and Schubert, but those works took decades to gain broad recognition—you wouldn’t have heard them at a typical public performance in the early 19th century. Instead, the average 1820s concert goer was much more likely to hear a brilliant rondo, fantasy, or variations on a well-known theme, such as those by Kalkbrenner, Herz, Czerny, Pixis, and Moscheles, who were just some of most active pianist-composers during this period. These cunning performers capitalized on the popularity of familiar melodies–typically borrowed from operas and folk tunes—by dressing them up in spectacular virtuosic arrangements to the delight of their audiences. This trend placed an increasingly high value on technique, often at the expense of compositional integrity; just take a look at one of these concert pieces and you’ll find dramatic-looking figurations built on nothing but basic chord progressions.
By contrast, what I find remarkable about this Rondoletto by Moscheles is how uncharacteristically restrained it is. The difficulty is intermediate at most, the ideas develop logically and efficiently, and overall the piece holds up as a solid composition without trying to be flashy. In fact, that was the opinion of a London critic who reviewed it in 1823:
“Mr. Moscheles’ Rondoletto has all the elegance and brilliancy of his style, with less of its accustomed difficulty. Even this composition, trifling as it is when compared with his other works, manifests the richness of his fancy, and his ability to do much with slight materials.”
In other words, here we have a piece in perfect harmony with the tastes of the day—a brilliant rondo on a popular theme—but marked by a rare economy of means and invention.
According to the title page, this rondo theme is supposedly based on a favorite “Nocturne” by Paër, but it more closely resembles a march. In the introduction, Moscheles cleverly foreshadows the main thematic material with a polyphonic texture. Like Beethoven, Moscheles received his contrapuntal training from Albrechtsberger and studied composition with Salieri, two respected teachers who gave him a solid foundation in the Classic Viennese style. You can hear elements of this traditional approach throughout, such as in the elegant transitional passages.
Each idea in the Rondo develops organically. For instance, Moscheles takes the theme's triplet chirping figure and expands it into an entire section, presented at first in E major and later on in C major. The pacing is also excellent; each phrase gradually builds on the last, intensifying at one moment from a quiet pedal point to a burst of brilliant passagework.
Simply put, this is an above-average composition for its time, a great example of genuine musical craftsmanship successfully merging with popular taste.
00:00 Introduction 01:13 Rondoletto - Allegretto 04:59 CodaForgotten Christmas March that delighted French audiences in 1905PianoCurio2024-12-22 | Charles-Marie Widor (1844–1937) Marche de Noël des Pêcheurs de St. Jean pour piano (1905) Arranged for piano by the composer 1926 Pleyel model F piano (Pianoteq) Performance: PianoCurio
Widor spent the better part of a decade working on his third opera, "The Fishermen of St. Jean," a maritime "drame lyrique" in four acts based on a libretto by Henri Cain. It was an outright success at the Paris Opéra after its 1905 premiere, though Isidor Philipp relates that Widor's refusal to give the lead role to the Opéra director's wife apparently resulted in the swift end of its initial run.
This Christmas March comes from the beginning of the third act, which takes place on Christmas Eve while the neighbors are heading to church service. Meanwhile, the protagonist is anguishing in her room about the safety of her father and brother, who have been at sea for two days as a storm is brewing outside. We hear a colorful portrait of the rustic maritime village setting, complete with sailors' fifes and a central hymn after the neighbors dig through the mud and grime of the stormy streets to enter the church. One critical review in 1905 singled out this interlude as "a charming symphonic piece . . . the design of which is full of grace and freshness, with an orchestration as Mr. Widor knows how to write." Widor is not known today as a symphonist, but he in fact developed a masterful technique in orchestration that can be heard in both the piano arrangement and its original symphonic form (linked below).
Godowsky tended to write the kind of music that makes you want to give up at first sight. His style might be described as "concert maximalism," wherein he composed intricate contrapuntal lines that weave throughout the texture, whether serving as a gloss on an arrangement of a Bach cello suite or as the DNA of an original composition. In this arrangement, Godowsky took Albéniz's already excellent Tango and appended luxurious inner and outer voices that complement the famous melody and its gently rocking accompaniment. It is an ideal encore piece.
Whereas Godowsky's complex arrangements can sometimes overpower the original music while overwhelming the listener and performer, I find that this one really works well. It is rich, to be sure, but it all falls easily enough within the hands for Godowsky's standards. The expressive possibilities far outweigh the difficulties, which is not always a given in this style. My interpretation is slower than the prescribed tempo and other recordings out there, offering a more indulgent perspective of Godowsky's craftsmanship and Albéniz's exquisite melody.
Godowsky wrote many of these arrangements to pass the time while traveling or touring, often completing one movement or more per day, sometimes without a piano at hand. It's incredible to imagine him doing so with the sophistication and quality of pieces like this one, which dates from July 12th, 1921 in Chicago, USA.
Support my sheet music fund: buymeacoffee.com/pianocurioWhat Happened to the Turkish March After Mozart? Its Evolution from 1783–1941 (on historical pianos)PianoCurio2024-12-05 | When most people think of Turkish marches for piano, Mozart’s and Beethoven’s famous pieces first come to mind, perhaps followed by the concert arrangements of Beethoven’s Turkish theme by Rubinstein, Liszt, and Rachmaninoff. Yet this subgenre extended far beyond these composers as the aesthetic tastes of the European continent evolved throughout the 19th and 20th centuries.
In this video, I perform a curated selection of Turkish marches for piano that tell a story of how this genre changed over time, from Mozart’s Rondo Alla Turca in 1783 to Alexander Krein’s March on a Turkish Theme published in 1941. I use a selection of historical instruments modeled by Pianoteq that roughly correlate to each date of publication.
While this list is not comprehensive—it is limited to original themes composed or transcribed for piano—I use each selection to represent a different manifestation of the Turkish march (and related pieces) as part of a Western musical genre. I consider it like a museum display, where many historical objects sharing a theme are lined up next to one another with contextual commentary. Individually, the pieces may be relatively uninteresting, but taken together, they become part of a meaningful historical narrative.
Below is a general list of these characteristics shared by many, though not all, of the pieces in this video. Composers also used many of these to depict vaguely “oriental” styles, but they often did so in the form of a march to signify that it was “Turkish.”
Common “Turkish March” Genre Markers: Military rhythm in 2/4 or 4/4 time Depictions of drum hits and rolls, cymbals, triangles and piccolos (Western equivalents to Turkish shawms) Exotic ornamentation such as trills and semitone grace notes Passages in rapid thirds and mordents/trills in thirds Whole-and-a-half steps in melody (e.g. harmonic minor) Often written in the key of A minor Bass drone/pedal
Pianoteq instruments used: 1. Schmidt square piano (1780) 2. Weimes pianoforte (1808) 3. Besendorfer grand piano (1829) 4. Erard grand piano (1849) 5. Streicher grand piano (1852) 6–8. Bechstein grand piano (1899) 9–10. Erard grand piano (1922)Chopthoven - Appassionata Harp Etude (pastiche by Heller, op. 133, var. 7)PianoCurio2024-11-25 | Stephen Heller (1813–1888) Variations on a Theme by Beethoven, Op. 133, Variation 7 (c. 1872) Based on a theme from the second movment of the Appassionata Sonata, op. 57 (1806), combined with the texture of Chopin's 'Aeolian Harp' Etude
PianoCurio, pf Instrument: Ant. Petrof (Pianoteq)
It is quite bold to compose original variations on a theme composed and varied by Beethoven himself. Stephen Heller did it twice in the latter half of the 19th century: his op. 130 is based on the C minor Variations WoO 80 while his op. 133 uses a theme from the Appassionata's Andante movement. It is unlikely that anyone would argue for Heller's sets as equal or superior to Beethoven's, but that may be missing the point in any case.
Heller knew his place in music history. He was a renowned pianist, teacher, and composer of slight but popular character pieces and studies. Charming and pleasing works abound in his output, and he rarely tackled the larger forms. By the 1870s, music from the first half of the century was being consolidated by teachers and performers into the pianistic canon, balancing the "old testament" of Bach with the "new testament" of Beethoven, plus works by Schubert, Chopin, Schumann, et al. In his later sets of variations from this period, Heller engaged in the typical virtuosic and salon styles of the day while creatively drawing upon this bank of well-known music by earlier composers. Because this is the same standard repertoire we know today, these meta references within Heller's variations are just as effective as they were in 1872, adding a layer of witty, clever pastiche upon the standard variation form.
Heller referenced several other works by Beethoven in the op. 133 variations, including: the scherzo of the 8th Symphony (var. 6), the allegretto of the 7th String Quartet (var. 13), and the finale of the Appassionata (final variation). At one point in his C minor variations, Heller combines the theme with the "fate" motif from Beethoven's 5th. This may be compared with Alkan's notorious cadenza for Beethoven's Third Concerto, in which he interpolates the finale of the 5th at a particularly climactic moment. In another set of variations, op. 142, Heller took Schumann's "Warum" theme from the Fantasiestücke and combined it with "Der Dichter Spricht" from Kinderszenen. So, it is clear that Heller was engaging in the familiarity of these works in playful and quite intelligent ways.
The mixture of Chopin's 'Aeolian Harp' etude texture and Beethoven's melody in this variation works quite well as music, but it also provides a fascinating window into the European musical culture of the 19th century.
00:00 Intro 00:22 A section 01:14 B section 02:20 Varied A section 02:44 CodaTsfasman - Jazz Suite for piano 4-hands, I. Snowflakes #classicalpiano #classicalmusicPianoCurio2024-11-23 | Alexander Tsfasman - Snowflakes from Jazz Suite for piano and orchestra, arranged for piano four hands by G. Di BiancoGrieg’s Modernist Twilight: revelatory piano miniatures from his final years (Slåtter, Op. 72)PianoCurio2024-11-18 | Edvard Grieg (1843-1907) 17 Norwegian Peasant Dances (Slåtter), Op. 72, selected movements PianoCurio, pf Instrument: Blüthner Model One (Pianoteq)
00:00 VI. Gangar (walking dance) 01:30 III. Bridal March from Telemark 05:49 IV. Halling from the Fairy Hill 06:54 "Civilizing the tune" 09:52 XVI. Springing dance (The Maidens from Kivledal) 11:39 XVII. Gangar (The Maidens from Kivledal) 13:35 V. The Prillar from Os Parish 14:52 XIV. The Goblins' Bridal Procession at Vossevangen (Gangar)
Many composers' lives fit squarely within the historical eras we have named - Baroque, Classical, Romantic, Modern, etc. - which serve to roughly categorize and summarize the cultural times in which they lived and worked. Many others lived during multiple major eras while still largely "belonging" to the one in which they first matured, since their styles did not develop any further. There is a third category that contains composers who pioneered transitional styles at the chronological seams between major eras, as in what Beethoven did between Classicism and Romanticism, for example. Grieg's forward-looking treatment of folk material in his Norwegian Peasant Dances (Slåtter), op. 72 (adapting it "on its own terms," in the words of musicologist Ståle Kleiberg), places him in this third category as a transitional figure between the Romantic and Modern eras of Western classical music.
The origins of the 17 Slåtter that Grieg published in 1903 are layered. These folk dance tunes were aurally passed down (un-notated) for generations, with some motivic material even as old as the 1000s, among players of Norway's national instrument, the Hardanger fiddle. This violin-like instrument typically has four sympathetic strings underneath, adding a resonant quality, plus a flatter bridge to accommodate droning on open strings and two-part playing. In the late 1800s, the folk fiddler Knut Dahle believed that the art form was dying out, so he wanted Grieg to write down and preserve the traditional music he played by heart. Grieg eventually arranged for a composer, Johan Halvorsen (also a violinist), to meet Dahle and transcribe the tunes for violin in standard notation. Halvorsen did so with great interest and difficulty, noting the many strange and fleeting ornaments that the fiddler passed off with ease. Adaptations of these can be heard throughout Grieg's piano version of the Slåtter, which he began arranging in 1902 (after much reluctance) based on Halvorsen's violin versions.
Grieg intended his piano versions of the Slåt tunes to serve as artistic representations of their folk origins. One can hear the great liberties Grieg took in doing so when comparing these pieces to their source material (still played by fiddlers in Norway today), yet Grieg adapted them in such a way that highlighted his transitional perspective in music history (he died in 1907 while musical Modernism was coming of age). Grieg works out many of the motives in overtly Romanticized sections while contrasting these episodes with ones that embrace the "wild" characters of the material, which exist outside of the Western musical canon. Grieg wrote that he wanted to "bring them under a system of harmony" to avoid monotonous passages, while preserving their originality and daring imagination.
As noted in the video, the young Percy Grainger went on to befriend Grieg and champion these dances while Béla Bartók owned a personal copy of them. The torch of Modernism that these composers took up would elevate national folk material to a new importance in music. Folk elements would no longer only serve as a creative gloss or for cheap exotic effects, but would be ethnographically researched, recorded, and painstakingly reproduced as valid artistic materials in their own right.
Ståle Kleiberg's quote in the video is taken form his paper "Grieg's 'Slåtter', Op. 72: Change of Musical Style or New Concept of Nationality?" jstor.org/stable/766395Why this obscure piano piece sounds vaguely familiarPianoCurio2024-11-10 | I somehow felt that I had always known this forgotten melody by Widor, until I realized that we all do, in a way. I believe I figured out why.
John Williams' music for the Harry Potter movies, especially the titular "Hedwig's theme," is an iconic part of film music and pop culture today. Many of his famous melodies draw inspiration from eclectic styles and composers including Dvořák, Wagner, Liszt, and 20th-century music from jazz to Penderecki. So it is not entirely surprising that one of his most archaic melodies, depicting the magical, castle-themed world of Harry Potter, would align very closely with a late-Romantic composer who also sought to depict a bygone age.
While some level of coincidence is involved, I argue that the crucial elements shaping the contours of these independently composed melodies (namely the siciliano rhythm paired with a minor melody) arose from isolated, parallel thinking between Widor and Williams. Writing over a century apart, these two composers arrived at strikingly similar ideas for the related sound-worlds that they wished to conjure.
Interestingly, the pseudo-medieval phrase "Ye olde" originated in the 1890s around the same time Widor wrote this imaginary "old-fashioned" melody. So, there seems to have been a certain vogue around that time for stylized, archaic language and art, not in a historically accurate sense, but rather one that primarily aimed to stir the human antiquarian imagination.
Note: the D-natural octave played by the LH in the penultimate bar is a holdover from Widor's original version that did not carry over into the revised version with F-natural shown here. I chose to retain the original in this performance.
Charles-Marie Widor (1844-1937) Air en style ancien/Pastoral Louis XV (1891/1912) PianoCurio, pf Instrument: Shigeru Kawai SK-EX by Pianoteq Background image: from Très Riches Heures du Duc de Berry by the Limbourg brothers (c. 1412-1416)
I performed each of these works on an 1812 Schöffstoss pianoforte by Pianoteq tuned to A=415 hz. See below for some additional comments on each sonata. The modulatory transitions are my own semi-improvisations created for this video. Each year represents either the composition year or date of first publication, as it was necessary to choose them selectively in order to create the best order.
00:00 Intro 00:13 1810 Kuhlau PSA: Kuhlau wrote more than just sonatinas! There are several full-scale, grand sonatas with very interesting writing, and yet modern editions only seem to offer his sonatinas. This beautiful adagio hints at the kind of melismatic vocal runs later adopted by Chopin.
04:36 1811 Ries Along with Czerny and to an extent Moscheles, Ries was one of Beethoven's closest pupils. His compositions usually aren't bad but rarely inspire profundity. This one is nice, and I'm intrigued by the sinking chromaticism that gives this work a unique flavor.
08:02 1812 Dussek Dussek's last and greatest sonata is full of his characteristic proto-Romantic effects and note-spinning phrases (in the best way) that consistently charm with their salt-of-the-earth melodicism.
11:01 1813 Müller (Intro) 13:57 1813 Müller (Allegro) Müller clearly admired his teacher and carried the torch of Bach before it was cool to do so (that is to say, after Mendelssohn). He actually wrote some other interesting keyboard works that are quite virtuosic, almost like proto-etudes. The introduction here is a well-developed fantasy, leading into a strong Allegro theme.
15:40 1814 Moscheles I love this sonata and admire its composer. Moscheles' life crossed paths with nearly every notable musician of the early 1800s and his memoirs are full of fascinating stories (Beethoven's everyday antics, Salieri's deathbed refusal of the rumor that he poisoned Mozart, etc.). The music so perfectly captures the post-Goethe angst that the Romantic generations would later run with.
19:47 1815 Schubert Not the Schubert we will come to know later, but still very much Schubert. The melody is simple, curiously unadorned in its repeat (typically the opposite occurs), and effective. Very Wanderer-like.
24:04 1816 Beethoven This sonata movement appears so small on the page but is full of the spacious ideas for which we love Beethoven. As always, the effect of Beethoven's music on period pianos is so different from what we are used to that it can be shocking at times. I don't think one is better than the other, they are just different, and variety is always nice.
28:21 1817 Weber I am not wild about Weber's piano sonatas and frankly wonder why they've been recorded several times by renowned pianists over so many other choices from this era. Still, here we have a stormy sonata that is fun to play and anticipates the bravura pianism of the 1820s.
32:22 1818 Beethoven I've always thought that the Hammerklavier sonata, for all its reputation of being one of the most intimidating piano works in the repertoire, does not look very menacing on paper. When you start to play it, though, you realize that every measure is so full of ideas, expression markings, ritardandi, unique technical devices, and intense thematic development that there is really nothing that can totally prepare you for it. Of course, the fugal finale is the real nail in the coffin for pianists, but the first movement is no slouch.
35:13 1819 Hummel Hummel's writing, at its most advanced, feels much more linked to the pianos of his era (see the passages in thirds and sixths), with their lighter Viennese actions and shallow keybeds allowing for rapid, agile movements that can be quite awkward on a modern instrument. The ideas are intricate, original, and well-crafted, but they don't "hit" quite as hard as Beethoven's better ones do. In my opinion, this sonata belongs to the same class of difficulty as Beethoven's Hammerklavier, but in such a totally different way that it's hard to compare them directly. You can't fault a musician as good as Hummel, who wrote many worthy hit pieces in his day, for not being able to stand the test of time. Some styles just don't carry over to other generations as well, but that does not mean that we can't enjoy them for what they are (or once were).2 pianos, 8 hands visualized (Boëllmann’s Toccata)PianoCurio2024-10-31 | ...2 pianos 8 hands: Toccata from Suite gothique by Boëllmann (scrolling score)PianoCurio2024-10-31 | Léon Boëllmann (1862–1897) Suite gothique pour orgue, Op. 25 (1895) IV. Toccata (arr. Léon Roques for 2 pianos 8 hands in 1915) Performed by PianoCurio
I had been searching for a good, spooky work to feature this Halloween when I came across this vintage arrangement of Boëllmann’s famous piece on IMSLP. When I didn’t immediately find an existing recording of it (what, nobody has 2 pianos, 8 hands and a microphone just laying around?), then I knew this was the perfect chance to try an 8-hands piece myself. The music and composer need no introduction, so I’ll share more about my production process here instead.
My recording setup using Pianoteq instruments was a pair of New York and Hamburg Steinways with a big hall reverb from Altiverb. I recorded each part using a click track at 132 bpm with only two ad lib. diversions, the brief ritardando in the middle and the one at the end. It’s easy for 4 parts to become a jumbled mess especially with all of the sixteenths, so recording in MIDI allowed me to notch some of the slightly unsynchronized notes into their correct positions. Still, I left most of the raw performance intact to achieve the realism of a live performance.
There are many organ works that sound fantastic when transcribed for two or more pianists (Alkan’s Impromptu on Luther’s Chorale, Op. 69 arranged for two pianos by Roger Smalley comes to mind). That’s not to say they are missing anything in their original form, but the piano’s more direct, percussive quality allows quicker pieces like this one with dense textures to really shine in a different way. Two pianos still can’t compete with the sheer sonic size of the full organ. Even so, this arrangement makes a work of moderate difficulty quite accessible for four pianists and it is still very musically effective. It would be an ideal encore piece for a studio or collaborative piano recital.
Happy Halloween 2024!
00:00 soft 01:21 louder 02:21 LOUD 03:09 LOUDEST 03:25 Appraisal1894 Piano Exam: Mens & Womens Sight-reading Pieces, Composed by WidorPianoCurio2024-10-21 | Two original piano pieces composed for an 1894 student competition at the Paris Conservatoire.
Men and women pianists: It is incredibly strange to us today, but the reality in the 19th century was that women did not directly compete with men in piano competitions. Though women were certainly encouraged, even expected, to learn the piano, they were usually not taken seriously as artists or concert pianists. This prejudice did not stop exceptional musicians like Clara Schumann from touring the continent, but it did still limit the acceptance of their playing; attitudes like "I suppose she plays well, for a woman" or "she plays like a woman imitating a man's playing" were all too common.
Why? According to 19th-century European society (though decreasingly so towards and into the 20th century), music was a woman's domestic duty in a private salon environment, but a man's profession as a composer and virtuoso. Therefore, competitions divided the two into separate categories. Despite the attitudes about gender, there was of course no talent difference and women were trained in virtuoso music just as much as men. One Conservatoire competition in the 1870s featured the men playing a Chopin concerto movement while the women were required to play the truncated first movement of Alkan's Concerto for solo piano, a piece no less difficult (if not more so) than the Chopin.
About the pieces: As Professor at the Conservatoire, Widor would have juried many of these competitions and in 1894 he wrote two original pieces for the sight-reading portion of the event. Pianists would be given the music on the spot and were expected to play it after a few moments of scanning. The men's piece was actually modified from an 1877 waltz Widor had already written, yet (as Harold Fabrikant points out) apparently the composer did not think anyone would know its theme.
Neither piece is technically difficult besides a few moments of intricate inner voicings. The real difficulty lies in the constant expression, dynamic, and tempo directions, plus unusually sudden and remote modulations with heaps of accidentals thrown in. Widor planted these musical landmines to see where the students would trip up, with the most difficult passages occurring towards the middle-end of the pieces.
It is interesting to consider why the men and women received different pieces for sight-reading. Perhaps it was simply for the sake of variety in a long day of hearing piano students play the same pieces over and over again. There may be a gendered element to the women's piece, which takes the texture and style of a nocturne, typical of the domestic salon environment. The men's piece also reaches a louder dynamic (a moment of fortissimo), but perhaps this is just splitting hairs. Still, the women studying at the Conservatoire were seriously talented musicians and their ability would not have differed from the men, so the separation seems like more of a holdover from tradition.
I hope you enjoy these delightful pieces and that their unique purpose inspires curiosity. Would you have passed either test on first sight? Which piece is the better or trickier one?the reason why so many pianists are latePianoCurio2024-10-17 | ...Lyadov Starter Pack – 5 Essential Preludes by a Late-Romantic PerfectionistPianoCurio2024-10-14 | Anatoly Lyadov (1855–1914) Five selected preludes for piano PianoCurio, pf Piano: Blüthner Model One (Pianoteq)
The Russian composer Anatoly Lyadov wrote some of the finest lesser-heard gems in the late-Romantic piano repertoire. They are not all obscure, as the first prelude of this set has rightly become one of his most famous melodies. To me, Lyadov represents a link between the pianism of Chopin and Rachmaninoff. His output was relatively small, some say due to laziness, others that his perfectionism hindered his productivity. Regardless, it is evident that Lyadov worked over every fine detail, crafting alluring melodies tinged with Russian flavor. Lyadov excelled in miniatures, exemplified by the numerous scattered preludes (two or three at a time) that he wrote over his career. Balanced in brevity and beauty, these preludes are the ideal entry point to discovering this composer.
My "essential" list of five preludes (in no particular order) is not an attempt to definitively pick the "best" ones, but to highlight five representative pieces, each of which articulates a different facet of Lyadov's style.
00:00 Prelude in B minor, Op. 11, No. 1 (1886) It is easy to hear why this piece sits atop Lyadov's works as the finest gem of them all. Its melody sings of mysterious sadness, perhaps tragedy, with undulating harmonies beneath, wafting through the air like incense.
03:10 Prelude-Pastorale (1894) This one is lesser known, but a sleeper favorite of mine. Lyadov captures the picturesque pastoral element in gently rocking open fifths and a breezy subject that appears just as quickly as it evaporates into a sweetly arpeggiated plagal cadence.
05:11 Prelude in Gb major, Op. 27, No. 3 (1891) Lyadov's best ideas were often serene slower movements rather than virtuosic showcases, but he did write many pieces that required solid technique, even if not terribly difficult by Romantic standards. This one reminds me of a miniature etude, like an offspring of Chopin's, bubbling over with energetic charm and wit, and capped by a wink at the end.
06:48 Prelude in Db major, Op. 57, No. 1 (c. 1905) The most Chopinesque of them all, we clearly hear the influence of Chopin's nocturnes in this gentle song that soon grows impassioned, almost desperate at one moment. It ends with a finely woven web of echoed counterpoint and an elegantly prepared final resolution over a pedal point.
08:59 Prelude in F# minor, Op. 39, No. 4 (1895) Almost Rachmaninoff, but not quite. You can hear the proximity – Lyadov was a professor at the conservatory where Rachmaninoff studied – in the menacing octave passages and shadowy, shifting harmonies. Sources give a tempo of dotted quarter = 100bpm, but I push it a bit here because otherwise it sounds too casual, not urgent enough.Who does this melody remind you of?PianoCurio2024-10-11 | Hermann Goetz (1840–1876) Piano Quintet, Op.16 (1874) II. Andante con moto (arr. for piano 4 hands by Friedrich Hermann) PianoCurio, pf
This music may bring to mind that of Mendelssohn, Schumann, or even Brahms at his most generous. Its harmonies have the warmth and clarity of the German Romantic composers and its melody has a natural Dvořákian ease to it, as if it sprang up from the soil.
Regardless of what you hear, it is clear that it took a musician of great sensitivity to compose this music. A late bloomer who took his first serious piano lesson at 17, Hermann Goetz possessed an introverted personality and a sickly physical constitution that led to his relatively early death at 35 from tuberculosis. These factors kept his music from fully maturing and his legacy from significantly outliving his time, but Goetz's artistic efforts did attract attention from his contemporaries.
The critic George Bernard Shaw enthusiastically proclaimed that “Hermann Goetz alone among the modern symphonists is easily and unaffectedly successful from beginning to end. He has the charm of Schubert… the refinement and inspiration of Mendelssohn… Schumann’s sense of harmonic expression… Brahms, who alone touches [Goetz] in mere brute musical faculty, is a dolt in comparison to him.” Shaw's opinion is certainly overstated, but it is still an impressive endorsement for such an otherwise forgotten composer.
We know that Goetz's Piano Quintet, written two years before his death, enjoyed some popularity because it was arranged for piano four hands, as performed here in possibly its first recording. 19th-century audiences regularly consumed symphonic and chamber works in this format due to its practicality and ease of performance in the home. The fact that the publisher ordered an arrangement means that it sold particularly well enough to warrant one. Besides the Quintet, Goetz's comic opera "Der Widerspänstigen Zähmung" (The Taming of the Shrew) was a huge international success in its day, notable for its re-embrace of classicism over Wagnerism.
00:00 Theme 00:56 Excursion 01:24 Hymn 01:42 Turmoil 02:00 Theme (variant) 02:38 Excursion (variant) 03:03 Turmoil and spinning up 03:25 Theme (flowing variant) 03:47 Soaring duet 04:08 Winding down 04:31 Hymn 04:49 Final climb & codaPlaying a sonata from every year of the 1800s: The first decadePianoCurio2024-10-07 | What if we could listen to one piano sonata from each year of the 19th century, witnessing the dramatic transformation of styles from Steibelt to Scriabin, with all of them performed on pianos from the era in which they were composed? That is what I plan to do in this ten-part series.
My goal is not only to play a sonata from each year, but to feature the largest variety of composers with as few repeats as possible. Composers who wrote several famous sonatas will only appear once in the whole series, when possible. I also considered the fact that sonatas belong to multiple years; the dates of composition and of publication often span one to several adjacent years. I freely chose between these dates to create the most compelling and (I hope) interesting order, while satisfying the first two objectives.
Part I: 1800–1809 Beethoven’s Rivals, Friends, & Contemporaries
1800: Steibelt, Sonata in Eb, Op. 45 Steibelt is famous for having challenged Beethoven to a piano duel and losing. Though Steibelt was by all accounts a vain and dishonest person, his skill as a pianist should not be diminished based on one brush with a talent like Beethoven. He dedicated this sonata to Madame Bonaparte herself, a sign of Steibelt's social ambition and prestige at the time. The sonata, though lacking in memorable themes, is still technically ambitious for its day, and I find the second theme in particular quite charming.
1801: Field, Sonata in C minor, Op. 1, No. 2 Dedicated to Muzio Clementi (see below), Field's Op. 1 sonatas show that he could do more than write flowing, dreamy nocturnes. In this exposition, he elegantly develops his subject within a classical framework, not unlike early Beethoven.
1802: Clementi, Sonata in G major, Op. 40 At the time, Clementi was arguably the most famous musician on this list, known for his influential teaching and compositions as well as his music publishing and piano manufacturing businesses. In this movement, he invented an irrepressibly catchy rondo theme reminiscent of Scarlatti and Haydn.
1803: Pinto, Sonata in A major, Op. 3, No. 2 George Pinto, an English pianist and Friend of John Field, died at just 20 years old. We hear prophetic shades of Schubert in the wandering middle section of this songful slow movement. What would have become of him had he lived a full life?
1804: Riem, Sonata in E, Op. 7, No. 1 This was Wilhelm Friedrich Riem's debut year as a published composer, a year in which he supposedly caused a stir for his originality. What caught my ear in this second movement was its passing likeness to the Allegretto from Beethoven's Seventh, which came several years later in 1811-1812.
1805: Bomtempo, Sonata in C, Op. 5 A rare Portuguese pianist-composer of the early Romantic era, João Domingos Bomtempo wrote prolifically for his instrument as well as in the choral genres. This skittish toccata-finale is not the best music, but it can be fun if you simply take it for what it is: a unique, manic romp.
1806: Cramer, Sonata in G, Op. 37, No. 1 Pianistically, contemporaries tended to mention Cramer in the same breath as Beethoven, though whereas they considered Beethoven the more expressive performer, Cramer possessed the finer technique. We hear a more conservative musical voice in this sonata but it is finely crafted, clean and pearly writing that is a joy to play.
1807: Dussek, Sonata in Ab, 'Le retour à Paris' Though not remembered today nearly as much as Clementi or even Steibelt, Dussek did more than any other composer on this list to push towards a more expressive Romantic style. His virtuosity is displayed in the extended passagework, while his harmonic explorations took his melodies in interesting directions. He republished this sonata in 1810 as ‘Plus Ultra’ to one-up Woelfl, whose Sonata ‘Non plus ultra’ appeared in 1808.
1808: Woelfl, Sonata in B minor, Op. 38 Another pianistic rival of Beethoven, Woelfl lost a piano duel to him the year before Steibelt’s attempt. He died in 1812 and perhaps could have achieved a lot more. This finale has a strong theme with a tight, almost neo-Baroque development.
1809: Eberl, Sonata in C, Op. 43 A good friend of Beethoven’s, Eberl was respected as a composer and as a genial person. He studied with Mozart and Salieri and died in 1807, though his expressive final sonata was published posthumously 1809, and so it appears last.
00:00 1800: Steibelt, Sonata in Eb, Op. 45 04:14 1801: Field, Sonata in C minor, Op. 1, No. 2 06:09 1802: Clementi, Sonata in G major, Op. 40 08:19 1803: Pinto, Sonata in A major, Op. 3, No. 2 13:24 1804: Riem, Sonata in E, Op. 7, No. 1 17:34 1805: Bomtempo, Sonata in C, Op. 5 21:38 1806: Cramer, Sonata in G, Op. 37, No. 1 25:29 1807: Dussek, Sonata in Ab, 'Le retour à Paris' 30:14 1808: Woelfl, Sonata in B minor, Op. 38 32:40 1809: Eberl, Sonata in C, Op. 43 (Andantino) 35:14 1809: Eberl, Sonata in C, Op. 43 (Rondo Vivace)when the theory prof says no parallel 5thsPianoCurio2024-09-28 | ...If you like this piece, he wrote 375 more over 8 yearsPianoCurio2024-09-27 | A passionate sketch born from romantic obsession.
Zdeněk Fibich (1850–1900) Moods, Impressions and Reminiscences Op. 41, Book I, No. 44, Andante PianoCurio, pf Instrument: 1922 Erard, close mic (Pianoteq)
Despite composing plenty of fine chamber works, symphonic poems, and several operas, Fibich is not nearly as recognized today as his Czech composer colleagues Smetana and Dvořák. One possible reason was his relative ambivalence to the Czech national cause in music, stemming from his half-Germanic background and training. Still, his operas form an important part of the Czech-language repertoire, and one of his librettists has everything to do with the music in this video.
After just one year of marriage, Fibich's wife died in 1875, and her dying wish was for him to marry her sister, a successful operatic singer. Their marriage was not a happy one, and in 1892 Fibich began to fall in love with his new piano student, Anežka Schulzová, who was 18 years his junior. The two began a passionate affair and Fibich left his wife for Schulzová in 1895 (she also wrote the libretti for his later operas). By then, Fibich was in the habit of outpouring his "Moods, Impressions and Reminiscences" of their relationship through a kind of musical diary in the form of piano pieces. Not only did the publication of these accessible, bite-size works help pay the bills, but they also became a manifestation of the couple's romance, with many of them supposedly inspired by the intimate details of Schulzová's dress and bodily appearance. Of course, Fibich published the pieces without their original erotic titles (most pieces from the op. 41 set are subtitled "Study for the opera 'The Storm'") and so the original meanings are lost, but their absence only adds to the curiously evocative quality of these enchanting sketches.
Stunningly, Fibich wrote 376 of these "Moods, Impressions and Reminiscences" between 1892 and 1899, the last of 24 which were published posthumously, indicating that he might have kept going had he lived longer. They range from several bars to several minutes long. The melody of no. 139, in D-flat, became one of Fibich's most famous works, "Poeme." Pianist Marian Lapsansky recorded the complete set in twelve volumes, but the recording here is my own. No. 44 has always been my favorite of the set, though it has been some time since I listened to all of them and there are many others worth discovering.
Stay curious! You never know what you'll uncover.Koechlins spectral pianism – A unique voicePianoCurio2024-09-25 | Charles Koechlin (1867–1950) Les heures persanes, Op. 65 (1913–1919) X. Roses au soleil de midi [Roses in the midday sun] PianoCurio, pf
Charles Koechlin was just one of many early-20th century modernists who forged a new musical path, not as an end to tonality, but as an extension of it in a "spectral" harmonic language. Koechlin's music can sound at once luminous and mysterious, transparent and hazy, of its time yet unique. Like Scriabin, he independently developed one of the most distinct tonal dialects of his era.
While the harmonies in this piece (beautiful as they are) might sound foreign to anyone hearing Koechlin for the first time, the elongated melodies are quite direct and suspended over the glowing texture. In this piece, the composer depicts roses glimmering in the midday sun, an common type of subject in its time (Koechlin also contributed to the much overdone poetic image of "clair de lune").
Most of Koechlin’s piano music lives between ppp and mf, rarely calling for the instrument’s loudest dynamics. This makes the difference between 'pianissimo' and 'mezzo-piano' much more important to convey so that the music retains dynamic contrast and never sounds flat. Expression markings like “tranquil,” “sweet,” and “luminous” give a clear idea of Koechlin’s poetic inspirations and musical intentions.
Note the exposed parallel 5ths at 01:49, a common feature of Koechlin's style, as well as their near constant appearance in the harmonic texture. While Koechlin was by no means the only composer of his era exploring the sonorities of parallel 5ths (Debussy's Sunken Cathedral Prelude is just one famous reference), the bare presentation of them here is more unique to his style.This dark gothic prelude belongs in a museumPianoCurio2024-09-22 | Surely there must be room, in the ever-expanding global repository of music we admire, to display and experience such an inspired piece.
Louis Vierne (1870–1937) 12 Préludes for piano, Op. 36 (1914–15) VII. Evocation d'un jour d'angoisse [Evocation of a Day of Anguish] PianoCurio, pf
Louis Vierne, principally known for his organ works, wrote some of his finest music for piano. Born nearly blind with congenital cataracts, Vierne was the favorite student of Charles-Marie Widor and went on to teach Nadia Boulanger Maurice Duruflé, among many others, at the Conservatoire. He served as the organist at the Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris for 37 years until his death there while performing his 1,750th recital; during an improvisation near the end, he slumped over and struck a low pedal E that resounded throughout the cathedral.
Vierne wrote most of his piano preludes between the outbreak of World War I in 1914 and a romantic breakup in May 1915. His two sons, one still a minor, left to join the war effort. The preludes reflect both fond memories (no. 4, "Memory of a Day of Joy" and no. 5, "Nostalgia) as well as painful ones (no. 10, "On a Grave" and no. 11, "Farewell"). They are all of remarkable quality and demonstrate a distinct personal voice.
Evocation of a Day of Anguish, no. 7 of the set, is a hauntingly gorgeous piece that deserves to transcend from obscurity as much has any other lesser-known piano work. It opens with a pair of voices in contrary motion; one ascends, the other sinks chromatically, an both return to form an elegant mirrored arch. Vast spans of arpeggiated harmonies transition into an austere, gothic tolling of octaves, like a hallucination of foreboding bells. After dispelling this grim omen, the scene eventually reaches a warm resolution, moving beyond the ordeal with a final gesture of benediction.
00:00 The evocation 01:04 Episode 02:40 The second evocation 03:40 Episode 04:50 The blessingSome say this melody is still going after 117 yearsPianoCurio2024-09-20 | ...Can you hear the orchestration?PianoCurio2024-09-19 | ...How to bring the house down in 1866PianoCurio2024-09-18 | Another gem from Georges Mathias, who was evidently a first-rate pianist.
Georges Mathias (1826–1910) Cossack March, No. 1 from Three Characteristic Marches for piano four hands, Op. 37 PianoCurio, pf Instrument: 1899 Bechstein (Pianoteq)
This is a cossack march, according to the composer, but could its theme not also double as the score for an early-Hollywood cowboy western film? The rollicking pace, galloping sixteenths, and hokey optimism fit the Wild West atmosphere all too perfectly. Of course, we hear the typical 19-century techniques of elongating the action in circle-of-fifths sequences and scale passages with oom-pah accompaniment, but Mathias also utilizes some syncopated chromaticism to keep things both brilliant and interesting.
Mathias' Cossack March is a perfect example of the mid-19th century virtuoso duet encore/finale, a more popular subgenre than many might imagine since they are not played very often today. Tastes change, and for the last century this music would have been considered a symptom of Romantic excess; another shortfall of the obsession with technique and trite brilliance over compositional depth. But regardless of more modern views, 19th-century audiences LOVED this stuff. It was their musical candy, empty calories surely, but enjoyable nonetheless.
So, let's indulge ourselves for three minutes and imagine a time when it was normal for concertgoers to roar with enthusiasm (often mid-performance) upon hearing a difficult passage executed with brio, or stand and demand a repeat of the movement on the spot, or (most horrendously for many people today) CLAP between movements!
If you've never heard of Mathias, I made a first recording of his piano piece "Intrada" in this video: youtu.be/fiQC8T8lybY
00:00 Intro 00:12 Cowboy theme 00:49 Episode 01:09 Spinning 5ths 01:20 Development and pedal point climax 01:41 The anti-climax; theme returns 02:02 Theme (brilliant variation) 02:10 Episode (brilliant variation) 02:31 Victorious codaIf only he had lived past age 36...PianoCurio2024-09-15 | The melancholy hope of a gravely ill young composer.
Gabriel Dupont (1878–1914) Les Heures Dolentes (1903–1905) II. Le soir tombe dans la chambre PianoCurio, pf
Bedridden from a bout of tuberculosis, the disease that would eventually claim his life eleven years later, 25-year-old Dupont composed this serene piece for piano, one in a set of fourteen. It describes a sense of bittersweet melancholy, which accompanies the fall of evening while isolated in a bedchamber.
At the time of writing this music, Dupont was poised for a great career in music. During the prior ten years, he had studied composition at the Conservatoire with Massenet and Widor and, in 1901, won second prize in the Prix de Rome competition (behind André Caplet but ahead of Maurice Ravel). Even in his mid-twenties, Dupont's style was already developed in its embrace of French modernism. 36 years of life was all too short for an artist of such promise, but he had enough time to leave behind many major works in a variety of genres, from piano works to operas.
00:00 The positive theme 00:34 The first episode 01:33 The negative theme 02:08 The second episode 02:19 The dead end 02:48 The return 03:28 The ascent 03:53 The resolutionWhy Beethoven used more pedal (sometimes) – historical vs. modern piano comparisonPianoCurio2024-09-11 | Beethoven wrote passages with extended pedal markings increasingly in his mid- to late-era piano music. The topic is a complex one, encompassing the both the evolution of the piano and Beethoven's stylistic development over his lifetime. This is a broad-level demonstration of how Beethoven's notated pedaling was best suited to the types of pianos on which he played and composed. This increase in pedaling (by no means reflected in all of Beethoven's piano works) was a stepping stone towards the later 19th-century reliance on the pedal as the "soul" of the piano.
In this video, I recorded (via Pianoteq) three passages with long pedal markings from Beethoven's sonatas: once on a modern Bösendorfer piano, and then again on an 1812 Schöffstoss piano. I used identical microphone, room, and reverb settings to provide a direct comparison. Once you hear how the originally notated pedaling (played as written in first editions) sounds muddy on a modern grand and clearer on a historical piano, you will understand why modern instruments require a modified approach. Today, of course, we compensate with more frequent pedal lifts and shadings, but the result is not quite what was notated. You will hear the modern piano version played without pedal compensation (too muddy) as a demonstration of these different characteristics.
Beethoven's lifetime saw the development from pianos with knee levers to those with foot pedals, and he likely wrote all of these sonatas on knee-lever pianos. While the historical instrument in this video features a pedal and was not owned by Beethoven himself, its comparable sustaining power does well to represent the kind of piano that Beethoven would have been familiar with. It is just one example of an instrument that Beethoven's music would have been played on during his lifetime. I chose it because it is one of the more well-suited pianos for this repertoire in Pianoteq’s library.
As it was called to my attention in the Beethoven 7 pianos video, the composer's tuning fork (one of them, at least) is preserved today and rings an A of around 455.4 Hz, significantly higher than the modern 440. Tuning was not standardized in his time like in ours, so a variety of tunings would have been heard. I used the 455.4 Hz tuning for the historical piano in this video as an added touch, though it is unclear if Beethoven's fork has warped over the centuries to produce a different frequency from the original.
Ever since coming across this piece, I have thought of it as the "Anti" Minute Waltz: the brisk tempo and whirling melodic line of Chopin's original are here transformed into a minor-key photo negative with twisting chromatic descents. It is impossible to say whether Amy Beach had this in mind when composing the piece, but it is how I hear it nonetheless.
Beach's biographer, Adrienne Fried Block, wrote a compelling description of the piece:
"Everything in nature had Beach's passionate attention, be it a bird's song, or the brilliant colors of autumn, or a summer garden. In "From Grandmother's Garden," each piece describes a flower. "Honeysuckle," the final number of the suite, describes a twisting vine with flowers that exude an intensely sweet scent. It can be the bane of gardeners, however: by its endless expansion it chokes off other plants. Its musical analogue is a fast waltz with cross-rhythms, twisting melodic lines, and abrupt modulations that suggest continuous spread. The contrasting section is a bitter-sweet waltz melody marked by dissonance, and accompanied by a chromatic descending figure. The title of the suite, "From Grandmother's Garden," suggests a sentimental look backwards; nevertheless, the music is contemporary [for 1922], even forward-looking in its harmonies."What do you hear in the music of Chopin’s student?PianoCurio2024-09-03 | ...Tell me Chopin was your teacher in one etudePianoCurio2024-09-03 | Georges Mathias (1826–1910) Intrada from 12 pièces symphoniques, Op. 58 (ca. 1878) PianoCurio, pf
This is a nice and quite difficult piece by a devotee of Chopin that aspires to Chopin's pianistic values: elegant velocity, nuanced polyrhythms, brilliance without excess, and avoidance of the shallow salon style.
While Mathias was not always a very interesting composer (I find most of the other 11 pieces in his Op. 58 relentlessly boring), he was an excellent pianist who very much idealized Chopin's style and sought to pass it down to his students. Though it is not an etude by name, this Intrada nonetheless resembles a study (the term "étude" was used rather broadly in the 19th century to denote nearly any mono-textured piece that posed technical challenges). The trickiest part about it is the recurring 8-against-3 polyrhythm that must be achieved smoothly at speed, a common feature in Chopin's music. Interestingly, the theme and its toccata-like texture happen to resemble Debussy's Doctor Gradus ad Parnassum, published 30 years later in 1908. It is possible that Debussy knew of this piece beforehand; he attended the Conservatoire beginning in 1872 during Mathias' tenure there as a piano professor. Mathias was a respected figure and his music would have been widely consumed among Conservatoire pianists.
In addition to studying piano with Chopin, Georges Mathias was also a pupil of Kalkbrenner and a graduate of the Conservatoire, where he became Professor of Piano from 1862–1887. He instructed countless students including Teresa Carreño, Paul Dukas, Isidor Philipp, and Erik Satie.The radiant poetry of Mel Bonis Mélisande for pianoPianoCurio2024-09-01 | In 1898, four years before Debussy famously set Maeterlinck’s symbolist play Pelléas et Mélisande to music, French composer Mel Bonis published a stunning piano portrait inspired by its titular female protagonist. The performance and annotated commentary of Bonis’ music in this video are my own and they may not be exactly how the composer viewed her work. Nonetheless, I hope they help convey some meaning behind this neglected music that is beginning to be more widely played. Bonis herself noted in the margin of her music catalog that this work was her favorite, and rightfully so, for it balances warmth, depth, and brevity to leave a glowing impression.
Mel Bonis (1858–1937) Mélisande, from 5 pieces for piano, Op. 109, No. 5
Subscribe for more original recordings of forgotten gems of the piano repertoire.
#piano #classicalpiano #womencomposersWidor’s catchy Turkish march for pianoPianoCurio2024-08-29 | ...The French Sequel to Schumanns Carnaval: 12 pieces for piano by C.-M. Widor (1891)PianoCurio2024-08-28 | Widor’s most expansive piano suite.
Carnaval: 12 pieces pour piano, Op. 61 (1891) by Charles-Marie Widor
Not only was Charles-Marie Widor (1844-1937) an iconic organist and accomplished pianist, but he was also a highly sought-after composer of opera, ballet, and incidental music in the 1880s and 90s. Carnaval, a set of twelve extraordinarily original and diverse piano pieces, comes from the height of this successful period. The writing is utterly theatrical, as if Widor were composing a ballet suite and decided to condense the entire pit orchestra into a piano score. Widor’s mature, fluent compositional style shines as he persistently develops themes and produces intricate variations, often to the point of sheer unpredictability. Nuanced rhythms and agile counterpoint abound and frequent excursions to remote key areas showcase the composer’s sleight of hand with late-romantic musical syntax. Framed by two outer works of festive grandeur, the inner movements present a variety of scenes, people, and national dances evoking the processions of Carnival celebrations.
I. Kettledrums and Trumpets. The parade approaches with the dull pounding of timpani, an unusual main theme that becomes more attractive as it develops throughout this overture, complemented by scraps of trumpet fanfares and capped with rapid piccolo scales in the final coda.
II. Flirtation. Amidst the crowd of festival goers we meet a flirting personality, one who charms and teases us while retreating into ever more remote key areas and finally disappearing, leaving us enchanted by echoes of the first blush.
III. Masked ball. A lively, light-footed waltz-scherzo takes a comic misstep through duple meter before regaining composure and building through several varied refrains. A sighing cantabile theme emerges with lush orchestration and expressive outbursts. The accelerated coda lands on its feet with panache.
IV. Rosita. The first of three unspecified female portraits in the suite. It possibly refers to Rosita Mauri, the prima ballerina in Widor’s extremely popular ballet La Korrigane from 1880. A gentle waltz in G searches for and discovers the warmth of an Eb Major chanson at the heart of the piano’s range. The melody wanders off into a dizzying cadenza before continuing with a variation of the waltz theme. A vivace coda ties a wildly capricious bow on this character sketch.
V. Turkish Entry. The first of a series of national portraits. An alluring march alla turca with a dotted, two-step gait opens up into a delightfully toe-tapping middle section. A gem.
VI. Zanetto. Mascagni’s 40-minute operatic lyric scene of the same name premiered several years after Widor’s Carnaval, but perhaps they both based their Zanettos on the same beloved Renaissance-era roaming minstrel character. A rustic melody with strummed accompaniment gives way to several improvisatory gestures. B major dissolves into Ab major as a serene berceuse arises with adoring variations in its wake.
VII. Viennese. A graceful street song that frolics through accented dissonances with a carefree demeanor.
VIII. Polish Entry. The characteristic polonaise rhythm leads a couple of brief but heroic cavalry charges. A da capo marking returns us to the preceding Viennese movement.
IX. Hungarian. A stern, pesante theme in bass octaves, punctuated by thorny acciaccatura echoes, opens this triple-themed portrait. A wistful folk song in A major eases the tension between reprises when there suddenly appears a rhapsodic duet of longing beauty, an unexpected treasure before returning to the beginning material.
X. Bohemian woman. The woman’s alluring dance alternates between two nimble refrains, the second of which exoticizes the whole-and-a-half-step jump between A# and G.
XI. Francesca. Widor’s Liebestraum with clear influences of late Liszt. The most expansive slow movement of the set is an indulgent and passionate romance with a spacious melody of noble repose. Structured and paced like an opera aria, this reverie ends with a recitativo sigh and the entwining of two voices within the warm embrace of an F# major sunset.
XII. Finale. The brooding E minor of the overture is now ebullient E major as the orchestra strikes up for the closing ceremonies. The sparkling main theme of this movement reappears throughout in a vibrant array of textures with a particular development of its ornamental trill. An alternate theme in hemiola triplets creates a festive, drumlike effect. Mirroring the approach of the parade in the first movement, the drums fade away into the distance before an eruption of octaves slams Carnaval to a close.
00:00 I. Kettledrums and Trumpets 04:48 II. Flirtation. 07:23 III. Masked Ball. 11:00 IV. Rosita. 13:23 V. Turkish Entry. 15:30 VI. Zanetto. 18:51 VII. Viennese. 19:43 VIII. Polish Entry. 20:43 Da capo Viennese. 21:38 IX. Hungarian. 25:44 X. Bohemian Woman. 27:03 XI. Francesca. 32:49 XII. Finale.
#classicalpiano #classicalmusic #widor⚡️Rameau⚡️🔌🔊PianoCurio2024-08-24 | ...12 year old Beethoven sounded like Mozart…PianoCurio2024-08-22 | ...The secret ending to Liszt’s “Beside a spring” that he added 30 years laterPianoCurio2024-08-21 | ...Liszts ‘Beside a spring’ in two versions on period pianosPianoCurio2024-08-16 | This experimental video contrasts the original “Au bord d’une source” from Album d'un voyageur (1834–1838), played on an 1835 Pleyel piano, with Liszt’s transformative revision that appeared in Années de pèlerinage (1848–1854), played on an 1852 Streicher piano, plus a bonus coda that Liszt added in 1863 played on an 1899 Bechstein. With the exception of the last one, the pianos that I chose (from Pianoteq) represent the time of composition/revision rather than the exact instruments that Liszt would have composed and played on. Nonetheless, had someone bought these works off the shelf at their times of publication, it is plausible that their instruments sounded similar to those heard in this video, and that’s pretty cool.
Liszt’s revisions in the second version are primarily textural rather than structural: rolling bass arpeggios are replaced by staccato hand crossings in the upper register, the cadenzas are refined and more varied, and the piece is overall much easier to play with a renewed sparkle to its effect. That being said, I have always had a soft spot for the first version and it certainly deserves a hearing every once in a while or to complement other pieces from Liszt’s early virtuoso period. Both versions capture, by different means, the poetic excerpt from Schiller that Liszt quotes in the epigraph: “In the whispering coolness begins young nature’s play.”
Liszt very much admired the Roman pianist and composer Giovanni Sgambati (1841-1914), whom he taught in the 1860s. Before Sgambati was to perform a concert featuring Au bord d’une source in December 1863, Liszt sent him a note on which he sketched a meditative addendum for the final coda, which is hardly ever heard but presented here on an 1899 Bechstein piano (this is the next closest 19th-century piano in Pianoteq’s library, excluding the 1858 NY Steinway square piano that didn’t quite fit the character needed here).
Franz Liszt - Au bord d'une source 1st version: S.156/3, 1834-1838 (played on an 1835 Pleyel piano) 2nd version: S.160/4 1848-1855 (played on an 1852 Streicher piano) 3rd version/added coda: S160/4bis, 1863 (Played on an 1899 Bechstein piano)
The performance alternates between versions 1 and 2, with the added coda at the very end.
00:00 Title 00:04 Theme 00:42 First cadenza 01:00 Variations set I 01:45 Second cadenza 02:14 Variations set II 03:07 Third cadenza 03:18 Variations set III 03:30 Build & culmination 04:05 Reprise 04:23 Coda 05:09 1863 coda addition
#musichistory #classicalpiano #classicalmusicPlaying Beethoven on 7 pianos from his lifetimePianoCurio2024-08-04 | Representing nearly all of the pianofortes in Pianoteq's library from Beethoven's lifetime, this video features my own performances of selected piano works composed around the time each piano was manufactured. I picked works that Beethoven composed as nearly as possible to the date of each piano. I was limited to Pianoteq's library, so there is a glaring gap between 1796-1808 when Beethoven composed some of his finest piano works. Nonetheless, you can still hear a general outline of his stylistic development. As for the pianos, you'll hear lots of variance in characteristics between each instrument but not necessarily a linear "evolution." This selection of instruments portrays some of the many personalities of pianos in Beethoven's day, but does not represent a comprehensive exploration of them.
Beethoven's ages relate to the time of composition, not the date of the piano. I included some transitional preludes to protect your ears from any abrupt key changes, my treat.
00:00 Sonata WoO 47, No. 1 on a 1780 Schmidt 01:01 Selected Variations on 'Venni Amore' on a 1790 Walter 03:06 Sonata No. 3, Scherzo on a 1795 Donhal 04:40 Sonata No. 5, Finale on a 1796 Broadwood 06:16 Sonata No. 26, 'Les Adieux', mvt. I on an 1808 Weimes 08:42 Sonata No. 27 in E minor, mvt. II on an 1812 Schöffstoss 11:35 Six Bagatelles, Op. 126, III. Andante Cantabile on an 1826 Graf
If you like the sound of these instruments, I recommend Ronald Brautigam's exquisite recordings of Beethoven the fortepiano.
#musichistory #classicalpiano #classicalmusicEduard Schütt - Andante Cantabile and Scherzino for two pianos, Op. 79PianoCurio2024-07-28 | Eduard Schütt (1856-1933) Andante Cantabile and Scherzino for two pianos, Op. 79 (1907)
00:00 Andante Cantabile 04:55 Scherzino
Created with Pianoteq (Bösendorfer 280VC Piano I and NY Steinway D Piano II)
My recent personal discovery of Eduard Schütt's piano music has been one of the most immediately rewarding excursions into the obscure piano repertoire. One encounters so much derivative junk in the late 19th and early 20th century literature before finally unearthing a pearl. Schütt specialized in a kind of suave, indulgent melodicism that gave a special poignancy to his andantes and adagios, always underscored by rich, late-romantic harmonies. His style recalls both the attractive melodies of Lyadov and the sliding chromatic harmonies of Stenhammar. Perhaps the Andante Cantabile and Scherzino for two pianos were originally supposed to form the inner movements of a sonata or concerto, but they work nicely as a standalone pair.
#classicalmusic #classicalpianoRameaus Gavotte but each variation is played on a newer pianoPianoCurio2024-07-21 | Jean-Philippe Rameau’s Gavotte et six doubles was meant to be played on a harpsichord, but it can sound great on a number of keyboard instruments. Using Pianoteq’s virtually modeled instruments, I performed each of these famous variations on a different historical instrument to demonstrate the significant advances of the piano over time. Though the modern piano is an excellent instrument, there are many fascinating colors and characters produced by 19th-century instruments that merit further exploration. There are surely more noteworthy instruments than those represented here and this is intended to be entertaining/educational rather than comprehensive.
00:00 Blanchet harpsichord (1733) 01:21 Walter pianoforte (1790) 02:27 Pleyel piano (1835) 03:33 Erard piano (1849) 04:46 Bechstein piano (1899) 05:41 Yamaha CP-80 electro-acoustic piano (1970s) 06:34 Modern Steinway Model D piano (New York)
#classicalpiano #classicalmusic #musichistoryAlex. Voormolen (“The Dutch Ravel”) - Suite de clavecin pour pianoPianoCurio2024-07-13 | Alexander Voormolen (1895-1980) Suite de clavecin pour piano (1921)
PianoCurio, pf
00:00 I. Ouverture - Grave et noble 02:24 II. Gigue - Très vite et léger 03:28 III. Sicilienne - Lentement et tendrement 05:37 IV. Toccatina - Très vite
Voormolen, a respected composer in his native Netherlands during the early 20th century, could reasonably be described as "The Dutch Ravel" (my own term). He did not study with Ravel directly, but the two became acquainted in 1915 when Voormolen moved to Paris to study with Roussel. I find Voormolen's music to be finely written and certainly evocative of French impressionism, though with its own individual character. The Toccatina finale recalls elements of Debussy's Jardins sous la pluie, and the Sicilienne is a gem. The whole suite is compact and generally satisfying, and while the slow movements are easy to play and fall beautifully under the fingers, the quicker ones have many awkward spots that need to be ironed out by the pianist. The composer suggests that this suite could also be played on a harpsichord.
Subscribe for more hidden gems of classical piano, rare piano works, and rare recordings.
#classicalpiano #classicalmusicFranz Neruda - Variations in B minor, dedicated to Edvard Grieg, Op. 49PianoCurio2024-06-24 | Franz Neruda (1843-1915) Variations on a Theme in B minor, Op. 49 (c.1890) Dedicated to Edvard Grieg
PianoCurio, pf
00:00 Theme 02:19 Var. I, Animato 04:45 Var. II, Presto 05:55 Var. III, Moderato assai 08:29 Var. IV, Allegro vivace 09:55 Var. V, Andantino tranquillo 12:46 Var. VI, Adagio 14:47 Var. VII e coda, Allegro moderato (Quasi Romanza)
Subscribe for more rare piano music, obscure classical piano gems, and original first recordings.
#classicalpiano #classicalmusic #pianomusicFriedrich Kiel - Duet for solo piano, Op. 18 No. 3PianoCurio2024-06-11 | Friedrich Kiel (1821-1885) - Duet for solo piano, Op. 18 No. 3 (1860)
If you were a German composer in the mid-nineteenth century, chances are you wrote at least several pieces of music in “canon-form” or “canon-style,” where a melody is chased by its twin that lingers just a few steps behind. It is easy to see why the vogue for canons arose from the same German musicians who prized academic fugue-writing as a show of skill and knowledge: canons are clever like witty plays on words, they pose a tricky set of problems for the composer who must harmonize beneath a mirror-like texture, yet when they are well-done, canons can be exceptionally pleasing and accessible (unlike most fugues) even in one hearing.
Cross this academic fad with a popular domestic genre at the time, the song without words, where a solo pianist imitates one or two singers with keyboard accompaniment, and you get something like this piece by Friedrich Kiel. Kiel was far from the first or last to contribute to the the solo piano canon-duet microgenre; Mendelssohn, Alkan, and Fauré (whose Romance sans paroles in A-flat is probably the most famous one) were among the crowd of composers who wrote fine examples. The formula is nearly identical in all of them—a brief introduction, a simple accompaniment, two voices spinning out a few minutes of catchy material, and a symmetrical coda.
Subscribe for more rare piano music, obscure classical piano gems, and original first recordings.
#classicalpiano #classicalmusic #pianomusicWhen one piano isn’t enoughPianoCurio2024-05-31 | #classicalpiano #classicalmusic
Excerpt from the first movement of Anton Rubinstein’s Fantasy in F minor for two pianos (1864)Anton Rubinstein - Fantasy for two pianos in F minor, Op. 73PianoCurio2024-05-30 | Anton Rubinstein (1829-1894) Fantasy for two pianos in F minor, Op. 73 (1864)
(00:00) I. Lento—Allegro con fuoco (F minor) (13:18) II. Moderato—Allegro vivace (A♭ major) (19:52) III. Andante con moto (12 variations) (F minor, ends F major)
PianoCurio, pf
The brothers Anton and Nikolai Rubinstein were monarchs of Russian Romantic-era pianism. Unlike most European countries by the mid-nineteenth century, Russia had no conservatory dedicated to training its young musicians until 1862, when Anton Rubinstein founded the Saint Petersburg Conservatory. Nikolai followed suit in 1866 by co-founding the Moscow Conservatory. Thus both Rubinsteins felt compelled to mold the future generations of Russian musicians as administrators of national institutions. They certainly made their impressions on young composers; Tchaikovsky wrote that Anton played piano “like a god,” while the young Rachmaninoff noted that his playing “gripped my whole imagination and had a marked influence on my ambition as a pianist.” Yet Nikolai reportedly possessed an even more impressive technique than Anton. Each brother had his strengths; Nikolai was more refined and even while Anton’s more inspired, impulsive performances made great impressions wherever he toured.
Nikolai Rubinstein is also notable for being the would-be dedicatee of what is now the world’s most famous piano concerto—Tchaikovsky’s first. Instead, Nikolai completely trashed Tchaikovsky’s first draft, deeming it technically unplayable and formally hideous. Anton, who taught the young Tchaikovsky in Saint Petersburg, also frequently lobbed harsh critiques at his precocious student’s early attempts at composition. These criticisms of such a fine composer may appear ridiculous with today’s hindsight, but they demonstrate the idyllic, often impossible musical ideals towards which the Rubinstein brothers strove their entire careers.
Anton dedicated this Fantasy for two pianos to his brother Nikolai, presumably for the two to perform together. It would have made for a historic occasion on two counts: the spectacle of two pianistic titans interpreting such a virtuosically ambitious work, and the fact that this incredible suite would remain virtually unknown ever since.
Subscribe for more hidden gems of classical piano, rare piano works, and rare recordings.
#classicalpiano #classicalmusicTheodor Kullak - Nachtgesang (Night-Song) for piano, Op. 92 no. 2PianoCurio2024-05-22 | Theodor Kullak (1818-1882) Nachtgesang (Night-Song) for piano, Op. 92 no. 2 (1854) From a set of two piano pieces titled "Violets"
PianoCurio, pf
Theodor Kullak's modern reputation mainly rests on his pedagogical exercises and editorship of Chopin's complete works, but an examination of his music reveals a highly refined Romantic pianist-composer who possessed solid craftsmanship and a flair for dramatic performances. Here we have an encore-worthy concert nocturne that shares many characteristics with Liszt's Consolations (published in 1850, just four years before Kullak's Nachtgesang), specifically the characteristic blend of dreamy melodic phrases and impassioned outbursts, all tied together with a central cadenza. Yet where its originality lacks, this sensuously intimate Nachtgesang can produce a fine effect given the right atmosphere and performance.
Subscribe for more rare piano works and musical gems by obscure composers and pianists #classicalpiano #classicalmusic #romanticpianoIf Bach wrote Romantic-era #piano musicPianoCurio2024-05-02 | ...Ignaz Moscheles - Pastorale in the Organ-Style for piano, Op. 135PianoCurio2024-05-01 | Ignaz Moscheles (1794-1870) Pastorale im Orgel-Style, Op. 135 (1860)
PianoCurio, pf
A neo-Baroque love letter to the style of Bach, composed by an early-romantic pianist in the twilight of his career.
Subscribe for more of the best obscure piano works, rare piano recordings and hidden piano gems.
Alfred Grünfeld enjoyed a position as one of the most sought-after salon pianists in fin-de-siècle Vienna, when light and showy piano music ubiquitously wafted through social gatherings of the aristocratic elite. He could charm with his wit in conversation just as much as with his limpid performances at the piano. His more than 100 compositions for solo piano comprise of exactly what you'd expect: attractive music that aims to please at first hearing with dashes of virtuosic flourishes throughout. But Grünfeld was not a mere crowd-pleasing hack; his surviving recordings demonstrate a refined technique of infinite subtlety, which suited perfectly for the intimate, if shallow, repertoire in which he specialized.
In the Spanish Serenade, Op. 37, Grünfeld adds another contribution to an exasperatingly popular 19th-century trend: Spanish exoticism. Hallmarks of the style include harmonic minor keys, imitations of strumming guitars, sensuous harmonic progressions, and improvisatory, cadenza-like gestures, all of which appear in this charming piece.hey Siri play Alkan but make it sound kinda Brazilian #piano #classicalmusicPianoCurio2024-04-23 | ...Alkans Tropical Fever Dream for piano four hands (Sérénade Op. 74)PianoCurio2024-04-20 | Alkan's Tropical Fever Dream for piano four hands (based on the solo piano Sérenade from Les Mois, Op. 74 No. 5) Arranged April 19-20, 2024 by PianoCurio
Alkan's Sérénade from Les Mois, Op. 74 has been begging for a remix since 1840 (I'm not the first to think of it). I thought it would sound great with the Brazilian textures from the third movement of Milhaud's Scaramouche.