Nigel Baldwin
Flame tests using cotton buds DSCN0349
updated
A level Chemistry practical to produce an organic solid and purify it.
One required practical on the A level Chemistry syllabus that is widely used is the production of aspirin by the reaction of 2-hydroxybenzoic acid with ethanoic anhydride.
But, what to do if ethanoic anhydride is banned in your location?
One possibility is to do a hydrolysis of aspirin, essentially the reverse of the above mentioned reaction.
In this video clip 6 aspirin tablets and 100ml of sodium hydroxide, 0.4M are used. The reaction was stirred overnight at room temperature, around 26 C.
The next day the reaction mixture was acidified using 25ml of hydrochloric acid, 2M. The product of the reaction precipitated out and was removed by filtration under reduced pressure.
Next steps, not shown in the video clip, are to dry the filtered solid and then recrystallise from ethanol.
In another experiment, the precipitated solid was allowed to dry over the weekend. It was then dissolved in the minimum volume of hot ethanol, filtered and allowed to crystallise. A sample from this procedure had a melting point within 1 C of commercial 2-hydroxybenzoic acid in the school chemical store.
Recrystallised solid 149 C
Chemical store 2-hydroxybenzoic acid 150 C
Both of these values recorded by A level chemistry students in the school laboratory are below the accepted literature value.
e.g. Melting point of 2-hydroxybenzoic acid 158.6 C Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salicylic_acid
Unfortunately, we were unable to carry out a thin layer chromatography experiment to investigate the purity of the hydrolysis product further.
Thanks to Dr Gavan Cooke for operating the vacuum pump for reduced pressure filtration using a Buchner funnel seen at the end of the video clip.
If we were to repeat the experiment we would acidify the hydrolysis mixture more gradually.
KAKW4470
Wear safety spectacles and carry out behind safety screen
Background video clip
A small scale reaction between iron oxide, aluminium powder and magnesium ribbon.
See details in the video clip
UWFI7062
Microscale Thermite reaction
Wear safety spectacles and carry out in a fume cupboard or behind perspex safety screens as available.
See 9.2(c) Microscale Thermite, page 33 of CLEAPSS Safer chemicals, safer reactions L195 April 2023
For the Thermite mixture we used 0.75g of iron (III) oxide mixed with 0.25g aluminium powder
We found the aluminium powder needs to be just that, a fine powder, because the reaction simply did not work with a coarse grain aluminium powder.
Also, we used 0.35g to 0.40g of barium nitrate igniter. This fell well below the maximum 0.45g mass of igniter mentioned by CLEAPSS. Since we did not have any magnesium powder we did not add any to the barium nitrate igniter.
We didn't have any small filter papers and found paper towel used for drying hands would suffice. A small piece of paper towel was wrapped around the end of a finger, the end of the paper towel twisted off to form a sealed end and then pushed into some sand whilst still on the finger. Pull out your finger whilst easing off the paper and the paper thimble should remain in the sand.
A 7 to 8cm length of magnesium ribbon was curled into a spiral, similar to how one might picture a coiled snake with raised head and placed in the paper thimble.
The Thermite mixture was dropped on top of the coiled magnesium using a steel spatula. One can use the spatula to pat down the mixture a little if one wishes.
The igniter was then dropped on top of the mixture around where the magnesium ribbon snake was raising its head.
Finally, the magnesium was lit using a Bunsen burner flame and the result was quite pleasing.
You never know what you are going to get with BZ reactions.
This one was particularly nice. Unfortunately, I only captured 21 seconds of shaky handheld footage after a Year 9 Chemistry class.
Safety
This experiment should be done in a fume cupboard
The bromine water test is on our IGCSE Chemistry specification as a required practical. And yet the procurement of bromine water can be problematic.
A quick substitute for bromine water on a small scale can be improvised using household bleach, 2M hydrochloric acid and potassium bromide solution.
Lot's of interesting chemistry to discuss and the bromine generated is decolourised by the addition of an alkene quite nicely.
I am sure this has been done many times before.
After a discussion with Dr Colin Dickinson
IGCSE Chemistry
Identify the three colourless gases in the video clip from their test results
Please note that I didn't get any of the chemicals on my hands whilst making the video clip.
Thanks to Dr Gavan Cooke for filming this one
Quick revision clip of the reactions of lithium, sodium and potassium metals in water
IGCSE Chemistry
Making crystals
Three samples of crystals made by IGCSE Chemistry students in lessons
Questions - What reactants could you use to make these compounds in an IGCSE Chemistry practical class?
1 sodium ethanoate
2 sodium chloride
3 ammonium sulfate
In each case the salts were made in an acid + alkali reaction carried out in a 100ml beaker.
Small volumes of the alkali were added to a approximately 20ml of dilute acid using a plastic dropping pipette. The pH change was monitored after each addition of alkali by sampling with a glass stirring rod and spotting onto Universal Indicator paper.
Answers
1 sodium hydroxide and ethanoic acid
2 sodium hydroxide and hydrochloric acid
3 dilute aqueous ammonia and sulphuric acid
IGCSE Chemistry
Making a salt
Method 1
acid + metal = salt + hydrogen
An excess of magnesium metal is added to a small volume of sulfuric acid in a beaker.
Magnesium reacts with sulfuric acid
Q1 What gas is produced?
Q2 What salt is produced?
The reaction can be monitored by observing the bubbles of colourless gas produced. However, magnesium also reacts slowly with water producing bubbles of the same colourless gas, so it is just as well to monitor the pH using Universal Indicator paper.
The reaction can be stopped by filtering off the excess magnesium metal when the pH reaches 6.
Answers to the questions above
1 Hydrogen gas
2 Magnesium sulphate
The salt produced is usually obtained in it's hydrated form, i.e. it contains water of crsytallisation.
Q3 What is the formula of the most commonly encountered hydrated form of magnesium sulfate?
Answer
Magnesium heptahydrate MgSO4·7H2O
IGCSE Chemistry
Testing for carbon dioxide gas using limewater
Traditional apparatus using a delivery tube and smaller scale apparatus using a cut off bulb from a plastic dropping pipette
The cut off plastic dropping pipette bulbs are easy to wash out and re-use.
Safety
Wear safety spectacles, lab coat and gloves
Fun with iron III thiocyanate
the dark red one that is sometimes called fake blood
After chatzida 8 minutes of joy with Chemistry experiments
experiment number 3 The Bleeding Heart
youtu.be/NOiHE_9a2Mc
Thank you Professor Chatzidakis
requirements
3% hydrogen peroxide, 250ml in a beaker
approx. 1.5g potassium thiocyanate
a length of steel wire, a rusty nail may do
a few drops of 6M hydrochloric acid
instructions
place the hydrogen peroxide in a small beaker
add the potassium thiocyanate and stir until dissolved
bend the steel wire into a desired shape and dangle in the beaker
carefully run drops of 6M HCl down the wire
enjoy the show
comments
one may be able to use a smaller mass of thiocyanate
ammonium thiocyanate was used instead of potassium thiocyanate in the video clip linked in the description above to chatzida
Safety
DO NOT USE 50% hydrogen peroxide, it decomposes very violently and exothermically when mixed with manganese dioxide.
50% hydrogen peroxide should be diluted at least 10X to 5% or less for use in experiments.
Wear safety spectacles, gloves and a lab coat
Factors affecting the rate of a chemical reaction
Topic primer or revision video
What are the four factors that lead to an increased rate of reaction in IGCSE Chemistry courses?
Four reactions in test-tubes
1 Surface area of solid reactants
limestone chips versus powdered calcium carbonate
calcium carbonate and hydrochloric acid
2 Effect of a catalyst
two black powders and hydrogen peroxide
copper II oxide and manganese dioxide
3 Concentration
Magnesium and hydrochloric acid
Dilute acid about 0.1M and concentrated acid 2M
4 Temperature
Hot and cold
Sodium thiosulfate, 0.5ml 0.1M and hydrochloric acid 2ml 2M
Heating iodine
Safety
Heating iodine should always be carried out in a fume cupboard.
It turns into purple iodine gas very easily and this should not be breathed in.
The violet vapour is harmful. It attacks the eyes, skin and lungs.
Iodine is also very toxic to aquatic life.
Experiment
What happens when you heat solid iodine in an evaporating basin using a Bunsen burner?
Does it melt?
Is there any evidence in the video of it turning directly from a solid to a gas? Does it sublime?
Does it have a low melting point or a high melting point?
Research a value for the melting point of iodine
What does the behaviour of iodine on heating tell us about its structure? Is it formed from a giant structure or a small molecule structure?
Key Stage 3 Chemistry resource
For homework or those studying at home
Heating sulfur
or sulphur
Safety
Heating sulfur should always be carried out in a fume cupboard.It burns very easily with a pale blue flame producing toxic sulfur dioxide.Sulfur dioxide is a toxic gas which should not be breathed in.
Experiment
What happens when you heat solid sulfur in a crucible using a Bunsen burner?
Does it melt?
Does it have a low melting point or a high melting point?
Research a value for the melting point of sulfur
What does the melting point of sulfur tell us about its structure? Is it formed from a giant structure or a small molecule structure?
Key Stage 3 Chemistry resource
For homework or those studying at home
How would you separate a mixture of salt and sand?
What techniques would you use?
Key Stage 3 resource video
For homework or those studying at home
Titration
A titration of 25ml of sodium hydroxide of unknown concentration against 1M hydrochloric acid using methyl orange indicator
SafetySafety spectacles must be worn when carrying out the titration0.4M sodium hydroxide is labelled irritant1M hydrochloric acid is labelled irritantAny spillages should be washed off with copious amounts of water immediately
Methyl orange indicator colours
red in acid
yellow in alkali
orange at the endpoint
I describe the colour as peach in the video clip, but you should use the word orange in GCSE chemistry examinations
The video clip is a little jumpy due to my editing
Here's a revision calculation for GCSE Chemistry students
Using the following data obtained from the video clip, calculate the concentration of the sodium hydroxide solution
Table of results
Starting volume 2.4ml
End volume 12.4 ml
Titration volume 10.0ml
The end volume was possibly 12.45 or 12.5 ml but this was not as clear as it should have been on the video clip. This illustrates the need to carry out repeat titrations until two concordant results are obtained.
Two concordant results in this titration experiment would have been two titration volumes with the same value or within 0.1ml of each other.
Titration calculation
The titration equation is
NaOH + HCl = NaCl + H2O
Thus 1 mol NaOH = 1 mol HCl
Step 1 What were the number of moles of HCl used in the titration
Number of moles of HCl = concentration x volume in dm3
10 ml HCl = 0.01dm3 HCl
Number of moles of HCl = 1 x 0.01 = 0.01 mol
Step 2 From the titration equation
0.01 mol HCl = 0.01 mol NaOH
Step 3 What is the concentration of the NaOH
Concentration = number of moles NaOH / volume NaOH
25ml NaOH = 0.025dm3
Concentration = 0.01 / 0.025
= 0.4 M
0.4M = 0.4 mol / dm3
You Tube text descriptions do not allow brackets etc
The experiment was filmed using a smartphone in portrait orientation to facilitate revision on a smartphone
IGCSE Chemistry
Testing anions and cations in solution
Test-tube reactions
1 Three blue solutions labelled 1, 2 and 3
chloride and sulfate tests are carried out
Identify which is the sulfate, which is the chloride and which is the nitrate
Which metal cation produces blue solutions on the IGCSE Chemistry specification
2 Green and orange solutions labelled 4 and 5
addition of sodium hydroxide
and
chloride and sulfate tests are carried out
From the result of the addition of sodium hydroxide you should be able to confirm the identity of the metal cations as listed on the IGCSE Chemistry specification
Then you can identify which is the sulfate and which is the chloride from the results of the further tests
3 Two colourless solutions labelled 6 and 7
addition of a few drops of dilute sodium hydroxide
followed by excess of dilute sodium hydroxide
From the results of the addition of sodium hydroxide you can tell which of the two solutions contains aluminium ions.
The other colourless solution is known to contain either calcium or magnesium ions. Which further test could you carry out to tell which of these two metal ions is in fact present
The IGCSE Chemistry specification mentioned above is the Oxford AQA International GCSE Chemistry specification 9202
See section 3.4.3 Identification of ions
Results
1, 2 and 3 are all pale blue solutions and hence are all copper II salts given the limitations of our specification.
These solutions are also known to be either a nitrate, a chloride or a sulfate
Solution 1
white ppt with acidified barium chloride, therefore this must be a Sulfate
Solution 1 is copper II sulfate
Solution 2
No ppt with either acidified silver nitrate or acidified barium chloride
Therefore, this must be the Nitrate
Solution 2 is copper II nitrate
Solution 3
white ppt with acidified silver nitrate, therefore this must be a Chloride
Solution 3 is copper II chloride
Solution 4
Green solution
green ppt with dilute sodium hydroxide
Iron II
white ppt with acidified barium chloride
sulfate
Solution 4 is iron II sulfate
Solution 5
Orange solution
orange ppt with dilute sodium hydroxide
Iron III
white ppt with acidified silver nitrate
chloride
Solution 5 is iron III chloride
Solutions 6 and 7 were known to contain either magnesium, calcium or aluminium ions
Solution 6
white ppt with dilute sodium hydroxide
ppt did not dissolve in excess sodium hydroxide
therefore this solution contains either magnesium or calcium ions
A flame test should be carried out to differentiate the two possibilities
calcium gives a red orange coloured flame
magnesium does not produce a colour in a blue Bunsen burner flame
Solution 7
white ppt with dilute sodium hydroxide
ppt dissolved in excess dilute sodium hydroxide
therefore this solution contained aluminium ions
A fun little experiment in which a small piece of magnesium ribbon was placed in iron sulfate solution
A displacement reaction occurred
The magnesium soon became attracted to a magnet. Can you explain why?
Write a word equation for the reaction
Write a symbol equation for the reaction based on iron II sulfate
Note
Iron ammonium sulfate was actually used
YouTube does not permit the use of brackets in text
GCSE Chemistry
Testing three unknown white crystalline solids.
The solids were labelled X, Y and Z
If the solids were known to be citric acid, sodium hydrogencarbonate and potassium chloride, which one was which?
Testing for
Solubility in water
pH using Universal Indicator paper
Flame tests
Halide ion test using acidified silver nitrate
Carbonate test
Results
X
dissolved in water quickly
pH 6
a flame test that included lilac, but admittedly there were orange-red colours visible too
a white precipitate with acidified silver nitrate
Y
dissolved in water quickly
pH 2 or 3
no flame colour
no precipitate with acidified silver nitrate
reacted with calcium carbonate to produce bubbles of colourless gas which were presumed to be carbon dioxide
Z
dissolved in water but not as quickly as the others
pH 8
yellow flame colour
orange-red colour was visible on the outside of the flame too
initially produced bubbles of colourless gas and a white precipitate in a first silver nitrate test acidified with 0.1M nitric acid
when acidified with 1M nitric acid in a second silver nitrate test no white precipitate was observed
bubbles of colourless gas were produced on addition of 1M HCl to a solution of Z and when the gas was passed through limewater a white precipitate was produced. Carbon dioxide. Z was a carbonate.
Identifications
X potassium chloride
Y citric acid
Z sodium hydrogencarbonate aka sodium bicarbonate
It would have been nice to have a clearer flame test with X
I did not have any blue glass with which to view the flame colour produced by X although lilac colour was clearly visible
Hydrogen peroxide and dried yeast were used to generate oxygen gas. However, the rate of production of gas was too slow, so a little potassium iodide was added to the mixture and oxygen gas was produced far quicker.
The beaker got very hot and big bubbles of gas were produced.
A glowing splint was introduced into the beaker near the bursting bubbles at the bottom.
The clip was shot at 240fps and should be in Slow motion
The movie clip was shot in portrait mode for viewing on a smartphone. I hope that You Tube doesn't autocorrect the orientation.
Hydrogen peroxide and dried yeast were used to generate oxygen gas. However, the rate of production of gas was too slow, so a little potassium iodide was added to the mixture and oxygen gas was produced far quicker.
The beaker got very hot and big bubbles of gas were produced.
A glowing splint was introduced near the top of the beaker near the bursting bubbles.
The movie clip was shot in portrait mode for viewing on a smartphone. I hope that You Tube doesn't autocorrect the orientation.
Hydrogen peroxide and dried yeast were used to generate oxygen gas. However, the rate of production of gas was too slow, so a little potassium iodide was added to the mixture and oxygen gas was produced far quicker.
The beaker got very hot and big bubbles of gas were produced.
A glowing splint was introduced near the top of the beaker near the bursting bubbles.
The movie clip was shot in portrait mode for viewing on a smartphone. I hope that You Tube doesn't autocorrect the orientation.
Hydrogen peroxide and dried yeast were used to generate oxygen gas. However, the rate of production of gas was too slow, so a little potassium iodide was added to the mixture and oxygen gas was produced far quicker.
The beaker got very hot and big bubbles of gas were produced.
A glowing splint was introduced near the top of the beaker near the bursting bubbles.
This is an edited version of the original clip using iMovie
The movie clip was shot in portrait mode for viewing on a smartphone. I hope that You Tube doesn't autocorrect the orientation.
Displacement reaction
Bubbling chlorine gas into potassium bromide solution
It was filmed in portrait orientation for viewing on a smartphone, I hope YouTube doesn't autocorrect to landscape view
Displacement reaction
Bubbling chlorine gas into potassium iodide solution
It was filmed in portrait orientation for viewing on a smartphone, I hope YouTube doesn't autocorrect to landscape view
Testing for hydrogen gas with a burning wooden splint.
Commonly referred to as the pop test.
The hydrogen gas burns with a small explosion, often producing a squeaky pop sound during the process.
Note that the bung was only placed very loosely on the mouth of the tube and did not make an airtight seal, but did trap enough gas for testing successfully.
Portrait orientation for viewing on a smartphone.
The video clip was shot at 240fps, but I don't know if it will play back in slow motion on You Tube.
At 240 fps one can stop frame and see the gas burning with a flame that extends down into the tube.
Testing for hydrogen gas with a burning wooden splint.
Commonly referred to as the pop test.
The hydrogen gas burns with a small explosion, often producing a squeaky pop sound during the process.
Portrait orientation for viewing on a smartphone.
Testing for oxygen with a glowing splint
Hydrogen peroxide and a small amount of manganese dioxide were used to generate the oxygen in a conical flask
Portrait orientation for viewing on a smartphone
Testing for oxygen with a glowing splint
Hydrogen peroxide and a small amount of manganese dioxide were used to generate the oxygen in a conical flask
Portrait orientation for viewing on a smartphone
Limewater test for carbon dioxide
Portrait orientation for viewing on a smartphone
Video clip with sound, portrait orientation
Using limewater to test for carbon dioxide
Carbon dioxide is produced by reacting calcium carbonate with dilute hydrochloric acid in a test-tube.
The gas is sampled using a plastic dropping pipette and bubbled through limewater.
Limewater is a solution of calcium hydroxide, which is sparingly soluble in water.
The limewater produces a white precipitate of calcium carbonate on reacting with carbon dioxide gas.
Using Universal Indicator paper to measure the pH of four solutions and two reactions with dilute hydrochloric acid.
Questions
Can you identify the four solutions whose labels have fallen off in the video?
Can you identify the names of the gases produced during the two reactions shown for dilute hydrochloric acid?
What are the tests for hydrogen gas and carbon dioxide gas on the GCSE Chemistry specification?
Further questions
What would you expect to see when dilute hydrochloric acid is added to dilute sodium hydroxide solution? How could you show that a reaction occurs? Is there a heat change associated with this type of reaction? What is it?
Answers at the end of the description.
Universal Indicator paper was used to measure the pH of four colourless solutions. These were known to be either hydrochloric acid, sodium hydroxide, ethanoic acid or ammonia solution. All of the solutions were approximately 0.1M concentration.
Dilute hydrochloric acid was reacted with a small piece of magnesium ribbon in a test-tube. The gas produced was tested by trapping it in the test-tube and then introducing it to an ethanol spirit burner flame.
The gas should be tested with a burning wooden splint.
Dilute hydrochloric acid was reacted with a few small marble chips and bubbles of colourless gas were produced.
I was unable to bubble the gas through limewater which is the diagnostic test at GCSE level Chemistry. However, the gas did extinguish a burning splint very rapidly.
These reactions are typical of those carried out at Key Stage 3 and Key Stage 4 in Chemistry at school and are presented here in portrait orientation for viewing on a smartphone.
Answers to the questions posed above
Universal Indicator
Solution A = dark red, pH 1, hydrochloric acid
Solution B = orange, pH 4, ethanoic acid
Solution C = green, pH 8, ammonia solution
Solution D = blue-purple, pH 12 - 13, sodium hydroxide solution
Hydrochloric acid + magnesium metal produced hydrogen gas.
Bubbles of colourless gas were observed. Remember, you cannot claim to see hydrogen gas when writing answers to examination questions.
Hydrogen gas burns with a pop when tested with a lit splint or burning wooden splint.
Hydrochloric acid + calcium carbonate produced carbon dioxide gas.
Bubbles of colourless gas were observed.
Carbon dioxide gas produces a white precipitate when bubbled through limewater. We often say that limewater turns milky when carbon dioxide is bubbled through it.
Carbon dioxide will extinguish a burning wooden splint, but so will other gases on the GCSE Chemistry specification such as nitrogen gas and chlorine gas, so this is not a diagnostic test.
Answers to further questions
Hydrochloric acid reacts with sodium hydroxide to produce sodium chloride and water. The sodium chloride product is soluble in water and no visible change is observed with our eyes during the reaction. However, the reaction can be monitored using Universal Indicator.
In the above example scenario when hydrochloric acid is added to sodium hydroxide the colours observed would change from purple-blue to blue, then green, then yellow, then orange, then finally red when the acid would be in excess.
The neutralisation reaction could also be monitored by taking temperature readings since heat is given out during the reaction. This is due to the formation of water molecules. The neutralisation reaction is exothermic. However, this is very difficult to show in a video clip using dilute 0.1M solutions of hydrochloric acid and sodium hydroxide and an alcohol thermometer.
The reactions of alkali metals with water
Small pieces of lithium, sodium and potassium are added to water in large beakers. The water had Universal Indicator added to it prior adding the metals.
Observations
Compare the similarities and differences in the reactions of the three group 1 metals with water.
A short video clip in portrait orientation which may be better for viewing on a smartphone.
The lilac colour to the flame produced by potassium was very subdued in this experiment.
Fun chemistry experiments you might choose to do at home.
Safety first
Do not stand over, put your face close to or point a bicarbonate rocket at anyone during launch. Stand well back and enjoy.
DO NOT USE GLASS BOTTLES
Requirements
A small plastic bottle
A bung (cut from a rubber pencil eraser to fit the mouth of the plastic bottle)
10ml vinegar, approx.
0.5g of sodium hydrogen carbonate, approx.
Half a square of soft toilet tissue
Procedure
Pour the vinegar into the bottle to a depth of 0.5 to 1 cm
Spread the sodium hydrogen carbonate onto the tissue paper and fold the edges of the paper forming a cylinder with the sodium hydrogen carbonate inside
Fold the tissue paper into a U shape and twist the two ends light together
Holding the bottle almost horizontal, insert the tissue paper until the end just protrudes from the mouth of the bottle
DON'T LET THE PAPER COME IN CONTACT WITH THE VINEGAR AT THIS STAGE
Insert the rubber bung, trapping the end of the paper
Place the bottle vertically on a flat surface, standing on the bung and stand back for lift-off
Enjoy and repeat as necessary
The chemistry of the chemical reaction between ethanoic acid and sodium hydrogen carbonate can be explored
acid + carbonate = salt + carbon dioxide + water
Have fun with small scale chemistry and microscale chemistry
Inspired and encouraged by Bob Worley, Jonathan Barton and Abdul Khan
Fun chemistry experiments you might choose to do at home.
Safety first
Do not stand over, put your face close to or point a bicarbonate rocket at anyone during launch. Stand well back and enjoy.
DO NOT USE GLASS BOTTLES
Requirements
A small plastic bottle
A bung (cut from a rubber pencil eraser to fit the mouth of the plastic bottle)
10ml vinegar, approx.
0.5g of sodium hydrogen carbonate, approx.
Half a square of soft toilet tissue
Procedure
Pour the vinegar into the bottle to a depth of 0.5 to 1 cm
Spread the sodium hydrogen carbonate onto the tissue paper and fold the edges of the paper forming a cylinder with the sodium hydrogen carbonate inside
Fold the tissue paper into a U shape and twist the two ends light together
Holding the bottle almost horizontal, insert the tissue paper until the end just protrudes from the mouth of the bottle
DON'T LET THE PAPER COME IN CONTACT WITH THE VINEGAR AT THIS STAGE
Insert the rubber bung, trapping the end of the paper
Place the bottle vertically on a flat surface, standing on the bung and stand back for lift-off
Enjoy and repeat as necessary
The chemistry of the chemical reaction between ethanoic acid and sodium hydrogen carbonate can be explored
acid + carbonate = salt + carbon dioxide + water
Have fun with small scale chemistry and microscale chemistry
The clip was originally filmed on an iPhone at 120fps
Inspired and encouraged by Bob Worley, Jonathan Barton and Abdul Khan
Chemistry experiments you might be able to do at home under lockdown.
SAFETY FIRST - DO NOT STAND OVER OR TOO NEAR TO THE BICARBONATE ROCKET AS IT IS ABOUT TO LAUNCH.
WEAR SAFETY SPECTACLES
Part 3 Launching the rocket
This movie clip shows how to add the sodium bicarbonate to the vinegar and perform a successful launch.
Reduce the amount of bicarbonate and increase the amount of tissue paper to slow down the reaction.
Have fun with chemistry experiments at home when you can, even under lockdown.
Thanks to Jonathan Barton, Bob Worley and Abdul Khan for inspiration and encouragement.
Chemistry experiments you might be able to do at home under lockdown.
This short movie clip shows an example of testing the bung in the top of the plastic bottle to make sure it is water tight and hopefully airtight under pressure.
This is the critical part of the rocket to ensure a successful take-off. If the bung leaks all you will get is a launchpad failure.
Have fun with chemistry experiments at home when you can, even under lockdown.
Thanks to Jonathan Barton, Bob Worley and Abdul Khan for inspiration and encouragement.
Chemistry experiments you might be able to do at home under lockdown.
SAFETY FIRST - GET AN ADULT TO CUT THE RUBBER BUNG OUT OF A SOFT PENCIL ERASER USING A SHARP KNIFE.
Part 1 Making the rocket
In this movie clip you can see an example of materials you might be able to obtain from the supermarket in order to make a small bicarbonate rocket.
The small plastic bottle used was approximately 20 - 30ml capacity and was an inexpensive candy container.
The remaining equipment is probably familiar and should be low cost.
Materials list
Small plastic bottle
Soft rubber pencil eraser
White vinegar -although any vinegar found in the kitchen should work
Bicarbonate of soda - sodium hydrogen carbonate
A sheet of tissue paper
Sharp knife to cut out the rubber bung - make sure an adult does this
When the rubber bung is cut out from the eraser its best to cut out a cone shape to ensure an airtight fit in the bottle when the bung is inserted. See next movie clip.
Have fun with chemistry experiments at home when you can, even under lockdown.
Thanks to Jonathan Barton, Bob Worley and Abdul Khan for inspiration and encouragement.
A brief movie clip showing a mixture of copper (II) oxide and carbon being heated in a test-tube.
A thermal reduction reaction is seen to occur.
A close-up recap of the snow statues experiments in the previous two movie clips.
Safety advice
Do not ingest any of the chemicals, particularly the potassium hexacyanoferrate II and potassium hexacyanoferrate III if these are used.
Wash off any spillages in contact with skin immediately and wear safety spectacles.
This movie clip follows on from the previous one showing the results of the snow statue experiments after 24 hours.
There is a brief discussion at the end of the clip of some of the factors involved in producing a good cardboard snow statue.
In order to carry out this experiment at home you need access to a tiny amount of potassium ferrocyanide, aka potassium hexacyanoferrate II.
You may be able to buy this online. I was able to buy 50g for 6 UK pounds.
You may be able to take a saturated solution of sodium chloride to the chemistry department of your school if you attend one and ask them to add 2 drops of a 0.1M solution of potassium hexacyanoferrate II to it.
Potassium hexacyanoferrate II is one of the chemicals used in commercial cooking salt or household table salt and thus there is very low risk involved once the tiny amount has been added to the saturated sodium chloride solution.
Lot's of interesting snow statues and snow scene experiments can be safely carried out once you have acquired your stock solution. Just remember to use pure salt, such as sea salt with no additives added when making up your saturated solution of sodium chloride.
Have fun with chemistry
An explanation of the formation of the snow crystals is given here
melscience.com/GB-en/chemistry/experiments/xmas-tree
or here
melscience.com/GB-en/chemistry/experiments/xmas-v2_xmas-tree
and a nice time lapse of the procedure here
melscience.com/SA-en/articles/homemade-christmas-tree
Snow statues
Making snow statues or snow scenes using a saturated solution of sodium chloride
There are edited jumps in the movies clip
0 to 2m 14s Setting up the experiments
2m 15s to 2m 35s After approximately 2 hours
2m 36s to 3m 2s After approximately 4 hours
3m 3s to finish After approximately 7 and a half hours
Five solutions were used
Two solutions at the front or in the foreground
Left = saturated sodium chloride solution + potassium ferrocyanide
Right = saturated sodium chloride solution + potassium ferricyanide
Three solutions at the back or in the rear of the shot as follows
Left = saturated solution of Low salt, a mixture potassium chloride 51%, sodium chloride 48% and anti-caking agents 1%. The anti-caking agents are listed as magnesium carbonate, potassium hexacyanoferrate II and sodium hexacyanoferrate II.
Middle or centre = saturated solution of sodium chloride made from sea salt, large crystals of sodium chloride with no additives explicitly stated on the bottle
Right = saturated solution of cooking salt with ingredients listed as salt and an anti-caking agent sodium ferrocyanide
A note on some chemical names
Salt = sodium chloride
Sodium ferrocyanide = sodium hexacyanoferrate II
Potassium ferrocyanide = potassium hexacyanoferrate II
Potassium ferricyanide = potassium hexacyanoferrate III
Please note YouTube does not allow the use of brackets in these descriptions. When writing names of chemicals in chemistry brackets should be placed around the Roman numerals in the above chemical names.
Questions
1 What is the chemical name and formula of common salt?
2 What is the chemical name and formula of the compound added to common salt in Low salt?
3 What is the health benefit of using Low salt instead of common salt, sodium chloride
4 What chemical is added to a saturated solution of sodium chloride to produce profuse white crystals that look like snow on a cardboard cutout shape?
5 What is the colour are the snow-like crystals formed if potassium hexacyanoferrate III is added a saturated solution of sodium chloride when carrying out these experiments?
6 What colour is hydrated iron III oxide and what name is used to refer to it in common English language?
7 Why are large crystals of sea salt of far greater purity than cooking salt or table salt used at home?
8 Why are chemicals such as magnesium carbonate and sodium ferrocyanide added to cooking salt or table salt?
9 What is another chemical name for potassium ferrocyanide and in what oxidation state is the iron in it?
10 What is another chemical name for potassium ferricyanide and in what oxidation state is the iron in it?
11 Find out the chemical formulae for the following
a sodium ferrocyanide
b potassium ferrocyanide
c potassium ferricyanide
Answers
1 sodium chloride NaCl
2 potassium chloride KCl
3 It is used to help reduce blood pressure
4 potassium ferrocyanide or potassium hexacyanoferrate II
5 yellow
6 orange, rust
7 Because chemicals often referred to as anti-caking agents are added to the sodium chloride, salt
8 To make the salt flow easily out of the container, even when moderate amounts of water are absorbed by the salt in humid atmospheres. Anti-caking agents stop the salt forming into lumps.
9 potassium hexacyanoferrate II and Fe2+
10 potassium hexacyanoferrate III and Fe3+
11 a to c It is not possible to write down the letters and symbols correctly in this description due to YouTube limitations, however they will be shown in a subsequent movie clip
Recrystallisation of copper sulfate
Errors and safety advice
Wear safety spectacles and wash off any material that comes in contact with skin immediately
2mins 50sec Do not use boiling water as this is too risky and unnecessary
7mins 50sec Error. Water evaporates, not the copper sulfate crystals
The Experiment
I wanted to see if I could carry out a recrystallisation of an ionic solid in the greenhouse using only materials commonly found at home.
250g of copper sulfate was obtained online for a couple of pounds
The copper sulfate from the online supplier was a greenish solid in colour, rather than the expected bright blue crystals.
A sample of the greenish solid was dissolved in hot water and filtered to remove any insoluble impurities.
The filtrate was placed in a bowl and left to stand overnight. Water evaporated and crystals of copper sulfate formed.
The crystals were removed from the solution by filtration and washed with de-ionised water.
Blue copper sulfate crystals were obtained.
Close-up movie clip of the crystals obtained from saturated solutions prepared from cooking salt and sea salt.
Questions
1 Give the chemical name of the compound commonly referred to as salt
2 Name the two types of salt used in these experiments
3 What shape are the crystals obtained from sea salt?
4 What is the anti-caking agent added to cooking salt?
5 Does the anti-caking agent appear to affect the shape crystals produced from cooking salt? Explain your answer.
6 Name two factors that affect how quickly solutions evaporate.
7 How could you alter the experimental conditions to produce larger crystals of sodium chloride from a saturated solution of sea salt
8 A common chemical reaction carried out at school is the neutralisation of an acid with a base. A base that is soluble in water is called an alkali.
The general equation is acid + base = salt + water
Name the acid and the alkali frequently used at school to produce sodium chloride in this way.
9 In everyday language when we use the word salt, we are usually referring to sodium chloride, as in this movie clip.
However, in chemistry the term salt has a much broader meaning, it is used as a general term for ionic compounds.
a Name another sodium salt
b Name another chloride salt
c Name a salt that is neither a sodium salt, nor a chloride salt
Answers
1 Sodium chloride
2 Cooking salt and sea salt
3 Cubic, cubes, cuboid, square shaped
4 Sodium ferrocyanide
5 Yes, the anti-caking agent does appear to affect the shape of the crystals produced. A mixture of irregularly shaped crystals appear to form, although there are some cubic crystals in the mixture. In general the solid particles are too small to discern a single, regular shape
6 Temperature, surface area of the solution and the humidity and movement of the surrounding air are four factors that affect the rate of evaporation. There are others.
7 Let the solution evaporate slowly at a cool temperature, in a narrow vessel with reduced surface area in still, not too dry surrounding air.
8 hydrochloric acid + sodium hydroxide = sodium chloride + water
9 Many answers are possible here, e.g.
a sodium iodide
b potassium chloride
c copper sulfate
Note YouTube does not allow angled brackets in text descriptions
Recrystallisation of sodium chloride from the kitchen.
Saturated solutions were made by adding an excess of solid salt to a small volume of hot tap water from a kettle.
Two saturated salt solutions were made, one using cooking salt and another using sea salt.
With cooking salt approximately 200g of salt were added to about 250ml water.
For sea salt approximately 100g of salt was added to about 120ml water
The salt solutions were made up in 1 litre milk cartons that had been thoroughly washed with water before use. Milk cartons were used because they allowed the salt solutions to be shaken quite easily. The salt solutions were left to stand overnight before pouring into the bowls as shown in the movie clip.
After pouring the solutions were left to evaporate for a few days. The rate of evaporation depends on the temperature and humidity which were quite variable in the greenhouse. Nevertheless, crystals were formed overnight and grew larger over the next few days.
Cooking salt contained sodium chloride and a small amount of sodium ferrocyanide as an anti-caking agent.
Sea salt contained solid sea salt, sodium chloride with no additives.
The crystals obtained by allowing saturated solutions of the two salts to evaporate looked quite different.
A close-up view of the results from the two experiments can be seen in another movie clip.
Electrolysis of a water ethanol extract from a yellow tulip flower.
6v battery, carbon fibre electrodes.
See the previous post on 15th April 2021 for details and research links.
Yellow tulip flower extract
Colourless in acid, as develops around the anode during electrolysis.
Deep yellow in alkali, around the cathode.
Can you explain the difference in colours observed?
Fun with small scale and microscale chemistry.
It's the time of year when tulips are in the garden which gives an opportunity to try out the electrolysis of a tulip flower extract as shown by Bob Worley in 2020
In the experiment shown here a few dark red tulip flower petals were cut up into small pieces and left to stand in an ethanol water mixture before filtering. The extract so obtained was elctrolysed using a 6v battery and carbon fibre electrodes in the greenhouse.
Bobs original video clip can been seen here Fruit skin and fruit dyes as indicators, Apr 24, 2020
youtu.be/WX2dSdvVPe0
At the end of this video clip Bob details the anthocyanins responsible for the colours observed and the same electrolysis of a tulip flower extract shown here.
Also see pH Profiling of Plant Extracts, Jul 31, 2020
youtu.be/tbR5dHcWWds
Many examples of the colours observed for various flower extracts in acid and alkaline conditions can be seen here in a Tweet from the Crocodile Chemist, Mar 2nd 2020 Garden Indicators project
twitter.com/CrocodileChemi1/status/1366724709975552002?s=20
and the linked Google sheet here
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1JqyWXZcYqyitfHPyyqVwHu7AVvV6Malo-T66uwDn9Ko/htmlview#
It's worth noting that the colours observed for the tulip flower extract in acid and alkali at the end of the video clip agree with those reported on the Garden Indicators project spreadsheet
Tulip flower extract in water ethanol
colour in acid red
colour in alkali green
Many thanks to
UncleBob
@UncleBo80053383
and
CrocodileChemist
@CrocodileChemi1
for inspiration and ideas
Have fun with microscale chemistry!
What time is it?
A failed iodine clock
Fun with vitamin C, iodine and hydrogen peroxide in the greenhouse.
Small droplets of a mixture containing vitamin C, starch solution and Povidone iodine were placed on a sheet of plastic.
Small droplets of hydrogen peroxide solution were placed next to them.
Pairs of droplets were mixed using a cocktail stick.
A clock face was fashioned by the reacting droplets.
What time is it showing at the end of the video?
Fun with micro-scale chemistry.
ROTATE 1617715994966
Testing for oxygen gas with a glowing splint.
IGCSE Chemistry
The splint re-lights or catches fire in oxygen.
Safety
Use extreme caution when opening an alkaline battery or cell. Wear gloves and safety spectacles. Do not let the black powder inside the cell come into contact with your skin. It is alkaline and corrosive.
The black powder contains manganese dioxide which acts as a catalyst for the breakdown of hydrogen peroxide, releasing oxygen gas.
Testing for hydrogen gas with a burning splint.
IGCSE Chemistry
If the gas burns with a pop, it's hydrogen, which is why many refer to this as the pop test.