Unzickers Real Physics
Real Physics Talk: Pierre-Marie Robitaille
updated
0:00:20 Introduction
0:02:21 Working in 2023 at Augsburg University on Weber’s Electrodynamics
0:03:00 Newtons own "Machian" concerns
0:04:23 The meaning of the acceleration in Newton’s second law of motion
0:06:00 Leibniz against Newton’s concept of absolute empty space
0:07:10 Performing Newton’s bucket experiment
0:11:25 The concavity of the water is due to the rotation of the bucket relative to what?
0:19:37 Mach’s critique of Newtonian concepts
0:23:43 Mach: the concavity of the water is due to its rotation relative to the distant masses
0:24:10 Mach’s famous thought experiment: Influence of distant stars?
0:29:50 Predictions according to Newton and Mach and the subtle difference.
0:32:45 Galileo’s free fall experiment and the anticipation of the equivalcence principle
0:38:28 The gravitational constant G and Mach’s principle: inertia and gravity
0:42:20 Dirac’s large number hypothesis
0:43:25 Schrödinger’s paper of 1925 on Mach’s principle
0:44:40 Sciama 1953, Dicke 1957 and Einstein 1911
0:46:45 Newton’s prediction of the flattening of the Earth due to its diurnal rotation
0:51:10 Thought experiment: What would happen to the shape of the Earth?
0:52:40 The rotating universe : Opposite predictions of Newton and Mach.
0:56:37 Foucault’s pendulum experiment
1:02:00 The remarkable coincidence people usually do not reflect upon.
1:07:10 What would be the shape of the Earth without distant galaxies?
1:09:20 Einstein’s general theory of relativity does not implement Mach’s principle
1:11:00 Ernst Mach rejected explicitly Einstein’s theory of relativity
1:14:45 Relational Mechanics and Mach’s Principle with Weber’s Gravitational Force
1:16:10 English translation of Weber’s works on electrodynamics
1:16:45 Unification of gravitation with electromagnetism
1:19:20 Local experiments with Newton’s bucket
First talk with André Koch Assis: youtube.com/watch?v=vVJ3WHft9d8
playlist Mach's principle and variable speed of light:youtube.com/playlist?list=PLFdjtNRUXCljnKJLKxN9oS2m6MbMbQPQf
Schrödinger's 1925 paper: onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/andp.19253821109
Sciama's 1953 paper; academic.oup.com/mnras/article/113/1/34/2602000
Dicke's 1957 paper:
journals.aps.org/rmp/abstract/10.1103/RevModPhys.29.363
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
See also my recent ZAMM paper:
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/zamm.202100280
Further reading:
arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0011064 - a tribute to Ekkehart Kröner
arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9612061
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
First Real Physics Talk with André Koch Assis: youtube.com/watch?v=vVJ3WHft9d8
02:00 Our meeting in Prague in 2019
02:40 Studying physics and history of science
03:30 Ampere never wrote the circuital law
05:38 Ampere never worked with the magnetic field concept
07:20 Oersted’s experiment of 1820
09:00 Ampere’s main assumptions
10:07 Interaction between two current carrying wires
13:05 Ampere’s central force between two current elements
16:00 Ampere’s force disappeared from the textbooks
16:50 Maxwell on Ampere
17:15 Grassmann's formula
17:20 Grassmann’s force between two current elements
19:05 Ampere’s bridge experiment and longitudinal forces
23:00 Possible experimental tests
23:35 Graneau’s experiments to distinguish Ampere from Grassmann
25:00 Are Maxwell's equations correct?
26:05 Maxwell’s comparison between Ampere and Grassmann
28:10 Weber's Electrodynamics - related to Ampere?
28:49 English translations of the works of Coulomb, Ampere and Weber
29:25 English translations of Coulomb, Ampere and Weber
31:40 Opposite paradigms: field theory vs direct interaction
35:00 Weber and Ampere
37:40 Unification of od ED with optics
40:00 Kohlrausch and Weber measurements
41:25 History of the wave equation
43:00 Is Weber's law compatible with energy conservation?
43:40 Helmholtz and Lord Kelvin versus Weber. The aether
45:45 Weber's Complete works translated into English
47:30 Intuitive meaning of Weber's electrodynamics
49:20 Precession of electrons in the atomic orbit?
51:00 Weber's force for pairs of electrons
53:45 A possible explanation of nuclear forces?
55:30 A forgotten gem of Weber
58:10 Calculating the size of the nucleus?
1:01:30 How to make progress in fundamental physics
1:05:30 wave/fields vs direct interaction/particles
1:06:30 Weber vs Lorentz: is there an experiment?
Second Talk (Mach's principle) : youtube.com/watch?v=PIKx-fGH5e0
Nature paper on tests of Ampere's law:
P. Graneau. Electromagnetic jet-propulsion in the direction of
current flow. Nature, 295:311–312, 1982.
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
https://www.amazon.de/Einsteins-Albtraum-Amerikas-Aufstieg-Niedergang/dp/3864893372
https://www.amazon.de/Wenn-wei%C3%9F-Verstand-Struktur-aktualisierte-ebook/dp/B09PF88HRQ/
Leider haben bei dieer Aufzeichnung verschiedene technische Komponenten nicht optimal funktioniert. Hinsichtlich der Audioqualität verlangt dies, besonders gegen Ende, viel Nachsicht vom Zuhörer, ich bitte um Verständnis!
6:18 Beginn Lesung
7:27 Einsteins zwei Seiten
8:00 Wissenschaft vor 100 Jahren und heute
11:00 Unterschiede der Wissenschaftskultur in Europa und USA
11:55 Lesung Vorwort "Einsteins Albtraum"
16:45 Der Unterschied zwischen Immanuel Kant und den Gebrüdern Wright
18:15 Psychologie - Freud und Bernays
20:05 Wahrheitssuche in Wissenschaft und Politik
21:05 Wahrheit, Frieden, Recht und Freiheit hängen zusammen
22:50 Lesung "Wenn man weiß wo der der Verstand ist, hat der Tag Struktur, Kap. 6
24:45 Weizsäcker Rede 1985 - Imperium USA
27:55 Kriege wurden immer durch Lügen begründet - ist dies heute anders?
28:35 Demokratie Ukraine
30:35 Sehen-Denken-Handeln
32:00 Assange: Wahrheit und Frieden
32:35 Geistige Tankstellen der Nation
32:55 Fragen Dr. Billig - Beginn Diskussion
35:10 Physik Anfang des 20. Jahrhunderts
36:35 Ringen um die Quantenphysik
37:20 Raum und Zeit - Warum?
37:50 Physik als Übersprungshandlung
39:05 US-Nachkriegsphysik
41:05 Big Science und ungelöste Fragen der Physik
41:55 Feinstruktur-Konstante
43:15 Beginn Allgemeine Diskussion - Wissenschaft und Geld
46:20 Wahrheit verkünden? Uns fehlt der Mut
48:13 Sprachmanipulation durch Medien - "territoriale Integrität"
49:33 Wie bringt man Leute zum Nachdenken?
50:25 "Du hast teilweise Recht" - Daniele Ganser
51:40 Sind wir von Pseudowissenschaft bedroht?
54:40 Frage Wissenschaft und Kapital
58:25 Wikipedia - das Gegenteil von Wissenschaft?
1:02:18 Was sind denn die ungelösten Fragen der Physik?
137, Machsches Prinzip, Gravitationskonstante, Johann Balmer
1:06:30 Warum LNG?
1:08:00 Verflechtung von Kapital und Staat
1:10:00 Imperien und Urknall
1:11:00 Der Fluss der Geschichte
1:12:00 LNG-Terminal auf Rügen, Atomkraft, regenerative Energien
1:14:00 Energiepolitik mit Verstand
1:17:00 Sprengung von Nord Stream 2
1:20:48 Wie löst man Konflikte?
1:21:33 Wie kommt man zu Evidenz?
1:23:35 Was ist von der These Nord Stream 2 und Mini-Nukes zu halten? (Prof. Braun)
See also my recent ZAMM paper:
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/zamm.202100280
Further reading:
arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0011064 - a tribute to Ekkehart Kröner
arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9612061
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
See also my recent ZAMM paper:
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/zamm.202100280
Further reading:
arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0011064 - a tribute to Ekkehart Kröner
arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9612061
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
See also my recent ZAMM paper:
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/zamm.202100280
Further reading:
arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0011064 - a tribute to Ekkehart Kröner
arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9612061
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
amazon.com/Liquid-Sun-Coming-Revolution-Astrophysics/dp/B0C6W39PGQ
http://www.zam.fme.vutbr.cz/~druck/SDO/Pm-nafe/2011_06_07/0-info.htm
youtube.com/c/SkyScholar
https://www.academia.edu/34889541/Progress_in_Physics_Vol_III_2011
youtube.com/watch?v=w21K4KiYd4I
Further commens on the lack of courage in science:
youtube.com/watch?v=zmZ_Z0ZnefQ
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
One of the most consequential findings for our civilization, driven by oure curiosity.
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Maybe the most consequential finding in the history of physics.
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
This book is about the liquid Metallic Hydrogen Model of the Sun developed by Pierre-Marie Robitaille.
See also his channel: youtube.com/c/SkyScholar
Robitailles papers in Progress in Physics:
ptep-online.com
A good point to start is the 2011 Special Issue: "The Sun — Gaseous or Liquid? A Thermodynamic Analysis" (vol 7. no.3)
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Talk given at the 2023 DPG meeting in Dresden.
I apologize for the missing video picture in the discussion.
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
scirp.org/journal/paperinformation.aspx?paperid=112928
“An Exceptionally Simple Experiment Testing Quantum Theory”:
thejournalofcosmology.com/Riofrio.pdf
“Calculation of Lunar Orbit Anomaly”,Planetary Science journal (on changing c evidence):
planetary-science.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/2191-2521-1-1
Riofrio's book:
amazon.com/SPEED-LIGHT-3RD-Louise-Riofrio/dp/B097BWZK3W
Summary:
1:20 Biography
4:00 actress
4:50 courage in physics
7:00 variable speed of light
7:30 Dirac's large numbers (until 10:00)
11:00 alternative cosmologies
13:40 Ernst Mach
15:00 reactions
16:00 wikipedia page
19:20 big questions
21:30 speed of light evolution
23:30 VSL, Dircke and Dirac
25:30 best of times and worst of times
27:00 NASA career
31:30 lunar laser ranging
33:30 increasing moon distance
35:30 a changing G?
38:00 mystery speed of light
39:00 view on particle physics
39:40 agian Dirac's large numbers explained
42:00 Planck mass
43:20 On Planck scale methods
44:20 equivalence principle, inertia
45:30 quantum inertia
46:40 G measurements
48:45 next projects
50:30 G measurements again
52:00 VSL and black holes
54:50 on dark energy
56:10 on cosmic inflation
58:50 are we in dark ages?
59:40 times of opportunity
1:01:30 sociology of science
1:04:00 Thomas Gold
1:06:00 film on Mars mission
1:07:00 astronaut candidate
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
amazon.com/dp/B0BRYXWZPC
amazon.co.uk/dp/B0BRYXWZPC
For free review copies, please contact me -- ChannelInfo
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
youtube.com/watch?v=0NOaYu-AxsI&t=983s
Kaku (10:50) is actually not Japanese, just of Japanese decent.
25:20: Actually, I was the only one in the end who was interested.
A round table discussion with some questions and comments.
Full length talk and discussion: youtube.com/watch?v=TUV5e1OqnGo
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Carver Mead on Semiconductors: youtube.com/watch?v=m99YI7HZs1o
Carver Mead Press conference: youtube.com/watch?v=bYRv7chhR_0
2023 paper on Gravitation: https://authors.library.caltech.edu/120186/
His Book on Collective Electrodynamics:
https://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262632607/collective-electrodynamics/
kyotoprize.org/en/2022/carver_mead
https://einsteinpapers.press.princeton.edu/vol4-doc/198
0:00 Mead's career
2:30 Moore's Law
3:15 Physical Law's
4:30 How did Mead's interest in fundamental physics arise?
6:00 Why bother with fundamental problems?
7:10 In view of new experiments, would you craft a physical law in the same form?
8:05 Mead's critique of GR and his theory of gravitation G4v
9:00 Brief comments on Quantum Theory
10:00 Do we have a proper description of reality?
10:30 Gravity again
11:15 Einstein's 1911 and 1912 papers and Mead's theory
17:25 Shapiro time delay and variable speed of light (VSL)
19:00 Pulsars
20:00 Taylor-Hulse
21:00 Methodological problems and VSL
24:00 standing waves and propagating light
25:00 Proposed experiment for the above difference
26:50 Mach's principle
27:15 Sciama's paper
28:40 Gravitational constant - one fundamental problem
29:30 Fiber optic gyroscopes
29:50 Accelerated frames - the other fundamental problem unsolved by Newton
31:20 Missing Mach's principle in current theories
32:30 Communication with experts
34:00 Intuitive and formal thinking
36:20 How much theory is hidden in observations?
37:30 Gravity Probe B
40:10 Gravitational waves
41:10 Open data
43:00 Microworld
45:00 The engineer's approach
46:10 comments on string theory
47:45 Science advances with one funeral at a time
48:50 Are we in the dark ages again?
51:30 Technology and physics
52:00 Tunneling and semiconductors- a groupthink example
53:30 On Bardeen
56:00 What hinders progress?
57:00 Americas computer revolutions
58:15 Sillicon valley research climate
1:01:00 Lasers and superconductors
1:03:00 Coevolution of physics and cosmology
1:04:00 Superconductors
1:05:40 High temperature superconductors
1:06:30 Ray Kurzweil
1:08:45 Neural networks and superintelligence
1:11:00 An optimist statement
1:14:00 Heinrich Hertz
1:15:00 Rooted in Nature
1:17:30 To young people: think in your own way
Apologies for the missing gallery view in zoom... next time I'll know how to do that!
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
To the question, there will be a two-fold answer, yet in any case, one can learn a lot about physics methodology from the history of k.
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
We should try to define first!
This is an entry for a contest of Theories of Everything with Curt Jaimungal: youtube.com/TheoriesOfEverything (specific video for the contest is youtu.be/V93GQaDtv8w)
#PaCE1 means just this.
Btw, for those who practice old-style reading books, here is similar content:
amazon.com/dp/B0849ZXQB1
And here is a recent paper in Physics Essays:
ingentaconnect.com/content/pe/pe/2021/00000034/00000003/art00016
Thanks to Deutsches Museum München for the kind assistance.
15:48 should be ijk, not ikj :-)
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
See also:
arxiv.org/abs/0708.3518
arxiv.org/abs/0708.3518
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Mind also my backup channel:
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Medium articles with many links:
https://www.heise.de/tp/features/Fake-News-from-the-Universe-4464599.html
medium.com/swlh/gravitational-waves-the-silent-disaster-ab18857c68f8
medium.com/@aunzicker/five-years-of-gravitational-waves-a-chronicle-of-strange-coincidences-7d22be19319d.
See also my backup channel: odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
See also my backup channel: odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
See also my backup channel: odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
See also my backup channel: odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
When formulating general relativity with variable speed of light (Einstein's original 1911 idea), one has to think about electrodynamics...
Follow also my backup channel at odysee.com/@TheMachian
This video was sponsored by Wren.
Thanks for the advice regarding audio. I know it is not pefect yet. I used audacity, normalizing with -2,0 dB, cutting below 80 Hz, little cut (1,5 dB) below 300 Hz, slight boost (+1,5 dB) from 2-6 kHz and compression. In the next videos, I will register at lower volume.
Follow also my backup channel: odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Follow also my backup channel: odysee.com/@TheMachian:c
My books: www.amazon.com/Alexander-Unzicker/e/B00DQCRYYY
Follow also my backup channel at odysee.com/@TheMachian
The audio is not optimal. I apologize and will work on the problem in future videos, based on the recommendations some of you gave here.
Follow also my backup channel at odysee.com/@TheMachian
6:54 frequencies decrease, consequently, the time unit has to INcrease.
Sorry for the misspelling.
Follow also my backup channel at odysee.com/@TheMachian