My brother and I review, without major spoilers, Elden Ring.
Elden Ring is the culmination—in gameplay design and aesthetic—of the past four Souls titles (Demon's Souls, Dark Souls 1, Dark Souls 2, and Dark Souls 3).
Though it is a new IP, it breathes the same air as prior From Software games and is a return to a style of game that From Soft was leaning away from with Bloodborne and Sekiro.
We discuss what this suggests about future titles, whether this return-to-form is a good thing or not, and how we should judge From Software games in terms of their technical prowess or lack thereof.
My brother and I review, without major spoilers, Elden Ring.
Elden Ring is the culmination—in gameplay design and aesthetic—of the past four Souls titles (Demon's Souls, Dark Souls 1, Dark Souls 2, and Dark Souls 3).
Though it is a new IP, it breathes the same air as prior From Software games and is a return to a style of game that From Soft was leaning away from with Bloodborne and Sekiro.
We discuss what this suggests about future titles, whether this return-to-form is a good thing or not, and how we should judge From Software games in terms of their technical prowess or lack thereof.
Additional Footage: youtube.com/c/FightinCowboyCOCOON Crushes You Beneath a Weight of Uncertainty | Analysis & ReviewTo Games It May Concern2023-10-24 | Cocoon & the search for ultimate truth. Review and analysis.
Chapters: 00:00:00 Intro 00:01:34 Instinct for Progress 00:10:06 More Than Worlds in Themselves 00:14:01 The Key to Infinity 00:16:35 Spoilers 1 00:18:08 Strange Loops & Necessity 00:23:38 Spoilers 2 00:24:31 Knowledge for Its Own Sake 00:28:57 Outro
Chapters: 00:00:00 Intro 00:04:26 Superliminal: Struggling Through One's Own Perspective 00:15:42 Viewfinder: Struggling Through Perspectives of Others 00:35:38 On Cait the Cat 00:45:04 Breakthrough (Ending Spoilers)
– Elijah Lee x Casiio – Phantasm – Provided by Lofi Girl – Watch: youtu.be/eYQQrdQ4_w0 – Listen: open.spotify.com/album/0cpzWWSm32gKSNbXh29jP1?si=bhiNQVAsQgCDwc5Pka-hhATaking GOD OF WAR: RAGNAROK SeriouslyTo Games It May Concern2023-05-23 | How God of War: Ragnarök deals with uncertainty, mythological archetypes, the allure of violence and pacifism, limitations of self set by family and others, prophecies, history, inevitability, and the cost of one's choices.
--- Chapters: 00:00:00 Intro 00:02:05 Consequences & Deviation 00:18:31 The Allure of Violence 00:50:48 The Limits of Family 01:27:20 The Weight of History
--- Music Credit:
– Lenny Loops x stream_error – Near Space / The Earth from Above / Noctilucent / Exosphere ft. Sleepermane / Glowing Sky / Discovery ft. Sleepermane / Event Horizon – Provided by Lofi Girl – Watch: youtube.com/watch?v=a6QqkEsGxNY – Listen: open.spotify.com/album/2GnclKDql83ZH93gcOjhH8?si=2ZptN_v6T16PV_EG78NaLQTaking OMORI SeriouslyTo Games It May Concern2023-02-11 | How Omori deals with loneliness, fixations, grief, repetition, psychological horror, memory, attachment, insecurity, death, and suicide (and much, much more).
--- Chapters: 00:00:00 Intro 00:02:59 Welcome to White Space: The Unfortunate Nature of Mind and Story 00:27:45 Three Days Left: The Cascading Errors of One's Choices 00:59:29 Two Days Left: Seeking Acceptance, or the Lack of It 01:45:35 Two Days Left: Nearer to Truth & Perseverance 02:03:55 (the part you may want to skip) 02:15:41 Two Days Left: Nearer to Truth & Perseverance (continued) 02:37:15 One Day Left: Nihilistic Tendencies of the Lonesome (Endings)
-- Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerTaking OUTER WILDS SeriouslyTo Games It May Concern2022-11-01 | How the story in Outer Wilds is one of self-growth, knowledge, sacrifice, deviation, freedom, luck, logic (the limits thereof), and entropy (and much, much else).
--- Chapters: 00:00:00 Intro 00:00:53 The Point of Mystery, Timber Hearth 00:14:05 Echoes of Generations, Hourglass Twins 00:28:54 Ozymandias Poem Interlude 00:29:48 Echoes of Generations continued 00:31:15 The Danger of Knowing, Sun Station 00:43:56 Coalescing Knots of Knowledge, Brittle Hollow & Quantum Moon 00:58:29 Losing Choice, Giant's Deep & Orbital Probe Cannon 01:18:10 The Fluke of Existence, The Interloper 01:24:24 An Aside: The Value of Deviation, Dark Bramble 01:36:36 The End(?)
-- Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerHorror-RPG Illustrates Inner Hell | OMORI Prologue AnalysisTo Games It May Concern2022-09-08 | Two brothers discuss their experiences playing through the prologue of OMORI for the first time. A review and analysis of our time in this early portion of the game with many attempts to decipher the twists and turns yet to come. First-Time Reaction & Analysis Discussion - Prologue
Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerNostalgic Murder on Rollerskates | ROLLERDROME Review with Some AnalysisTo Games It May Concern2022-08-30 | Two brothers sit down to discuss, analyze, and review the free-flowing arena shooter Rollerdrome and how its main character serves as an amoral enigma. Analysis & Review Discussion
Chapters: 0:00 Intro 2:03 Arena Flow 11:09 Infinite Nostalgia 17:17 Who is Kara Hassan?
---
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerFinding Purpose in Games that WanderTo Games It May Concern2022-08-19 | Sable, Death Stranding, Journey—these games hone silence and empty expanse into budding catharsis. We review them by searching for purpose in their boredom and ambiguity.
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerOur Inescapable Distance From Other Minds | STRAY Analysis & ReviewTo Games It May Concern2022-08-02 | The cat-astrophe of our remoteness from other minds and the difficulty in embodying those minds in a video game, as seen through the indie darling Stray. But what else do we fail to grasp? Two brothers discuss. Review and story analysis discussion.
Chapters: 0:00 Emerging in a Time and Mind Unlike Our Own 1:46 Our Neighbors in This World, or The Distance of Other Minds 18:21 The World We Leave Behind, or What We Fail to See 31:40 A Final Moment of Reflection, or What Are We Doing?
---
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerNeon White and the Merits of Speedrunning | Review with Some AnalysisTo Games It May Concern2022-07-25 | Two brothers break down the clever design elements and fun to be found in Neon White, a fast-paced speedrun-oriented puzzle platformer in the guise of a shooter with cards. Review and gameplay analysis discussion.
Chapters: 0:00 Intro 1:13 Game Analysis & Review 10:05 A Taste of Speedrunning 21:36 Speedrunning as Collaboration 25:18 Final Thoughts
---
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerWhen a Game is More than It Seems | INSCRYPTION Review with Some AnalysisTo Games It May Concern2022-07-17 | Inscryption is a card game. That tells you almost nothing about Inscryption. This game tugs at curiosity and suggests the stultifying weight of knowledge. Two brothers discuss, with a spoiler-free section at the start and a spoiler-filled one at the end (marked with a warning). Review and gameplay analysis discussion.
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerA Sci-Fi Poetic Love Story about Death | GENESIS NOIR Analysis & ReviewTo Games It May Concern2022-07-08 | My brother and I analyze and review Genesis Noir, a high-stakes, point-and-click mystery about the creation of the universe. Story analysis and review discussion.
Chapters: 0:00 Intro Nonsense 0:22 What is Genesis Noir? 4:19 Genesis Noir as Love Story 8:40 Genesis Noir as Poem 13:09 Genesis Noir as Science Fiction 16:09 Spoilers 24:08 Final Thoughts
---
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerThe Future of Gaming is Nostalgic, Subtle, and Freeing | Best Indies from Steam Next Fest 2022To Games It May Concern2022-06-27 | A detailed look at 10 of my favorite independent games (with 7 additional honorable mentions) from the Steam Next Fest 2022 demo showcase.
Chapters: 0:00 Intro 2:08 Agent 64 5:43 Melatonin 9:59 Anger Foot 13:55 The Cub 16:48 Cult of the Lamb 20:40 Ghost Song 25:39 Backfirewall_ 29:53 Signalis 33:36 Cultic 36:47 Naiad 41:11 Honorable Mentions
---
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerThis Game Bleeds Oil | NORCO Analysis & ReviewTo Games It May Concern2022-06-18 | A review discussion of the point-and-click adventure game Norco, which takes place in a future South Louisiana and involves a young woman searching for her lost brother after the death of her mother. We hope you enjoy. Story analysis and review discussion.
Chapters: 0:00 Intro 1:31 Thomas Pynchon & the Absurd 5:20 Theatrical Suffering 8:15 Shame 12:21 Conspiracy [Major Spoilers] 14:52 Conspiracy / Final Thoughts
---
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerFear and Ethics in THE FORGOTTEN CITY | Analysis & ReviewTo Games It May Concern2022-06-03 | A conversation between brothers about the run-off effects of a strict moral system using The Forgotten City as example. Story analysis and review discussion.
Chapters: 0:00 Background 2:47 Overview [skip if you've played the game] 5:27 Analysis / Morality 17:23 Spoiler Discussion 23:14 Final Thoughts / Review
---
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerState Control, Propaganda, and Photographs | UMURANGI GENERATION Analysis & ReviewTo Games It May Concern2022-05-27 | The chilling constraint of not knowing. Umurangi Generation: Special Edition (includes Macro DLC) is a game of photography in the midst of crisis: you take photos of minor objects while the world crumbles down around you. My brother and I discuss, analyze, and review our experiences with this game. Story analysis and review discussion.
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerWhat CITIZEN SLEEPER Tells Us About Relationships and Identity | Analysis & ReviewTo Games It May Concern2022-05-20 | On a derelict space station you discover and define your place in a shattered world. My brother and I have a conversation about Citizen Sleeper. Story analysis and review discussion.
Chapters: 0:00 What is this game? 4:57 Thinning Boundaries 8:57 Upending Boundaries 15:39 Conclusion
---
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerThe Satisfying Tenor of Misery | TREK TO YOMI—A MeditationTo Games It May Concern2022-05-13 | Sometimes a game inspires only a single thought. That’s what this is: a thought extended out into a short meditation on the subject of morality and violence. Story analysis.
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerThe Horrifying Weight of Memory and Choice | STANLEY PARABLE: ULTRA DELUXE Analysis & ReviewTo Games It May Concern2022-05-06 | My brother and I review our experiences playing through The Stanley Parable: Ultra Deluxe Edition. We break down what's included, what's new, some critiques, and the personal meaning we gather from our time with the game. Story analysis and review discussion.
Chapters: 0:00 Intro Nonsense 0:48 The Original 7:13 Nostalgia & Isolation 16:29 Critique
---
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerWhy Its So Hard to Understand the World | TUNIC Analysis & ReviewTo Games It May Concern2022-05-01 | Tunic upends expectation through a clever doling out of textual hints and visual clues, all in service of pushing the player to interpret beyond the surface, to consider new ways of seeing and new avenues of exploration. The obvious direction is not the only one. What is there is not always clear. In this video I both review and analyze the gameplay and meaning packed within the dense adventure on offer from TUNIC Team and Finji. Check it out! Gameplay analysis and review.
Additional footage: youtube.com/c/SunnyCrappy/videos youtube.com/c/ASMRRetro/videos [excellent doc on ilovebees.com ARG; WATCH IT!] youtube.com/watch?v=bJQJqlZXQtk&Indie Snowboarding Game with Heart | SHREDDERS ReviewTo Games It May Concern2022-04-22 | Humble, absurdist, indie. Shredders doesn't aim for bombast and spectacle. It aims for finesse. You the player practice and refine your lines and tricks down various mountains, seeking glory and potential fame or merely to better yourself at a sport. I had fun with this one. Check out my review for more.
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerShould ELDEN RING Have Been Open World? | Review Discussion - 2 - Spoilers up to Leyndell CapitalTo Games It May Concern2022-04-15 | What are the pros and cons—the tradeoffs—of Elden Ring switching to an open world design? In this discussion, my brother and I review Elden Ring after 150+ hours of playtime.
Though this is the second of a two-part discussion, you do not need to watch the first part to enjoy this one. That said, here is part 1: youtube.com/watch?v=L6qb3PlsJpE&
Chapters: 0:00 "If I wanted to play Assassin's Creed, I would play that." 6:43 "... how deep the rabbit hole goes..." 10:00 "The voluntary nature of it, makes it personal." 20:34 "A confession..."
---
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerGhostwire: Tokyo Misses the Mark | Review DiscussionTo Games It May Concern2022-04-08 | In many ways Ghostwire: Tokyo is a solid game, and we say as much in this review. In a world with fewer games to play and more free time to play them, my brother and I would probably continue playing this game and enjoying it all the way through. But for various reasons we find Ghostwire: Tokyo lacking, in spite of its otherwise exceptional qualities. Check out our review discussion to understand why.
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerNearly Perfect Zelda-Like Indie | UNSIGHTED Review DiscussionTo Games It May Concern2022-04-02 | Unsighted is a top-down action-rpg in the style of the Legend of Zelda. But it takes many of the familiar mechanics of those sorts of games—interlocking overworld, intricate dungeons, variety of abilities for progression—and expands on each in creative ways. The game does not overstay its welcome. In fact, the length is near perfect for what it offers. Check out our review discussion of Unsighted to hear our detailed thoughts on this fantastic indie game. Thank you.
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/rubenjrod twitter.com/cheerydownerBOOMERANG X | Review DiscussionTo Games It May Concern2022-03-25 | Another trippy, surreal Devolver Digital classic, Boomerang X is a fast-paced, tense, streamlined, and concise shooter-of-sorts. Your boomerang is both your weapon and you as you fling yourself sky-high through unorthodox arenas, moving from one to the next without rhyme or reason or sanity.
In our review of Boomerang X, my brother and I break down what works and what doesn't in this game. Should you play it? Are the mechanics deep enough? Watch and find out!
Additional Footage: youtube.com/c/MikeysWalkthroughs/videosI Played Through HORIZON ZERO DAWN This Year—Should You? | ReviewTo Games It May Concern2022-03-08 | With the sequel Forbidden West now out, I decided to dive back into the prequel to review Horizon Zero Dawn: Complete Edition. It's been five years since that game initially came out. Is it still good? Should you bother to spend 30ish hours making your way through it? Watch my video to find out. And leave a comment with your own thoughts.
Though they appear similar on the surface, Spiritfarer is the opposite of Animal Crossing: Animal Crossing is about new beginnings, plans, potential—each new villager is a slot along a grid of possible villagers; Spiritfarer is about endings and guaranteed loss—you are assisting in redemption, grief, and, ultimately, death. My brother and I give our thoughts on what Spiritfarer brings uniquely to the table and on how effectively the game mixes the various facets of its design.
#Spiritfarer #Review #Indie #podcastI Got My Brother to Play Through DISCO ELYSIUM—Should You? | Review DiscussionTo Games It May Concern2022-01-07 | I had played Disco Elysium—a reflective, depressive, confessional role-playing game—on my own when it initially released and loved it. I told my brother he had to play. Years later, he finally did. Here is our review of Disco Elysium: The Final Cut. Enjoy!
Like, subscribe, and share!Playing a Mass Murderer Who Flies a Spaceship | CHORUS DiscussionTo Games It May Concern2021-12-14 | The game Chorus is a spaceflight shooter that follows a formerly genocidal protagonist. This is an intriguing premise for any game, and so my brother and I discuss the implications of such a story and how well the world and game design complements it. This is a review of Chorus in terms of its story premise and main gameplay mechanics, but it does not cover the full game. So no major spoilers to worry about, and the gameplay is not from deep within the playthrough. Enjoy!
Chapters: 0:00 Opening of the Game 0:19 Story Analysis (No Major Spoilers) 3:52 World 4:36 Quest Design 6:28 Combat & Gameplay 9:12 The Rites 11:15 The Ship 12:54 Concluding ThoughtsMixing Speedrunning with Rhythmic Combat | SOLAR ASH DiscussionTo Games It May Concern2021-12-07 | In this video, my brother and I attempt to break down what worked and didn't for us in Solar Ash. We both wanted to like the game more, but, unfortunately, it didn't click for either of us. There is plenty that's great about it. However, some elements of the game became stale far sooner than we would've liked, and with so many games to play nowadays, it's tough to stick with a game that doesn't wholly grab our attention. We do our best to explain our thinking here.
Remember, this is just our opinion. We know plenty love the game and that's fantastic! We're not trying to convince anyone who liked the game to feel otherwise.
Whether you liked or disliked the game, we hope you find our conversation interesting and packed with food-for-thought. Enjoy!
Additional footage: Jet Set Radio - youtube.com/user/BLACKB0ND Hyper Light Drifter - youtube.com/user/pielord72Getting Lost in Radioheads KID A MNESIA Exhibition | Review DiscussionTo Games It May Concern2021-12-01 | KID A MNESIA may be a taste of art galleries to come. I sit my brother down to discuss this unusual interactive experience, one which touches our youth through the music it employs. We consider the benefits of displaying art in such a medium, its limits, and how we felt getting lost in its hallways and open spaces.
-- Buy us a coffee! ko-fi.com/togamesitmayconcernTwelve Minutes Traps Us in an Empathy Box (Ending Explained @ 8:16)To Games It May Concern2021-08-26 | Secrets between spouses, repetition as game design, limited space leading to forced focus, memory, forgiveness—I cover plenty in this story analysis and explanation of Twelve Minutes. Enjoy!
-- Buy us a coffee! ko-fi.com/togamesitmayconcernWhat Its Like to Play LEGO Builder’s Journey, or Why I Wish My Dad Didnt Have to Work So HardTo Games It May Concern2021-08-20 | Video games are often described in terms of mechanics and as products. In this video I opt to describe my personal experience and the thoughts that arose while playing LEGO Builder's Journey. Perhaps you can relate.
-- Buy us a coffee! ko-fi.com/togamesitmayconcernHow Arthur Morgan Confronts Real Empathy | Red Dead Redemption 2To Games It May Concern2019-08-24 | After more than two years with no uploads... This channel is back with one of our most in-depth reviews so far. Is this video more than a review? Is it less? Either way THIS VIDEO IS FOR EVERYONE, even those who have not played Red Dead Redemption 2.
-- Buy us a coffee! ko-fi.com/togamesitmayconcernThe Walking Dead (Season 3) - A Reborn Series - Review DiscussionTo Games It May Concern2017-01-02 | With Season 2 of The Walking Dead a slight downward turn for the series, does Season 3 revive the horror and intrigue and heartbreak of the first? Listen to our discussion of the first couple episodes of the new season to find out. Enjoy!Mafia 3 - An Open World or a Richer One? - Review DiscussionTo Games It May Concern2016-11-11 | An extended discussion of Mafia 3, in which we go over the mission structure, characters, and racial aspects of the game.Mafia 3 - To Overstay a Remarkable Experience - ReviewTo Games It May Concern2016-10-26 | Mafia 3 is a valiant effort that falls prey to some of the worst aspects of open-world design: rote missions that stack atop one another for far too long. When this game is good, though, it's really, really good. Check out our review to hear why.
-- Buy us a coffee! ko-fi.com/togamesitmayconcernN++ (NPLUSPLUS) - Stick Ninja Death on Loop - ReviewTo Games It May Concern2016-10-14 | With thousands of levels, N++ offers more than most, but is there quality to match its quantity? Check out our review to find out.
-- Buy us a coffee! ko-fi.com/togamesitmayconcernVirginia - A Lasting Silence - ReviewTo Games It May Concern2016-10-05 | Virginia is an anomaly, a game with jump cuts like a film and silent characters throughout, a mystery that is more than a little surreal. Check out our review to see what we thought of this incredibly unusual game.
-- Buy us a coffee! ko-fi.com/togamesitmayconcernThe Bunker - Full Motion Solitude - ReviewTo Games It May Concern2016-09-30 | The Bunker is an indie game that employs full motion video for its gameplay. Is it more than just an intriguing format? Watch our review to find out.
-- Buy us a coffee! ko-fi.com/togamesitmayconcernMother Russia Bleeds - Roads of Acute Exasperation - Review DiscussionTo Games It May Concern2016-09-12 | With an emphasis on high octane violence, drug abuse, detailed pixel art, co-op gameplay, and a coarse soundtrack, Mother Russia Bleeds is a modern take on Streets of Rage that pushes its brutality to the forefront rather than leaving it to the mind of the gamer. Is it a successful re-imagining of an otherwise stagnant genre? Listen and find out. Enjoy!Deus Ex: Mankind Divided - Apartment Hunting - Review DiscussionTo Games It May Concern2016-09-07 | Games are so open ended that one person's experience with the same game can be vastly different from someone else. My brother and I tackled all the same quests, with much the same moral decisions, yet my brother took 60 hours to finish while I only took 30. Huge difference. In this review discussion we go over the effect such a difference in experience can have on our evaluation of the game. Enjoy!The Witcher 3: Blood and Wine - Fairytale Ending - Review DiscussionTo Games It May Concern2016-08-27 | Took a while but one of us finally did everything there is to do in this DLC. And so here we are to discuss why it is a fitting (though imperfect) end to a fantastic series. Enjoy!
-- Buy us a coffee! ko-fi.com/togamesitmayconcernNo Mans Sky - Mining Inward - Review DiscussionTo Games It May Concern2016-08-22 | With all the discussion surrounding No Man's Sky, we give our review of the game and explain why we somehow, in some way, by some means, love it.INSIDE - Review Discussion (Spoilers from 8:35 onward)To Games It May Concern2016-07-11 | What is inside INSIDE and is it worth it? Yes. Yes it is. Play the game. Check out our review. Ponder and discuss.
-- Buy us a coffee! ko-fi.com/togamesitmayconcernHard Reset Redux - Review DiscussionTo Games It May Concern2016-06-17 | How old-school is Hard Reset Redux and does this game satisfy the itch left-over by the new DOOM? Check out our review discussion to find out.DOOM (2016) - Review DiscussionTo Games It May Concern2016-05-21 | DOOM (2016) is finally out. Two brothers discuss why this reimagining of the series works so well.