gordonmcdowell
Cubic Mile of Oil - Dr. Ripudaman Malhotra @ TEAC7
updated
Categories of Nuclear Waste In the USA:
(Different than Europe because of the larger amount of defense waste.)
- Spent Nuclear Fuel (SNF)
- High Level Waste (HLW)
- Transuranic Waste (TRU-CH&RH)
- Low Level Waste (LLW)
Deep Geologic Disposal is required for SNF, HLW and TRU.
National Academy of Sciences (NAS) concludes in 1957 that the most promising disposal option for all radioactive waste is in massive salt deposits.
“Salt at great depth ‘flows.’ It will encapsulate any waste placed at depth and isolate it from the surface environment for eons.” - NAS
“The great advantage is that no water can pass through salt. Fractures are self healing..” – NAS
Disposal options for different waste streams begins to diverge in the 1970s.
1957 - Deep geologic disposal adopted; salt chosen as best.
1970 - AEC establishes new category for transuranic waste, distinct from low- and high-level radioactive waste but with significant overlap in radioactivity. EPA formed.
1976 – Reprocessing of commercial spent fuel put on hold; separate retrievable disposal concept born for SNF/HLW not to go into salt; TRU still to go into salt.
1982 – Nuclear Waste Policy Act…
But the idea of retrieving SNF in the future took hold, killing salt as the host rock and by 1987 the candidate sites were narrowed from 17 to 3:
- Yucca Mt, Nevada
- Hanford, Washington State
- Deaf Smith, Texas
In 1987, Speaker of the House was Jim Wright from Texas, House majority lead was Tom Foley from Washington State. A new junior, Harry Reid, was from Nevada. SoNevada was chosen. Harry Reid became Senate Majority Leader and led the effort to shut down the Yucca Mountain project. In 2008, the YM license application submitted. In 2009, YMP was halted and President Obama put a Blue Ribbon Commission together to develop a new strategy.
Extreme re-engineering, and great cost (~$200 billion extra) is required to counter-act the choice of the wrong rock:
-reducing inverts
-shotcrete
-ceramic coating
-titanium drip shield
-vitrified waste
-package supports
-gravel backfill
Yucca Mt. is a highly fractured, oxidizing, variably saturated, dual porosity, hydrologic system that sits on the edge of the Las Vegas Shear Zone.
Unknown to most, transuranic waste (bomb waste) continued oninto the salt as planned, leading to the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant.
WIPP is ahead of schedule and under-budget.
Only defense-generated TRU waste presently permitted: 100 nCi/g to 23 Ci/L of alpha-emitting 239Pu equivalents but WIPP was originally designed to handle all nuclear waste.
At the 2000 lbs/inch2 pressure at this depth, the salt exhibits significant creep closure, i.e., the salt completely closes all fractures and openings, even micropores, making the salt extremely tight, such that water cannot move even an inch in a billion years.
This discussion took place at Thorium Energy Alliance Conference #11, in Albuquerque.
TEAC11 Day2 6a Forum v20221124d
• Last American SNF recycling plant operated in 1972
• 86,000 MT of SNF in 75 sites across 35 states
• 2,000 MT annual production rate
• U.S. Government paying ~$1B in damages every year since 2014
• Circular economies are the future
• Vast amounts of untapped energy in SNF
• Recycling SNF is a no-brainer
America must evolve:
• From mine to repository less than 1% of uranium utilized
• Only 4% of energy harnessed from the enriched fuel
• Disposal with long-term stewardship burden due to radiotoxicity
• #1 reason for opposition to further deployment of nuclear power
NuCycle uniquely leverages well-understood processes in an innovative set of integrated and modular systems that allows for a scalable approach to facility construction and operation.
NuCycle technology offers a bold solution to all stakeholders by allowing for a series of de-risking projects and maximizing the potential of all parties' investments.
• Modular, integrated, compact, and scalable
• No pure plutonium ever, safeguards-by-design
• Minimized waste streams
• Semi-autonomous operation
• Multiple products harnessed
• Ready for existing supply chains
IAEA's original video can be found here: iaea.org/topics/climate-change/the-iaea-and-cop/cop27/nuclear-energy-climate-friend-or-foe
This 36 minute version is a de-stammered and no-introductions version of IAEA's video. All arguments are retained, they're just delivered faster. Audio is louder.
Low resolution moments are when the speaker's footage was presented as picture-in-picture.
Follow IAEA on social media:
Facebook - facebook.com/iaeaorg
Twitter - twitter.com/iaeaorg
Instagram - instagram.com/iaeaorg
LinkedIn - linkedin.com/company/iaea
This video was not created at the request of IAEA. I expect they won't care, but this is how I think such an event can reach more viewers.
Mark Nelson of radiantenergygroup.com is an amazing communicator. I'm a fan, following him on Twitter, where he goes by the handle EnergyBants...
twitter.com/energybants
...and the many podcasts he's joined, such as his appearances on DECOUPLE.
As an example of what Mark might typically get up to, Radiant Energy wrote a nice little report, "Life Extension and Restoration of Germany’s Reactors. Can it Be Done?" (Answer: Yes.) radiantenergygroup.com/reports/life-extension-and-restoration-of-germany-s-reactors-can-it-be-done
On 2022-10-13 (Oct 13th, 2022) Mark announced at Thorium Energy Alliance Conference #11, that a new type of nuclear fuel, ANEEL, was "waiting to go into a test reactor TODAY."
ANEEL combines HALEU (High-Assay Low-Enriched Uranium) with Thorium to address some of the disadvantages of heavy-water reactors such as CANDU.
I'm Canadian. Canada makes CANDU. I'd very much like to see a CANDU constructed in my home province of Alberta. To say I'm excited about this is an understatement, as I think ANEEL makes it more likely Alberta will one day be generating clean energy from a CANDU.
Prose from the presentation slides follows...
Clean Core changes the smallest component (fuel pellet) of a reactor system with world-leading safety and a modular core that can be refuelled during operation.
Meltdowns like those suffered at TMI or Fukushima Daiichi cannot occur in a PHWR, making it an excellent choice for countries to deploy and Clean Core to focus on.
Clean Core’s fuel requires no modifications to the PHWR platform. Instead, Clean Core will be replacing the natural uranium fuel pellets with our proprietary fuel pellets.
Each one-centimeter ANEEL fuel pellet can power a household for a year.
~10% Reduced Operating cost through fuel.
~88% Reduced Waste management and storage.
Improved Safety: Proliferation resistance & accident tolerance.
(Does Mark Nelson proclaim this is "accident tolerant fuel"? No he does not, because he's NOT an idiot, and is aware of downside to the industry when such phrases are used... However, ANEEL does happen to be... accident tolerant fuel. Let's just keep this between us.)
Without modifying a reactor, Clean Core’s ANEEL fuel provides significant cost & performance benefits to the PHWR (including CANDU) platform.
Mehul Shah: Founder & CEO
Executive with 3 decades of experience scaling major multinational enterprises.
Seed investor & strategist responsible for Clean Core’s business development.
Elina Teplinsky: Legal Counsel
Partner in Pillsbury’s Energy & International Nuclear Projects practices.
Internationally recognized expert in nuclear trade & export control issues.
Dr. Paul Chan: Head of Technology
RMC of Canada Professor and award-winning Canadian nuclear scientist.
Oversees R&D strategy and acts as the technical point-of-contact for ANEEL Fuel.
Dr. Koroush Shirvan: Head of Fuel Design
MIT Professor and internationally recognized nuclear fuel and design expert.
Oversees ANEEL Fuel performance and multi-physics simulation capability.
From regulators to technologists, each member of Clean Core’s team is a leader in their respective field and an invaluable asset to the success of the ANEEL fuel.
I thought it was a rather impressive talk given the audience.
The original talk was 22 minutes, this is basically a highlight reel.
Original can be viewed here:
vimeo.com/761934482
I began this process because I found the Vimeo copy to be too quiet. So to make it listenable on my phone I boosted the audio. Then I liked it enough that I tightened it up.
Overview:
00:00 China: A History of Ascent & Ascendance
11:20 What are Critical Materials?
23:17 Rare Earths and China's Monopoly
33:12 How Did It Happen So Fast and So Completely?
41:23 Why Does It Matter?
44:58 China's Control over other Critical Materials
jkennedy@threeconsulting.com
threeconsulting.com/resources
This presentation was originally hosted here:
utk.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Viewer.aspx?id=96ea7aa7-23a5-44f2-9098-af08010d30c0
"China's Geopolitical Strategy in Rare Earth Elements and the steps the US Can Take to Build a Fully Integrated Value Chain"
Render v20221024a HWEnc High50 vbr150.
Successful demonstrations on key gas and molten salt phase systems are laying the foundation for expanded applications and opportunities.
Our goal: support timely, safe, and cost-effective deployment of MSs.
Other PNNL Teams Amanda calls out for particularly tight integration with their own work…
- Bill Glass bill.glass@pnnl.gov Ultrasonics For: vessel integrity, heat x monitoring, energy harvesting, communication.
- Bruce McNamara bruce.mcnamara@pnnl.gov Kilogram scale: production and volatility of fluoride salt, processing of chloride salt systems.
- Praveen Thallapally praveen.thallapally@pnnl.gov MOFs for off-gas Capture.
- Brian Riley brian.riley@pnnl.gov Waste Forms for Salt Wastes and Partitioned Salt Wastes: dehalogenation (remove halides), waste forms (glasses /glass-ceramics /ceramics).
What On-line Monitoring (OLM) Provides:
- Sensors directly in or on the process.
- In situ and real-time analysis of a given process or system.
Flexibility in Information and Integration:
- Chemical composition: identification, quantification, redox state, Speciation.
- System matrix: solid, liquid, gas, molten salt.
- System scale: commercial scale, lab scale, micro scale.
How OLM Can Support MSRs:
- More timely development and demonstration of processes
- Process control and monitoring of deployed MSR systems
- Examples: gas treatment, salt handling, fluorination.
This video documents the interactions on the street, in the hope that other pro-nuclear advocates will attempt similar community outreach at festivals.
The shirts can be purchased at:
nuclear.myspreadshop.ca
...they are listed at-cost. Zero profit for me, I just think they are a good communication tool and every nuclear advocate should try wearing one.
The audio is poor for the first 30 minutes of the video, then we started wearing one PicoMic each.
I'm not expecting anyone to watch this beginning-to-end. Rather, skip around, sample some of the interactions. Think as to whether this is something you'd like to try do yourself.
Stand-Up For Nuclear helped put Jessica and I together to co-host the table. If you're looking for a team, SUFN can probably help you out.
More details on the Stand-Up For Nuclear can be read here:
patreon.com/posts/stand-up-for-71667962
Senator Tommy Tuberville and Senator Dr. Roger Marshall have introduced the "Thorium Energy Security Act of 2022"
It is very short and readable...
congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/4242/text
Here is a sample (sections 7, 8 and 9)...
SEC. 7. INTERAGENCY COOPERATION ON PRESERVATION AND TRANSFER OF URANIUM-233.
The Secretary of Energy, the Secretary of the Army (including the head of the Army Reactor Office), the Secretary of Transportation, the Tennessee Valley Authority, and other relevant agencies shall—
(1) work together to preserve uranium-233 inventories and expedite transfers of uranium-233 to interim and permanent storage facilities; and
(2) in expediting such transfers, seek the assistance of appropriate industrial entities.
SEC. 8. REPORT ON USE OF THORIUM REACTORS BY PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA.
Not later than 180 days after the date of the enactment of this Act, the Comptroller General of the United States, in consultation with the Secretary of State, the Secretary of Defense, and the Administrator for Nuclear Security, shall submit to Congress a report that—
(1) evaluates the progress the People’s Republic of China has made in the development of thorium-based reactors;
(2) describes the extent to which that progress was based on United States technology;
(3) details the actions the Department of Energy took in transferring uranium-233 technology to the People's Republic of China; and
(4) assesses the likelihood that the People's Republic of China may employ thorium reactors in its future navy plans.
SEC. 9. REPORT ON MEDICAL MARKET FOR ISOTOPES OF URANIUM-233.
Not later than 180 days after the date of the enactment of this Act, the Director of the Congressional Budget Office, after consultation with institutions of higher education and private industry conducting medical research and the public, shall submit to Congress a report that estimates the medical market value, during the 10-year period after the date of the enactment of this Act, of actinium, bismuth, and other grandchildren isotopes of uranium-233 that can be harvested without downblending and destroying the uranium-233 source material.
...works for me!
The 2008 IG U-233 report Secretary Granholm has not (yet) read is here:
energy.gov/sites/default/files/igprod/documents/IG-0795.pdf
I think it is reasonable to ask (via Twitter) @SecGranholm to please read the report ASAP.
If you think saving U-233 from destruction is a-good-thing then contacting Sen. Tuberville and Sen. Dr. Marshall would be a good thing, as well as contacting your own representatives.
U233 is an alternate fissile. While America's supply of U233 is only 450kg, it can seed a pilot SMR capable of creating more U233... an alternate supply of fissile for Advanced Reactors and Small Modular Reactors.
Appearing in this video (in order of appearance):
REP. JEFF DUNCAN (R-SC)
SENATOR TOMMY TUBERVILLE
WILLIAM WHITE
SENATOR JOE MANCHIN
DR. KATHRYN HUFF
SEC. OF ENERGY GRANHOLM
SENATOR ROBERT MARSHALL
BOB OLSON
On top of DOE downblending U233, DOA has also opposed Th/U233 fuel cycle funding... as well as any other means of reducing our dependency of Russian HALEU before Russia invaded Ukraine.
DOE GAIN program has excluded alternatives to HALEU dependency since 2020-12-02:
U. S. Department of Energy, Idaho Operations Office, U.S. Industry Opportunities for Advanced Nuclear Technology Development Funding Opportunity Number: DE-FOA-0001817
SECTION E. APPLICATIONS SPECIFICALLY NOT OF INTEREST
Examples of the types of applications which will be deemed non-responsive to this FOA and will not be reviewed or considered (also see Section III of the FOA), include:
• Applications involving reactor technologies primarily for the purpose of producing industrial or MEDICAL ISOTOPES, or other medical applications;
• Applications that involve the development of URANIUM ENRICHMENT technologies or associated research and development;
• Applications involving research, development, design, or licensing of FUSION ENERGY; and
• Applications that involve the development or use of HEAVY-WATER MODERATED TECHNOLOGY.
• Applications proposing a commercialization case within the next decade that is dependent on
development of a large-scale domestic THORIUM FUEL cycle infrastructure.
...that has been further clarified...
Question: In DOE-FOA-0001817, Revision 8, section I.E. "Applications Specifically Not of Interest", thorium related technology is called out in this category as "Applications proposing a commercialization case within the next decade that is dependent on development of a large-scale domestic thorium fuel cycle infrastructure." Can you clarify which thorium related technologies remain eligible for award?
Answer: The objective of the Industry Funding Opportunity Announcement (DE-FOA-
0001817) is to advance near-term concepts toward the marketplace, whether these are new reactors or supporting technologies that would enhance the existing or future fleet. Currently, there is no domestic fuel cycle infrastructure in place to support thorium-based concepts, and no clear evidence of near-term commercial market interest in establishing it, beyond the developers themselves. Therefore, within the current resources available for the FOA, DOE-NE is focusing on concepts that do not rely on development of a large-scale domestic thorium fuel cycle infrastructure. US developers of thorium-based technologies targeting the export market remain eligible for award. Excluding up front the technologies that are unlikely to be selected under this announcement saves the substantial resources that would be expended in preparing and reviewing applications seeking to advance these technologies.
---
In the context of today's scramble for HALEU, let's look again at those exclusions.
- Medical Isotopes.
- URANIUM ENRICHMENT
- FUSION ENERGY
- HEAVY-WATER MODERATED TECHNOLOGY
- THORIUM FUEL CYCLE
Of those exclusions, medical isotopes are the ONLY exclusion which could NOT have helped alleviate HALEU shortage.
Uranium Enrichment... that's exactly what is/was needed. Specifically excluded!
Fusion Energy, while probably having valid reasons for being out-of-scope, certainly would have alleviated dependency on Russian HALEU. (And there a many synergies between fusion and fission R&D.)
CANDU are an example of heavy-water moderated reactors, which do not need ANY enriched uranium. They run on NATURAL URANIUM!
Thorium Fuel Cycle, with its creation of fissile U233 from Thorium, is a way to alleviate dependency of Russian HALEU. Either with reactors which don't need HALEU, or by creating U233 for use in SMR and Advanced Reactors.
Mandy Nolan is a Green candidate for Australia NSW Richmond riding.
Before the conversation took place, I warned Mandy Nolan that Dr. Helen Caldicott might make inaccurate statements about nuclear power, as she has done so in the past...
twitter.com/gordonmcdowell/status/1441469887398875141
This video is the result of misinformation Mandy Nolan allowed Dr. Helen Caldicott to propagate.
The original Zoom conversation, free of my own interjections, can be viewed here:
facebook.com/mandy4richmond/videos/182411350700937
1:30 Nuclear submarine deal?
4:25 If an Australian nuclear submarines was hit by a torpedo?
5:25 Australia would be only nuclear submarine country without nuclear power?
5:56 Where will the submarines be built?
6:30 Nuclear power is illegal in Australia, for now.
8:05 No democracy involved? (This conversation missing obvious points.)
9:21 Accidents?
10:10 Gord is not Australian... mate!
10:28 Nuclear waste repository risks?
11:26 Plutonium.
14:57 Reprocessing? (1,000 years.)
16:44 Store nuclear waste for a million years? (Oklo.)
17:56 Compare nuclear to coal. (Contained vs uncontained waste.)
19:24 Why Gord (from Canada) created this video for Australians.
21:49 Radioactive waste facility at Napandee.
22:26 Fukushima?
24:40 Thyroid cancer? (How Caldicott misleads on radiation and cancer.)
35:10 Sky is falling! (Caldicott's predictions never come true.)
36:36 Gord's warning to Mandy Nolan about Dr. Helen Caldicott.
38:59 Dr. Ben Heard: Nuclear breaks the environmental paradox.
39:43 Mandy Nolan broadcast Dr. Helen Caldicott without a fact-checker.
40:17 Psychologists working in DoE on billion year signs to warn of radiation!
40:32 Australia, the renewable energy superpower! (Elect Mandy Nolan!)
43:20 Nuclear power is unsustainable. High-carbon! (Is low carbon.)
46:30 Dr. Helen Caldicott pivots to sex.
48:05 Thorium?
56:30 SMR will power a nuclear sub for decades. Australian uranium is energy dense.
1:00:15 Media controlled by pro-nuclear interests? (No. Understand: nuclear is low-carbon.)
1:03:13 We need to be provocative. (Nudes-not-nukes story.)
1:05:07 Caldicott shares co-credit for keeping Ireland burning hydrocarbons for electricity.
1:05:51 Playboy Mansion fundraising on fears of nuclear war.
1:06:33 Scaring people off nuclear power leads us towards war, not away from it.
1:07:45 Dr. Helen Caldicott advocates for candlelight: Energy austerity.
1:09:25 Recap of some Caldicott lies.
1:10:00 Caldicott spreads misinformation which benefits Russia.
1:10:38 Caldicott vs NATO. (We still have time to disarm NATO!)
1:11:31 Mandy Nolan, do not platform Caldicott without a fact-checker.
1:11:44 George Monbiot vs Dr. Helen Caldicott. ("That revolting little man!")
Just like Europe decided. Just like TD Asset Management decided.
Because nuclear is low-carbon power. Canadian nuclear is ultra-low-carbon.
Canadians For Nuclear Energy: canfornuclearenergy.org
Canada's Green Bond Framework (which excluded nuclear power): canada.ca/en/department-finance/programs/financial-sector-policy/securities/debt-program/canadas-green-bond-framework.html
EU Scientific review that resulted in nuclear being added to their green taxonomy:
https://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/handle/JRC125953
TD Asset Management on Nuclear Power:
td.com/ca/en/asset-management/documents/institutional/pdf/nuclear_energy_EN.pdf
The Molten-Salt Reactor Experiment (20:31)
youtu.be/tyDbq5HRs0o
Remote Maintenance of Molten Salt Reactors (19:39)
youtu.be/uHT-w2x6dDg
The 40 minutes of footage was edited down at the request of John Kutsch, of the Thorium Energy Alliance. TEA will be revealing a Molten-Salt Reactor exhibit at The National Museum of Nuclear Science and History, in Albuquerque, New Mexico.
The reveal will take place during TEAC11 (Thorium Energy Alliance #11) in Oct 13th and Oct 14th, 2022.
If you can attend, please register here:
thoriumenergyalliance.com/tea-conference
The highlight reel had a technical challenge, in that both ORNL documentaries were heavily scored. The resulting audio sounded jarring and distracting.
iZotope RX9 Advanced was used to isolate dialog from music, and lower the prominence of the musical score.
If you are trying to help communicate the value of Molten-Salt Reactors, you can use my RX9-ed full-length versions of the ORNL documentaries.
The Molten-Salt Reactor Experiment
youtu.be/XAFlQ-Ls5lY
Remote Maintenance of Molten Salt Reactors
youtu.be/5nRIJ26WaV0
Please contact me if you'd like my own MP4 instead of YouTube rips.
patreon.com/thorium
https://www.minerals.org.au/news/small-modular-reactors-should-be-part-australia’s-energy-mix
It reviews 3 SMR designs that are currently undergoing regulatory approval – NuScale’s Power Module, GE-Hitachi’s BWRX 300 and Terrestrial Energy’s Integral Molten Salt Reactor.
Speaker: Dr Ben Heard, Frazer-Nash Consultancy Ltd
Introduced by: Joanne Lackenby, President Australian Nuclear Association
The ANA Webinar was held on 2021-11-02 (Nov 2nd, 2021).
What are small modular reactors?
Small modular reactors are power generators of typically 300 MWe or less that use nuclear fission to provide clean, fully reliable heat and power, on-grid or off-grid.
Where can Australia put small modular reactors?
SMRs can connect directly to the existing grid, be used to power regions or independently supply mines due to their compact size, fuel density and ability to air cool.
What are the costs of small modular reactors?
Robust estimates suggest that by 2030 and beyond, SMRs will offer power to grids from $64 –$77 MWh, depending on size and type. The next 10 years are crucial.
Small modular reactors are an evolution of nuclear power generation technologies. Currently in use for maritime applications, including surface ships and submarines, SMRs are under active development in fourteen countries.
Small modular reactors (SMR) are bringing to market greater diversity in nuclear technologies, with lower projected costs, greater flexibility, greater versatility, and advanced safety cases.
Now that Australia has committed to building nuclear-powered submarines, Australia will need to develop the skills and expertise to support the new fleet. This capacity could also support the deployment of SMRs.
The new SMR designs are being commercialised to provide low cost 24/7 zero emission heat and power. With smaller size, lower unit costs and passive and inherent safety features, SMRs have the potential to deploy more quickly in a broader range of markets.
From replacing aging power plants in mature, slow-growing and (commonly) liberalised power markets; to developing nations with lesser underlying transmission infrastructure; to reliable clean power for remote, off-grid locations, SMRs can potentially underpin zero emission power supplies in many settings.
Several new designs are expressly intended to support operations in conditions of water scarcity, either entirely water-free by design, or with greater potential for dry-cooling in operations.
SMRs are intended to be built in factories and shipyards, delivering the economies of serial production with increased quality, shorter construction time, fewer manufacturing constraints and simpler safety cases.
Delivered to site, SMRs will avoid the need for large, skilled construction teams to operate for long periods in potentially remote locations. This has the potential for meaningful reduction in cost.
With around 20,000 MW of baseload power stations due for retirement over the next 20 years, SMRs are ideally placed to be part of Australia’s future energy mix.
They will be of a fit-for-purpose size, utilising existing power transmission and network infrastructure. This reduces the need for additional infrastructure spending and offers meaningful options to redeploy workforces and sustain local economies and communities.
SMRs will support the cost-effective integration of variable renewables by providing a flexible base that offers strong load-following. Their synchronous generation, which can run day-long in a net zero industrial system, will maintain the essential system grid security currently under threat from the close of baseload power stations.
A blend of clean generation sources will also maximise the cost-effective production of hydrogen and synthetic fuels, and ensure best, economical use is made of storage capacity in the grid. Their full-time production of emissions-free electricity and heat supports more efficient and productive paths to hydrogen production, as well as a broad range of industrial applications including ammonia production, food processing, synthetic fuels and metal ore processing and metal smelting.
Costs are estimated at $1.2B for a 1GWe site. Largely verified by DSME and Doosan.
A large shipyard can produce 20 Gwe/year.
Build time is 1 year. Time from permits and land to grid power is 2 years.
Electricity costs are $0.03 USD/kWhr.
Can compete directly with coal in the developing world.
Recent change is the addition of the vault – dry cask storage for 80 years operation by adding 5m to the 180m long hull.
Source video: youtu.be/0G-4pcDW4Kc
The original was not presented in a YouTube-friendly manner. This edit is about 1/2 as long, but retains the substance. There are jump-cuts.
The original "Roundtable on Canada's Nuclear Policy" can be watched here:
facebook.com/6954922243/videos/934857067289154
An excerpt is taken from "Seamus O'Regan + the Political Panel | The Herle Burly":
youtube.com/watch?v=vj7HrRdDarE
While I was editing this video, Green MP Jenica Atwin left the Green Party of Canada to join the Liberal Party. I make no mention of that, as it had nothing to do (apparently) with energy policy or nuclear power.
Uranium-233, when hit by a moderated neutron, releases more neutrons when it splits than Uranium-235. More neutrons than Plutonium-239. Enough neutrons are released by U-233 that it can be used to create a breeder reactor which operates with moderated neutrons. Such a reactor would be incredibly fuel-efficient compared to today's conventional nuclear power plants.
China knows this, and is currently building TMSR-LF1 in pursuit of that goal.
India knows this, and is currently building PFBR in pursuit of that goal.
Both countries expect to begin running these Advanced Reactors within the year.
America, in contrast, is destroying its own reserve of U-233. Once destroyed, America will be permanently handicapped in any pursuit of a moderated-neutron breeder.
Jennifer Granholm, do not allow the downblending of U-233 with U-238 to continue.
It is an act of clean-energy vandalism.
-Gord
This video shows an incorrect date briefly as 2021-07-08 which should have been 2021-06-24.
Source: 2021-06-24 armed-services.senate.gov/hearings/department-of-energy-and-national-nuclear-security-administration-on-atomic-energy-defense-activities-in-review-of-the-defense-authorization-request-for-fiscal-year-2022-and-the-future-years-defense-program
As an Albertan who's been concerned about air pollution, including greenhouse gasses, since 2006, this is the very best news I've ever heard.
In the past election I voted for Rachel Notely, not Jason Kenney. I do not belong to a provincial political party.
So I asked Rachel Notley if she would abandon such an agreement if she was elected Premiere. She did not directly answer the question, but stated "Historically, our party [NDP] has been opposed [to nuclear power] because of safety concerns".
Here are some quick facts most Canadians do not know about nuclear power.
1. Not once has a nuclear incident caused a death in Canada. Ever. Zero.
2. Used nuclear fuel has never harmed anyone, anywhere, in the entire world.
3. Nuclear power has a lower lifecycle carbon footprint than even Solar Power.
4. (This is because) Nuclear power does not involve combustion. Nothing burns. There is no chemical reaction taking place.
5. Nuclear power does not pollute the air, nor does it pollute the water. Nuclear is clean energy.
6. Canadians manufacture nuclear reactors. We don't import them like Wind Turbines or Solar Panels. Canadian nuclear has a Canadian supply chain.
If you didn't know these facts, that is not an accident. Canadians have been subjected to a barrage of nuclear misinformation. The fact is, the single largest decarbonization accomplishment in North America took place in Ontario, thanks to Canaidan nuclear power.
The biggest decarbonization failure on the planet, is taking place in Germany, because they are shutting down their nuclear reactors. Today, Germans burn biomass, coal, Russian natural gas, and Euros to makeup the shortfall. Because the wind stops blowing.
In 2021 I joined Canadians for Nuclear Energy. We are here to tell the truth about nuclear power. And to challenge those who lie about it. A lot of us are from Alberta.
Dr. Helen Caldicott's lectures are reviewed by Dr. Chris Keefer and Doctah Gordo, to explain a tiny, fraction of the misinformation she has spread. (Doctah Gordo is not a licensed physician, and is barred by court order from practicing medicine in the province of Alberta.)
Dr. Chris Keefer's podcasts are "Decouple" and (for Canadian specific talks) "We CANDU It!"
Here are some source materials...
Canada, Ontario, France, Sweden, Germany, USA CO2eq/kWh and mix:
opg.com/climate-change
Fukushima "Fallout Map" not-created-by-ARS:
snopes.com/fact-check/nuclear-fallout-map
(...and I emailed ARS-now-SGS myself to double-confirm they never made it.)
(Seriously, look up what those numbers mean! It is crazy.)
2014 IPCC, Global warming potential of selected electricity sources:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life-cycle_greenhouse_gas_emissions_of_energy_sources#2014_IPCC,_Global_warming_potential_of_selected_electricity_sources
2002-2015 Graph of Ontario's coal combustion hitting zero:
brucepower.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/190422A_GovernmentBriefing_R000_DIGITAL-2-1.pdf
...also contains CANDU refurbishing jobs data, GDP data, and healthcare savings.
If you're Canadian and enjoyed this video, then please head to:
c4ne.ca
...and do whatever you gotta do.
If you're not Canadian, or Canadian and did-whatever-you-gotta-do, consider I'm running a Patrons campaign to help cover video creation costs: patreon.com/thorium
If you are reading this, and you are DR. HELEN CALDICOTT, then why not take a moment to apologize to George Monbiot (in calling out your misinformation) for saying the following about him:
DR. HELEN CALDICOTT (transcript):
That revolting little man said [that] after Fukushima he's become pro-nuclear.
He's either got a cerebral tumor or he's had a psychotic breakdown that's my clinical diagnosis.
I mean how can you be pro-nuclear after Fukushima, which is a tragedy beyond all proportions?
And he's very arrogant. And he published our email exchanges in his blog on The Guardian.
How dare he?
He wanted references for everything I'd said in our debate. Like "give me a reference that the arm connects to the shoulder." That sort of thing.
So stupid.
I studied medicine for 6 years to get my degree and then another 4 to get membership in the Royal Australian College of Physicians.
I'm a very highly qualified physician. I know what I'm talking about.
And then he wanted all the references... and the articles I've written.
This was right after Fukushima. Well I've written a lot of articles in the literature!
I couldn't find them and I was tired. I was nearly having a nervous breakdown.
Then he attacked me in The Guardian.
What a nasty little man.
Who does he think he is?
He's not a scientist.
Is he being paid?
Because many people have asked me, is he being paid?
I do wonder.
You always have to follow the money.
Something fishy is going on.
“Static” molten salts in fuel pins was rejected by ORNL because convection of fluids would be unreliable in an aircraft due to gravity's impact on reactor being variable during flight.
Fast spectrum “Wasteburner” SSR-W:
Fueled by higher actinides from conventional oxide fuel
Chloride salt fuel
Output temperature 600°C
Patented exceptionally simple process (Waste to Stable Salts) to extract Pu/Am from spent CANDU fuel with only 0.38% Pu
SSR-W is expected to be piloted in New Brunswick, powered by "nuclear waste" / "spent fuel" from CANDU reactors.
Dr. Ian Scott presented to Oak Ridge National Lab's 2020 Molten-Salt Reactor Workshop on 2020-10-14 (Oct 14th, 2020). ORNL's conference captures and slide-decks can be found here: msrworkshop.ornl.gov/msr2020
Edited and uploaded to YouTube by Gordon McDowell:
thoriumremix.com
copenhagenatomics.com
Aslak Stubsgaard, the CTO and co-founder of Copenhagen Atomics shares their work on this supply chain, and lab work with various materials, salts and pumps. The presentation is titled: "Copenhagen Atomics path to a 1MW demonstration MSR."
Salt / Valves / Pumps available via Copenhagen Atomics product page:
copenhagenatomics.com/products.php
Aslak presented to Oak Ridge National Lab's 2020 Molten-Salt Reactor Workshop on 2020-10-14 (Oct 14th, 2020). ORNL's conference captures and slide-decks can be found here: msrworkshop.ornl.gov/msr2020
Edited and uploaded to YouTube by Gordon McDowell:
thoriumremix.com
IMSR Technology:
- 442 MWth liquid fueled and cooled
- thermal spectrum, pool type
- graphite moderated
- molten fluoride salt reactor
- Hydrostatic operating pressure, 700 0C outlet, 620 0C inlet 195 MWe/44% thermal efficiency
- 600 °C liquid salt industrial heat supply
- Fuel enrichment under 5%
- 7-year fuel cycle length
- 56-year plant design life
- 17-acre site layout
- Plant boundary EPZ
- Black start capable
- Inherent and passive decay heat removal, no operator action required
- Capable of 10% per minute from 100% to 50% to 100% load following ramp rate
Key innovation is integration of primary reactor components
o Reactor core
o Primary heat exchanger
o Pumps
A sealed reactor vessel within a compact replaceable unit
o 7-yearoperation Integral design captures full commercial value
o Inherent safety
o Operational simplicity
o High capital recovery
IMSR® has successfully completed the Canadian CNSC Vendor Design Review (VDR) Phase I.
⎯ VDR Phase II is on schedule to complete in 2021
US NRC regulatory engagement is underway.
⎯ 10CFR Part 52 Standard Design Approval of the IMSR Core-unit
⎯ Prerequisite to 10CFR Part 50 Construction Permit Application
IMSR® Regulatory Progress: IMSR in joint CNSC/USNRC collaborative regulatory review.
⎯ Successful completion of regulatory reviews will be catalytic
⎯ Domestic regulatory approvals are required for deployment to international markets
⎯ Green light for first electric utilities to start deployment of first IMSR® power plants
⎯ Nuclear supply chain commitment to IMSR development
⎯ Broader private capital involvement
IMSR will see commercial deployment before 2030.
Dave Hill presented to Oak Ridge National Lab's 2020 Molten-Salt Reactor Workshop on 2020-10-14 (Oct 14th, 2020). Video conference capture and slide-deck can be found here: msrworkshop.ornl.gov/msr2020
Edited and uploaded to YouTube by Gordon McDowell:
thoriumremix.com
Cristian Contescu presents with Kristian Myhre on behalf of co-workers Nidia Gallego and Kristian Myhre.
Topics:
ORNL’s experimental facility for high pressure salt intrusion.
Examination of porosity properties of multiple graphite grades.
Salt intrusion experiments (FLiNaK at 750 °C).
Correlating salt intrusion with mercury porosimetry data.
Characterization of salt-exposed graphite samples.
Polygranular nuclear graphite is a synthetic composite obtained by molding or extruding a paste made from coal tar pitch or petroleum coke filler grains and a pitch binder, followed by thermal treatments and reimpregnation for densification. The last step is graphitization at 2500-2800 C (or even higher temperature). XRD shows a crystalline structures with and average d002 spacing just a little larger than of perfect graphite. The resultant material has an apparent density in the range of 1.7-1.8 g/cm3, i.e., about 20 % porosity.
Ongoing Work:
Performing LIBS analysis of FLINAK and FLIBE exposed samples with determined measurement methodology. Exploring correlative analysis between multiple techniques (LIBS, Raman, FTIR, XPS, scanning probe microscopies). Building capabilities to serve the MSR community.
Slide deck:
msrworkshop.ornl.gov/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/2020-MSR-Workshop-Contescu-Myhre-Gallego-final_rev1.pdf
Delivered at ORNL MSRW on Oct 14th (2020-10-14), Oak Ridge National Laboratory's Molten Salt Reactor Workshop in 2020. msrworkshop.ornl.gov
Uploaded to YouTube by Gordon McDowell:
thoriumremix.com
Kirk argues on behalf of FLiBe salts, graphite moderator and the supercritical CO2 recompression cycle.
This panel was funded by Terrestrial Energy, a nuclear startup developing a Molten-Salt Reactor, the I-MSR.
terrestrialenergy.com
Dr. Jason Donev led the discussion:
energyeducation.ca/encyclopedia/Energy_Education:About_us#Dr._Jason_Donev
Kirsty Gogan of Energy for Humanity:
energyforhumanity.org/en
Leigh Phillips, Journalist & Author:
https://www.leighphillips.work
Bonita Chan was representing Canadian Nuclear Laboratories:
cnl.ca ...and Bonita is now with Oklo... oklo.com
Energy Disruptors has features Nuclear Power discussions in their 2018 and 2019 events. They were very accommodating in giving me event audio/video capture to assist in my own independent video capture. (Consumer cameras, iPhone, etc.) This panel was held 2019-09-17. energydisruptors.com
I (Gordon McDowell) am an independent video editor looking to share the fascinating possibilities of Nuclear Power. I came to the topic from my concern with Global Warming. Having learned what we already do with Nuclear Power, and what we could do with Nuclear Power, I echo the sentiment of the panelists who found their own early aversion to Nuclear Power was not rooted in evidence.
Funding for this capture and editing is facilitated here:
patreon.com/thorium
...if you live in Calgary or Alberta, and are interested in seeing our energy portfolio diversified, please consider pledging $1/year to my Patreon campaign. It'll keep you in my communications loop. And quite possibly you'll be informing me as much as I might be informing you.
The $1 fee (hassle) is a very deliberate filter. I'm sure you can figure out why.
ThorCon is a molten-salt fission reactor. Unlike all current nuclear reactors, the fuel is in liquid form. It can be moved around with a pump and passively drained. This 500 MW fission power plant is encapsulated in a hull, built in a shipyard, towed to a shallow water site, ballasted to the seabed. ThorCon is a straightforward scale-up of the successful United States Oak Ridge National Laboratory Molten Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE).
The complete ThorCon is manufactured in 150 to 500 ton blocks in a shipyard, assembled, then towed to the site. This produces order of magnitude improvements in productivity, quality control, and build time. A single large reactor yard can turn out twenty gigawatts of ThorCon power plants per year. ThorCon is a system for building power plants.
ThorCon has been working with the Indonesian government to add reliable electric power to the grid. In 2019 the Ministry of Energy completed a successful study of the safety, economics, and grid impact of the 500 MW prototype ThorConIsle. Phase 1 is to build and test it with step by step commissioning, ending in a type license for future power plants. Phase 2 is shipyard production of ThorCon plants to provide an additional 3 GW of cheap, reliable electric power.
Scientists attending the International Conference on Emerging Nuclear Energy Systems in Bali, Indonesia, were excited by ThorCon CEO Lars Jorgensen’s presentation of the design of the TMSR-500 liquid fission power plant. Nuclear engineering professors termed the design brilliant and clever. The conference added a second session to answer questions in detail. Nuclear professionals from Malaysia, Brazil, Japan, and South Africa engaged in subsequent discussions. Indonesia’s former Minister of Energy came specifically to hear about ThorCon.
The ThorCon team then returned to state-owned shipyard PT PAL Indonesia, which had begun reviewing ThorCon specifications in July. Potentially PAL can manufacture the exchangeable Cans which contain the liquid fuel, pump, and reactor vessel. Teams from PAL and ThorCon spent two days discussing specifications. ThorCon is revising them, and PAL will verify its capability and provide a budgetary cost estimate. PAL is seeking to diversify its shipbuilding business to include the energy sector. “The thorium molten salt power plant can produce clean energy cheaper than coal, and could be a reliable energy system in a low-carbon economy” -PAL.
This video was captured by Bob Effendi on 2019-10-16. Bob posted his original edit here:
youtu.be/EyApF90-GEI
...Bob also shared his raw footage with me, as I was interested in applying iZotope RX 7 noise reduction (and echo-removal) audio processing to make Lars easier to hear. I don't think my edit nor Bob's original have great audio, but perhaps you'll find one easier to listen to than the other.
Thanks to Bob for access to his footage. Hopefully this alternate edit will help ThorCon tell their story.
I've also included brief audio snippets from Rod Adam's podcast "Atomic Show", as Lars made some clarifying (audio) remarks after this video was shot:
atomicinsights.com/atomic-show-275-managing-advanced-nuclear-development-during-pandemic
ThorCon Power: thorconpower.com
My nuclear-power video projects (MSR, Thorium, etc.) can be monitored here:
http://patreon.com/thorium
-Gord
Featuring Jessica Lovering, Ben Heard, Michael Shellenberger, Richard Garriott and Robert Bryce.
An in-depth look at how we generate electricity, and consume it. What was can do when there's plenty. How we fare without.
I was lucky enough to watch a screener before the release, and I believe this doc will radically change the conversation around energy... if enough people see it.
I hope you do. -Gord
http://juicethemovie.com
We have entered into what I like to call an "Age of Anxiety". Some of you may recall Leonard Bernstein's second symphony is entitled "The Age of Anxiety."
Our life expectancy has increased (particular in the United States) by about 20 years since the turn of the century. Despite the fact that we're all living longer, we seem to fear death more than ever before.
Indeed, we have given up the notion that there's such a thing as a natural death.
Every death must now be attributed to some very specific cause. An identifiable or presumed cause. In this we seem to be going back to a kind of primitivism.
A very famous of French anthropologist, his name is Levy Bruhl. He pointed out that one of the primary characteristics of primitive society is that in a primitive society, the notion of natural death was never accepted.
If you died, it is because your enemy had poisoned you or if he hadn't poisoned you, he had uttered some terrible impartation and the gods somehow were not friendly to you, they're friends of your enemy. And so, you die.
The public's perception is: Dying "earlier" can be attributable to technology.
It is not we technologists who are going to decide how safe a technology has to be. It is the public that makes that decision. If the public's estimate of how safe is "safe enough" differs from the estimate of a technologist, then the technologist has no choice but to conform to public opinion.
Delivered on April 1990, the occasion of a conference of The Women's League for Conservative Judaism, sponsored by the Beth El Congregation of Oak Ridge. Produced by TAKE 1 VIDEO. Alan Manning was camera operator. Joan-Ellen Zucker was editor.
In protest of the closure, a coalition of environmental organizations will put on “Connect the Dots”, a live streamed protest event featuring multiple (socially distant) protests in downstate New York, connecting the dots between the closure of Indian Point to the increased usage of fracked gas at several gas plants and its impact on lower income communities. Analysis, commentary, and entertainment will be provided by scientists, activists, and musicians. The event will be live streamed on Facebook, Youtube, and Twitter and can be found at http://facebook.com/generationatomic/live
The on-the-ground protests will be held at three NY natural gas plants which will be making up the lost energy production from Indian Point: Cricket Valley Energy Center in Dover Plains, Ravenswood Generating Station in Long Island City, and CPV Valley Energy in Middletown. Protesters must follow all NY State social distancing guidelines, and must wear masks and any other protective equipment that is available. Waterproof signs and rain-friendly clothing are encouraged.
Hosted by:
GenerationAtomic.org
Protect Orange County
NuclearNY.org
Footprints to Wings
Stop Cricket Valley
ClimateCoalition.org
Confirmed Guests:
Robert Stone (Filmmaker, Pandora's Promise)
Dr. Pushker Kharecha (Climate Scientist, Columbia University)
Iida Ruishalme (Mothers for Nuclear, Thoughtscapism)
Jim Hopf (Climate Advocate, Citizens Climate Lobby, Retired Nuclear Engineer, Energy Solutions)
Meredith Angwin (Chemist, Yes VY Yankee)
Amardeo Sarma (Electrical Engineer, GWUP - German Skeptics)
Baba Brinkman (Peer Reviewed Rap Artist)
Mayor Theresa Knickerbocker (Mayor of Buchanan)
Dr. Kerry Emanuel (Climate Scientist, MIT)
To measure Thermal Conductivity of various Molten-Salts, we based our design off of J.W. Cook's 1970 variable gap design. That was a 20-year effort that finished in the 70s. The test apparatus that we've developed, if you've got a stainless steel it is about $13,000. If you went with Inconel it's about $25,000. The supporting materials would be a one-time purchase around $25,000.
Oak Ridge National Laboratory Molten Salt Workshop:
msrworkshop.ornl.gov
Interviewed and uploaded to YouTube by Gordon McDowell:
thoriumremix.com
Dianne Ezell and Ryan Gallagher ORNL Staff Profiles:
ornl.gov/staff-profile/n-dianne-d-ezell
ornl.gov/staff-profile/ryan-c-gallagher
Amanda Lines of Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) describes how numerous, versatile tools are available to capture fingerprints of huge range of fission products/species of interest to the fuel cycle. Raman spectroscopy (actinide oxide ions). UV vis NIR absorption (Actinides and lanthanides in multiple oxidation states).
Currently developing Molten-Salt Reactor off-gas treatment on-line monitoring to quantify iodine species. Dual methods: LIBS at ORNL, Raman at PNNL.
Video footage courtesy of Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) from their 2019 Molten Salt Reactor Workshop (ORNL MSRW 2019). Photos and video also courtesy of Amanda Lines and PNNL.
Oak Ridge National Laboratory Molten Salt Workshop:
msrworkshop.ornl.gov
Amanda Lines:
energyenvironment.pnnl.gov/staff/staff_info.asp?staff_num=1923
Interviewed and uploaded to YouTube by Gordon McDowell:
thoriumremix.com
Matthew Lish is working at Flibe Energy to help make the "Chemical Kidney" (LFTR's online chemical processing) a reality.
Challenges of equipment in a radioactive environment are damage to integrated circuits and motors. People also tend to stop working when exposed to massive doses of gamma radiation.
Matt noted that ORNL produced a film on this exact topic titled:
Remote Maintenance of Molten Salt Reactors
youtube.com/watch?v=uHT-w2x6dDg
Flibe Energy: flibe-energy.com
Matthew Lish's interview with Gordon McDowell was captured as part of Thorium Remix project, for use in future narrative video creations. https://ThoriumRemix.com/
REBCO superconducting tape enables doubling magnetic fields.
Size of magnetic fusion system for any given power output varies as one over the fourth power of the magnetic field. Higher magnetic fields can shrink fusion system size by an order of magnitude, power density in the fusion blanket increases by an order of magnitude.
Higher power densities in the blanket make it difficult to cool solid blankets. High magnetic fields create large incentives to have a coolant with low electrical conductivity to avoid coolant/magnetic field interactions.
REBCO Fusion Favors a Molten-Salt (particularly FLiBe Salt) Blanket.
Why Flibe (Li2BeF4) Salt?
Maximize tritium production (90% Li-6) to produce sufficient tritium for self-sustaining fusion machine. Beryllium (n, 2n) reaction generates more neutrons. Lithium plus neutron yields tritium. Excellent heat transfer relative to other salts.
Flibe (Li2BeF4) Salt Fusion Blankets Applicable to all Fusion Technologies. ARC is the First Design with REBCO Superconducting Magnets; Other Fusion Systems Likely to Follow with Incentives for Flibe Blankets.
Synergisms Between Flibe-Salt-Cooled Fission and Fusion Reactors:
•Basic science of salts
•Design tools
•Technology (materials, tritium control, salt purification, power cycles)
•Supply chains (equipment, FLiBe salt, lithium isotopic separation)
Synergisms Will Accelerate Development of All Salt Systems.
Dr. Charles Forsberg presentation given at Oak Ridge Molten Salt Reactor Workshop 2019 [ ORNL MSRW 2019 ]: msrworkshop.ornl.gov
THE PAPER: doi.org/10.1080/00295450.2019.1691400
Fusion Blankets and Fluoride-Salt-Cooled High-Temperature Reactors with Flibe Salt Coolant: Common Challenges, Tritium Control, and Opportunities for Synergistic Development Strategies Between Fission, Fusion, and Solar Salt Technologies
Charles Forsberg, Guiqiu (Tony) Zheng, Ronald G. Ballinger & Stephen T. Lam
Received September 12, 2019
Accepted for Publication November 7, 2019
Abstract — Recent developments in high-magnetic-field fusion systems have created large incentives to develop flibe (Li2BeF4) salt fusion blankets that have four functions: (1) convert the high energy of fusion neutrons into heat for the power system, (2) convert lithium into tritium—the fusion fuel, (3) shield the magnets against radiation, and (4) cool the first wall that separates the plasma from the salt blanket. Flibe is the same coolant proposed for fluoride-salt-cooled high-temperature reactors that use clean flibe coolant and graphite-matrix coated-particle fuel. Flibe is also the coolant proposed for some molten salt reactors (MSRs) where the fuel is dissolved in the coolant. The multiple applications for flibe as a coolant create large incentives for cooperative fusion-fission programs for development of the underlying science, design tools, technology (pumps, instrumentation, salt purification, materials, tritium removal, etc.), and supply chains. Other high-temperature molten salts are being developed for alternative MSR systems and for advanced Gen-III concentrated solar power (CSP) systems. The overlapping characteristics of flibe salt with these other salt systems create significant incentives for cooperative fusion-fission-solar programs in multiple areas. We describe the fission and fusion flibe-cooled systems, what has created this synergism, what is different and the same between fission and fusion in terms of using flibe, and the common challenges. We review (1) the characteristics of flibe salts, (2) the status of the technology, (3) the options for tritium capture and control in the salt, heat exchangers, and secondary heat transfer loops, and (4) the coupling to power cycles with heat storage. The technology overlap between flibe systems and other high-temperature MSR and CSP salt systems is described. This defines where there are opportunities for cooperative programs across fission, fusion, and CSP salt programs.
Dr. Charles Forsberg research areas include Fluoride-salt-cooled High-Temperature Reactors (FHRs) and utility-scale heat storage including Firebrick Resistance-Heated Energy Storage (FIRES). He teaches at MIT the fuel cycle and nuclear chemical engineering classes.
Presentation given at Oak Ridge Molten Salt Reactor Workshop 2019 [ ORNL MSRW 2019 ].
Video footage courtesy of ORNL and Dr. Charles Forsberg.
Video presented on this YouTube channel as part of Thorium Remix project. thoriumremix.com
Elysium Industries: http://www.elysiumindustries.com
ORNL MSRW 2019: msrworkshop.ornl.gov
Supplementing the discussion, Ed Pheil did also give testimony in Ohio Legislator concerning Ohio's HB104. Ed's articulated advantages of EI's MCSFR and challenges faced by all Advanced Reactor vendors.
egeneration.org helped supply HB104 testimony. All Ohio HB 104 testimony can be viewed here: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLuGiwaUJYEZcKOTgZJEvBNBr2-I0fgJCE
Ohio State Legislator HB 104: legislature.ohio.gov/legislation/legislation-committee-documents?id=GA133-HB-104
http://ThoriumRemix.com/ Video shot by volunteers and edited by Gordon McDowell as part of ongoing Thorium Remix project. Thorium Remix is Patreon funded. patreon.com/thorium
Scott Medwid and Gordon McDowell conducted the interview, with Scott Medwid asking questions on behalf of Oberlin College radio. This was so our conversation could be leveraged both in audio and video formats.
http://www.elysiumindustries.com
http://ThoriumRemix.com/ Video shot by volunteers and edited by Gordon McDowell as part of ongoing Thorium Remix project. Thorium Remix is Patreon funded.
http://ThoriumEnergyAlliance.com/ Presented at TEAC10 ( Thorium Energy Alliance Conference #10 ) on 2019-10-01 ( Oct 1st, 2019 ).
Copenhagen Atomics offers:
- Portable pumped molten salt loop
- FLiNaK Salt ingots
- Check valves
- U-clamps
- Temperature data logger
- K-type thermocouples
...http://www.copenhagenatomics.com/products.php
This talk was captured at Thorium Energy Alliance Conference #10 (TEAC10) in Oak Ridge, Tennessee. The footage will be recycled by https://ThoriumRemix.com/ for narrative purposes.
The entire TEAC10 playlist is here: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLuGiwaUJYEZe7mBUklByFpQlPtfZonI_X
Ashkhen Nalbandyan acknowledges the help of her colleagues from Seaborg technologies Jacob Groth-Jensen and Rowan Steyn. seaborg.co
COUPLED NEUTRONICS/THERMAL HYDRAULICS ASSESSMENT OF GRAPHITE MODERATED MOLTEN SALT REACTORS
Multiphysics coupling scheme between finite volume Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) code OpenFOAM and Monte Carlo based neutronics code Serpent. Scheme employs the Serpent Multiphysics interface allowing high fidelity coupling to OpenFOAM by directly passing variable fields between the two codes.
We simulate a graphite-moderated channel type MSR and compare the simulation results to data available on the Molten Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE). Specifically, fuel and graphite temperature profiles and fuel velocity fields are derived for steady state operation and compared to the results of model calculations performed at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL). A simple transient scenario of a step reactivity insertion is also modeled and the feedback of the system is evaluated and compared to experimental results.
Thorium Energy Alliance Conference #10 [TEAC10]: http://thoriumenergyalliance.com
This video captured for future use in Thorium Remix projects: thoriumremix.com
Ecomodernist Societies are grassroots organizations supporting a wide spectrum of pro-science environmental, health, and political issues.
Connect with Seattle Friends of Fission: seattlefof.org
Seattle Ecomodernist Society: https://seattle.ecomodern.club
Watch Karl's environmental videos at yestv.org
Thorium Energy Alliance Conference #10 [TEAC10]: http://thoriumenergyalliance.com
This video captured for future use in Thorium Remix projects: thoriumremix.com
I do own both of those (1st gen and 2nd gen) and on 2019-10-30 did visit an Apple Store to check out AirPods Pro... specifically the microphone.
I can't say microphone hardware has been identical between AirPods1 and AirPods2, but the performance when used in conjunction with video capture software to act as a "Bluetooth Microphone" was identical. (H1 is also used in Pro as in AirPods2, just a more power efficient version.)
This was my AirPods1 vs AirPods2 microphone comparison: youtube.com/watch?v=YR1o2M8ZLb4
...identical performance. And in stark contrast to all other non-Bluetooth options which sound far better.
So do AirPods Pro function as a superior Bluetooth Microphone over AirPods? No. They do NOT. The quality is identical.
With the redesign, it seems even less likely the microphone hardware is the same. Most likely it is Bluetooth audio compression and bandwidth causing the distortion.
Perhaps this can be addressed by using the same codec but with higher bandwidth. Or a different codec entirely? Apple controls the hardware, so assuming AirPods to iPhone it ought to be possible to get better performance out of the exact same hardware. (With the trade-off likely shorter battery life.)
When I speak on-the-phone using AirPods people can hear the difference. Audio isolation from the environment is pretty good, but no matter how quiet the room can be my voice always sounds poor. Very usable, but just not-as-good as the old wired-headphones mic or the iPhone's mic itself (speaker or handheld).
For video interviews, it is not so usable.
I did NOT buy AirPods Pro. Noise cancellation WAS very interesting... they sound great for music, and I'm sure I'd love them on a plane. But my primary need, a better video-capture microphone that I'll always have in my pocket, was not met.
ThorCon is a molten salt fission reactor. Unlike all current nuclear reactors, the fuel is in liquid form. It can be moved around with a pump and passively drained. This 500 MW fission power plant is encapsulated in a hull, built in a shipyard, towed to a shallow water site, ballasted to the seabed. ThorCon is a straightforward scale-up of the successful United States Oak Ridge National Laboratory Molten Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE).
The complete ThorCon is manufactured in 150 to 500 ton blocks in a shipyard, assembled, then towed to the site. This produces order of magnitude improvements in productivity, quality control, and build time. A single large reactor yard can turn out twenty gigawatts of ThorCon power plants per year. ThorCon is a system for building power plants.
ThorCon has been working with the Indonesian government to add reliable electric power to the grid. In 2019 the Ministry of Energy completed a successful study of the safety, economics, and grid impact of the 500 MW prototype ThorConIsle. Phase 1 is to build and test it with step by step commissioning, ending in a type license for future power plants. Phase 2 is shipyard production of ThorCon plants to provide an additional 3 GW of cheap, reliable electric power.
ThorCon: http://thorconpower.com
Thorium Energy Alliance: http://thoriumenergyalliance.com
This video captured for future use in Thorium Remix projects: thoriumremix.com
A modern version of ORNL’s MSRE dynamic modeling by Syd Ball and Tom Kerlin (ORNL-TM-1070, 1965).
Downloadable Slides:
https://msr.ne.utk.edu/~o/TEAC10_Chvala.pdf
Why Dynamic System Modeling?
- Simple and adaptable modeling approach that captures underlying physics.
- Ascertain transient behavior during normal operation and accident scenarios. Useful for I&C development.
- Determine safety limits and parameter sensitivities.
- Develop a validated open-source tool with accessible computational requirements.
MSR Dynamic Models Developed
- Molten Salt Reactor Experiment (PKE for core; PHX; radiator, validated with MSRE data).
- Molten Salt Breeder Reactor (Two-fluid modular MSBR, 1000MWe/4, ORNL-4528, 1970).
- Molten Salt Demonstration Reactor (Single fluid MSDR, 350MWe, ORNL-TM-3832, 1972).
Full power plant modeling: MSDR, ORNL-TM-3832
The OTSG combines the subcooled, boiling, and superheating regions into a single component body. The moving boiling and superheating boundaries allow the OTSG model to change the average heat transfer coefficient and thus function at different power levels.
The balance-of-plant system is composed of a nozzle chest, high-pressure turbine, moisture separator, reheater, low-pressure turbine, condenser, and two feedwater heaters.
These components together operate the superheated steam working fluid flowing from the OTSG through the reheated-regenerative Rankine cycle.
In this variation of the Rankine cycle two turbines work in series. The exhaust steam from the HPT is dried and reheated using a bypass flow before expansion in the LPT.
Furthermore, bleed flows and bypass steam are used to preheat feedwater that is pressurized via pumping to the steam generator.
These steps combine to increase the thermal efficiency of the Rankine cycle while providing practical advantages such as a higher quality exhaust at both turbines, which increases their lifetime, and a larger pressure difference between the boiler and condenser.
The full model consists of some 100 state variables.
When modeling a reactor plant, incorporating the full steam generator and balance-of-plant components can be burdensome.
Moreover, if the design for the turbine cycle is not finalized, adding an OTSG and BOP may not be ideal.
For these reasons, previous models included only the fuel salt and coolant loops.
Doing so, however, ignored some of the dynamic features which may have considerable impact on the power response.
So we calculated power-to-reactivity frequency response for three tertiary loop boundary conditions: constant energy removal from the Hitec loop, constant feedwater inlet temperature to the OTSG, and the full OTSG and BOP model.
For the most part, the behavior of the plant with only OTSG is indistinguishable from the full system model implying that most of the dynamics of interest are in the OTSG.
On the other hand, the behavior of MSDR with constant heat removal is similar but with important distinctions. Namely, the gain is lower than the cases with OTSG and full BOP and is seen to converge with the two at lower frequencies. However, the phase diverges at lower frequencies, but converges at higher frequencies.
Hence, a constant heat removal system simplifies the secondary side behavior, leads to an overestimation of feedback response, and is, in general, not fully accurate for modeling such systems for control studies.
CONCLUSIONS
- MSRs: tremendous progress in the last 10 years!
- Dynamic modeling characterizes system behavior in time.
- Useful for instrumentation and control.
- Accident scenarios, parameter sensitivity to guide research.
- Novel methods of safeguards.
- Functional requirements for a decay heat removal system.
- Well designed MSRs are stable and can rapidly follow demand load.
- Low pressure system with constant flow rates.
Thorium Energy Alliance: http://thoriumenergyalliance.com
This video captured for future use in Thorium Remix projects: thoriumremix.com
Andrew Yang has repeatedly expressed support for Thorium Reactors. In town halls, in policy proposal and in his candidacy blog. Popular Mechanics critiqued this proposal by citing solid-fuel challenges, despite there being no indication at all Andrew Yang is proposing solid-fuel reactors... in fact his website is very explicit about funding Thorium MOLTEN-SALT Reactor research.
CNN Climate Change Town Hall - Andrew Yang transcript: http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1909/04/se.02.html
Yang's policy blog mentioning Thorium Molten-Salt Reactors:
yang2020.com/blog/climate-change
Yang's Nuclear Power policy page mentioning Thorium Reactors:
yang2020.com/policies/nuclear-energy
Cory Booker has also been a long-time strong supporter of Advanced Nuclear.
2019 Coal Ash Report:
earthjustice.org/sites/default/files/files/National%20Coal%20Ash%20Report%203.4.19.pdf
This video uses footage from "Thorium." a 6.5 hour documentary about Thorium Molten-Salt Reactors. youtube.com/watch?v=2oK6Rs6yFsM
I recommend using "4K Video Downloader" to repurpose my video assets directly off YouTube. More video assets can be found here: http://thoriumremix.com
Introduced by Senator Marco Rubio, this Senate Staffer briefing shows the legislation being argued in favor by U.S. Army Brigadier General John Adams (Retired), the senior geoscientist Dr. Ned Mamula (USGS, DoE, CIA), James Kennedy (expert on Rare Earths), and Mark Noga who's spent 25 years sourcing Rare Earths for automotive, medical, aerospace and defense systems.
ThREE Consulting (James Kennedy)...
http://threeconsulting.com
Thorium Energy Alliance (John Kutsch)...
http://thoriumenergyalliance.com
S. 2093 RE-Coop 21st Century Manufacturing Act...
congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/senate-bill/2093
John Kutsch of Thorium Energy Alliance and James Kennedy of ThREE Consulting speak (briefly) on why a Rare Earth Cooperative is necessary, and the incentive structure which will enable massive foreign investment in domestic manufacturing infrastructure.
This presentation does NOT explain the importance of Rare Earths in high-tech manufacturing. It is assumed the viewer already understands the importance and irreplaceability of Heavy Rare Earths, and the question to address is: How can China's dominance be addressed?
ThREE Consulting (James Kennedy)...
http://threeconsulting.com
Thorium Energy Alliance (John Kutsch)...
http://thoriumenergyalliance.com
S. 2093 RE-Coop 21st Century Manufacturing Act...
congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/senate-bill/2093
NEXT Mission to Provide:
• energy that is less expensive and safer
• water that is pure and abundant
• medical isotopes used to diagnose and treat cancer
...by advancing the technology of molten salt reactors while educating the next generation of leaders in nuclear science
“A major issue that may hamper wide implementation in the clinic and that needs to be simultaneously addressed is the availability of suitable alpha particle emitters”
- Frontiers in Oncology Jan 2014 Volume 3 Article 324
Challenge of Alpha Emitters:
- Must be made.
- Short half-lives requires a continuous source.
Solution:
- Liquid Fuel
- Molten Salt Coolant
- Thorium Fuel Cycle
This talk was captured at Thorium Energy Conference 2018 (ThEC2018) in Brussels, Belgium. The footage may be recycled by https://ThoriumRemix.com/ for narrative purposes. Thorium Energy (World) conferences can be found here: http://www.thoriumenergyworld.com
ThEC2018 videos are collected in this ThEC2018 Playlist: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLKfir74hxWhPll2rp9pJO2oiCceFccHls
- Clean abundant energy
- Clean water
- Medical isotopes
How do we get to a Thorium Reactor?
- Making a safety case
- We need data to compare with simulation
- We need better instrumentation
- Flow, pressure, and temperature monitoring
MSTL Status: What are the Design parameters?
- Volume: approximately 19 liters with gas space for 7.5 more liters
- Currently running 36 kg of a eutectic mixture of Li NO3,K NO3,Na NO3.
- Side and bottom heaters supply 10 kW to the sump.
- 3 hp motor drives a centrifugal-type pump submerged in the salt bath from 1 to 60 Hz.
- Pump is made of 316 SS, and has been modified from the original configuration.
- Original impeller was replaced with a better balanced one.
- Pump is made of 316 SS, and has been modified from the original configuration.
- Original impeller was also replaced with a better balanced one.
- Change in the shaft diameter from 1” to 1.5” was made after we had some trouble with resonances.
- Loop itself is made of 7.8 m of 25 mm diameter 316 SS pipe with mostly threaded fittings.
- Testing unions, 3 valves, and a Krohne 4400 HT (450 C) flow meter.
- Testing several different sealant aids in the threads including Teflon (370 C), Graphoil GTS Thread Sealant paste (635 C), and Deacon 8875 sealant (982 C).
- Loop is wrapped with 12.5 mm wide heat tape that operates at 230 V.
- Currently have 23 type K thermocouples mounted to the loop and surrounding areas. We plan to add more as we add insulation.
- Gas blanket system provides humidity for drying salt as well as cover gas.
- Data Acquisition system is based on the MIDAS software developed at PSI and TRIUMF for Medium energy Physics slow controls.
- Currently handles RS485, Ethernet, USB, and 4-20 mA current loop inputs.
This talk was captured at Thorium Energy Conference 2018 (ThEC2018) in Brussels, Belgium. The footage may be recycled by https://ThoriumRemix.com/ for narrative purposes. Thorium Energy (World) conferences can be found here: http://www.thoriumenergyworld.com
ThEC2018 videos are collected in this ThEC2018 Playlist: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLKfir74hxWhPll2rp9pJO2oiCceFccHls
When fuel cycle parameters: power, reprocessing scheme, feed composition, etc. are fixed, reactor will converge to equilibrium state / fuel composition. The composition depends on feed type 238U or 232Th and on the reactor spectrum.
The spectrum is determined by scattering materials. Equilibrium composition and spectrum determine the multiplication factor. Equilibrium is inherent core state (composition, spectrum, reactivity). Equilibrium reactivity indicates neutron efficiency of the core and its capability for breeding in closed fuel cycle.
Better performance: Th-U in thermal and U-Pu in fast spectra. Graphite moderated MSR only in Th-U. Fluorides fast MSFR possible in both cycles (equal performance). Chlorides fast MSR maximum reactivity in both cycles. B&B possible for U-Pu.
Parasitic captures strongly differ between reactors.
- 20% in fast & up to 40 % in thermal Th-U cycle.
- 30% in fast & up to 120 % in thermal U-Pu cycle.
- Reactivity loss in Th-U is much lower (1/3 in thermal, 2/3 in fast case).
Th-U: lower ν and lower parasitic capture of 233U, breeding also in thermal spectrum.
U-Pu: higher ν and higher parasitic capture of 239Pu, better performance in fast spectra.
Th-U high efficiency.
U-Pu high economy.
Jiri Krepel | Advanced Nuclear System Group | Paul Scherrer Institute
This talk was captured at Thorium Energy Conference 2018 (ThEC2018) in Brussels, Belgium. The footage may be recycled by https://ThoriumRemix.com/ for narrative purposes. Thorium Energy (World) conferences can be found here: http://www.thoriumenergyworld.com
ThEC2018 videos are collected in this ThEC2018 Playlist: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLKfir74hxWhPll2rp9pJO2oiCceFccHls


