Uploaded February 2022 | Updated September 2026, 19 hours ago
Compatibilism is the thesis that free will is compatible with determinism. In other words, a compatibilist is someone who doesn’t have a quarrel with using the term “free will” and who doesn’t think we need to run around with our hair on fire if determinism turns out to be true. I think free will skeptics and libertarians are entirely wrong about the dramatic consequences that would follow from not possessing libertarian freedom.
As you may have gathered, I’ve finally migrated from the free will skeptic camp over to the compatibilist camp. Years ago, learning about determinism and moral luck for the first time rocked my world. But as the dust settled, I wondered if I had been too quick to reject the entire notion of free will. How much does it matter that we don’t have libertarian free will? How much has actually changed? Is our ordinary sense of free will really unsalvageable?
Consider supporting the show patreon.com/waldenpod or patreon.com/counter
Follow on Twitter @waldenpod @OnPanpsychism
Transcript emersongreenblog.wordpress.com/2022/02/21/can-a-determinist-believe-in-free-will
https://linktr.ee/emersongreen
/ timestamps /
00:00 Determinism and luck
01:06 Has anything actually changed?
05:20 Could've done otherwise
10:13 Final thoughts on compatibilism
Compatibilism is the thesis that free will is compatible with determinism. In other words, a compatibilist is someone who doesn’t have a quarrel with using the term “free will” and who doesn’t think we need to run around with our hair on fire if determinism turns out to be true. I think free will skeptics and libertarians are entirely wrong about the dramatic consequences that would follow from not possessing libertarian freedom.
As you may have gathered, I’ve finally migrated from the free will skeptic camp over to the compatibilist camp. Years ago, learning about determinism and moral luck for the first time rocked my world. But as the dust settled, I wondered if I had been too quick to reject the entire notion of free will. How much does it matter that we don’t have libertarian free will? How much has actually changed? Is our ordinary sense of free will really unsalvageable?
Consider supporting the show patreon.com/waldenpod or patreon.com/counter
Follow on Twitter @waldenpod @OnPanpsychism
Transcript emersongreenblog.wordpress.com/2022/02/21/can-a-determinist-believe-in-free-will
https://linktr.ee/emersongreen
/ timestamps /
00:00 Determinism and luck
01:06 Has anything actually changed?
05:20 Could've done otherwise
10:13 Final thoughts on compatibilism
