Long Story Short
Help us make more videos: patreon.com/c/LongStoryShort22
updated 2 years ago
patreon.com/c/LongStoryShort22
References.
00:14 Yes, this actually was a topic of real scientific research. See: Steinhauser G. The nature of naval fluff. Medical Hypotheses. 2009: 72; 623-625.
00:49 These criteria are not absolute - although fulfilling them provides more confidence (i.e., a higher likelihood of finding the truth), fulfilling them certainly does not guarantee arriving at truth. Additional criteria can be added to enhance confidence, but we wanted to keep this list concise. For more on this, see The Scientific Approach to Evolution, by Rob Stadler
02:10 We discussed Methodological Naturalism previously in our videos “Debunking popular science videos on the origin of life & RNA world.” and in “The Information Dilemma: How knock-knock jokes are a problem for evolution and the origin of life”.
03:59 Leaving the cupcakes in the oven for a million years, for instance, will ruin them. To assume that prebiotic earth not only had all the right ingredients, but could also do all of the things that the scientists do in their experiments is absurd. But that’s basically what they expect you to believe.
04:07And homochiral, we haven’t even talked about that yet…
04:11 Kitadai N, Maruyama S. Origins of building blocks of life: A review. Geoscience Frontiers. 2018; 9: 1117-1153. This is a review paper, detailing what other origin of life experiments did.
04:45 It is claimed that these substances could reach high concentrations through "drying out" on the beach of the warm little pond. BUT! These substances can't react without floating around in a solution to find their partner. This dilutes them and slows down or stops the reaction altogether! A pretty tough catch-22.
08:53 Mills, D. R., R. L. Peterson, and S. Spiegelman, An extracellular Darwinian experiment with a self-duplicating nucleic acid molecule. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 1967; 58: 217–224.
09:07 The replication was performed by a complex protein enzyme that was stolen from already living organisms (QBeta replicase).
09:34 Joyce G. Forty years of in vitro evolution. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2007: 46; 6420-6436. DOI: 10.1002/anie.200701369.
10:12 Tjhung KF, Shokhirev MN, Horning, DP, Joyce GF. “An RNA polymerase ribozyme that synthesizes its own ancestor.” PNAS 2020: 117; 2906-2913.
11:22 A more recent paper from Joyce’s lab: (Papasravuou N, Horning DP, Joyce GF. RNA-catalyzed evolution of catalytic RNA. PNAS. 2024; 121: e2321592121.) reported a small increase in replication fidelity but that was copying a much smaller RNA (about ⅙ of its size), and continued to disregard all of the other cheats commonly used.
11:32 About 1 out of 12 nucleotides that the ribozyme matched to the template were incorrect matches.
11:41 Mycoplasma mycoides and JVCI Syn 3B have the highest recorded mutation rate of any known cell: 1 in 33,000,000 nucleotides are incorrectly copied. Moger-Reischer RZ et al. Evolution of a Minimal Cell. Nature. 2023: 620; 122-127.
13:18 And besides, the case for ID isn't based upon negative reasoning, but positive evidence. Information points toward intelligence.
13:36 See all previous videos for more of the challenges.
Imagine you discovered a stone with ancient words carved into it! And they told a really good knock-knock joke. What an archaeological find! But to your surprise, scientists concluded that it came about through purely natural processes: “just physics and chemistry acting on an exposed rock.”
What? You’d need very specific lines and shapes to form letters, and then those letters would need to be in very specific arrangements to even get a bad knock knock joke.
“Well, if you leave rocks out in the wind and rain for long enough, you’re bound to get knock knock jokes eventually.”
Nobody would buy that. But this is eerily similar to typical explanations for the origin of life, except life is no joke (pun intended), and there are many more layers of complexity that would have to come together to kickstart life.
Help us make more videos: patreon.com/c/LongStoryShort22
Debunking "Where Did Life Come From? (feat. PBS Space Time and Eons!) "youtube.com/watch?v=_uAJY1mqtw4
Debunking "Can Science Explain the Origin of Life?" youtube.com/watch?v=fgQLyqWaCbA
Debunking "What Is the RNA World Hypothesis?" youtube.com/watch?v=K1xnYFCZ9Yg
Defining things is hard and when it comes to defining “life”... it’s not much easier. But at minimum, we’re pretty sure that to get to where we are today, life needed to replicate.
Every known cell, including all the cells in your body, came about through replication of a preceding cell, but cellular replication is waaaay too complicated. When scientists talk about how the first forms of life replicated, they have to think simpler, far simpler. Like at the molecular level (DNA).
All living things have DNA and have to copy it in order to reproduce. Problem is, copying the DNA molecule is also difficult, why start there? Let’s go even simpler! Scientists figure that RNA is a better candidate for the first replicating molecule. RNA is also found in all of life and is likewise capable of storing the instructions needed to build things, and it’s a bit simpler than DNA.
So, in 1962 MIT professor Alexander Rich first put forth the “RNA world” hypothesis that all of life we see in the world today started from RNA...
Could life have started from simply natural processes? Little bit of chemistry here, a dash of physics there — a LOT of time… and boom! We’ve got the beginning of life, abiogenesis…right?
We’ve already detailed a number of serious issues with abiogenesis (chemical evolution) in previous videos, but we’ll just assume that all of the scientific challenges mentioned in all these prior videos have been vaporized...
#originoflife #evolution
Charles Darwin and some modern scientists think that life started all on its own, it sort of just...happened, spontaneously. It’s called chemical evolution (aka Abiogenesis). They say it started with chemicals forming building blocks, and then combining into polymers like DNA and RNA.
The next step toward life would be CELL MEMBRANES. All living things are made of cells that are surrounded by a cell membrane, life simply cannot exist without membranes.
Origin-of-life researchers claim that cell membranes are easy to make and that they have demonstrated this in the lab. They point toward experiments where these molecules called “phospholipids” (or more generally “amphiphilic molecules”) are placed in water and they form into a spherical shell–kind of like a cell membrane–all on their own. Wow!
But is it really the case that cell membranes are so easy to form? Let’s take a look more closely….
References: docs.google.com/document/d/1XV1i4K9bs8SX-uJjCgmbcZb3d7nWnUUtUFsVzpTTm0Y
#originoflife
Abiogenesis: Before life began, assuming that we’ve got some of the building blocks needed for life - what’s the next step in chemical evolution we’d need to turn them into something actually living?
This video has been produced in collaboration with and reviewed for scientific accuracy by a panel of PhD scientists in the relevant fields.
Video References: docs.google.com/document/d/1QmWuFfHjeri_9eF15D-YlpYSUfGY4q_XD_csXhuVtcQ/edit?usp=sharing
#originoflife #evolution
Some really smart people, from Charles Darwin to scientists today, believe in abiogenesis. A “primordial soup” of chemicals led to life as we know it. But is this really the case?
1. Charles Darwin To J. D. Hooker, 1 February [1871] darwinproject.ac.uk/letter/DCP-LETT-7471.xml
2-5. Biological Science, Freeman, 5th ed. pg. 44, 4, 33,59
6. "The consensus is that life did arise naturally from the nonliving … the conclusion has, indeed, really become inescapable, for the first steps in that process have already been repeated in several laboratories".
– George Gaylord Simpson, Commenting on the results from the Miller-Urey experiment in the prestigious journal "Science", The World Into Which Darwin Led Us. Science 1960. 131: 966-974.
7. “There was some optimism that, had the experiment been left running, living creatures would soon be crawling out of the laboratory.”
–Walker SI, Packard N, Cody GD. 2017 Re-conceptualizing the origins of life. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 375: 20160337. http://dx.doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2016.0337
8. *Toxic in the chemical sense; that is, it reduces or prevents desired chemical reactions. Many necessary ingredients for abiogenesis are also toxic to existing life. For example: hydrogen cyanide (once used as a chemical warfare agent) and formaldehyde (the active ingredient in embalming fluid). That, while interesting, is not the criticism here.
9. A. Wotos el al., "Synthetic connectivity, emergence, and self-regeneration in the network of prebiotic chemistry," Science (2020). science.sciencemag.org/content/369/6511/eaaw1955
10. Generation Round 7 of Synthesis Date: 82 Biotic Molecules generated / 36,685 Cumulative Sum of All Molecules = 99.777% Ratio of Abiotic to Biotic Molecules. This problem would be compounded greatly with more time and successive rounds of generation.
11. *technical note: Unwanted cross reactions would leave these amino acids unable to properly interact to fold into functional proteins. Sort of like a lock packed with concrete or gum. Not to mention the various problems of dilution, chirality, and stability if polymers could form.
12. The Murchison meteorite contained “tens of thousands of different molecular compositions, and likely millions of diverse structures,” which “suggests that the extraterrestrial chemodiversity is high compared to terrestrial relevant biological- and biogeochemical-driven chemical space”
Translation: For each molecule you did want there are innumerable things we don’t want and would get in the way.
[Schmitt-Kopplin, P., et al., High molecular diversity of extraterrestrial organic matter in Murchison meteorite revealed forty years after its fall. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 2010. 107(7): 2763–2768.]
13. Ruiz-Bermejo, M., Menor-Salvan, C., Osuna-Esteban, S., Veintemillas-Verdaguer, S., 2007. Prebiotic microreactors: a synthesis of purines and dihydroxy compounds in aqueous aerosol. Origins of Life and Evolution of the Biosphere 37, 123e142.
14. “[Miller & Urey] showed that organic molecules (in this case amino acids) could be created from inorganic materials by natural environmental conditions” americanscientist.org/article/the-origin-of-life
15. "Geochemical Sources and Availability of Amidophosphates on the Early Earth"
Gibard C, Gorrell IB, Jiménez EI, Kee TP, Pasek MA, Krishnamurthy R. Geochemical Sources and Availability of Amidophosphates on the Early Earth. Angew Chem Int Ed Engl. 2019 Jun 11;58(24):8151-8155. doi: 10.1002/anie.201903808.
16. “Ribose is the sugar that is the building block to produce RNA. Ribose rapidly decomposes in aqueous solution. The half-life of ribose is 73 min at 100 oC and pH 7.0, and 44 years at 0 oC and pH 7.0.” The authors also point out that the degradation rate of ribose in a prebiotic ocean could have been even faster, considering that the pH of the ocean today is 8.2 (more than 10x more alkaline) than neutral pH, which would increase the ribose destruction rate by ~50%.
Larralde, R., Robertson, M.P., Miller, S.L.*, 1995. Rates of decomposition of ribose and other sugars: implications for chemical evolution. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 92, 8158e8160.
17. Levy, M., Miller, S.L., 1998. The stability of the RNA bases: implications for the origin of life. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 95, 7933e7938.
18. Chart adapted from © 2003 International Union of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology 22nd Edition Designed by Donald E. Nicholson, D.Sc., The University of Leeds, England – and Sigma-Aldrich. Used with permission.
19. For more information: The Stairway to Life amazon.com/Stairway-Life-Origin-Life-Reality/dp/1734183705
The mystery of Life’s Origin amazon.com/Mystery-Lifes-Origin-Charles-Thaxton/dp/1936599740
#originoflife #evolution
Bacterial evolution and antibiotic resistance is one of the all time greatest hits regarding evidence for Evolution. It’s true that antibiotics do stop working sometimes, AND antibiotic resistance is a form of evolution. But is this a demonstration of the creative power of Darwinian evolution, or is there something else going on?
Ecocyc, E. coli citrate related genes: ecocyc.org/ECOLI/NEW-IMAGE?type=MAPTICK&object=645100/654550&chromosome=COLI-K12&bp-range=645100/654550
Richard Lenski on his lab work: youtube.com/watch?v=PQr8ldEeO04
AP News article: apnews.com/article/cdadad7ccc304ab7dc54b5e52feebdda
If you have any feedback or criticism, let us know and we’ll try to address it (please be civil): longstoryshort@discovery.org
Original Video on Whale Evolution: youtube.com/watch?v=wq_oYftA2ow
Our Followup Rebuttal Video: youtube.com/watch?v=5ErLGxrSdw0
Jackson Wheat’s Critique: youtube.com/watch?v=gvj1p4ywNXM
Buono M. R., Fernández M. S., Reguero M. A., Marenssi S. A., Santillana S. N., Mörs T. 2016. Eocene basilosaurid whales from the La Meseta Formation, Marambio (Seymour) Island, Antarctica. Ameghiniana 53(3):296–315. DOI:10.5710/AMGH.02.02.2016.2922.
Marenssi S. A. 2006. Eustatically controlled sedimentation recorded by Eocene strata of the James Ross Basin, Antarctica. DOI:10.1144/GSL.SP.2006.258.01.09.
Reguero M., Goin F., Acosta Hospitaleche C., Dutra T., Marenssi S. 2013. Late Cretaceous/Paleogene West Antarctica terrestrial biota and its intercontinental affinities. DOI:10.1007/978-94-007-5491-1_1.
Gelfo J. N., Mörs T., Lorente M., López G. M., Reguero M. 2014. The oldest mammals from Antarctica, early Eocene of the La Meseta Formation, Seymour Island. DOI:10.1111/pala.12121.
Gelfo J. N., López G. M., Santillana S. N. 2017. Eocene ungulate mammals from West Antarctica: implications from their fossil record and a new species. DOI:10.1017/S0954102017000244.
Cenizo M., Acosta Hospitaleche C., Reguero M. 2015. Diversity of pseudo-toothed birds (Pelagornithidae) from the Eocene of Antarctica. DOI:10.1017/jpa.2015.48.
Engelbrecht A., Mörs T., Reguero M. A., Kriwet, J. 2019. Skates and rays (Elasmobranchii, Batomorphii) from the Eocene La Meseta and Submeseta formations, Seymour Island, Antarctica. Historical Biology 31(8):1028–1044. DOI:10.1080/08912963.2017.1417403.
Doguzhaeva L. A., Bengtson S., Reguero M. A., Mörs T. 2017. An Eocene orthocone from Antarctica shows convergent evolution of internally shelled cephalopods. PLoS ONE 12(3):e0172169, 1–20. DOI:10.1371/journal.pone.0172169.
Marramà G., Engelbrecht A., Mörs T., Reguero M. A., Kriwet J. 2018. The southernmost occurrence of Brachycarcharias (Lamniformes, Odontaspididae) from the Eocene of Antarctica provides new information about the paleobiogeography and paleobiology of Paleogene sand tiger sharks. Rivista Italiana di Paleontologia e Stratigrafia 124(2):283–298. DOI:10.13130/2039-4942/9985.
Davis S. N., Torres C. R., Musser G. M., Proffitt J. V., Crouch N. M. A., Lundelius E. L., Lamanna M. C., Clarke J. A. 2020. New mammalian and avian records from the late Eocene La Meseta and Submeseta formations of Seymour Island, Antarctica. PeerJ 8:e8268, 1–27. DOI:10.7717/peerj.8268.
Original Video on Whale Evolution: youtube.com/watch?v=wq_oYftA2ow
PZ Myers’ Critique: youtube.com/watch?v=MiuOCh7MhSU
Jackson Wheat’s Critique: youtube.com/watch?v=zbkmbi8ggMI
Behe & Snoke’s original waiting time paper: ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2286568
Durrett & Schmidt’s response paper: genetics.org/content/180/3/1501.full
Behe’s Response: discovery.org/a/9461
Durrett & Schmidt’s Reply: genetics.org/content/181/2/821.full
Behe’s Further Reply: discovery.org/a/9611
White 2004 ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC385418
Behe & Snoke’s reply to Lynch: ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2253464
Back in the 80s and 90s a series of fossils were found that rocked the evolutionary landscape, paleontologists thought they had found a clear transitional series of fossils documenting the evolution of whales.
University of Chicago Evolutionary Biologist Jerry Coyne says in his book, Why Evolution is True: “This is one of our best examples of an evolutionary transition...”
Wow, one of the best... let’s take a look at the story behind whale evolution, is it a good argument?
References:
Origin of Species
Jerry Coyne, Why Evolution is True. Penguin Books (2010)
Robert A. Martin, Missing Links: Evolutionary Concepts & Transitions Through Time, pg. 153
Muddy tetrapod origins Philippe Janvier & Gaël Clément Nature volume 463, pages 40–41(2010) nature.com/articles/463040a
Interview with paleontologist Günter Bechly
youtube.com/watch?v=93V6l2PPJws
Waiting for Two Mutations: With Applications to Regulatory Sequence Evolution and the Limits of Darwinian Evolution ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2581952
Very interesting discussion with Behe, Durrett & Schmidt regarding their calculations: discovery.org/a/9611
Giraffe genome sequence reveals clues to its unique morphology and physiology
Morris Agaba, et al. Nature Communications volume 7, Article number: 11519 (2016) nature.com/articles/ncomms11519
Eocene basilosaurid whales from the la Meseta formation, Marambio (Seymour) Island, Antarctica researchgate.net/publication/294107780_Eocene_basilosaurid_whales_from_the_la_Meseta_formation_Marambio_Seymour_Island_Antarctica
evolutionnews.org/2020/03/researchers-it-exists-therefore-it-evolved
Questions, comments, hate mail? theshortstoryvideos@gmail.com
My original video: youtu.be/KXmuN2orx28
Jackson's 1st reply: youtu.be/yNiLgA5afos
My first response: youtu.be/4VYISu9N7hk
Jackson's 2nd reply: youtu.be/6NhKrnJSnXk
References are below:
1: Pattern pluralism and the Tree of Life hypothesis pnas.org/content/104/7/2043
Scientist giving up on darwin after reading ID work:
2: youtube.com/watch?v=NmZd4SzVD7M
3: claremontreviewofbooks.com/giving-up-darwin
4: youtube.com/watch?v=noj4phMT9OE
5:Does ID make predictions, is it testable? youtube.com/watch?v=fcjUcM-d3jA
6: Jargonistic non-answers: Darwin’s Doubt pg 227-228 “Word Salad”
7: Phylogenetic Incongruities: Woese C. 1998. “The universal ancestor.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 95:6854-6859.
9: Bapteste E., et. al. 2005. “Do orthologous gene phylogenies really support tree-thinking?.” BMC Evolutionary Biology 5:33.
10: Convergence: evolutionnews.org/2017/05/the-real-problem-with-convergence
hate mail: theshortstoryvideos@gmail.com
regular mail: theshortstoryvideos@gmail.com
My Video on Homology: youtube.com/watch?v=KXmuN2orx28
Jackson Wheat's Response: youtube.com/watch?v=yNiLgA5afos
More info on nested hierarchies & cladistics:
“Matzke, Cladistics, and Missing Ancestors” Stephen C. Meyer, Chapter 4 of Debating Darwin’s Doubt. Pgs 42-70 (2015)
“The Fossil Record and Universal Common Ancestry” Gunter Bechly & Stephen C. Meyer, pgs 331-361, Theistic Evolution: A Scientific, Phlosophical, and Theological Critique (2017)
“The Tree of Life” Johnathan Wells, pgs 23-48 Zombie Science: More Icons of Evolution (2017)
evolutionnews.org/2018/07/bio-complexity-presents-a-better-model-than-common-ancestry-for-explaining-the-pattern-of-nature
Important information about platypuses: youtube.com/watch?v=Av7pO59yhqE
hate mail: theshortstoryvideos@gmail.com
One of the best arguments Darwin used for his theory was that of homology: the odd similarities between very different animals. Why would they be so similar unless they were related? He thought. And this does make sense, after all take siblings, they look pretty similar - they’re closely related. Then take cousins, or 3rd uncles, or former roommates. Less similar looking, less related. More similar looking = more related. Makes sense!
Darwin wasn’t the first to notice this, but he did harness it as a central proof in The Origin of Species. It’s to this day used a great evidence for evolution...but is really? Here’s the story.
More Reading:
iconsofevolution.com/survival-of-the-fakest
Do All Life Forms Fall into a Nested Hierarchy? evolutionnews.org/2015/06/do_all_life_for
Responding to the NCSE: exploreevolution.com/2009/02/23/anatomical_homology_and_circul_1
A Primer on the Tree of Life: discovery.org/a/10651
Questions? theshortstoryvideos@gmail.com
It’s 1859 and there was this guy named Charles Darwin and he rode on a beagle to these islands, and had a little idea....(Evolution). Just like humans can take the variety that they saw in animals (descent with modification) and breed horses to be faster or dogs to more hot-dog-like; given enough time, Ol’ Charlie D. figured, nature could take even the smallest, slimiest, of creatures and create the biggest and most baddest of T-Rexes (random mutation & natural selection). Nice.
BUT, there was one doubt that he couldn’t shake, a problem that threatened to undo his entire theory. here’s the story...


