Orthodox Christian Theology (Craig Truglia)
Life After Death: Tollhouses, Hades, and More with Father John Whiteford
updated
Purchase "The Rise and Fall of the Papacy": amazon.com/Rise-Fall-Papacy-Orthodox-Perspective/dp/1639410325/ref=tmm_pap_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&dib_tag=se&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.RNbspfzvBA2YhNhdvD6NYbxpphQ4gW7QQ3FrUMldkQM.y7qr_5xCKtifN58HY_RIgqPCBbmlzrbPUw4oiES7Irw&qid=1726046018&sr=1-2
Check out the "Charitable Apostolic Christian Discussion" Discord server: discord.gg/46HVm2jE4R
Support missionary work in Cambodia: http://www.OrthodoxChristianTheology.com/donate
Cameron Riecker's YT Channel: youtube.com/@CameronRiecker
Check out the "Charitable Apostolic Christian Discussion" Discord server: discord.gg/46HVm2jE4R
Support missionary work in Cambodia: http://www.OrthodoxChristianTheology.com/donate
0:00 Introduction
1:02 1. Saint Pope Clement
1:48 2. Saint Irenaeus
5:19 3. Pope Victor I
7:12 4. Saint Cyprian & All Bishops Inherit Peter's Keys
11:24 5. Arguments From Silence
11:44 6. The Council of Ephesus
13:11 7. No One Denies Papal Supreme Authority!
14:24 8. Popes Are Deposed, Anathematized, Excommunicated...
15:22 9. Uselessness of Papal Infallibility Doctrine
16:52 Do Your Research! Which View Reconciles Everything?
The History of the Papacy in 12 Minutes: youtube.com/watch?v=KDOKd1z3NmM&
The Early Church Fathers on the Papacy: orthodoxchristiantheology.com/2022/08/28/the-early-church-fathers-on-the-papacy-an-orthodox-quote-mine
Purchase "The Rise and Fall of the Papacy": amazon.com/Rise-Fall-Papacy-Orthodox-Perspective/dp/1639410325/ref=tmm_pap_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&dib_tag=se&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.RNbspfzvBA2YhNhdvD6NYbxpphQ4gW7QQ3FrUMldkQM.y7qr_5xCKtifN58HY_RIgqPCBbmlzrbPUw4oiES7Irw&qid=1726046018&sr=1-2
Check out the "Charitable Apostolic Christian Discussion" Discord server: discord.gg/46HVm2jE4R
Support missionary work in Cambodia: http://www.OrthodoxChristianTheology.com/donate
Check out the "Charitable Apostolic Christian Discussion" Discord server: discord.gg/46HVm2jE4R
Support missionary work in Cambodia: http://www.OrthodoxChristianTheology.com/donate
Check out Counsel of Trent: youtube.com/@TheCounselofTrent
Check out the "Charitable Apostolic Christian Discussion" Discord server: discord.gg/46HVm2jE4R
Support missionary work in Cambodia: http://www.OrthodoxChristianTheology.com/donate
Purchase "Fellowship with Christ’s Suffering: A Critical and Orthodox Interpretation of the Book of Job" here: amazon.com/dp/B0DCGMJZTB?psc=1&smid=ATVPDKIKX0DER&ref_=chk_typ_imgToDp
Check out the "Charitable Apostolic Christian Discussion" Discord server: discord.gg/46HVm2jE4R
Support missionary work in Cambodia: http://www.OrthodoxChristianTheology.com/donate
Support missionary work in Cambodia: http://www.OrthodoxChristianTheology.com/donate
0:00 Introduction and Challenge
0:40 10. Why Are the Scriptures Silent About the Papacy?
2:28 9. Why Are the Scriptures Silent About Double Procession?
5:13 8. Why did before the schism the pro-Filioque side deny double procession?
18:55 7. How is Papal Infalliblity a verifiable or even useful doctrine?
21:10 6. Why does Pope Martin deny direct jurisdiction?
23:11 5. How is doctrinal development anything other than an epistemic ad hoc?
25:22 4. How are indulgences an apostolic doctrine without an arbitrary appeal to development of doctrine?
27:24 3. How is the Immaculate Conception an apostolic doctrine without an arbitrary appeal to development of doctrine?
30:15 2. How does the Pope have the final say when he excommunicated Nestorius and Dioscorus, but they were treated as bishops by ecumenical councils?
34:37 1. How is the RCC not schismatic without a twisted, self-serving view or morality?
NFTU: True Orthodox News and Apologetics: youtube.com/@theorthodoxapologeticschan9378
Support missionary work in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
Join "Charitable Apostilic Christians" Discord: discord.gg/tG25xh6Qp3
0:00 Introduction
6:13 What Really Is Papal Infallibility?
9:45 Good Historical Resources
11:20 Pre-Schism Historical Ecclesiology
30:37 Nicea II and Ecumenicity: In Context
43:15 The Ecclesiology of Pope Vigilius
49:15 Constantinople II Dogmatizes Conciliarism
1:01:49 Where Does Constantinople II's Decree Start?
1:07:34 What Role Did "Conciliar Contextualism" Play In Constantinople II?
1:18:18 Was Vigilius Really Pope?
1:20:58 Circular Nature of RC Apologetics
1:21:37 Saint Menas' Wanted Papal Review?
1:22:28 Was Saint Maximus Pro Vatican I?
1:26:17 Were Saints Anatolius and Justinian Pro Vatican I?
1:27:25 Did Constantinople II Accept All Papal Decretals?
1:30:38 Popes Can Be Deposed By Councils and Kings
1:34:25 Pope Leo IV Accepted "Imperial Review"
1:36:19 Popes Can Be Canonically Judged For Heresy
1:38:54 Was Pope Vigilius a Heretic?
1:40:45 "Bad Guy Justinian" Is a Poor Polemic
1:42:08 Questions and Comments
Purchase "The Rise and Fall of the Papacy:" amazon.com/Rise-Fall-Papacy-Orthodox-Perspective-ebook/dp/B0CNMLW481/ref=sr_1_1?crid=RFELI1S3STRN&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.69o2OP7onKrpIcSkk-TfOtwO_zKIOJGkjoXH220eaIJKjpSHCQxvRPTzc968Fh2Np150D3Qy5ofhnvla42LZJaOuEpKTFXgJsSFACi7FveFVaSsMZmexisFjOdiuq4HVmVNvC5ZFdvYIfFV6iKk0FnSRnztpVi317wRB-Z3IhPo.D5JOTHUX1R4TajiGkGM5tFGoARgLm6TsCF_UeHJfNAc&dib_tag=se&keywords=rise+and+fall+of+the+papacy&qid=1716034411&s=digital-text&sprefix=rise+and+fall+of+the+papacy%2Cdigital-text%2C119&sr=1-1
"History of the Papacy" on Youtube: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLVwbBvePrG5K4GJ6QQCeSeYH7gOZcZdDt
Check out the "Charitable Apostolic Christian Discussion" Discord server: discord.gg/46HVm2jE4R
Support missionary work in Cambodia: http://www.OrthodoxChristianTheology.com/donates
-Church buildings (Eusebius and Clement of Alexandria)
-Altars (Ignatius)
-Sign of the cross (Pompeii "Crosses of Pompeii," Tertullian)
-Godparents (Hippolytus)
-Renunciation of Satan before baptism (Hippolytus)
-Baptism of children (Origen, Cyprian)
-Chrismation (Theophilus of Antioch, Tertullian)
-Prayers for the dead (2 Timothy, Tertullian, Cyprian)
-Deacons and Church lay orders (Hippolytus)
-Particular hypostasis doctrine (Origen, conceptually hippolytus)
-"Chalcedonian" Christological terminology such as "without confusion/change" (Hippolytus, Philo)
-EED (Theophilus of Antioch, CL)
-Iconodulia (Irenaeus, Acts of John)
-Dormition (Book of Mary's Repose, Dormition of Ps-John)
-Profound Angelology (Ignatius, Ascnsion of Isaiah, Qumran)
This video is not about the authenticity of the corpus, which is covered in "The Life of Saint Dionysius the Areopogite," available here: amazon.com/dp/B0CTG6KLJP
The Other Paul's YT Channel: youtube.com/@TheOtherPaul
To support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
Join our Discord server "Charitable Apostolic Christian Discourse:" discord.gg/U7ASqfwVJX
For more discussion, check out the Charitable Apostolic Christians Discord Group: discord.gg/tG25xh6Qp3
To support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
For citations and a comprehensive discussion of Patristic Mariology: https://www.revistateologica.ro/wp-content/uploads/RT-4-2021.pdf
Watch original debate on Standing For Truth: youtube.com/watch?v=uamC7gLFzVI&
For more discussion, check out the Charitable Apostolic Christians Discord Group:
discord.gg/2H58PfSP7Y
To support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
- Married into it
- Culture Warriors
- History Bros
- People who believe that there's more to Christianity than the Bible
- Artsy Fartsy Types
- Reverts when they have kids
- People tired of secularism
For more discussion, check out the Charitable Apostolic Christians Discord Group: discord.gg/qB26XRkYB9
To support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
For more discussion, check out the Charitable Apostolic Christians Discord Group: discord.gg/qB26XRkYB9
To support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
For more discussion, check out the Charitable Apostolic Christians Discord Group: discord.gg/qB26XRkYB9
To support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
Father John Whiteford's Youtube Channel (please subscribe): youtube.com/@st.jonahorthodoxchurch5607
NFTU: True Orthodox News and Apologetics: youtube.com/@theorthodoxapologeticschan9378
Support missionary work in Cambodia: http://www.OrthodoxChristianTheology.com/donate
For more discussion, check out the Charitable Apostolic Christians Discord Group: discord.gg/N5GCRnYgyy
To support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
0:00 Introduction
1:39 A recent miracle in the parish
4:47 Father Roman's Formation
10:26 What must I do to be saved?
12:25 Is there salvation outside the Church?
18:24 How is it fair that Orthodoxy is mostly in only certain countries?
21:03 Is Father Seraphim Rose a Saint?
22:39 Sainthood of Fr Daniel Sysoev
26:41 Baptism Debate: Form, Rebaptism, Etc
33:29 Do we evangelize to old relatives?
38:21 Fate of unbaptized children
41:16 Contraception
44:40 Marital fasting
52:07 Spiritual effects on children born from unchaste relations
58:20 Is contraception mortal sin?
1:05:19 Who to root for in Rocky IV
1:07:56 Ecumenism versus Evangelism
1:11:17 How can Orthodox improve their missionary work?
1:18:05 Being called a "LARPer" hurts my feelings!
1:20:43 What do I do if there is no Orthodox church nearby?
1:25:00 Do you have a favorite saint?
1:27:57 Confessions of Mogila and Dositheus
1:30:05 Thoughts on Western Rite Orthodoxy
1:31:53 Icons of (or with) the Father
1:38:52 Are there many True Orthodox in Russia?
1:41:56 Are there still clairvoyant spiritual elders in Russia today?
1:43:41 Can Greeks commune in a Russian church?
1:47:44 Should some people get corrective baptisms?
1:58:40 Oriental Orthodox in Cambodia
1:59:48 Is the Filioque really that big a deal?
2:03:46 Support the mission in Cambodia
For more discussion, check out the Charitable Apostolic Christians Discord Group: discord.gg/qB26XRkYB9
To support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
To support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
Purchase "The Rise and the Fall of the Papacy:" amazon.com/Rise-Fall-Papacy-Orthodox-Perspective/dp/1639410325/ref=sr_1_2?crid=2H5VY06WDWN08&keywords=truglia&qid=1700577925&rnid=2941120011&s=books&sprefix=truglia%2Caps%2C359&sr=1-2
Join our Discord server "Charitable Apostolic Christian Discourse:" discord.gg/Rf7ceN5rHy
Check out Kaleb of Atlanta: kalebatlantaprime.medium.com
Check out Patriarch Prime on Twitter: twitter.com/Kaleb_Atlanta?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Eauthor
Check out the "Charitable Apostolic Christian Discussion" Discord server: discord.gg/46HVm2jE4R
Support missionary work in Cambodia: http://www.OrthodoxChristianTheology.com/donate
To support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
Purchase "The Rise and the Fall of the Papacy:" amazon.com/Rise-Fall-Papacy-Orthodox-Perspective/dp/1639410325/ref=sr_1_2?crid=2H5VY06WDWN08&keywords=truglia&qid=1700577925&rnid=2941120011&s=books&sprefix=truglia%2Caps%2C359&sr=1-2
Join our Discord server "Charitable Apostolic Christian Discourse:" discord.gg/Rf7ceN5rHy
Purchase "The Rise and Fall of the Papacy:" amazon.com/Rise-Fall-Papacy-Orthodox-Perspective/dp/1639410325/ref=sr_1_2?crid=2H5VY06WDWN08&keywords=truglia&qid=1700577925&rnid=2941120011&s=books&sprefix=truglia%2Caps%2C359&sr=1-2
History of the Papacy in 12 Minutes: youtube.com/watch?v=KDOKd1z3NmM&
For more discussion, check out the Charitable Apostolic Christians Discord Group: discord.gg/qB26XRkYB9
To support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
Read the deatils here: orthodoxchristiantheology.com/2024/01/19/was-papal-infallibility-interpolated-into-saint-pope-agathos-letter
To support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
Purchase "The Rise and the Fall of the Papacy:" amazon.com/Rise-Fall-Papacy-Orthodox-Perspective/dp/1639410325/ref=sr_1_2?crid=2H5VY06WDWN08&keywords=truglia&qid=1700577925&rnid=2941120011&s=books&sprefix=truglia%2Caps%2C359&sr=1-2
For more discussion, check out the Charitable Apostolic Christians Discord Group: discord.gg/qB26XRkYB9
To support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
Purchase "The Rise and the Fall of the Papacy:" amazon.com/Rise-Fall-Papacy-Orthodox-Perspective/dp/1639410325/ref=sr_1_2?crid=2H5VY06WDWN08&keywords=truglia&qid=1700577925&rnid=2941120011&s=books&sprefix=truglia%2Caps%2C359&sr=1-2
For more on the historical Papacy purchase "The Rise and Fall of the Papacy": uncutmountainpress.com/shop/product/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-papacy
For more discussion join the "Charitable Apostolic Christians" Discord: discord.com/invite/qB26XRkYB9
00:00 Introduction
00:40 A Russian's Impression of the Russian Diaspora
3:20 Fr Ambrosey's Repentance and Faith in Christ
5:35 Do Russians Really Understand Slavonic?
10:40 Why Christianity and Not Heathenism?
13:00 Can Educated People Be Christian?
13:55 Why Orthodoxy and Not Protestantism? Exclusivity.
19:16 Fr A's PHD Dissertation's Discussion on the "Invisible Church"
22:49 Meeting New Martyr Daniel Sysoev
26:43 Why Evangelize?
30:40 How Does Overcoming Trial Relate to Evangelism?
32:01 Dealing With "Rejection" When Evangelizing
37:48 Spiritual Preparation for the Evangelist
39:26 Do Monks Have a Height Requirement?
39:59 How Does One Consider Monasticism?
41:41 Why Evangelize Heterodox Christian Grenadans?
44:56 How Can You Support the Mission? GrenadaOrthodox.org
47:49 Let's Organize an Evangelism Society
52:57 The Connection With Cambodia
54:20 Caribbean Needs Missionaries!
57:31 Will All the Jews Be Saved?
59:04 The Will to Evangelize
To support the mission in Grenada go to: grenadaorthodox.org
For very large donations, please specify it is for the Grenadan mission: fundforassistance.org
To help organize missionary efforts go to the "Charitable Apostolic Christians" Discord: discord.com/invite/qB26XRkYB9
Father John Whiteford's Youtube Channel (please subscribe): youtube.com/@st.jonahorthodoxchurch5607
To purchase newly translated hagiographies: http://www.scriptoriumpress.ca
To support missionary work in Cambodia: http://www.OrthodoxChristianTheology.com/donate
To purchase newly translated hagiographies: http://www.scriptoriumpress.ca
To support missionary work in Cambodia: http://www.OrthodoxChristianTheology.com/donate
Script is from the book "The Rise and Fall of the Papacy" available at: uncutmountainpress.com/shop/product/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-papacy
Video created by Deo Creative: youtube.com/@DeoCreative
Narration provided by HarmonyHarmonyHarmony: youtube.com/@harmonyharmonyharmony
March 14 – 16, 2024
Sign up here: uncutmountainpress.com/shop/product/conference-8th-oecumenical
The conference will take place at Lake Guntersville State Park Lodge and Conference Center from March 14-16, 2024 on the theme: The Eighth Oecumenical Council: The Catholic Condemnation of the Filioque. The conference speakers will explore the history, ecumenicity, decisions, and significance of the Council especially with respect to the Great Schism. At the heart of this conference will be an Athonite-style vigil for the Feast of the Eighth Oecumenical Council. A rare gathering and an exceptional opportunity you won’t want to miss!
Honorary Chairman:
His Grace Bishop LONGIN of New Gracanica-Midwest America
For more discussion, check out the Charitable Apostolic Christians Discord Group: discord.com/invite/qB26XRkYB9
To support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
Original video: youtube.com/live/cRIbb5YMG98?feature=share
For nitty gritty:
orthodoxchristiantheology.com/2023/09/15/hieronymus-catholic-is-wrong-on-augustine-and-the-filioque-part-1
orthodoxchristiantheology.com/2023/09/18/hieronymus-catholic-is-wrong-on-augustine-and-the-filioque-part-2
Has this film blessed you? Support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
Original video: youtube.com/live/cRIbb5YMG98?feature=share
For nitty gritty:
orthodoxchristiantheology.com/2023/09/15/hieronymus-catholic-is-wrong-on-augustine-and-the-filioque-part-1
orthodoxchristiantheology.com/2023/09/18/hieronymus-catholic-is-wrong-on-augustine-and-the-filioque-part-2
Has this film blessed you? Support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
Check out Father Stephen at: stephanebigham.com/en
For more discussion, check out the Charitable Apostolic Christians Discord Group: discord.gg/qB26XRkYB9
Support Orthodox Christian Theology by supporting the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
Note: A section in the middle, where I made an error interpreting Aquinas' "Against Greek Errors" has been removed to prevent confusion. The pinned comment discusses this. The rest of the video had useful content, so I have put it back up in edited form.
For more discussion, check out the Charitable Apostolic Christians Discord Group: discord.gg/qB26XRkYB9
To support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
Craig Truglia reviews the Novatian and Dontatist controversies, the canonical teaching of the Church (including the Pan-Orthodox synods of Iasi 1643 and Jerusalem 1672), the Russian tradition of broadly applying economia, and the modern state of Orthodoxy. Audience questions and comments will be interspersed and guest Orthodox "influencers" are invited to join, no matter their views, and have a civil discussion.
For more discussion, check out the Charitable Apostolic Christians Discord Group: discord.gg/qB26XRkYB9
To support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
Watch "The Errors of the Catholics:" youtube.com/watch?v=Wfeo6A-5agE&
For more discussion, check out the Charitable Apostolic Christians Discord Group: discord.gg/qB26XRkYB9
To support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate
Note for viewers: This is an interview, not a debate or refutation of his work. The goal is to draw out more fully the nature of Protestant objections so people can intelligently evaluate what both sides bring to the table.
For more discussion, check out the Charitable Apostolic Christians Discord Group: discord.gg/qB26XRkYB9
Has this video blessed you? Support the parishes in Cambodia: http://www.orthodoxchristiantheology.com/donate


