Robert Saltzman
Whats Wrong With Nonduality?
updated
Robert's Books:
The 21st Century Self:
amazon.com/21st-Century-Self-Illusion-Machinery/dp/0645888788
Understanding Claude:
amazon.com/Understanding-Claude-Artificial-Intelligence-Psychoanalyzed/dp/1738529665
Depending On No-thing:
amazon.com/Depending-No-Thing-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353595
The Ten Thousand Things:
amazon.com/Ten-Thousand-Things-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353501
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Robert's Books:
The 21st Century Self:
amazon.com/21st-Century-Self-Illusion-Machinery/dp/0645888788
Understanding Claude:
amazon.com/Understanding-Claude-Artificial-Intelligence-Psychoanalyzed/dp/1738529665
Depending On No-thing:
amazon.com/Depending-No-Thing-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353595
The Ten Thousand Things:
amazon.com/Ten-Thousand-Things-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353501
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
There is no fixed you.Summary of the Video by GPT4o:In this wide-ranging conversation, Robert rejects the notion of a permanent, unified self. He describes awakeness not as a spiritual attainment, but as the clear seeing that no one is in control—that “myselfness” is assembled moment by moment and has no fixed essence. Drawing from psychotherapy, Buddhism, and personal observation, he critiques nonduality culture, spiritual authority, and metaphysical consolation. The message is direct: what you are, you already are—and there’s nothing to become. Awakening is not arrival, but the end of striving.
A must-read for every seeker of truth in this confusing age. Dr. Robert Saltzman’s The 21st Century Self (amazon.com/21st-Century-Self-Illusion-Machinery-ebook/dp/B0FH5R2DMM) is not just a book—it is a mirror held up to the illusions we live by. With razor-sharp insight and rare humility, he tears through the modern myths of identity, ego, and spiritual posturing. No jargon, no preaching—only deep seeing. This work touched my heart and shook my assumptions. Highly recommended.— Anirudh Sharma, PuneBooks By Robert:The Ten Thousand Things (amazon.com/Ten-Thousand-Things-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1739724941/ref=monarch_sidesheet_title) Depending On No-Thing (amazon.com/dp/1999353595) Understanding Claude (amazon.com/Understanding-Claude-Artificial-Intelligence-Psychoanalyzed-ebook/dp/B0F6PHHVFQ) The 21st Century Self (amazon.com/21st-Century-Self-Illusion-Machinery-ebook/dp/B0FH5R2DMM)
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit robertsaltzman.substack.com (https://robertsaltzman.substack.com?utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=CTA_1)
Robert's Books:
The 21st Century Self:
amazon.com/21st-Century-Self-Illusion-Machinery/dp/0645888788
Understanding Claude:
amazon.com/Understanding-Claude-Artificial-Intelligence-Psychoanalyzed/dp/1738529665
Depending On No-thing:
amazon.com/Depending-No-Thing-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353595
The Ten Thousand Things:
amazon.com/Ten-Thousand-Things-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353501
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Robert's Books:
The 21st Century Self:
amazon.com/21st-Century-Self-Illusion-Machinery/dp/0645888788
Understanding Claude:
amazon.com/Understanding-Claude-Artificial-Intelligence-Psychoanalyzed/dp/1738529665
Depending On No-thing:
amazon.com/Depending-No-Thing-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353595
The Ten Thousand Things:
amazon.com/Ten-Thousand-Things-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353501
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Robert's Books:
The 21st Century Self:
amazon.com/21st-Century-Self-Illusion-Machinery/dp/0645888788
Understanding Claude:
amazon.com/Understanding-Claude-Artificial-Intelligence-Psychoanalyzed/dp/1738529665
Depending On No-thing:
amazon.com/Depending-No-Thing-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353595
The Ten Thousand Things:
amazon.com/Ten-Thousand-Things-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353501
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Robert's Books:
The 21st Century Self:
amazon.com/21st-Century-Self-Illusion-Machinery/dp/0645888788
Understanding Claude:
amazon.com/Understanding-Claude-Artificial-Intelligence-Psychoanalyzed/dp/1738529665
Depending On No-thing:
amazon.com/Depending-No-Thing-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353595
The Ten Thousand Things:
amazon.com/Ten-Thousand-Things-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353501
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
robertsaltzman.substack.com
Robert's Books:
The 21st Century Self:
amazon.com/21st-Century-Self-Illusion-Machinery/dp/0645888788
Understanding Claude:
amazon.com/Understanding-Claude-Artificial-Intelligence-Psychoanalyzed/dp/1738529665
Depending On No-thing:
amazon.com/Depending-No-Thing-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353595
The Ten Thousand Things:
amazon.com/Ten-Thousand-Things-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353501
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Robert's Books:
The 21st Century Self:
amazon.com/21st-Century-Self-Illusion-Machinery/dp/0645888788
Understanding Claude:
amazon.com/Understanding-Claude-Artificial-Intelligence-Psychoanalyzed/dp/1738529665
Depending On No-thing:
amazon.com/Depending-No-Thing-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353595
The Ten Thousand Things:
amazon.com/Ten-Thousand-Things-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353501
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Robert's Books:
The 21st Century Self:
amazon.com/21st-Century-Self-Illusion-Machinery/dp/0645888788
Understanding Claude:
amazon.com/Understanding-Claude-Artificial-Intelligence-Psychoanalyzed/dp/1738529665
Depending On No-thing:
amazon.com/Depending-No-Thing-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353595
The Ten Thousand Things:
amazon.com/Ten-Thousand-Things-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353501
Robert's Books:
The 21st Century Self:
amazon.com/21st-Century-Self-Illusion-Machinery/dp/0645888788
Understanding Claude:
amazon.com/Understanding-Claude-Artificial-Intelligence-Psychoanalyzed/dp/1738529665
Depending On No-thing:
amazon.com/Depending-No-Thing-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353595
The Ten Thousand Things:
amazon.com/Ten-Thousand-Things-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353501
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Robert's Books:
The 21st Century Self:
amazon.com/21st-Century-Self-Illusion-Machinery/dp/0645888788
Understanding Claude:
amazon.com/Understanding-Claude-Artificial-Intelligence-Psychoanalyzed/dp/1738529665
Depending On No-thing:
amazon.com/Depending-No-Thing-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353595
The Ten Thousand Things:
amazon.com/Ten-Thousand-Things-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353501
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Robert's Books:
The 21st Century Self:
amazon.com/21st-Century-Self-Illusion-Machinery/dp/0645888788
Understanding Claude:
amazon.com/Understanding-Claude-Artificial-Intelligence-Psychoanalyzed/dp/1738529665
Depending On No-thing:
amazon.com/Depending-No-Thing-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353595
The Ten Thousand Things:
amazon.com/Ten-Thousand-Things-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353501
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Robert's Books:
The 21st Century Self:
amazon.com/21st-Century-Self-Illusion-Machinery/dp/0645888788
Understanding Claude:
amazon.com/Understanding-Claude-Artificial-Intelligence-Psychoanalyzed/dp/1738529665
Depending On No-thing:
amazon.com/Depending-No-Thing-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353595
The Ten Thousand Things:
amazon.com/Ten-Thousand-Things-Robert-Saltzman/dp/1999353501
New Book: hedgehogreview.com/web-features/thr/posts/conversations-with-claude
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit robertsaltzman.substack.com (https://robertsaltzman.substack.com?utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=CTA_1)
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit robertsaltzman.substack.com (https://robertsaltzman.substack.com?utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=CTA_1)
Q: Robert, if our attention is on the senses, we are in the moment. If our attention is on thoughts, we are not in the moment. In human evolution, the brain expanded dramatically. With this new brain, we started having more thoughts, and more advanced thoughts. Our attention was drawn to those thoughts. So we evolved to be more not in the moment. If we want to be more in the moment, we just need to retrain ourselves to put our attention more on the senses.
A: I cannot agree. “Be here now” is an injunction against being lost in thought—not any kind of ultimate “truth”. One may be lost in thought to be sure, but one may also be lost in sensing. I see no superiority to either of those two conditions. Lost is lost. The best case is when you are lost in neither, but simply open and present to whatever may arise, be it a thought, a perception, an emotion, whatever. That is when one is most alive, I say.
My friend Joan Tollifson (facebook.com/joan.tollifson.54?__tn__=%2CdK-RHH-R-R&eid=ARDtZvXE6C7lRPOc4xQehWvqoGN1qwXo6uiHDiBmBbWxCSteR3Em6ZUt52yWP_f8B33UytzA4B5ekck9&fref=mentions) has said that if we give “open attention to sensations rather than ideas, impermanence is quite obvious, not as an idea we logically understand, but as our direct experience.” As I understood her, Joan was not recommending that one ought to prefer noticing sensations to noticing thoughts. She meant only that, for many of us, it may be easier to notice the fleetingness of sensations than it is to notice the transitory nature of thoughts, many of which, being habitual, seem “stickier” than sensations. This is particularly true of certain kinds of thoughts such as self-judgments, anxieties, and fears, etcetera.
However, one might equally well sit quietly and observe the flow of thought—how a thought rises, unbidden, only to be replaced by the next thought, and the next, and the next… That flow is no different from the flow of sensations. They are, in fact, parts of the same flow, the stream of consciousness.
Sensations, perceptions, feelings, thoughts, emotions—all of it—are occurring constantly, whether noticed or not, and cannot be divided.
The idea here is to open one’s eyes to the impermanence of all experience—including the experience of being “me.”
Thanks for reading The Ten Thousand Things. Please feel free to share it.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit robertsaltzman.substack.com (https://robertsaltzman.substack.com?utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=CTA_1)
Depending On No-thing free chapters to read (dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing)
Thanks for reading The Ten Thousand Things. Please feel free to share it.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit robertsaltzman.substack.com (https://robertsaltzman.substack.com?utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=CTA_1)
Q: Hello, Robert. I hope you are well. Would you mind if I ask you something? You have said that life is supposed to have suffering, and that we can’t really escape it. But many teachers, including the Buddha, say that there is an end to suffering. You say that you are awake—so why do you still suffer?
A: I do not say that life is “supposed” to have suffering—I say that suffering is part of this aliveness, and that efforts to avoid suffering or escape from suffering are a denial of this aliveness. Some of that denial may employ belief in the words of so-called masters, including the Buddha—who, in the mind of modernity, is more than just a master, but an iconic, mythological character whose words are held by many to be absolute truth.
I do not think that anyone’s words are absolute truth. We are all just human here, including Gotama, assuming that such a person actually existed historically. But even if there was once such a man, we cannot know what he really believed or really said, despite the insistence by some Buddhists—mainly the Theravadins—that the suttas in the Pali Canon are accurate historical accounts. Obviously they are not. Those suttas, which are said to be accounts of talks given by Gotama to the monks of his era, were preserved orally for around 450 years—passed from one person to another in the form of stories—until finally, after much debate, they were put into written form during the Fourth Buddhist Council in the first century BCE.
Four or five hundred years is a long time. It’s easy to say “four or five hundred years” but difficult to imagine a span like that in human terms. If you ever played the game of telephone as a child, you will know that even a single sentence can be distorted—and possibly have its meaning changed entirely—in just a few minutes of being passed from mouth to mouth.
So the idea that those suttas are in any way an accurate accounting strains credulity. But so great is the desire of humans to have an infallible authority on whom to rely, that millions of Buddhists take every word of those scriptures as literally true and factual.
And it is not only Theravadins who believe in an end to suffering—that idea has penetrated modern spirituality so fully that contemporary teachers speak of it confidently, as if they themselves had experienced self-consciousness without suffering, leaving students to imagine that, as long as they still suffer, they have not yet come to “Truth.”
That misunderstanding is what moves me to point out that, although I find myself awake, I still suffer.
I still suffer, for example, when I hear the American President, who, in my professional opinion as a psychologist, is seriously mentally ill, talking like a gangster and lying about everything with no regard at all for facts, while the people who voted for him dote on every word of that hate-filled, racist, sexist verbal diarrhea. That cat is one sick kitty, and he is contagious.
I suffer from having to see that I am part of a race—the human race—that consists of a large proportion of nincompoops and that many of the habits and customs of this world of ours are fashioned by nincompoops for nincompoops.
Or I come upon a dog with a chain around his throat tied up in the sun with no water in his bowl, a look of despair in his eyes. He has been tortured beyond even looking for help from me, the way a normal dog would. He won’t look me in the eye. And when I try to bring water to him, I find myself being threatened with physical harm by the dog’s owner. It’s his f*****g dog.
If I did not suffer at such a sight and did not want to alleviate the dog’s suffering, I would consider that a form of spiritual bypassing. So, although I am not thirsty myself, I must suffer along with the dog— and that cannot be explained away by “awakening.”
I guess it’s hard for you to get over hearing that even the wide awake ones among us must suffer. Suffering cannot be avoided. Trying to avoid or escape suffering just makes matters worse. I despise hearing from “teachers” that suffering is “all in your mind.” Everything is all in your mind—but that does not mean it’s not real.
I was talking with my friend, Dr. Robert K. Hall, an expert on Theravada Buddhism, a dharma teacher himself, and a lifelong meditator in the vipassana tradition, who, at the time of this conversation, was in hospice care, and in considerable physical distress. We were discussing suffering and the Four Noble Truths, which Robert had said were “kindergarten stuff, meant for beginners.”
Robert recalled a conversation with Jack Kornfield in which Robert said, “Jack, there’s no escape from suffering. What is this b******t?” And, Robert told me, Jack agreed. He doesn’t know anyone who has escaped.
Now, contemporary Buddhist teachers never claim to be “enlightened.” A faux pas like that would put them beyond the pale. But th...
robertsaltzman.substack.com
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
#Zohar #mysticism #Torah #mystical #jewish
robertsaltzman.substack.com
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
facebook.com/groups/3633907716835096
Frequent writing, audio, and video at robertsaltzman.substack.com
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Depending On No-Thing discussion group:
facebook.com/groups/3633907716835096
Frequent writing, audio, and video at robertsaltzman.substack.com
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
facebook.com/groups/3633907716835096
Frequent writing, audio, and video at robertsaltzman.substack.com
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
facebook.com/groups/3633907716835096
Frequent writing, audio, and video at robertsaltzman.substack.com
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
facebook.com/groups/3633907716835096
Frequent writing, audio, and video at robertsaltzman.substack.com
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Depending On No-Thing discussion group:
facebook.com/groups/3633907716835096
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
facebook.com/groups/3633907716835096
Frequent writing, audio, and video at robertsaltzman.substack.com
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
facebook.com/groups/3633907716835096
Frequent writing, audio, and video at robertsaltzman.substack.com
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
facebook.com/groups/3633907716835096
Frequent writing, audio, and video at robertsaltzman.substack.com
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-
facebook.com/groups/3633907716835096
Frequent writing, audio, and video at robertsaltzman.substack.com
Depending On No-Thing excerpts:
dr-robert.com/depending-on-no-thing
The Ten Thousand Things excerpts:
dr-robert.com/the-ten-thousand-things-


